Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t have another lockdown to protect vaccine refusers?

266 replies

Susie477 · 17/05/2021 18:35

Everyone over 40 or in high-risk groups has now been offered a vaccine. The overwhelming majority, including me, have gratefully taken up the offer. A small minority have refused the vaccine, as is their right, of course.

Now we are seeing new ‘variants of concern’ and unvaccinated vulnerable people in some areas are now being hospitalised because they have been infected.

Some people are now calling for extended restrictions in these areas to prevent the new variant spreading. Why should responsible people who have been vaccinated be punished by yet more lockdown because idiots in their communities are too stupid or too selfish to get vaccinated?

OP posts:
WebCookiesAreIntrusive · 18/05/2021 13:17

This is not fair to the younger people in our society. They are staying in and having their lives screwed up to save others, mainly older people. Now their 21 June freedom date is in jeopardy because the govt. are chasing those who have failed to step up and do their bit.

It's time to move on.

Protect those who cannot have the vaccine for whatever reason.
Stop chasing those who have been offered and have not taken it up.
From Monday tell the 18-36-year-olds (or whatever age they are at) that they can walk in/ book appointments and get their jabs.

If you don't want to take up the jab, crack on. We should be no longer wasting time and resources selling this idea to you. We are up against it with the Indian variant. Our young people deserve better.

ConstanceGracy · 18/05/2021 13:16

[quote picturesandpickles]You are wrong, sadly (I usually say you have misunderstood but someone said I say that too often so going for the blunt approach).

If we had to lock down, it would be to protect the vaccinated as they are still more likely to be the ones who get ill: twitter.com/ChristabelCoops/status/1394286767440896003[/quote]
Who is this person ? This is not the case .
Most are unvaccinated, a few have only had one which we know means you’re still not fully protected and I’m pretty sure one person who had both vaccines died but he was very elderly and infirm.
We know vaccines aren’t a cute but they help tremendously in helping stop the spread and death/ serious illness .
Only reason anyone should be refusing is if they have other health reasons that mean the jab is not suitable.

Snoozer11 · 18/05/2021 13:10

@VeganVeal

I think we should definitely go back into a hard lockdown, we dont want another spike
You are joking?

Are hospitals at risk of being overwhelmed? Are deaths increasing to hundreds a week? Are cases rising exponentially? Are the vulnerable awaiting vaccination? Is 7 in 10 adults having antibodies not enough?

For the love of god, use your brain.

Will the public adhere to a strict lockdown when daily deaths are in single figures? Will the businesses, restaurants, hospitality, mental health issues be worth it?

Ridiculous.

Theredjellybean · 18/05/2021 13:05

Sh05
Do you know how rare having an allergy to one of the ingredients in the vaccines is?
2.5 allergic reactions in 10 million.
That's people who have reacted after the vaccine.
The ingredients are pretty rare in any other products so those 2.5 probably didn't know they were allergic until they had the jab.
Now do you really believe 13 people in Bolton alrwady knew they were allergic?
Very very unlikely.
I'm not sure what is so wrong in saying these people were eligible for the vaccination and chose not to have it. They decided to take that risk. OK, fair enough that's up to them, but the consequences may now affect all the population.
People who did get their vaccine, people who have not yet had theirs, potential business owners, people hoping to go back to work in hospitality, the mental health of our young people, our older people, the millions now waiting for medical treatments, operations... The list of ramifications of this is endless.
It is selfish... Most of us have done what is in the interests of the whole population, putting aside personal feelings.
To have this derailed by a few, well I feel angry.
Vaccines are free, safe and available... Housebound are being done by roving teams, clinics have been set up all over areas, it really is not that hard.
Information is plentiful in multiple languages.
No one can say vaccination has been selective or certain groups disadvantaged.

Snoozer11 · 18/05/2021 13:05

The vast majority of protection is delivered by the first dose.

I think it's appalling that people think they are so special that they don't need the vaccine and refuse it. We have a moral and civic duty to be vaccinated to protect others. It is a public health issue, not a personal one.

It takes time for immunity to build, which explains why some vaccinated people have ended up hospitalised.

They need to hurry up and vaccinate younger people with a first dose over the next four weeks. Massive test centres in the city, mobile vaccination hubs etc.

As they're not giving younger people AZ, they are currently sat on a stockpile of doses.

We all know vaccines aren't a miracle cure that will protect everyone. But I cannot believe people are still so unable to see the damage caused by lockdowns and are unable to understand that the aim is never to protect every single person from covid. Over 7 in 10 adults currently have antibodies.

Covid is here to stay. People will die from it, as they do from a myriad of preventable illness and disease and respiratory conditions.

Lockdowns are not a proportional response to prevent a handful of deaths.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 18/05/2021 12:51

There’s talk on the net that the reason India wasn’t red listed earlier was because the government were permitting flights in from fruit and veg pickers to replace the EU ones.

freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 12:38

@VeganVeal

I think we should definitely go back into a hard lockdown, we dont want another spike
If we must, not before November thank you. We all bloody need a holiday and a decent summer. Can you imagine having to cancel your summer and your October half-term booking? Fuck that.
freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 12:36

Rubyrecka
Actually it is easy if you do the research and not pay attention to scare monger.

You clearly are one of those who like to scare people.

Ignoring and dismissing basic facts, and refusing to acknowledge that NO ONE has any data on effects on long term effects on people in general, and unborn babies in particular, is not giving you any credibility.

Unless you believe in some weird conspiracy theory, there was no covid vaccine just a year ago... So I'd love to know where you found studies about the short and long term effects.

Who is trying to scare people? I am guessing some posters are trying to reassure themselves they made the right choice. The point was merely that we do NOT KNOW and it does not make for an EASY decision.

Sh05 · 18/05/2021 12:25

It's not one area, it's one whole town!
Bolton only has one main hospital for 285,000 people so 12 out of that many doesn't seem that unlikely really.

luckylavender · 18/05/2021 12:15

How quickly we've all bought into the government spin that this is all the fault of people who have refused to be jabbed. Firstly this ignores those under 40 & what we know about this variant is that it is worse for younger people. It ignores those who cannot take the jab & those who cannot easily get to a centre. And on. It also ignores the fact that the government let this variant in by not protecting our borders. And that Track & Trace cost £37 billion & is supposed to work better when there are low cases, so where the hell is it? Don't fall for it people.

Theredjellybean · 18/05/2021 12:11

@Sh05

The facts are, five out of 18 patients in hospital with covid Indian variant in Bolton had one jab, one person two, they are described as very frail.
That leaves 13 people who are described as eligible for a vaccine who did not have one.
I'd struggle to believe these all had allergies to the ingredients of the vaccine.
I have given over 1000 vaccines and have not yet had one person who had allergies to the ingredients of the vaccine. So to have 13 in one area would be improbable.
I can infer from this that is 13 people who did not have the vaccine through choice.
They potentially will have infected many more people.. People who have not yet had a chance to get vaccinated... The cases rises and panic sets in and we all have to suffer.
I think that's selfish...

KarmaKarmaKarmaChameleon · 18/05/2021 12:00

And I don’t think it’s at all unreasonable for a pregnant woman to be unsure about accepting the vaccine, given the length of time the vaccine has been used and the rapidly changing guidance on the subject. I’m not saying I think pregnant women should have it or shouldn’t have it - there are certainly risks associated with catching Covid in pregnancy - but I don’t think it’s remotely unreasonable to find it a difficult decision.

KarmaKarmaKarmaChameleon · 18/05/2021 11:55

More divide and conquer from the government following hot on the heels from snitching on neighbours. This time with an added layer of barely concealed racism in the media. Nice. Just what society needs.

Couldn’t agree more. Why do people swallow such divisive sensationalist drivel?

Thelnebriati · 18/05/2021 11:55

YABU and confusing vaccine 'refusal' with travel which enables the virus to mutate and spread.

Sh05 · 18/05/2021 11:48

@Theredjellybean

I agree OP... Widely reported that majority in hospital with Indian variant had refused vaccination. I am incensed that the road map maybe derailed and the majority who have followed the rules, and have had their vaccines etc arw going to be subject more restrictions, with its detrimental effects all because people were too selfish to get vaccinated.
If this is in regards to Bolton then I'd just like to correct that as of yesterday 18 were hospitalised with covid, out of those 1/3 were vaccinated, the others were not. There's no way of knowing why not, no proof that they were refusers or ineligible due to other health problems or allergies. So Matt Hancock trying to lay the blame at unvaccinated patients is really just just deflecting the blame from Boris Johnson and the government.
PhatPhanny · 18/05/2021 11:43

I clicked YABU because I have not been offered mt vaccine yet and if there is a new variant that can still kill I'd like protecting until I willinglt accept my vaccine.

VeganVeal · 18/05/2021 11:30

I think we should definitely go back into a hard lockdown, we dont want another spike

BashfulClam · 18/05/2021 11:15

Not everyone is vaccinated yet. I’m only getting my first one today and I’m 42. We need a much higher % to be vaccinated before we can say the risk is reduced.

Rubyrecka · 18/05/2021 10:43

@MargaretThursday

The safety data for pregnant women isn’t based on the U.K, it’s based on the US. 90,000 pregnant women there have received the vaccine with no issue. That’s the basis on which it was recommended here.

Firstly the US only started giving the vaccine in mid December. That's 5 months ago, so there can't be much data on people who had it in the first trimester.

And Thalidomide isn’t a vaccine. It's a medication. Medications and vaccines can both have side effects.
And my point was that when something causes a side effect, especially one that can sometimes occur naturally, it takes time to realise that it isn't just "one of those things". Thalidomide had a horrific effect, and still took 5 years for them to link it.
For the example I gave. 60 children a year a born with a limb deficiency. That varies from being the end of a finger, through to all four limbs missing. There's about 700k children born each year (UK), so that's less than 0.01% of births.

  • Limbs are formed in the first 5 weeks of pregnancy, so they'd have had to have the injection then to effect the development of a limb, so the US market wouldn't have had the vaccine at that stage and given birth, and no, a missing limb isn't always picked up at the scan. I'd reckon at best about 50/50 are picked up at the scan. DD's was, but plenty aren't, even among people who had several scans for other reasons. I'd reckon the numbers of limb deficient babies could probably increase ten times and it still would take time to realise it wasn't just one of those things because it would still be small numbers. You get unusual clusters in random distribution, so a hospital suddenly having two in quick succession is unusual, but I do know of it happening. For example overall a limb deficiency is twice as likely in a girl. However dd was one of very few girls at her limb centre when growing up-it was about 75% boys. Just one of those random things.

*I am not implying that the Covid Vaccine causes limb deficiency or any other birth defect. As far as I am aware, there are no links being investigated. However I am saying that I understand if someone doesn't want the injection because they are pregnant as I would say they can't state with certainty that it won't.

I wondered when some idiot would start posting about Thalidomide.

Your post is ABSOLUTE bollocks.

Thalidomide Crossed the placenta. There is absolutely no evidence that the MRNA vaccines cross the placenta. Please for fuck sake EDUCATE yourself before posting such absolute drivel.

Limb deformities are picked up in the anomaly scan - it’s EXACTLY what the scan is for amongst other anomalies.

Rubyrecka · 18/05/2021 10:32

@oneglassandpuzzled@Toty I’m interested in this link also as Wales are now vaccinating people under 30.

Rubyrecka · 18/05/2021 10:30

@freakyfridays

normalsaline

It’s very easy for most people to make the choice, including pregnant women. I am one. It’s recommended by RCOG etc, why wouldn’t you?
The ones I feel sorry for are those who CAN’T get it due to allergies etc

It's not easy at all, we have no data on the long-term effects, on the effects on the baby and, until you have it done, no idea on how YOU will react! Some people reacted very badly with high temperature after the jab, really not ideal when you are pregnant.

Good for you if you find the decision easy, but in a world where new researches have proven that even paracetamol is not as inoffensive as people pretend , you cannot say it's "easy",

It's a gamble.

Actually it is easy if you do the research and not pay attention to scare monger.

You clearly are one of those who like to scare people.

The high temp is rare and can be handled via paracetamol. What do u think happens to your body when you get covid?

There are KNOWN covid risks in pregnancy for premature birth and they have difficulty ventilating pregnancy women. If you get covid in the third trimester your more likely to be admitted into the ICU. These are facts. It won’t happen to everyone who’s pregnant that infected by covid but it happens. With the uptick in infections now and expected in autumn /winter it’s responsible for you & your unborn baby to get the vaccine.

nancywhitehead · 18/05/2021 10:13

The more it is allowed to spread, the more likely it is to mutate into something more dangerous and vaccine-resistant.

BogRollBOGOF · 18/05/2021 10:06

More divide and conquer from the government following hot on the heels from snitching on neighbours. This time with an added layer of barely concealed racism in the media. Nice. Just what society needs.

It's not refusing to have not been offered the vaccine yet.
People may have clear reasons to be exempt, or more commonly, specific concerns about whether the vaccine is the best course of action for specific conditions where there is a lack of evidence.
Some people are just "not yet" and want to have more information than is currently avaliable and will be likely to consent with time.
Better to rattle through the keen masses then work on catching up with people who are more concerned and potentially persuadable.
The small number of genuinely anti-vaxx (in the normal context) people won't be persuaded either way. Fortunately they are low enough on numbers not to be significantly detrimental to the performance of the vaccination programme.

Some communities will need a more targeted approach listening to and adressing their concerns and making it more accessible at a localised level. Much more successful than being "othered" and ostricised.
For some people in low-paid work, they won't be willing to risk an unpaid day off ill with side-effects. Especially they've already had the illness and the isolation time from that.

The more people vaccinated, the better, but people should not be bullied into medical procedures with a high chance of inconvenient mild side effects.

Lockdowns damage society and we are already at a stage where vaccination should be protecting the NHS and the vast majority who are more suceptible to serious cases. By the time we get to the autumn and colds/ flu season, all adults should have had the opportunity to be vaccinated once and most twice. Lockdowns should not be needed again. We need to undo the damage already caused in the past 14m.

This 40yo is hoping that next month's second vaccine is better than her first round experience... meanwhile other peoples' situations and choices are not my personal problem.

oneglassandpuzzled · 18/05/2021 09:28

@Toty

Oh ffs, when did MN turn into the daily mail. Do people actually fall for these targeted sensationalist headlines Hmm. The Only reason further lockdowns are now needed is because of our governments continual monumental cock ups, allowing all these varients in to the UK in the first place, even then these lockdowns were about covering up the fact the our NHS isn't fit for purpose, they are not and never have been about saving lives. The majority of vaccine refusers won't have even been offered a vaccine yet so how the fuck is it their fault. I'm 47 and haven't been offered my vaccine yet. The rest of the UK is way behind England.
please can you provide a link showing evidence that the rest of the uk is behind England. As far as I remember, Wales is actually ahead and NI at about the same level.

Scotland may be behind and my family in the Highlands say that’s par for the course.

MrsIsobelCrawley · 18/05/2021 09:09

@ozymandiusking

I said months ago. If you Choose not to have your vaccination and you catch Covid, do not come running to the NHS for treatment. Choices have consequences.
I suppose you believe the same should apply to smokers, gin drinkers, overweight, etc.
Swipe left for the next trending thread