Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t have another lockdown to protect vaccine refusers?

266 replies

Susie477 · 17/05/2021 18:35

Everyone over 40 or in high-risk groups has now been offered a vaccine. The overwhelming majority, including me, have gratefully taken up the offer. A small minority have refused the vaccine, as is their right, of course.

Now we are seeing new ‘variants of concern’ and unvaccinated vulnerable people in some areas are now being hospitalised because they have been infected.

Some people are now calling for extended restrictions in these areas to prevent the new variant spreading. Why should responsible people who have been vaccinated be punished by yet more lockdown because idiots in their communities are too stupid or too selfish to get vaccinated?

OP posts:
Rubyrecka · 18/05/2021 16:06

@freakyfridays

Where are your facts that the vaccine will affect anyone negatively? Confused

maybe have a chat with doctors who had to deal with people who reacted badly for a start?
Where are your facts that the vaccine will not have any effect?

What we DO KNOW is the risk of covid and pregnancy.
Which in many cases are .. none. The risks of catching covid are pretty low at the moment in many places around the country - and all you have to do is refrain from flying on holiday until you have the baby.

I just strongly disagree with people pretending that it's such an "easy" choice to make for many people.

Okay I don’t think this debate is really going anywhere. Thank you for the advice I have indeed sought it from my doctor, neo natal nurse and neo natal doctors who have seen the increase in premature babies and mums first hand who’ve sadly been affected by covid.

I’m yet to hear of anyone who has been negatively affected by the vaccine that is comparable. A saw arm or a headache for a week isn’t really a life changing side affect. I think your missing the point that no one knows what the virus is going to do so to say it’s low risk of infections maybe so right now but I doubt it will be the case in the autumn or winter as they are expecting it to behave the same way as flu, not to mention the Indian variant. So compound that with all the other issues for pregnant ladies (flu, repressed immune system) the known risks of catching covid vs vaccine is pretty clear IMO.

Whoarethewho · 18/05/2021 16:02

Certainly it sticks in the throat to see people going about their day to day business without the worry of catching covid and telling me we should be unlocking when my only crime is not being old enough to qualify for the vaccine. Especially when the young have given up so much to protect them forced to by the government.

BarbarianMum · 18/05/2021 16:00

@Blossomtoes that's not really how it works. Mutations are random, and just as likely to make a virus more dangerous than less (actually many are neutral). In the long term a virus that causes severe illness and death is less likely to persist in large numbers than a milder one but that's the long term. Unchecked, a severe virus could quite easily burn it's way through billions of people before dying out if it's also highly transmission, see bubonic and pneumonic plagues fe

Blossomtoes · 18/05/2021 16:00

I have given up a lot so the cev and old can be protected and I expect the same in return

If you’re not high risk, you don’t need the same in return.

Whoarethewho · 18/05/2021 15:54

We made a decision about covid to lock down I would rather either everyone gets treated the same and we don't let up untill they have been vaccinated or we just let everyone carry on and let the sick elderly and unlucky take their chances. Personally I would be happy with either. But definitely not this halfway house where we don't protect everyone who wants it. For flu we don't lockdown that was fine I have given up a lot so the cev and old can be protected and I expect the same in return.

SlipperyDippery · 18/05/2021 15:53

@Whoarethewho

I agree however much of those wanting restrictions have to be lifted have had their vaccine. There are millions of adults who want the vaccine but cannot get it. Until everyone who wants a vaccine has it then we should have lockdowns when appropriate to protect them.
I am one of those people waiting for their vaccination. I am at very low risk of getting seriously ill from covid because I’m under 40 and no underlying health condition making me vulnerable. This is true of the majority of people waiting.

Yes I’m in the high risk bracket for long covid, and yes I could be one of the rare unlucky ones who gets ill despite being comparatively young and in good health.

But lockdowns are so dreadfully harmful that you cannot justify them to protect individuals at low risk. It’s one thing to lock down to prevent overwhelming the NHS and prevent tens of thousands of deaths among an unvaccinated vulnerable demographic. But it’s totally disproportionate to suggest locking down and causing so much suffering so the young and low risk don’t catch it.

That’s the point of this thread really - the hospitalisations have been disproportionately among the vulnerable but unvaccinated, and that’s the OP’s concern.

Blossomtoes · 18/05/2021 15:43

@Whoarethewho

I agree however much of those wanting restrictions have to be lifted have had their vaccine. There are millions of adults who want the vaccine but cannot get it. Until everyone who wants a vaccine has it then we should have lockdowns when appropriate to protect them.
Those who remain unvaccinated are very low risk. We locked down to minimise hospitalisation and death, not to stop people getting ill. Where does it stop? Flu kills people, should we lock down for that?
Whoarethewho · 18/05/2021 15:27

I agree however much of those wanting restrictions have to be lifted have had their vaccine. There are millions of adults who want the vaccine but cannot get it. Until everyone who wants a vaccine has it then we should have lockdowns when appropriate to protect them.

NoMLMbots · 18/05/2021 15:24

[quote Theredjellybean]@Sh05

The facts are, five out of 18 patients in hospital with covid Indian variant in Bolton had one jab, one person two, they are described as very frail.
That leaves 13 people who are described as eligible for a vaccine who did not have one.
I'd struggle to believe these all had allergies to the ingredients of the vaccine.
I have given over 1000 vaccines and have not yet had one person who had allergies to the ingredients of the vaccine. So to have 13 in one area would be improbable.
I can infer from this that is 13 people who did not have the vaccine through choice.
They potentially will have infected many more people.. People who have not yet had a chance to get vaccinated... The cases rises and panic sets in and we all have to suffer.
I think that's selfish...[/quote]
Yep agree.
Idiots avoiding vaccine then get ill... their own fault, however I feel for those that they pass it to.

NoMLMbots · 18/05/2021 15:19

@UhtredRagnarson

So fuck everyone under 40 and those older who are unable to have the vaccine?
Calm down. The vaccine reduces the symptoms so less likely to need hospital rather than dropping dead from covid. That age range is very likely to have very little problem.
SoupDragon · 18/05/2021 15:15

Interesting that the OP never came back to the thread.

Blossomtoes · 18/05/2021 15:05

@nancywhitehead

The more it is allowed to spread, the more likely it is to mutate into something more dangerous and vaccine-resistant.
The first part of that is true. The second isn’t, mutations tend to make viruses less dangerous as killing the host reduces its chance of survival.
Sugarplumfairy65 · 18/05/2021 14:31

There are 230,000 people in the UK who have some form of blood cancer. Leukemia, lymphoma, non Hodgkin etc, most of who have had both vaccines. Unfortunately, its come to light that even both doses of the vaccine has given them little or no immunity to covid. Having any type of blood cancer at any stage of treatment puts you in the highest risk group of death or severe illness. Then there are those who cannot have the vaccine even if they wanted to.
This is why its so important for as many people as possible to have the vaccine. Fair enough, they may not get ill if they catch Covid but they could unwittingly pass it on who has no defense against it.

MargosKaftan · 18/05/2021 14:25

It is unfair to blame the tiny numbers who are able to have the vaccine now but are refusing (and the numbers not taking it up include those who can't have it for other medical reasons).

There really isn't wide spread refusal. The vast majority are having the vaccine when called.

Speeding up the vaccination programme makes more sense. The government were slow to put India on the red list, so we need to counter that by vaccinating as many as possible.

In areas with high numbers of the new varient, they should be jabbing anyone over 18, even if that means other areas have to wait for supply a bit. (They should also be testing everyone in those areas to work out how wide spread it is)

freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 14:18

It would be unfair and unreasonable to blame people who decide not to have the vaccine when half the population has been ignoring guidelines and rules for weeks if not months!

But I don't want to live in a country where medical procedures or jab could be imposed against your will.

CaptainWentworth · 18/05/2021 14:13

Just to add my tuppence worth, I am pregnant (second trimester) and have booked my vaccine appointments (will be 38 before the 1 July cut off date). I wasn’t overly worried about safety, given the lack of serious side effects being reported in the US and also the number of vaccines that are routinely administered in pregnancy (whooping cough and flu to name the two most common) but I didn’t feel particularly at risk anyway so wasn’t sure whether to just wait until after the birth - to be honest I wasn’t expecting to be eligible so soon.

Anyway DH is a GP and advised me to have it as he felt the risks of catching COVID later in pregnancy outweighed the (theoretical) possible risks from the vaccine- he is expecting a third peak in the autumn when I am due. Also it would be fairly awful to test positive for covid around my due date and not know what to expect with respect to hospital admission/ birth arrangements, even if I wasn’t especially badly ill.

TheKeatingFive · 18/05/2021 14:08

I 100% agree with this But this is perfectly compatible with the opinion that we should not even consider lockdown to protect those who choose not to protect themselves.

Agreed

There is a risk that the treatment of those who choose not to be vaccinated may fill up hospitals and mean lockdown is necessary to prevent collapse of the health care system. Looking at proportion of people accepting the vaccine, though, this is unlikely.

I hope this turns out to be true, because that's an extremely difficult situation and I don't know how it should be handled.

Snoozer11 · 18/05/2021 14:06

@freakyfridays

Where are your facts that the vaccine will affect anyone negatively? Confused

maybe have a chat with doctors who had to deal with people who reacted badly for a start?
Where are your facts that the vaccine will not have any effect?

What we DO KNOW is the risk of covid and pregnancy.
Which in many cases are .. none. The risks of catching covid are pretty low at the moment in many places around the country - and all you have to do is refrain from flying on holiday until you have the baby.

I just strongly disagree with people pretending that it's such an "easy" choice to make for many people.

The doctors who have dealt with side effects from the vaccine will likely tell you of a great many more patients who've been hospitalised, ventilated and died of covid or who are dealing with the effects of so-called long covid.

Yes, there are those who cant be vaccinated for health reasons. But opting to get vaccinated is a remarkably easy decision for the vast majority.

I say this as someone who isn't yet eligible to be called up and who will likely be waiting another month or so before I'm asked. But I won't hesitate when that happens.

ilovesooty · 18/05/2021 14:03

@reallyreallyborednow

Don’t forget there will be some people who can’t have the vaccine because it’s medically contraindicated.

There will also be a small % who are fully vaccinated, but who didn’t develop antibodies, and are therefore not immune.

Until herd immunity is reached by vaccinating the required % of the population, these people remain vulnerable.

It isn’t just about the over 40’s or CEV.

I care about protecting those people, and young people and children who've not yet been vaccinated. I couldn't care less about protecting vaccine refusers and whatever happens to them is their own responsibility.
wink1970 · 18/05/2021 13:58

*VeganVeal

I think we should definitely go back into a hard lockdown, we dont want another spike*

Hope you're comfortable sat there with the bills paid, the mortgage covered, your future secured ...

freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 13:50

Where are your facts that the vaccine will affect anyone negatively?
Confused

maybe have a chat with doctors who had to deal with people who reacted badly for a start?
Where are your facts that the vaccine will not have any effect?

What we DO KNOW is the risk of covid and pregnancy.
Which in many cases are .. none. The risks of catching covid are pretty low at the moment in many places around the country - and all you have to do is refrain from flying on holiday until you have the baby.

I just strongly disagree with people pretending that it's such an "easy" choice to make for many people.

ChloeCrocodile · 18/05/2021 13:46

Some people are worried about the vaccine, they have the right to be and they have the right to decline.

I 100% agree with this But this is perfectly compatible with the opinion that we should not even consider lockdown to protect those who choose not to protect themselves.

NHS treatment for covid should obviously be available to everyone (anti-vax or not) in the same way the NHS treats smoking or obesity related illnesses, and you don't get charged for injuries caused by voluntary activities (eg being drunk or playing rugby).

There is a risk that the treatment of those who choose not to be vaccinated may fill up hospitals and mean lockdown is necessary to prevent collapse of the health care system. Looking at proportion of people accepting the vaccine, though, this is unlikely.

Rubyrecka · 18/05/2021 13:33

@freakyfridays

Rubyrecka Actually it is easy if you do the research and not pay attention to scare monger.

You clearly are one of those who like to scare people.

Ignoring and dismissing basic facts, and refusing to acknowledge that NO ONE has any data on effects on long term effects on people in general, and unborn babies in particular, is not giving you any credibility.

Unless you believe in some weird conspiracy theory, there was no covid vaccine just a year ago... So I'd love to know where you found studies about the short and long term effects.

Who is trying to scare people? I am guessing some posters are trying to reassure themselves they made the right choice. The point was merely that we do NOT KNOW and it does not make for an EASY decision.

I haven’t ignored any basic facts and I certainly haven’t claimed there no long term affects so let’s keep it accurate. What we DO KNOW is the risk of covid and pregnancy. Where are your facts that the vaccine will affect anyone negatively? Oh right we don’t know so better err on the side of caution and ignore the effects of covid on pregnant women.

Ethically they cannot test on pregnant women so what happened when flu or whooping cough vaccines were rolled out.

All u need to do is go on the RCOG and have a look, it gives information to make an informed choice which is all anyone can do at this point.

freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 13:22

You'd be much more successful acknowledging the actual risks and side effects of the vaccine and putting them into perspective than denying them entirely.

freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 13:20

I think it's appalling that people think they are so special that they don't need the vaccine and refuse it. We have a moral and civic duty to be vaccinated to protect others. It is a public health issue, not a personal one.

oh come on , you could say that about a lot of things.

Some people are worried about the vaccine, they have the right to be and they have the right to decline.

Let's not be hypocrite and pretend everyone is always putting public health and the country as a whole over their own need or interest!

I have a strong dislike of conspiracy theorists who ignore the facts and what actually happened in hospitals and is still happening elsewhere today, and a strong dislike for the ones who deny the risks and genuine concerns of others.

But people only start talking about civic duty when it touches them personally.