Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t have another lockdown to protect vaccine refusers?

266 replies

Susie477 · 17/05/2021 18:35

Everyone over 40 or in high-risk groups has now been offered a vaccine. The overwhelming majority, including me, have gratefully taken up the offer. A small minority have refused the vaccine, as is their right, of course.

Now we are seeing new ‘variants of concern’ and unvaccinated vulnerable people in some areas are now being hospitalised because they have been infected.

Some people are now calling for extended restrictions in these areas to prevent the new variant spreading. Why should responsible people who have been vaccinated be punished by yet more lockdown because idiots in their communities are too stupid or too selfish to get vaccinated?

OP posts:
Bluefinger · 18/05/2021 23:15

Is it flu? Because there have been very deadly waves of that. Good job the vaccines and complete shut downs of society have gotten rid of it. Well done everyone.

twelly · 18/05/2021 23:12

Another lockdown would be too much for people, the young have suffered so much, normal life needs to be resumed, we have to learn to live with this virus

Bluefinger · 18/05/2021 23:10

Which other virus has mutated to be more and more virulent and deadly? I'd really be scared of that one. Must be loads of literature detailing it?

user1471539324 · 18/05/2021 23:07

Absolutely @GappyValley.

As a scientist, I’ve been reading @freakyfridays posts with bemusement. I’m so sick of people who think that confidence = competence.

user1471539324 · 18/05/2021 22:49

@AFS1

I entirely understand why you say that, and I share your anger at the selfishness of the anti-mask/anti-lockdown/anti-vaccine mob.

However, the thing I’m most concerned about is the virus mutating and the more it spreads, the more risk it will develop into a vaccine-resistant strain. For that reason, we all need to be cautious, even if it’s primarily down to the selfish idiots who won’t gat vaccinated.

Exactly this. Every new case is a new chance for mutation and development of a new variant. Nobody is safe until everyone is safe.
caringcarer · 18/05/2021 22:05

A lot of people have still not had the opportunity to have the vaccine yet. We have to be fair to younger people in who have had to wait the longest.

OlympicProcrastinator · 18/05/2021 21:30

The state of the NHS? On which planet could anyone be satisfied with the lack of infrastructure, the lack of staff, the ridiculous waiting lists, the post code lotteries. How would anyone find it acceptable to have ambulances queuing in front of hospitals (when you are lucky enough to get an ambulance), people dumped in the corridors, women without even a drink for hours, urgent treatments taking MONTHS on a waiting list

That’s got nothing to do with the governments decision to lock down over low numbers of Covid deaths (currently) when they are happy to have restrictions when twenty thousand people with flu die. It’s just a rant about the state of the NHS.

freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 21:11

That’s just political hyperbole.

The state of the NHS? On which planet could anyone be satisfied with the lack of infrastructure, the lack of staff, the ridiculous waiting lists, the post code lotteries. How would anyone find it acceptable to have ambulances queuing in front of hospitals (when you are lucky enough to get an ambulance), people dumped in the corridors, women without even a drink for hours, urgent treatments taking MONTHS on a waiting list..

3 weeks to see a GP! How is that ever right.

It's not political, it's fact. And frankly, if we hadn't be so blind or complacent, covid wouldn't have brought such a mess.

You can be against restrictions and happy to see people dying India-style, you can't deny how poor the NHS is.

OlympicProcrastinator · 18/05/2021 20:23

I am not sure anyone in the UK can pretend that the NHS wasn't overwhelmed before the pandemic when it was already an absolute shamble. Covid would have just worsen an already dramatic and unreliable situation

That’s just political hyperbole. However you personally feel about the government and NHS, the government has never shut the country down for annual flu deaths in their tens of thousands. There have been hardly any flu deaths this winter but there have been Covid deaths.

At what point do we accept, as we have done with flu, that people will die. If the government told you we couldn’t come out of lockdown for another year would you accept it?

If so what about the year after? Or the year after that? How many years would people, on the whole, accept living with restrictions? We have merrily accepted an endemic that kills thousands each year for our entire lives already.

Snoozer11 · 18/05/2021 19:52

@SoupDragon

A saw arm or a headache for a week isn’t really a life changing side affect.

Fatal blood clots are.

Fatal blood clots are.

...extremely uncommon.

Rubyrecka · 18/05/2021 19:44

@SoupDragon

A saw arm or a headache for a week isn’t really a life changing side affect.

Fatal blood clots are.

You mean like the contraceptive pill that women take? Perspective.
RedcurrantPuff · 18/05/2021 19:11

*One of the features of covid is the number of younger people who are severely affected, who spend longer spells in ICU/on ventilation.

Covid is much than flu for every age group bar the very young.

Covid + flu will be a very large amount for the NHS to manage.

Regarding 'how long should we carry on locking down' - below the level at which the NHS will be overwhelmed is the government's current position. A third wave could still go above this threshold despite the vaccinations (and no, that does not mean vaccinations were pointless, it would be approx ten times worse without them).*

Where to even start with this

Plumedenom · 18/05/2021 18:51

Fat chance. Until everyone has been offered and given time to get both jabs, they really can't start pointing the finger at the unvaccinated! There are plenty of immunocomoromised elderly people who may have had the vaccine but for whom it will do bugger all good because they don't develop the antibodies. Those people are only protected when the whole population is vaccinated.

picturesandpickles · 18/05/2021 18:22

@OlympicProcrastinator

But if the NHS wasn’t overwhelmed in 2014-2015 when there were over 20,000 flu deaths that winter and in previous years there are always at least 10,000 flu deaths in the UK annually, why would it be overwhelmed with Covid deaths? Why is ok for tens of thousands of people to die with flu each year but not from Covid? Flu is a worldwide endemic and kills hundreds of thousands globally each year. How long should we carry on locking down for? Until deaths are ‘only’ in the hundreds? Tens? Single digits? We are going to have to live with it? What if it never goes away and we can’t keep the number of deaths under a few hundred each year? Do we never live properly again??
One of the features of covid is the number of younger people who are severely affected, who spend longer spells in ICU/on ventilation.

Covid is much than flu for every age group bar the very young.

Covid + flu will be a very large amount for the NHS to manage.

Regarding 'how long should we carry on locking down' - below the level at which the NHS will be overwhelmed is the government's current position. A third wave could still go above this threshold despite the vaccinations (and no, that does not mean vaccinations were pointless, it would be approx ten times worse without them).

Iggly · 18/05/2021 18:15

@OlympicProcrastinator

But if the NHS wasn’t overwhelmed in 2014-2015 when there were over 20,000 flu deaths that winter and in previous years there are always at least 10,000 flu deaths in the UK annually, why would it be overwhelmed with Covid deaths? Why is ok for tens of thousands of people to die with flu each year but not from Covid? Flu is a worldwide endemic and kills hundreds of thousands globally each year. How long should we carry on locking down for? Until deaths are ‘only’ in the hundreds? Tens? Single digits? We are going to have to live with it? What if it never goes away and we can’t keep the number of deaths under a few hundred each year? Do we never live properly again??
The nhs was on its knees already and that’s why there was the worry about the annual flu season - because it put a strain on the NHS.

The answer is to fund the nhs properly and improve the health of our population. The latter would take an effort to improve education and the economic outlook of people - better housing, better paid jobs, better public transport etc.

The government is not interested in that. So the nhs continues to crumble.

freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 18:12

I am not sure anyone in the UK can pretend that the NHS wasn't overwhelmed before the pandemic when it was already an absolute shamble.

Covid would have just worsen an already dramatic and unreliable situation.

OlympicProcrastinator · 18/05/2021 18:08

But if the NHS wasn’t overwhelmed in 2014-2015 when there were over 20,000 flu deaths that winter and in previous years there are always at least 10,000 flu deaths in the UK annually, why would it be overwhelmed with Covid deaths? Why is ok for tens of thousands of people to die with flu each year but not from Covid? Flu is a worldwide endemic and kills hundreds of thousands globally each year. How long should we carry on locking down for? Until deaths are ‘only’ in the hundreds? Tens? Single digits? We are going to have to live with it? What if it never goes away and we can’t keep the number of deaths under a few hundred each year? Do we never live properly again??

Oblomov21 · 18/05/2021 18:00

Which is the best vaccine for COVID-19? The one you are offered

Do they cause COVID infection?
Vaccines don’t cause COVID. If you tested positive after the shot it’s real infection

Do they suppress immunity?
No, COVID vaccines don’t suppress immunity

When can you take them after having a COVID Infection?
in 4-wks after recovery

Can vaccines cause Clots?
Yes, 4 in a million. Significantly less than what HRT, Smoking, pregnancy, over weight and most importantly #COVID19 infection can cause.

Who’s responsible about spreading the word?
Everyone. Medical community ALONE cannot fix vaccine hesitancy. Media, politicians, religious leaders and EVERY influencer must do their part.

Some doctors are against the vaccine?
No evidence supporting their claims.

Do vaccines effect fertility?
NO

Do they work against spread of the virus?
Yes!
#COVID19 cases are down in countries with strong vaccinations programs and
Vaccines are widely available. Those fully vaccinated are less likely to transmit virus.
See the attached plot about spread of infection in the US after the huge program adopted there; similar trends are seen in the UK. The map summaries Vaccinations around the world. It’s a race against the variants.

Can you take the vaccine if you are pregnant or breastfeeding?
Yes.

Simply the alternative is you having a covid infection! Which can be fatal.
The Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI) has advised that pregnant women should be offered COVID-19 vaccines at the same time as people of the same age or risk group. In the USA, around 90,000 pregnant women have been vaccinated mainly with Pfizer and Moderna vaccines and no safety concerns have been identified.

CDC guidance USA:

www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/recommendations/pregnancy.html

GOV.Uk guidance:

www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-vaccination-women-of-childbearing-age-currently-pregnant-planning-a-pregnancy-or-breastfeeding/covid-19-vaccination-a-guide-for-women-of-childbearing-age-pregnant-planning-a-pregnancy-or-breastfeeding

Are they efficient?
Vaccines = 90-95% effective in real-world studies. Look at the US numbers again prior and after the vaccination program.

Does it decrease the transmission of infection and variants?
Yes, to the best of our knowledge, Vaccines are working against variants till now. Although many variants have been identified, the hospitalised numbers are still low. Evidence supports that those fully vaccinated are less likely to transmit virus ؜

Time intervals between vaccines?
It’s ok to get the 2nd dose at 4, 8 or 12 weeks. Countries delay second dose to manage supply constraints. Efficacy won’t be compromised

Do antibody tests have a role after vaccination?
There is no need check antibody levels after vaccination. More test, more confusion

#COVID19
#CoronavirusPandemic

Sh05 · 18/05/2021 17:42

@Theredjellybeaned
I stand corrected that there must be some who were refusers but it's not only about allergies is it? What about those who are on immuno-surpressants? I know some have been able to get the vaccine، others have been advised against it. I also know some people who delayed there jabs due to illness and other health problems. You can't blame them for not getting the vaccine asap if it wasn't possible for them.

The government want us to lay the blame on each other to deflect from themselves and they've successfully done just that.

freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 17:39

[quote BarbarianMum]@freakyfridays so what is it that you think the vaccine will do to a pregnant woman or fetus that the virus won't . And how - which bit of the vaccine is the problem?

Negative affects from the virus are far, far more common than those from vaccination, even if rare. And the virus is here, now. It's not like measles when you might not meet a case for years.[/quote]
Did you even bother to read my posts?

I am not saying it "have it" or "don't have it", I am saying that we have so little information about long-term effects that it's a really shit situation to be in when you are pregnant, and it's not such an easy decision to make when it's your own baby, despite what some silly posters pretend (or that they are talking on behalf of the entire medical community).

It's still a gamble over whether you might get covid in the next 6 to 8 months (or less if your pregnancy is even more advanced), and how you'll react to the jab and the completely unknown effects on your baby.

It''s not an easy decision, and it would be ridiculous to blame pregnant women to delay getting the jab for a few months. But compassion and common sense is always lacking on some posts.

Oblomov21 · 18/05/2021 17:29

I have to agree. I can't help it. If there's a valid reason ie pregnancy then that's different.

But absolute refusers? Zero sympathy. They've made their choice. Educated and informed choice I assume. So no, no allowances from me.

BarbarianMum · 18/05/2021 17:24

@freakyfridays so what is it that you think the vaccine will do to a pregnant woman or fetus that the virus won't . And how - which bit of the vaccine is the problem?

Negative affects from the virus are far, far more common than those from vaccination, even if rare. And the virus is here, now. It's not like measles when you might not meet a case for years.

freakyfridays · 18/05/2021 17:18

GappyValley

being rude because you don't agree with me doesn't make you right. Confused

Just implying that "anyone in the medical community" is in favour of vaccinating pregnant women shows you are confusing your own opinion and actual facts.

I totally understand that a pregnant woman who has chosen to have the jab will reject any post that it might have negative and long-term consequences on their unborn baby. Once it's done, of course you want to be right and everybody else to shut up, we got that.

GappyValley · 18/05/2021 16:53

@freakyfridays

Where are your facts that the vaccine will affect anyone negatively? Confused

maybe have a chat with doctors who had to deal with people who reacted badly for a start?
Where are your facts that the vaccine will not have any effect?

What we DO KNOW is the risk of covid and pregnancy.
Which in many cases are .. none. The risks of catching covid are pretty low at the moment in many places around the country - and all you have to do is refrain from flying on holiday until you have the baby.

I just strongly disagree with people pretending that it's such an "easy" choice to make for many people.

Your posts on this thread are the most textbook example I have ever seen of someone who doesn’t have the first clue about statistics or risk

And that post has to be the icing on the cake

Just mind boggling that you think your opinion should carry equal sway of anyone in the medical community when you don’t have even a primary level of understanding of the subject Confused

SoupDragon · 18/05/2021 16:18

A saw arm or a headache for a week isn’t really a life changing side affect.

Fatal blood clots are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread