Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can my ex claim back maintenance?

145 replies

ConfusedCarrie · 06/05/2021 21:32

My DS is 10. His DF left in 2013. When he left, he contacted the CSA and told me he would voluntarily pay me £350 per month. I have no idea what he earned. He did say that he had rounded it up to make it a better number. By how much, I don't know. FF to 2021 and I am struggling financially. My hours have been cut drastically and my DS has outgrown all his clothes and I have our mortgage to pay. I asked if ExH would just consider an increase in his maintenance. He said he couldn't afford to, he's struggling financially because of Covid (he's a keyworker so no change in wages and he has no mortgage or rent). He says he has been in contact with the CMS and he has been overpaying me, I'm entitled to £210 per month. The CMS have said he can claim back all the money he has over paid.

YABU - of course I should pay it back, I wasn't entitled to it.
YANBU - he knowingly and voluntarily overpaid so I should not have to pay to back.

OP posts:
Rejoiningperson · 07/05/2021 22:58

@Thepennyhasdroppedq

YABU. You shouldn't of asked him for more money. £350 is a lot of money each month.
I cannot believe that in modern times people would be openly trying to reduce financial security for any child, and to enable men to scrape the bare minimum for their kids, and prop up misogynistic and evasive funding of the costs of children.

If he could afford to pay it, why should he hang onto his money and not fund his children’s upbringing? You couldn’t rent a room for £350 in most places in the UK let alone feed, clothe etc

Unbelievable that anyone would prop up men keeping their money for themselves and not their family.

Rejoiningperson · 07/05/2021 22:54

The CMS is not a ‘fair division’ of what it costs to bring up a child.

It is the minimum enforceable amount.

That is a key difference and it’s crazy that anyone would actually think the CMS is able to calculate what a child needs in terms of costs. It doesn’t. It’s just a fail safe for people who are too mean to pay more!

Hawkins001 · 07/05/2021 22:49

All the best op

Wishitsnows · 07/05/2021 22:40

He sounds like a complete nob. Glad you are going to CMS, yes he will pay the government bare minimum requirement rather than do the best for his child but its so laughable that he thinks he can get back payments.

Thepennyhasdroppedq · 07/05/2021 22:39

So you can't buy your child clothes out the £350 he pays you each month? Where are you buying your clothes from designer village? Sorry to be rude but asking someone for more money while they are giving you £350 a month and struggling themselves is ludicrous

Thepennyhasdroppedq · 07/05/2021 22:36

YABU. You shouldn't of asked him for more money. £350 is a lot of money each month.

CombatBarbie · 07/05/2021 20:15

He doesn't have to provide his p60, they go direct to HMRC, one of the benefits of the new system so there is no attempts to delay or fudge figures.

I think your in for a nice increase OP. I went from voluntary 170 to CMS 289 a month.

harknesswitch · 07/05/2021 20:06

He will have to provide his P60 to the cms so it won't just go on his say so.

Good for you for putting a claim in. My ex moaned like a good un when I did it, but it saves any arguments and meant when he argued the toss I said it wasn't my decision it was the cms's

ConfusedCarrie · 07/05/2021 19:52

@NeverDropYourMoonCup
I have asked "is that what you want to do?" And he has said yes that way I get what I'm entitled to Hmm. He send the message via WhatsApp so I have it in writing Grin

OP posts:
ConfusedCarrie · 07/05/2021 19:49

LaurieFairyCake

OP can you come back when you've opened a CMS case and got your first payment please?

We could run a book on how much you get

I'm picking £550 a month ..

Definitely.

For everyone saying why am I believing him, everything Google showed me backed him up but logic told me no. He is adamant I would have to pay him.

He has no other kids. My other DC father pays nothing (CMS do a direct pay and he quits) and he has just found out. Tonight I've had the whole "I'm not paying for them" speech Hmm

I have phoned the CMS and no I don't need to pay it back but I can't claim underpayment either. I have given them all his details as far as I know them (he is very secretive). Claim started so watch this space Grin

OP posts:
ConfusedCarrie · 07/05/2021 19:34

Silly man! It's not a debt, it's him giving maintenance. If it went any further a solicitor would point out that he voluntarily gave this amount each month to support his son. No one forced him. If he'd felt he couldn't afford it he could have got CMS involved earlier.
I didn't think of it that way

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMoonCup · 07/05/2021 16:12

Go through the CMS and if he asks why 'oh, well, I thought it would be best for them to adjust for any overpayment rather than risk them making a mistake and taking too much from you'

As though you actually believed the bollocks that was coming out of his mouth and it's all his fault that you went to them...

knittingaddict · 07/05/2021 15:47

@ivegotthisyeah

Wow I am in this exact position but scared to go to CMS incase I have to pay back his voluntary payments which were more that cms calculated so I'll be even worse off as my ex has made up a figure and that's what I now get. I have messaged Cms to ask this very question so will update you all!
We already know the answer, thanks. You won't have to pay it back.
Bibidy · 07/05/2021 15:44

@ivegotthisyeah

Wow I am in this exact position but scared to go to CMS incase I have to pay back his voluntary payments which were more that cms calculated so I'll be even worse off as my ex has made up a figure and that's what I now get. I have messaged Cms to ask this very question so will update you all!
I honestly don't think there's any way you would have to pay voluntary payments back.

The only way I could ever see any money going back in the other direction is if it was in a case where CMS was taking the money from the NRP and they had accidentally taken the wrong amount.

JustLyra · 07/05/2021 15:19

@ivegotthisyeah

Wow I am in this exact position but scared to go to CMS incase I have to pay back his voluntary payments which were more that cms calculated so I'll be even worse off as my ex has made up a figure and that's what I now get. I have messaged Cms to ask this very question so will update you all!
CMS categorically don’t get involved with anything before you open a case.

Can you imagine the outrage if it was possible for a RP to suddenly put in a backdated CMS claim chasing years of non-payment or under-payment?

It’s the same thing. Until you open a claim they don’t have any involvement or care of what went on between you.

ivegotthisyeah · 07/05/2021 15:17

Wow I am in this exact position but scared to go to CMS incase I have to pay back his voluntary payments which were more that cms calculated so I'll be even worse off as my ex has made up a figure and that's what I now get. I have messaged Cms to ask this very question so will update you all!

Bibidy · 07/05/2021 15:04

I think the best thing you can do is go to CSA yourself and have it assessed officially, but obviously beware that it could go up or down for you. There is no way you will be asked to pay back something he gave you voluntarily though, definitely not.

He said he couldn't afford to, he's struggling financially because of Covid (he's a keyworker so no change in wages and he has no mortgage or rent).

I don't think you can assume his financial situation to such an extent really, he could have had a paycut/change in hours like you, or any number of other things.

I think potentially you might also need to look for some light on the horizon with your own job - maybe contact HR and question them about when/whether they intend to increase your hours again, or start looking for something else.

Realistically the CM you receive from your ex doesn't depend on what you earn, he's not really responsible for making up the wages that you've lost, in the same way he shouldn't have to give you less if you got a payrise.

Graphista · 07/05/2021 14:02

No. The cms amount is a MINIMUM required amount, he agreed to pay more that was his choice he has no right to ask for it back now. Also cms amounts are pathetic anyway

If he's a keyworker do you know what his salary is? If so you can check on the cms calculator yourself what he should be paying as a MINIMUM.

Stand up for your dc and yourself

sofato5miles · 07/05/2021 13:49

Why oh why do posters say things like "ooh that's loads i get 20p a month for 7". It is entirely unhelpful and is frankly ignorant.

SleepingStandingUp · 07/05/2021 13:44

Bollocks.

He's lying to manipulate you.

19lottie82 · 07/05/2021 13:42

I googled the average salary for a Tesco area manager and it’s 50k ish. Then put it into the CMS calculator based on your circumstances, he has no other kids, 1 child stays with other parent less than one night a week and it says he should be paying £477 a month. Go to the CMS and put in a claim.

LaurieFairyCake · 07/05/2021 13:41

OP can you come back when you've opened a CMS case and got your first payment please? Grin

We could run a book on how much you get

I'm picking £550 a month ...

BoomBoomsCousin · 07/05/2021 13:36

[quote ConfusedCarrie]@mainsfed 1p a week. I can do that 🤣
@BoomBoomsCousin He works for a supermarket as a area manager.

He has DS 1-2 nights a month. The arrangement is every other weekend but he never has him Friday. He picks him up Saturday and brings him home Sunday. He often bails on at least one weekend overnight and sees him for a couple of hours instead.[/quote]
According to Glassdoor, typical salary for an area manager for Morrison’s is £120k+ a year (plus bonus)

The CMS calculator gives a payment of £850 a month on that base salary even if he had your DS 1 night a week. £1k a month if you use the actual number of nights DS stays.

Now he may not be on quite that much, and if he pays maintenance for other kids or lives with someone with kids then that could reduce things a bit. But seems highly unlikely it would be pulling the number down close to the £200 a month he suggested.

ALevelhelp · 07/05/2021 09:28

@harknesswitch

My exdh had me thinking he was on about 30k a year. For 4 years he paid cm based on that. I eventually went via cms for various reasons, he was earning 64k Confused strangely enough when he found out how much he'd have to pay he suddenly wanted 50/50 care. It never came to that once he realised he'd actually have to 'care' for his dc. But I'll never trust a word he says, he wanted me to close the cms case once it had all been settled, I'm presuming because he doesn't want them to check each year and include any bonus or salary increase. I told him to bugger off.
I'd be so ashamed of myself, who do these "parents" think they are?
ALevelhelp · 07/05/2021 09:27

My Ex has conveniently not got his tax form in on time 2 years in a row, so when the annual CMS renewal comes in it's always zero! HmmAngry. Out the kindness of his heart, he gives a set amount a week - lucky me. He's always been a bit of a wheeler dealer so I'm sure he's working on the side, I just can't prove it and TBH can't be bothered to prove it - I'm lucky to be in a position that I don't need his sodding money to live on. It's his ex wife I feel for, she has two children with him and I hope he pays more to her