Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask: do you have an inner-monologue?

529 replies

allthatgrace · 03/05/2021 21:32

I don't have an inner-monologue and never realised that some people do. My thoughts are rapid, abstract and conceptual rather than verbal.

For example, if I am thinking that I'm hungry and want to start making dinner it takes the form of something like: concept of hunger+concept of dinner+concept of it being the evening/dinner time. After speaking to my family members they would have an inner-voice that actually says "I'm hungry, I think I'll go start dinner".

I have also always been confused about the idea of having an inner-critic that berates you. I've never heard an inner-voice say, for example, "nobody cares what you have to say, don't bother speaking, everything you say is stupid", instead I would just feel the sensation of shyness and wanting to stay quiet.

I can make myself have an inner-voice and I will use it occasionally, for example if I'm trying to remember a particular phrase or something but my default thinking is not an inner-monologue.

Which kind of thoughts do you have?

OP posts:
Panda2021 · 03/05/2021 23:19

So interesting, my husband doesn’t read the same way as me- I read aloud in my head and he doesn’t he said she just sees the worlds and knows the meanings like @Bluebutterfly36 described. Also no internal chitter or monologue for him unlike me , there’s times he says he seeing my mouth move as if I’m chatting to myself silently- most likely going over a conversation- real or not!

Teenagehorrorbag · 03/05/2021 23:17

@FortunesFave

I narrate myself a lot. "She walked down the stairs and turned the light on. It was raining..."

It drives me bonkers at times!

OMG I should have RTFT earlier - this is exactly what I was referring to in my earlier post, but I thought I was a complete weirdo and nobody else ever did it....!

I think I did it more as a child - but nice to know I'm not totally odd....Smile.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/05/2021 23:13

@Bluebutterfly36

that is absolutely fascinating and very unusual to remember them the next day, especially in detail? I always forget mine within a few hours of waking or just hazy recollections. I am really intrigued by dreams! My worst one was when I dreamt I was made of ice and I was slowly melting!! Do you think your dreams have any connection to real life?

Oh wow that one sounds scary!

They don't tend to correlate with real life at all, though I have a few times told myself what to dream about and I have done.

I remember them to the extent I would remember a film - I can remember all of this week's for example, and a few of the last months particularly weird ones.

They are so specific, so random and so all consuming that it baffles me!

I have epilepsy too and nights I have seizures that experience is tenfold. My neurologist mentioned that my body seems to try and make sense of the seizures through dreams - so if I have a dream I'm flying through the air for example, I'll now notice that in the morning my wrists and ankles are particularly sore and my partner will
Confirm that in that particular overnight seizure I was massively flexing those joints downwards as if pushing up. Hence the feeling of projecting through the air.

I love our brains, they're incredible.

I've also had a dream of a children's book plot which was then picked up and published. Ditto with ideas for work campaigns sometimes - which then feels a bit like cheating as was it 'me' or dream me who came up with the concept?!

ErrolTheDragon · 03/05/2021 23:12

I definitely don’t have a constant voice talking in my head, but there are never no thoughts. I’m constantly thinking, just not always in words. I can think using words and my inner voice but it’s much quicker to think without words.

So to all the people who are asking if it’s quiet without constant voices in your head, it’s definitely not quiet. It’s not an absence of thought.

How do you work through options and solutions to problems quickly if you have to have all your thoughts by saying them in your head? Doesn’t that take ages?

.....

Not everything is in words for me.

So if I'm (for example) putting together IKEA furniture I might crack on with it without any words.

Yeah. It's a mix. I write scientific software and I definitely don't come up with what I'm going to do in words - sometimes it's sort of visualising what I need to do, sometimes... well, probably by definition hard to put into words what exactly the nonverbal thinking is! Sometimes I'll be doing the garden or making dinner and verbally think 'oh yes, I know what to do...'

Our ancestors must have been able to think before they had words. I suspect that for most people there must be a lot more non verbal thinking going on than you realise.

Heartofstrings · 03/05/2021 23:12

I've read the whole thread and so think I'm the first person to say this. I used to have a really active and racing internal monologue but in my mid twenties had a massive breakdown. Took me 12 months to recover. During this time I couldn't handle and external stimulus like tv or radio. I'm not sure when exactly, but the monologue also switched off at the same time. It's never returned. I now get nothing apart from the odd passing thought

Teenagehorrorbag · 03/05/2021 23:10

@Shadedog

Mine is constant and can be very intrusive when I’m tired. It shouts and sings loudly so I can’t sleep then I get more tired and it goes on and on. Often Beethoven’s 5th. I’m not musical, I never listen to music so it’s all the more frustrating. Over the last few years ive trained it to tell me bedtime stories and I can drop off in 5 mins like that. It’s a good storyteller.
OMG that is so me! It only sings songs that I've heard recently - but the DCs know not to sing certain earworms near me or I will suffer for hours. But I do have a couple of stories that I tell myself when I want to go to sleep - because it will stop me thinking about other things that keep me awake.

Are we weird - I thought everyone had this?

Claymorekick · 03/05/2021 23:08

I have asphantia and do not have an inner monologue - wonder if the 2 are connected Confused

I do replay conversations in my head if I am troubled by them and 'rewrite' them or plan a tricky conversation I might be due to have but generally no, I would never say to myself 'oh I'm hungry, it's dinner time, better go and make some food's- it is definitely just abstract concepts as the OP describes.

I cannot visualise anything at all which is pretty shit tbh. I probably border on being a maladaptive daydreamer but there are no proper visual images attached to them (weird I know) - but I can still 'see' what is happening and put words to it and could describe it perfectly but can't actually picture it. God knows how much time I would spend daydreaming if I could actually see them Grin

littlepieces · 03/05/2021 23:06

I have near constant dialogue with myself in my head unless focused on an intricate task. I'm a chronic daydreamer and procrastinator. An old housemate of mine said she used to solely think in colours, images and numbers which I just couldn't understand!

Bluebutterfly36 · 03/05/2021 23:05

@youvegottenminuteslynn

I also have incredibly vivid dreams and always remember them, in detail, the next day. They are honestly cinematic in detail and complexity - to the point I am impressed my brain can conjure them up! Is this something most people experience? If not, what does dreaming look like to you?
@ youvegottenminuteslynn that is absolutely fascinating and very unusual to remember them the next day, especially in detail? I always forget mine within a few hours of waking or just hazy recollections. I am really intrigued by dreams! My worst one was when I dreamt I was made of ice and I was slowly melting!! Do you think your dreams have any connection to real life?
baroqueandblue · 03/05/2021 23:04

I can identify with pretty much everyone on here who has said they have ADHD, which is quite shocking for me. Perhaps I need to look into it, might explain a lot of my struggles.

My inner voice is constant and not just my own either! I even frequently imagine what people who overlook me and can see through my windows are thinking about what I'm doing as I do it. Pretty much every move I make is announced to myself beforehand, and then accompanied by other thoughts that I can hear as I'm doing stuff. Definitely a verbal processor, in fact I rarely just look at objects, usually I'm aware of the word for the object as I look at it. I dream a fair bit and have very visual memories of them, but I struggle to visualize deliberately. It's more that I can see what I'm thinking of on some faint layer of awareness that's not in the forefront of my mind.

Constantly ruminate on all sorts of memories, mistakes, regrets, dead people, anxieties, and it's all verbal. Everything I read I 'hear' in my head, predominantly in my own voice but will also do accents and stuff for characters. When watching telly I have a pretty constant commentary going on.

I could say so much more about this, but the realisation that some people don't experience day to day life in this way is astounding to me, and very poignant. I can't even hold a job down because of the way my mind works, I imagine the worst about what people are thinking of me so much that I then can't believe it's not real. And mostly that side of things is persecutory.

Teenagehorrorbag · 03/05/2021 23:03

I massively talk in my head, and when I was young I would talk in the third person - as in 'she walked down the street to see her friend....' etc. That started about age 3 and I think carried on until about 10.

I am a very aural person - always revised for exams best by talking through with peers and testing each other etc. I love listening to the radio. I have often wondered how deaf people can dream because my dreams are very chatty. But then I could say the same about blindness....?

When I was in France I would find my inner monologue being in French - albeit very bad French....

My DCs are not aural at all. DS is autistic. After reading Temple Grandin, she says she sees everything like a video clip, so maybe DS does too. I found that fascinating but couldn't relate - but DD is not autistic and yet she says she is the same. She doesn't think in words, but pictures. It opened my eyes to how different we all are....

But I know other people are different.

paniniswapx3 · 03/05/2021 23:02

I'm the same as you Op. I didn't realise people had an inner monologue until a couple of years ago when a friend was diagnosed with anxiety and depression and was reading a self help book that she said perfectly described what was going on in her head - I tried reading it but couldn't get into it as it just wasn't something I've ever experienced.

Ikeameatballs · 03/05/2021 23:01

As my kids have got older and sat in the front passenger seat of the car they have noticed than, as I’m driving (automatic) I use my left hand to gesture....in the conversation that I am having with myself.

I can also remember things that I have read pretty much exactly as I have read them. So as I remember it is as if I have the book open and I’m reading from it again. My auditory processing for things that I have heard is much worse. DP on the other hand can recall exactly dialogue that he has heard in a film or as apart of a conversation.

Shadedog · 03/05/2021 23:01

Mine is constant and can be very intrusive when I’m tired. It shouts and sings loudly so I can’t sleep then I get more tired and it goes on and on. Often Beethoven’s 5th. I’m not musical, I never listen to music so it’s all the more frustrating. Over the last few years ive trained it to tell me bedtime stories and I can drop off in 5 mins like that. It’s a good storyteller.

BananaPie · 03/05/2021 22:59

@wheresmymojo “The voice inside my head is much quicker than talking out loud though I think because you're not actually having to sound anything out.”

I think that’s what I’m saying - I’m constantly thinking, but definitely not sounding out all the words. The inner monologue people seem to be saying there are always words going on in their heads

ofwarren · 03/05/2021 22:58

@gah2teenagers
I always have a song, at all times. I monologue over the song and it's there when I'm not thinking of anything in particular.

Pieceofpurplesky · 03/05/2021 22:57

I am a visual thinker and see myself having conversations - I am also a maladaptive daydreamer. It's fun in my head sometimes - but it never bloody stops

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/05/2021 22:57

I also have incredibly vivid dreams and always remember them, in detail, the next day. They are honestly cinematic in detail and complexity - to the point I am impressed my brain can conjure them up! Is this something most people experience? If not, what does dreaming look like to you?

Bluebutterfly36 · 03/05/2021 22:57

@Gilead

Most of the time my eyes skim over several words and I understand the meaning so I process the meaning of a sentence rather than hear the individual words. If I'm struggling to concentrate I will have to slow down and read the words in my head, but I find that frustrating to do. I’m sorry, I don’t understand what’s happening in your head when your (nearest I can get) assimilating the words on the page.
@gilead I do this too. I can skim-read hundreds of pages of text very quickly and just pick out the relevant bits I need to know (and ignore the rest). My brain just subconsciously processes the words without me registering them as words. I would not skim read like this if reading a book to relax, but I still read quickly - the images from the words just appear instantly in my mind without the words forming. I’m not sure if that is a very good explanation Confused
gah2teenagers · 03/05/2021 22:56

[quote DazzlingHaze]@gah2teenagers how strange, we just posted about the song thing at the same time! [/quote]
I definitely can’t play a whole album !

Livpool · 03/05/2021 22:56

I do this before I fall asleep (probably makes me crazy)

A-Z of counties
A-Z of world cities
A-Z names

It takes me a while to get to sleep and this my version of counting sheep

BrightYellowDaffodil · 03/05/2021 22:53

I narrate myself a lot. "She walked down the stairs and turned the light on. It was raining..."

I do this too, slightly differently though - it’s as if I’m describing myself to someone else.

Much as my.p brain does chatter I find it quite easy to stop thinking. I can have quite long periods of “brain silence” if I want, although it’s a conscious effort.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/05/2021 22:52

@apalledandshocked

Like a screen, but its 3-d and interactive if that makes sense. So I can imagine a flat image of a kettle. I can then make it an actual 3-d kettle, I can pull the kettle closer to me or rotate it. I can put it in a kitchen. I can then put the kitchen around me so I am standing in the kitchen with the kettle in front of me. Wierdly I can then get rid of the kitchen but I cant make the kettle 2-d again. All I can do is turn it into a picture of a kettle but then its an actual picture on a piece of paper and the paper is 3-d

EXACTLY this for me. I can manipulate the image in the way you describe, so change the colour, size etc. I thought everyone could do this bit so it's fascinating to hear that other people don't.

Livpool · 03/05/2021 22:51

I have a constant one too - it never shuts up!

thegreylady · 03/05/2021 22:51

Yes. I tell myself stories in my head before I can sleep. I have done it all my life the stories evolve but sometimes I tell the same part over and over again to get it just right.