Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask: do you have an inner-monologue?

529 replies

allthatgrace · 03/05/2021 21:32

I don't have an inner-monologue and never realised that some people do. My thoughts are rapid, abstract and conceptual rather than verbal.

For example, if I am thinking that I'm hungry and want to start making dinner it takes the form of something like: concept of hunger+concept of dinner+concept of it being the evening/dinner time. After speaking to my family members they would have an inner-voice that actually says "I'm hungry, I think I'll go start dinner".

I have also always been confused about the idea of having an inner-critic that berates you. I've never heard an inner-voice say, for example, "nobody cares what you have to say, don't bother speaking, everything you say is stupid", instead I would just feel the sensation of shyness and wanting to stay quiet.

I can make myself have an inner-voice and I will use it occasionally, for example if I'm trying to remember a particular phrase or something but my default thinking is not an inner-monologue.

Which kind of thoughts do you have?

OP posts:
HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 15:50

@ofwarren

Those with no inner dialogue, are you able to rehearse for an interview in your head? Like, go over the possible questions and your answers?
Aaargh the incredibly awful "rehearse in front of the mirror" advice! I can't do it. I think through possible questions they might ask and often write these down. Then spend some time considering answers. I'll maybe look over the list again before the interview and mentally check off that yes, I could answer all of these, so be calm!! Grin Hate interviews. But no I wouldn't rehearse something word for word as that would be like a script and unnatural I think?
HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 15:47

[quote ofwarren]@Halyconsea
I have words in my head but also thoughts, concepts, images, feelings, smells, emotions, memories.
It isn't just words and it isn't lesser than those who don't have words. In fact, I'd say it's more. It's variable. If I follow a thought, it turns into words but it's a whole experience with words along side it. [/quote]
I wasn't meaning to imply it is lesser. I do think it would be limiting in some ways as I've described, to have words distracting from thought all the time. But I suppose there must also be benefits to this or we would not have evolved with so many people having different brains. I just can't imagine it! Even though much of what I've studied and my work is focused on language, I cannot imagine thinking in words. I translate thoughts to words as best I can, when I need to share my thoughts with others - and often badly I guess hence accidentally offending people! I am very excited to discover people's internal worlds are so diverse and am still trying to wrap my head around it; I apologise if what I said came across as disparaging, that was not intentional. I have found this thread absolutely fascinating.

ofwarren · 04/05/2021 15:43

Those with no inner dialogue, are you able to rehearse for an interview in your head? Like, go over the possible questions and your answers?

HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 15:39

@ErrolTheDragon

HalcyonSea's posts, especially the one at 1:45 express much I agree with . (words do have their uses. Grin communication, and 'thinking about thought'.)

I would be curious to know if the different modes of thinking described on the thread correspond with peoples aptitudes and chosen professions. I can't imagine doing maths and science without a mix of them.

Musicians? Artists? A poet may obviously work in the medium of words but Wordsworth refers to his 'inward eye'.

This is a good point. My presumption from some work in both fields is that artists think in images and "re-create" what's in their minds in the real world. And musicians similarly think in sounds. No words describing a picture or the construction of the music. Different ideas/ memories lend themselves to different types of thought or memory where you imagine or re-live the sensation/ smell/ vision/ sound/ taste in your head, for me anyway. And the feeling it gave you. Or the abstract thoughts it stimulated. Not something expressed in words, unless the memory/ imaginary thing itself was of a conversation.
ofwarren · 04/05/2021 15:30

@Halyconsea
I have words in my head but also thoughts, concepts, images, feelings, smells, emotions, memories.
It isn't just words and it isn't lesser than those who don't have words. In fact, I'd say it's more. It's variable. If I follow a thought, it turns into words but it's a whole experience with words along side it.

HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 15:24

[quote Mrsdarwin]@HalcyonSea I have an inner monologue but I also see visual images etc.

It’s like I’m talking to myself constantly. If I’m making a decision i will think do I need this, am I hungry, should I go park there? Etc.

I would probably say it’s like talking in front of a painting / visual image for me. Like I’m talking to myself 🤣[/quote]
Oh nooooo! Like an endless zoom meeting!!! ShockGrin

HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 15:23

When I go walking/running I rarely listen to music or podcasts because I love the time to talk with myself or whoever (in my head) I am walking with.

Goodness. Physical activity for me is a way I can just tune into my body and nothing else and clear my mind of all thoughts. Chattering in my head, or music etc, would be awful!

So fascinating how differently our minds work. It just highlights how you can never really know how somebody else experiences the world. We see only 5% of what goes on in other's minds at most times, I think. For oversharers maybe it gets to 30%! 😂

HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 15:20

Just out of interest, are those of you who do not have an inner monologue extrovert?

No, I am very introverted. I like people, in small doses. Provided they aren't noisy or irritating. But am happy to spend days or weeks totally alone (or would be given a chance these days!!)

HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 15:16

Ah I guess you said it's your voice thinking. That's the difference. How can a voice think? It only talks. Grin It's your mind that thinks.

HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 15:08

It's not "voices in your head though" it's your own voice thinking instead of talking.

But that's what those of us do who don't have the monologue: we think which is ideas, abstracts, concepts. What people have been describing is thinking "in words" which is really odd; so limiting in terms of the concepts accessible, bound by your own language and expressible concepts in it. And very slow and imprecise, like language, due to its nature. To think "in words" seems to be what people mean by a monologue and I'm so surprised and fascinated to discover this is how many people think, I had no idea. Rather than thinking then "translating" their thoughts into words as best they can when needed, within the limitations of the shared language of the person they are conversing with.

E.g. a 3 year old can have emotions and thoughts that they wouldn't be able to put into words even in one language until maybe 10 years old. If they limited their thoughts to just what they could find words for, they would not develop how they do. Language is for communicating as best we can but it isn't and can't express the sum of human experience, thought and understanding. I think that similarly, as an adult, limiting your own thoughts to only what can be said in words you know to use as a shared approximate reference point with others would inevitably keep your thought forever at a lower level of complexity and nuance and depth and limit conceptual connectivity between ideas.

TrulyOutrageousJem · 04/05/2021 15:05

No internal monologue here but I think the topic is fascinating.

Stillgoings · 04/05/2021 15:01

Yes I do.
Mine uses the royal we. Shall we see what there is in for tea? We had best go the toilet etc.
It also has a nasty side and shouts Stupid cow and wtf did you do that for? often.
I also do a lot of explaining/narrating in my head in the form of emails or diary entries that i will never write and go over a lot of old ground.

If things are quiet my internal voice (and it does sound like me) likes to chant the names of colours i can see. I don't know where this came from but i do it without thinking and have done for years. Don't know what it is all about.

HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 14:58

"DinosaurDiana I can’t imagine not having something going on in your head. It must be bliss."

"Yes, my inner voice is constantly waking me up at inappropriate times"

That's a misinterpretation, based on my personal experience. My head is busy flitting between emotions and conceptual thoughts and connecting between them. It's only "quiet" in the sense that these are ideas, thoughts, feelings, images: not voices or words. I agree though my inner world does sound like bliss compared to what you're describing, I'd go bonkers if there was constant chatter inside my head, literally can't imagine it. I feel such relief when I'm away from other people's chatter, it seems masochistic to then inflict more of it on yourself! 😆

AryaStarkWolf · 04/05/2021 14:53

@Confuzzlediddled

Nope nothing here, no voices and no pictures, I can't imagine having voices in my head!
It's not "voices in your head though" it's your own voice thinking instead of talking

*Although I wouldn't mind having Morgan Freeman narrate my life :p

HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 14:52

@nocoolnamesleft

Not constant, but yes to an inner monologue. Minimal mind's eye.
But a mind's eye sees, it doesn't talk! Grin
AryaStarkWolf · 04/05/2021 14:51

I've had this discussion before with people and I honestly can't wrap my head around the idea of not having an inner monologue, I just can't understand how you could go though life without one, it must be really boring!

HalcyonSea · 04/05/2021 14:51

@Campervan69

I have a constant inner monologue. I'm also a maladaptive daydreamer though and I don't think you can be a daydreamer without one. I'm very happy in my own company. I've often wondered if that's because I'm very chatty with myself

Are you me? Nothing I like better than whiling away the day lying in the sun and daydreaming.

Oh, you can definitely daydream without a monologue going on!!! I would find chattering during my daydreams incredibly irritating.
Frymetothemoon · 04/05/2021 14:50

@DinosaurDiana

I can’t imagine not having something going on in your head. It must be bliss.
Yes, my inner voice is constantly waking me up at inappropriate times
Belindabelle · 04/05/2021 14:45

There was a fantastic thread on here a few years ago about maladaptive daydreaming. I do this and I have always talked to myself of have conversations with other people in my head.

As a young child I had imaginary friends and I can still remember in great detail all about them. I have very vivid memories of my childhood going back to the age of 2.5.

When I go walking/running I rarely listen to music or podcasts because I love the time to talk with myself or whoever (in my head) I am walking with.

Often on here I will instantly reply to a thread in my head but I don’t actually write my reply then I get confused when the thread doesn’t appear on my watch list.

Often when I cook I narrate the whole thing like I am giving a cookery demonstration. Or I dance or sing on stage in my head when I listen to music.

SD1978 · 04/05/2021 14:23

I have an internal monologue/ dialogue, but don't have the ability to picture things in my head, so can't imagine a tree, now imagine it's growing, etc. I know what a tree is, and what a big tree is, but can't do that meditative imagine stuff- I see no pictures in my head, but I do have extremely overly vivid dreams

Lazierdays · 04/05/2021 14:23

Yes I have an inner monologue but not really a minds eye. My thoughts are narrated rather than viewed. I would love a good minds eye where I could watch films rather than just listening to the radio Grin.

TheAirbender · 04/05/2021 14:20

Yes I do. Just been diagnosed with ADHD and I think it’s linked.

Confuzzlediddled · 04/05/2021 14:18

Nope nothing here, no voices and no pictures, I can't imagine having voices in my head!

nocoolnamesleft · 04/05/2021 14:16

Not constant, but yes to an inner monologue. Minimal mind's eye.

Campervan69 · 04/05/2021 14:12

I have a constant inner monologue. I'm also a maladaptive daydreamer though and I don't think you can be a daydreamer without one. I'm very happy in my own company. I've often wondered if that's because I'm very chatty with myself

Are you me? Nothing I like better than whiling away the day lying in the sun and daydreaming.

Swipe left for the next trending thread