Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that your if daughter tells you she feels the same as Elliot Page

207 replies

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 08:46

... To please explore all the reasons why she might feel intensely uncomfortable with her growing female body, and not just assume she's transgender?

There's such an epidemic of sexual assault, harassment and sexualised bullying towards girls of all ages. Kids are exposed to violent porn from the moment they can use a phone. Eating disorders are exploding, further evidence that hatred of bodies is rife among young people. Adolescence has always been a storm of hormones and emotions, girls have always discovered that their bodies are treated as public property but that is so much worse now.

If your daughter hates her female body please don't assume she's transgender. She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. She needs your help to discover how women throughout time have helped each other navigate this experience, looked after each other, and organised together to change things.

OP posts:
Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 01/05/2021 11:15

The whole trans thing has been blown out of proportion by people with an interest in keeping people on drugs or prepubescent. I’d tell her to start loving herself and not worry about anything else. Good self image is important as today’s society doesn’t help.

terfinginthevoid · 01/05/2021 11:14

@brainwave89

‘Gender dysmorphia is a well diagnosed condition’

All this means is that some people experience gender dysmorphia and their symptoms have been described. Psychiatry is very different from the rest of medicine. The existence of a recognised diagnosis doesn’t mean anything is understood about the aetiology of the condition, or that there is an effective treatment.

Even in adults there is no strong evidence that medical and surgical transition is the best way to treat gender dysphoria.

puppychaos · 01/05/2021 11:14

@Branleuse in the case of my mum she really did wholeheartedly support me. She's bisexual and has lots of transgender friends and saw it as her responsibility to support me. She supported me just as much when I decided that I wasn't a man and came out (again) as a lesbian, but she really didn't do it to keep me in her good books!

JellySlice · 01/05/2021 11:12

[quote Brainwave89]@JellySlice. Sorry but I do not agree. Gender dysmorphia is a well diagnosed condition. There will be some girls and boys who will wish to transition and will need support in doing so. I agree there may be other things that are contributing to a desire to be different and careful consideration is required, but some people genuinely need to transition.[/quote]
Doesn't change anything, though. None of the other dysmorphias are treated by causing permanent harm to the patient's body, not by obliging society to affirm their distorted self-image.

There is growing evidence that physical transition rarely leads to long-term improvement in the person's mental health, and that the happiest transitions are those well recognise that they remain the sex they were observed to be at birth and have simply modified their bodies to more closely resemble the sex they wish they were.

To treat people with respect and compassion you have to be honest and realistic. Lies and pretence do not help in the long run. It is unkind to lie and pretend something that can never come true

Branleuse · 01/05/2021 11:11

@puppychaos

Oh I don't know. I came out as a trans man when I was 15. It was right for me at the time and being validated by my mum did help a whole lot in at least giving me the space to explore that posibility.

I'm not a trans man now, several years later. I'm non binary but identify more with womanhood in a political sense than I do with manhood, and don't (and never have) taken blockers or T. But I do also think I would still be quite miserable today if I wasn't given the option to explore being a trans man. It helped me understand my gender identity and sexuality on a level that I wouldn't have been able to do, otherwise.

Thats quite sweet. I wonder what your mum really thought about it. I know people who have been quite supportive and validated their kids identity yet it was a strategy to keep a positive relationship with their child - ie they didnt actually believe it. Another friend believes that boy or girl is actually a feeling for real, so there is no cognitive disonnance there. I guess it depends on what gender means to them too, and their own experience with identity
Snoozer11 · 01/05/2021 11:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

puppychaos · 01/05/2021 11:06

[quote IheartJKR]@puppychaos

I’m glad you had support from your mum Flowers[/quote]
Thank you. Having someone happily use my chosen name and he/him pronouns helped me realise that it wasn't for me. I would still be stuck in utter turmoil if I hadn't have had that support - that's why it's important to support children who do have feelings around being transgender: because it truly gives them the space to figure it out.

ArabellaScott · 01/05/2021 11:05

YANBU, OP.

Children and young people need proper support, not unquestioning 'affirmation'.

No ideology that requires extensive and sometimes dangerous medical treatments on a healthy body sounds like something that children and young people should be encouraged to align with.

There is no such thing as the 'wrong body'.

TheGlassBlowersDaughter · 01/05/2021 11:05

@Mumoblue

I think a lot of the problem is people assuming that their body needs to be making a statement about who they are. Maybe this doesn’t make sense, but it seems like a lot of people lately view their body as something separate from them, so I’m not surprised they feel disconnected from it.

I think if young girls have body issues, while body positivity can be kindly meant, it’s sometimes more helpful just to view your body as you. Focus on the things it can do for you rather than it making any kind of statement.

This is coming from someone who struggled with gender confusion in my early 20s (though I never really spoke to anyone about it until after I had sorted through it by myself). While transitioning can be helpful for adults, I think more focus should be on the fact that your body and mind don’t need to match, because they are the same.
Maybe I’m just talking out of my arse though. Grin

I agree with this and don't think you're talking out of your arse. Grin I see it with our teen DC and their friends. There is a disconnect and there's also a degree of using their bodies to make statements (which is understandable in a world saturated with social media and porn). Bodies become currency and agency - but also become about an external audience rather than internal connection. As someone who strongly resisted labels, I find it fascinating that the teens we know are all so keen to stick labels on themselves and each other. We've had lots of conversations with our teen about this - about how they might see a label as liberating just now or as necessary to 'fit' in but actually that label can be restrictive if they decide it doesn't apply any more. I think Elliot Page has looked unhappy and uncomfortable for a long time. I hope they find happiness but am sadly aware that elective surgery hasn't been proven to change outcomes for depression or MH issues relating to dysphoria. I also think high profile campaigns and interviews aren't necessarily a kindness to someone undergoing big changes. I wish Oprah was more interested in duty of care to her interviewees rather than catching headlines.
IheartJKR · 01/05/2021 11:04

@puppychaos

I’m glad you had support from your mum Flowers

IheartJKR · 01/05/2021 11:03

*They look very ill and uncomfortable despite being “their best self”

I agree.
I wanted so much to put my arms around Elliot watching that interview.

puppychaos · 01/05/2021 11:03

Oh I don't know. I came out as a trans man when I was 15. It was right for me at the time and being validated by my mum did help a whole lot in at least giving me the space to explore that posibility.

I'm not a trans man now, several years later. I'm non binary but identify more with womanhood in a political sense than I do with manhood, and don't (and never have) taken blockers or T. But I do also think I would still be quite miserable today if I wasn't given the option to explore being a trans man. It helped me understand my gender identity and sexuality on a level that I wouldn't have been able to do, otherwise.

Branleuse · 01/05/2021 11:02

Obviously in real life if its your own child rather than discussing with strangers on an anonymous internet board, there is a fine balance and listening and discussing how they feel and why is hugely important.
Hopefully people arent going to immediately dismiss their childs feelings , but also it would be a bit weird to immediately just validate it all and believe everything they think with no discussion.
Teenagers often have a hard time with bodies changing. Conflicting feelings about their identity and working out who they are in the world. Its complicated. A lot of gender critical people have kids who are gender non conforming and thats whats led them to investigate and educate themselves on the topic of gender and they are well aware theres a balance to be had between being supportive, yet realistic. Such a huge issue

terfinginthevoid · 01/05/2021 11:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BanginChoons · 01/05/2021 10:58

Adults yes, but children/teens, particularly girls, do go through phases of self loathing, or wanting to be boys. So their feelings need to be explored and they need help to work out how they really feel and why.

Yes I absolutely agree. However the lack of services make it near impossible to access support for a non gender conforming child or teen.

Contrary to popular opinion, blockers and testosterone gel are not distributed to under 18s with gay abandon. In fact the waiting list to access even an initial appointment or counselling to wade through the minefield that is gender dysphoria is 3-4 years long, and growing.

Tistheseason17 · 01/05/2021 10:49

There is a big difference between -
1.I feel like a boy
and

  1. I want to be a boy because they don't have periods/breasts and sexual harassment to deal with.

The latter is how I suspect most girls feel going through puberty - I for one did not enjoy having the boys stood at the end of the sand pit when I did the long jump watching my boobs going up and down as their heads bobbed up and down in unison. I would not be exploring transition for my DDs if they expressed this. I would help them to understand it and appreciate it is a temporary, shitty part of growing up.

Brainwave89 · 01/05/2021 10:46

@JellySlice. Sorry but I do not agree. Gender dysmorphia is a well diagnosed condition. There will be some girls and boys who will wish to transition and will need support in doing so. I agree there may be other things that are contributing to a desire to be different and careful consideration is required, but some people genuinely need to transition.

doublehalo · 01/05/2021 10:41

[quote Ponoka7]@BanginChoons

"If someone tells you who they are, maybe you should believe them."

Adults yes, but children/teens, particularly girls, do go through phases of self loathing, or wanting to be boys. So their feelings need to be explored and they need help to work out how they really feel and why.[/quote]
And very specifically - young lesbians.

In years to come we will look back on this time with shame.

JellySlice · 01/05/2021 10:39

@BanginChoons

If someone tells you who they are, maybe you should believe them.
It is not possible to be the opposite sex. If a child tells you this they are either confused, distressed or experimenting. Without exploring these things you cannot support your child fully.
ElphabaTWitch · 01/05/2021 10:37

Agree op. Some things are actually a ‘phase’.

JellySlice · 01/05/2021 10:36

@Thatisnotwhatisaid

My 9 year old often says she wishes she was a boy. It stems mostly from boys not having to have periods or breasts and the fact boys don’t seem to have silly arguments and fall out with each other constantly like girls do. She sadly does seem to have a lot of negativity towards her own sex despite me raising her with a feminist approach. We have plenty of books about amazing women, we talk about how great women are and she has a strong girls club T-shirt too Grin but she sadly currently feels life would be easier as a boy. Tbh she’s probably right, men do have it easier in many ways...

Anyway, I would never jump straight into the ‘oh you must be transgender’ approach with a child. Children experiment with all manners of different identities over the years.

I think it is important to recognise and explore her feelings. Yes, it can be tough being a woman in our patriarchal world. Only ever showing women as strong etc can set up for her an image of an ideal woman that seems as unachievable as Barbie.
terfinginthevoid · 01/05/2021 10:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

zzizzer · 01/05/2021 10:31

Indeed Branleuse. An anorexic child may sincerely believe that they're fat. This isn't a lie for them, it's true, and they're happier when they lose weight.

However we'd bloody judge their doctors and parents who agreed and enabled them.

Mumoblue · 01/05/2021 10:28

I think a lot of the problem is people assuming that their body needs to be making a statement about who they are. Maybe this doesn’t make sense, but it seems like a lot of people lately view their body as something separate from them, so I’m not surprised they feel disconnected from it.

I think if young girls have body issues, while body positivity can be kindly meant, it’s sometimes more helpful just to view your body as you. Focus on the things it can do for you rather than it making any kind of statement.

This is coming from someone who struggled with gender confusion in my early 20s (though I never really spoke to anyone about it until after I had sorted through it by myself). While transitioning can be helpful for adults, I think more focus should be on the fact that your body and mind don’t need to match, because they are the same.
Maybe I’m just talking out of my arse though. Grin

Moonsick · 01/05/2021 10:25

In the 90s I had an account which I was going to use for a mastectomy - had £3000 in it by the time I was 18 as I put every penny I had into it. I wore baggy clothes and had short hair, rejected anything even slightly feminine, insisted on the male version of my name. Hated the attention my large boobs got from creepy men and boys (including my lecherous uncle). Hated having periods, hated the changes in my body, swore never to have children ever. Dreamed of a male body and living as a man. Desisted at university when I discovered radical feminism and decided to fight society rather than my own body.