Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that your if daughter tells you she feels the same as Elliot Page

207 replies

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 08:46

... To please explore all the reasons why she might feel intensely uncomfortable with her growing female body, and not just assume she's transgender?

There's such an epidemic of sexual assault, harassment and sexualised bullying towards girls of all ages. Kids are exposed to violent porn from the moment they can use a phone. Eating disorders are exploding, further evidence that hatred of bodies is rife among young people. Adolescence has always been a storm of hormones and emotions, girls have always discovered that their bodies are treated as public property but that is so much worse now.

If your daughter hates her female body please don't assume she's transgender. She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. She needs your help to discover how women throughout time have helped each other navigate this experience, looked after each other, and organised together to change things.

OP posts:
HeadNorth · 01/05/2021 11:52

Bear in mind, Elliot is an adult in their 30s, so you cannot dismiss their feelings as pubertal angst. I think most/all parents would want their child to take their time and proceed with caution, but once they are 18 they are adults and can make their own decisions. It is then up to you, as a parent, to make peace with those decisions if you want to maintain a loving relationship with your child. If your hatred of trans is stronger than your love for your child, that is a choice for you to live with.

AvocadoBathroom · 01/05/2021 11:50

Unfortunately, I'm seeing this a lot in groups of girls - whole friend groups. Make of that what you will. My worry would be what happens the other side when after the cheerleading dies down and the person now finds themselves with a lifelong dependence on meds. I would be very very worried if this was my daughter. I'd not be affirming too quickly, instead I would be looking for the sensible wait and see approach - as most young people with sudden onset dysphoria grow out of it by the time they have been through puberty. It's different if you are viewing this as one rare case, the thing that I am seeing is three or four girls in a friend group all suddenly announcing they are trans. When you are seeing it so frequently - it's getting to the point where all of my daughter's friend groups have one or two girls in them now saying they are trans - you have to wonder what is going on (what they are consuming on the internet)

I fear this will not end well for a lot of very confused young people.

It's also interesting that women who point out some of the issues to do with safeguarding young people and not pushing them into medication and affirmation - are given death and rape threats on the internet. Surely that in itself tells you a lot about what is going on here.

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 11:47

@puppychaos I'm so glad that you had such great support and space to work things out. Anyone in distress who is just dismissed is going to retreat and feel so much worse.

OP posts:
SelkieIntegrated · 01/05/2021 11:47

I agree with you OP.
It's so rare but suddenly it's a fashionable reaction to sexism and misogyny.

That's not the same as saying I do not believe there are no struggling trans daughters out there.

But when it's talked about so constantly, it's become the go to label to hang your misgivings on. We were mired in oppressive catholicism ten minutes ago (metaphorically) and now my daughter has a trans girl in her convent, she gets a lot of attention from being trans which is what my daughter suspects she really needs. She was a vegan first. That got no attention. And my son's school, an ET and they're always sending home alerts through the app on how to be an ally etc. Geez. Relax. Just wait and see what the children become. Often they become.. poor. Abused. Lonely. Disengaged. All of these meetings about how to be a trans ally when there are many many many bigger issues all of them unaddressed. Poverty, for one. Domestic abuse!? Parents abusing alcohol or drugs? Verbal abuse at home?

I would like to see a mentoring programme for sons in single parent families. This is just one issue which is a much much bigger issue in reality but nope, trans obsession.

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 11:43

@terfinginthevoid

The increasingly widespread belief that there is such a thing as ‘being genuinely trans’ is a major part of the problem. No one is ‘genuinely trans’, in the sense that no one is born in the wrong body.

Psychiatric illness is cultural. People who experience mental distress express it in culturally available ways. Once it was ‘believing you are made of glass’.

Young people in psychological distress can currently adopt ‘being trans’ as a culturally approved explanation and expression of their pain. And rather than receive appropriate psychological therapy to explore what is really going on, misguided psychologists and doctors are giving them hormones and surgery.

Yep, well said. There have been so many versions of this phenomenon, but none as lucrative for the medical and pharma industries.
OP posts:
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/05/2021 11:43

Full thread from.above link

"My daughter was 12 when she told us she was trans.

"I had never heard of ROGD or @LisaLittman1 at that time, but even then I knew that she'd gotten the idea from the Internet.

"I'm a geek. I'm internet savvy. I knew exactly what kinds of shit my daughter would find /1on reddit and DeviantArt and tumblr. And I knew she was surfing those sites. So when she told me she was trans, it wasn't really a surprise. Like a lot of girls, she really hated her period. And she didn't like puberty. And hey, here's a bunch of people online telling her /2"That means you have gender dysphoria! You're trans!"

"And boom, right there, a handy all-purpose explanation for all the awkwardness she was feeling. And it lets her be a Social Justice Hero to boot. What's not to like?

"I have never told her she isn't trans. /3I've never put it in those absolute terms.

"But I have told her that there are alternate explanations for what she's experiencing and how she's feeling. That everybody feels awkward and weird when they go through puberty. Especially girls, whose bodies go through a much /4bigger change than boys. And that what she thinks of as gender dysphoria might be just the fact that she can remember years and years of not having boobs and a period and now all of the sudden she's got both. And it's kinda weird, right? /5So when I talk to her about being trans, I don't frame it as "You're not trans". That's adversarial, and I think that's not going to be productive.

"Instead, I frame it as "Being trans is ONE explanation for how you feel. And it MAY be the correct one, I dunno." /6

"But it also may not, right? There may be other explanations. And your mom and I think it's important for you to keep that in mind. We're not trying to push you through the 'not Trans' doorway. But you're trying really really hard to close that door, and we /7just think it would be a good idea to keep it open until you're at least a little older."

"As always, we'll see how it goes in 3-6 years."

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/05/2021 11:40

This is a very interesting thread from a father in that position, and how he's chosen to act.

twitter.com/RogdDad/status/1311367531840647169?s=19

JellySlice · 01/05/2021 11:40

But actually, what turned out to be the issue was that A- I was autistic, and B- I was scared and frightened by sexuality and expectations and the 'how to' of having a relationship.

As is very likely with mine.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 01/05/2021 11:38

@terfinginthevoid

The increasingly widespread belief that there is such a thing as ‘being genuinely trans’ is a major part of the problem. No one is ‘genuinely trans’, in the sense that no one is born in the wrong body.

Psychiatric illness is cultural. People who experience mental distress express it in culturally available ways. Once it was ‘believing you are made of glass’.

Young people in psychological distress can currently adopt ‘being trans’ as a culturally approved explanation and expression of their pain. And rather than receive appropriate psychological therapy to explore what is really going on, misguided psychologists and doctors are giving them hormones and surgery.

Spot on.
JellySlice · 01/05/2021 11:38

@BanginChoons

Have you ever cared for a teenager? Do you know how being a teenager in this toxic, sexist, lesbophobic society affects girls?

Yes, I have a teen who identifies as trans.

As do many of us.

There's a difference between having a very strong opinion on the whole trans ideology, and how we talk to our teens.

BanginChoons · 01/05/2021 11:38

I wish there was more space for parents with teens going through this to be able to find common ground without either having to agree with and validate it all, or dismiss and talk them round.
The reality is often far more nuanced and somewhere in the middle

Yes, I agree

persistentwoman · 01/05/2021 11:36

Great to see so many thoughtful and reflective posts about this issue. Surely society must eventually join up the dots between the outpouring of revelations about systematic abuse / objectification of girls and women (from www.everyonesinvited.uk/ to the awful revelations about Noel Clarke) ?
We are allowing generations of girls to believe that they can identify their way out of crap like this and instead of parents getting thoughtful support to explore this with their children, they are gaslighted and told they're bigots if they don't immediately affirm them.
When those children who have accessed drugs and surgery (online or elsewhere) realise as they reach adulthood that this has negatively impacted on their fertility, their sex lives and their future health they will be devastated - and will ask why they weren't protected from their adolescent demands.
We must have these difficult discussions and ensure that children don't make life altering decisions until they are fully old enough to comprehend and consent.

NettleTea · 01/05/2021 11:34

I also used to think I might be a boy - or at least have a boy brain, right up until I was around 36ish, even after having given birth after a surge of maternalism kicked in.
I never 'identified' with the adolescent girls - I wasnt interested in the things they talked about and their social interactions left me blindsided. Boys were straightforward.
And They liked cool stuff that I liked - maths, science, computers.
I read books like 'men are from Mars;' and definately felt that I must have a masculine brain.
At that point I didnt realise that a feminine or masculine brain was impossible - that there was no such thing, and that I was attributing sex stereotypes and socialisation to some kind of inner sense of gender.
Also fortunately there was no gender idiology taught at school, or I definately would have dropped myself into that box, especially if would have taken me from socially awkward, definately not cool outsider to elevated person celebrated and possibly having assemblies arranged around my brave decision. And that would have meant I probably wouldnt have had my beautiful children.

But actually, what turned out to be the issue was that A- I was autistic, and B- I was scared and frightened by sexuality and expectations and the 'how to' of having a relationship.

there are many reasons for opting out of 'femininity'

true gender dysphoria is very rare. Body dysphoria not so much. Hating the expectation of being sexually available in a porn soaked culture is even more common, hiding your sexuality as a lesbian, pretty common. Hiding your sexuality because of abuse- sadly very common. Wishing to harm your body is self harm, and a common expression amongst teenage girls/young women in all its forms

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 01/05/2021 11:33

[quote terfinginthevoid]@Bangingchoons
“There was a time when being gay was considered a mental illness”.

This equating being transgender with being gay has done so much damage.

Being gay is similar to being gender non conforming. Being a very masculine girl, or a very feminine boy- not accepted by some people (the same people who would be homophobic), but not a mental illness. Liking the clothes/ activities/hairstyles stereotypically associated with the other sex - not a mental illness. Wishing you had been born the other sex, but accepting reality - not a mental illness.

Believing that your ‘real self’ actually is the other sex, and being so distressed by your actual body that you want dangerous medical and surgical treatment to cosmetically modify it to resemble the other sex - definitely a mental illness.[/quote]
Yes.

Tippexy · 01/05/2021 11:29

Agree OP.

Please also explore whether your daughter has been abused or experienced any trauma and if so how she has been supported to deal with this.

Also consider if she may have autism.

And whether she may be being bullied at school.

Also please start intensively monitoring internet usage.

waitingforthenextseason · 01/05/2021 11:28

Completely agree with the OP.

puppychaos · 01/05/2021 11:27

[quote BanginChoons]@puppychaos thank you for sharing. It's really useful to have a perspective on this from someone with a genuine lived experience.[/quote]
It's certainly rare on these threads! It's not worth the hassle so I generally post elsewhere, but sometimes it can be useful.

titchy · 01/05/2021 11:26

I'm non binary but identify more with womanhood in a political sense than I do with manhood, and don't (and never have) taken blockers or T. But I do also think I would still be quite miserable today if I wasn't given the option to explore being a trans man. It helped me understand my gender identity and sexuality on a level that I wouldn't have been able to do, otherwise.

That seems like an eminently sensible and well considered approach - nothing medical which ensured you have no long term consequences of your younger gender exploration. I'm glad it helped.

It's funny how middle aged men are allowed, encouraged even, to explore their gender identity without any need for medicalisation, but teen girls in particular are immediately encouraged to go down the medical route.

Psychiatric illness is cultural. People who experience mental distress express it in culturally available ways.

Yes of course. I've never really thought about it that way but yes, it's blindingly obvious isn't it?

Branleuse · 01/05/2021 11:24

I wish there was more space for parents with teens going through this to be able to find common ground without either having to agree with and validate it all, or dismiss and talk them round.
The reality is often far more nuanced and somewhere in the middle

CecilyP · 01/05/2021 11:24

*I thought it was quite normal to hate your body growing up.^

Yeah, why wouldn’t you? When all you’ve known is being a child and being perfect the way you are! Getting taller is the only attractive advantage!

BanginChoons · 01/05/2021 11:23

@puppychaos thank you for sharing. It's really useful to have a perspective on this from someone with a genuine lived experience.

tinkywinkyshandbag · 01/05/2021 11:22

I agree and it's not about dismissing her feelings, but about offering different ways of looking at what she's feeling. My DD went through a period of thinking she had gender dysphoria, she looked very much like a boy for a year or two, wore boys clothes, had a very short haircut, and was often mistaken for a boy. Now 2 years on and she's the most feminine girl you could imagine with long hair and a penchant for flicky eye liner. I think a lot of it was experimentation, lack of confidence, and uncertainty about identity. I don't think any of it was because she is trans. Of course it might have been, so I had to allow that possibility too.

BanginChoons · 01/05/2021 11:21

Have you ever cared for a teenager? Do you know how being a teenager in this toxic, sexist, lesbophobic society affects girls?

Yes, I have a teen who identifies as trans.

Branleuse · 01/05/2021 11:18

@puppychaos

Although i think thats great for you as a child, I worry about the bigger picture about what it means for other kids and safeguarding etc rather than the individual person, and what it means later down the line for other issues. While i cant see a problem with you as an individual trying out and exploring identities, i cant help but worry that this would mean boys being allowed to identify into girls spaces and what this would mean for their safety amd fairness
One persons rights end where another persons start. I wish there was a better answer, as obviously id want you to be happy, but if a policy change that helped you, put others in danger, then theres a conflict

ArcheryAnnie · 01/05/2021 11:15

@BanginChoons

If someone tells you who they are, maybe you should believe them.
Have you ever cared for a teenager? Do you know how being a teenager in this toxic, sexist, lesbophobic society affects girls?

Yours is a trite, stupid, sloganeering response to a very pressing, uncomfortable, distressing issue.