Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that your if daughter tells you she feels the same as Elliot Page

207 replies

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 08:46

... To please explore all the reasons why she might feel intensely uncomfortable with her growing female body, and not just assume she's transgender?

There's such an epidemic of sexual assault, harassment and sexualised bullying towards girls of all ages. Kids are exposed to violent porn from the moment they can use a phone. Eating disorders are exploding, further evidence that hatred of bodies is rife among young people. Adolescence has always been a storm of hormones and emotions, girls have always discovered that their bodies are treated as public property but that is so much worse now.

If your daughter hates her female body please don't assume she's transgender. She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. She needs your help to discover how women throughout time have helped each other navigate this experience, looked after each other, and organised together to change things.

OP posts:
HeadNorth · 01/05/2021 13:16

[quote oxalisRed]@HeadNorth
If your hatred of trans is stronger than your love for your child, that is a choice for you to live with.

It's not about "hating trans" at all. It's about one's child's unhappiness and distress, it's about helping your child to accept who they are without irreversible and life long damage. Being transgender is just one of many options, it's not necessarily The Answer but in today's cultural climate our youngsters are conditioned into believing it is the only option.

Unfortunately those who think NHS waiting lists will hold back determined teens - there are (IMHO) unethical websites offering minimal consultation and easy access to medication if you pay £££. Which makes it more difficult for some parents to delay their teens from making irreversible physical choices, especially when we are fed the "accept them without question or they will kill themselves" line.

I'm surprised and grateful that this thread has happened, glad to see a mostly nuanced discussion from many perspectives.

Having read the article, I wish EP peace with themselves.[/quote]
There is a lot of trans hatred on Mumsnet. A lot. It is basically the engine that fuels the FWR board (as Meghan hatred fuels the Royal Family board). Elliot is an adult who has made adult choices that he has assessdd are essential to him to live and funtion. The fact he is not clicking his heels and singing 'Zippedy Doo Dah' does not mean his choices are wrong, or invalid.

Trans people exist and they all have parents. So some parents are just going to have to learm to live with and accept their child is trans. The predominant Mumsnet message is children are wrong to say they are trans and can always be talked out of it for their own good. I am just saying, not necessarily. We have to accept the existance of trans people as entitled to try and live their life in the way that seems right for them, they same as all of us.

Judging Elliot for being too pale, or too thin, or not happy enough seems, to me, to be spectacularly missing the point.

ViciousJackdaw · 01/05/2021 13:07

I thought I was trans when I was 16-17. I ended up telling my Sociology tutor during a 121 and he was so, so lovely. He gave me a couple of books to read, introductions to feminist theory and they were a revelation! Helped me understand that it wasn't me who was 'wrong', it was society.

Whilst I would never simply dismiss a teen who felt they were trans, it is always worth discussing society's expectations of sex/gender.

oxalisRed · 01/05/2021 12:57

@HeadNorth
If your hatred of trans is stronger than your love for your child, that is a choice for you to live with.

It's not about "hating trans" at all. It's about one's child's unhappiness and distress, it's about helping your child to accept who they are without irreversible and life long damage. Being transgender is just one of many options, it's not necessarily The Answer but in today's cultural climate our youngsters are conditioned into believing it is the only option.

Unfortunately those who think NHS waiting lists will hold back determined teens - there are (IMHO) unethical websites offering minimal consultation and easy access to medication if you pay £££. Which makes it more difficult for some parents to delay their teens from making irreversible physical choices, especially when we are fed the "accept them without question or they will kill themselves" line.

I'm surprised and grateful that this thread has happened, glad to see a mostly nuanced discussion from many perspectives.

Having read the article, I wish EP peace with themselves.

AvocadoBathroom · 01/05/2021 12:57

@HeadNorth

Bear in mind, Elliot is an adult in their 30s, so you cannot dismiss their feelings as pubertal angst. I think most/all parents would want their child to take their time and proceed with caution, but once they are 18 they are adults and can make their own decisions. It is then up to you, as a parent, to make peace with those decisions if you want to maintain a loving relationship with your child. If your hatred of trans is stronger than your love for your child, that is a choice for you to live with.
"Hatred of trans" is spectacularly missing the point and deliberately using inflammatory language. Very few mothers talking about this have any kind of hatred for trans people. Having concern about unnecessary mastectomies and a lifetime of medical intervention for an otherwise healthy bodied female isn't having a "hatred of trans" - what a ridiculous assertion! Having concern about your daughter's body - and about what may happen if your child feels after the surgery that they regret their decision - is a normal reaction to something that is a very extreme medical pathway. If a child is experiencing body dysmorphia - would be amputated healthy body parts? We wouldn't! What is the difference between body dysmorphia and gender dysmorphia?

You do make the point that Page is an adult - however that adult is on national television telling people that children will DIE if they don't get to play sports which is a ridiculous assertion. That adult is directly influencing young people. That adult is a role model for young girls.

Telling mothers who are concerned about their daughter's mental health and their daughters making irreversible decisions that will affect their healthy bodies that they "hate trans" is a reactionary and incoherent tactic.

BiBabbles · 01/05/2021 12:50

Not unreasonable at all, though I'm torn between feeling like parents are often not the best person to help explore complicated feelings (even well-intended parents) and concerns about the lack of resources outside of the home with how overstretched mental health services and the difficulty in finding the right other people to help. It's rough for too many children, girls particularly in this regard.

If someone tells you who they are, maybe you should believe them.

I started talking about sex changes when I was about 7. When I was 9, I would have said I am someone who shouldn't have been born (I mean, if we view that women who do not want children shouldn't have them, then it's still objectively true, but I had more emotions attached to it back then).

I was of course a child who didn't have the language or other skills to discuss trauma and emotions, I was just using what media representations and other rhetoric I had been exposed to - the joys of being raised on soap operas, it was mostly weird shite. I was very lucky to get schools access to mental health care - I saw the school psych in elementary, had group therapy in middle school, and a mix in the higher grades.

We never talked about 'who I was' - I was a child, my identity was continuously in flux and impacted by those around me (as is also true of adults to a lesser extent). We talked about coping mechanisms, making choices on our thoughts, how people aren't really all that great at knowing what causes or even identifying emotions all the time and how to practice that & understand that just like our other senses, our emotions send messages but aren't always reliable.

I find the individualistic identity centered way culture is going on how to view people doesn't do much good and just because someone says they feel a certain way doesn't mean it automatically leads to a certain identity as defined by the culture the person happens to have been born in. My feeling threatened by being perceived as female doesn't mean anything about who I innately am.

You cant just ban the internet with teenagers. They have to learn to navigate it. You can put parental controls to stop them having unfiltered access to porn and 18+ sites, but you cant stop them talking about things.

Banning would likely be difficult, but parents can 'intensively monitor' it within their homes, especially for younger teenagers.

After many long conversations about issues my then-13 year old DS1 was having online, he asked us to remove his phone's web browser he found even parentally blocked internet access too much and we listened. He spent a few years only working on computers at home on a computer attached to our TV where everyone could see it. He was much happier and was perfectly able to learn how to navigate it doing that way. It's not really that hard to do, especially these days, and a bit of extra maturity really helped him so now he manages fine.

I had pretty much free range internet usage from an early age, joys of being a late 80s kid with a dad working in tech where a home computer with internet was a perk of the job, and 'they have to learn to navigate it' was my parents attitude that fucked us all up and led to my brother ending up arrested and expelled and barred from every school in the county. Even on non-18+ sites, you can talk about illegal shite that has repercussions.

I can't stop them discussing anything, but my children - particularly my sons - are in high risk demographics for radicalisation in a city which has known problems with it so yeah I restrict and monitor internet usage. There are so many other identity-focused groups out there other than gender-based that just love teenagers, inexperienced by definition, looking for community, understanding, and an explanation for their feelings.

Thatswatshesaid · 01/05/2021 12:43

Elliott is 34 he’s not a teenager. If this is what he feels will help him to feel happier then, although it’s sad that it’s come to this, i support him.

ArabellaScott · 01/05/2021 12:35

Just watching this clip.

My heart aches for Elliott. This is not someone who looks well and happy. (CW - discussion of suicide, inc some pretty hyperbolic claims). I'm really sorry for the terrible pain Elliott seems to have undergone and be undergoing.

www.msn.com/en-us/entertainment/story/elliot-page-says-top-surgery-was-lifesaving/vp-BB1geuMS

IheartJKR · 01/05/2021 12:34

And now radical feminism has been all but completely suppressed at university, we are left with transition

So sad.

Yep. Rad Fem = terf bitch at uni.

That doesn’t really leave anywhere for women to go does it???

Someone might think that was the plan all along.

RantyAnty · 01/05/2021 12:31

I wonder if it has to do with how horrible women are treated in society?

There was a document done in Australia of school girl's experience of rape, assault, sexual harassment some starting at age 10.

So many of them wrote about how they've been touched by their fellow male students at school, on buses and schools did nothing.

Teen girls are expected to behave like porn stars to have a boyfriend and coerced to do anal, slapped, choked as well as be poly these days.

Maybe some of them realise they are prey and and blame their maturing bodies? Some might think if they had a chance to be a white male in society, why wouldn't they be!

I was a tomboy as it was just who I was. I moved to being more feminine in high school partly due to peer pressure. I did the normal things got married and had children and never thought much more about it.

I'd say since menopause and turning 50, I feel I'd much rather present as a man. I'm not sure why. The decrease in female hormones making me feel like I was prior to puberty? Who knows. I have no attraction to women so it is nothing sexual. I don't want a beard or penis either.

I'm just one person so don't want to speculate about what others feel.

For those of you who have daughters, I'd say just listen.

doublehalo · 01/05/2021 12:27

@nolongersurprised

I watched the interview with Elliot page. Elliot looks emaciated and very emotionally fragile and not like a positive role model at all
This. Unfortunately we are not allowed to talk about the co-morbidities that exist in many trans identified people.
Mummyoflittledragon · 01/05/2021 12:24

@Moonsick

In the 90s I had an account which I was going to use for a mastectomy - had £3000 in it by the time I was 18 as I put every penny I had into it. I wore baggy clothes and had short hair, rejected anything even slightly feminine, insisted on the male version of my name. Hated the attention my large boobs got from creepy men and boys (including my lecherous uncle). Hated having periods, hated the changes in my body, swore never to have children ever. Dreamed of a male body and living as a man. Desisted at university when I discovered radical feminism and decided to fight society rather than my own body.
And now radical feminism has been all but completely suppressed at university, we are left with transition.

So sad.

Tibtom · 01/05/2021 12:21

If a 6 stone adult told you they were fat would you believe them?

Tibtom · 01/05/2021 12:19

Between 80% and 95% of teenagers who present as transgender will be happy with their sex once they past puberty. If 'affirmed' they are much more likely to end up as lifelong medical patients putting themselves forward for major and risky surgery.

Female to male patients tend to be teenagers and be told they must medically transition

Male to female transitioners tend to be middle aged and not only do the vast majority not have surgery but it is put forward that changes to presentation or dress are not necessary either (such as shaving off a beard)

Suicide is often falaely presented as a readon for transitioning but rusk of suicide increases multifold post transition

Startingagainperson · 01/05/2021 12:18

@PurgatoryOfPotholes that is a really interesting article. I do feel quite fiercely protective of autistic children. No-one should be strongly encouraging their emerging thoughts to ‘be anything’ as I do feel that autistic children need as much space and time without influence to grow, think, gather their own selves in their own way.

Unfortunately there is also a young adult, vocal autistic community who are heavily trans, quite dictorial in what thoughts are OK and not OK, and so that becomes the norm for a teenage autistic. They need a much more diverse and broad community who are not so prescriptive.

Viviennemary · 01/05/2021 12:13

I really think you need to take a wider view on this. The bodies of both sexes change when going through puberty. And at other stages in life. A man might go bald rarely welcomed. A woman might get more facial hair again not welcomed.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/05/2021 12:12

This account of misattributing issues to gender dysphoria is highly relevant to the thread, I feel.

4w.pub/autism-puberty-gender-dysphoria-view-from-an-autistic-desisted-woman/

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 01/05/2021 12:11

Totally OP. I was a "tomboy". Short hair, refused to wear girly clothes, wanted to play with boys, play football. I outgrew it. I genuinely think it is allowing your hormones to kick in that helps you comes to terms with the changes in your body.

I also stopped being disgusted by the idea of sex/relationships at about 16 and realised that I didn't mind if growing breasts made me attractive to the boys ar school.... if anything, it was a perk!

I still like sports, rarely wear dresses & skirts or makeup, but I'm a 100% happy heterosexual woman.

nolongersurprised · 01/05/2021 12:10

I watched the interview with Elliot page. Elliot looks emaciated and very emotionally fragile and not like a positive role model at all

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 12:07

@HeadNorth

Bear in mind, Elliot is an adult in their 30s, so you cannot dismiss their feelings as pubertal angst. I think most/all parents would want their child to take their time and proceed with caution, but once they are 18 they are adults and can make their own decisions. It is then up to you, as a parent, to make peace with those decisions if you want to maintain a loving relationship with your child. If your hatred of trans is stronger than your love for your child, that is a choice for you to live with.
Totally. My concern is that a single, specific explanation of young women's distress about their experience of growing up with a female body becomes the dominant one and parents and therapists become afraid, not least because of suicide threats and lack of decent mental health services, to take the time to explore other issues.
OP posts:
Startingagainperson · 01/05/2021 12:01

@JellySlice

But actually, what turned out to be the issue was that A- I was autistic, and B- I was scared and frightened by sexuality and expectations and the 'how to' of having a relationship.

As is very likely with mine.

I totally agree with that. I have a child who is special needs and very vulnerable, in that they have no idea about social expectations, very little idea of their own identity yet (but it is coming slowly).

I am very wary that my child tends to ‘go’ with whatever society tells them and I am limiting social media and choosing their schools very carefully because of that - any school with too much of an ‘agenda’ of identity- whether that is very pro trans, or the opposite no diversity at all - I am going to avoid to give my child the best chance of being allowed to blossom in their own way. Not anyone else’s!

Igmum · 01/05/2021 12:00

Well done OP for starting a common sense discussion on this. I'm the parent of a teen LGBTQ+ child. Thank heavens DC is sensible and school are great. They are able to explore themselves, their feelings, how they want to dress and be without being forced into untested medication and sterilization. I am horrified by these crazy adult activists who want to medically experiment on young people and demonize the women who stand in their way. More sensible common sense discussion please, fewer slogans, medication and rape threats

Soontobe60 · 01/05/2021 12:00

@BanginChoons

If someone tells you who they are, maybe you should believe them.
My DD told us she was married to David Beckham when she was 5. Should we believe her?
Branleuse · 01/05/2021 11:54

@Tippexy

Agree OP.

Please also explore whether your daughter has been abused or experienced any trauma and if so how she has been supported to deal with this.

Also consider if she may have autism.

And whether she may be being bullied at school.

Also please start intensively monitoring internet usage.

It depends what you do with that information though. Mine is autistic. It doesnt mean I get to go " youre just autistic" and dismiss their feelings. You cant just ban the internet with teenagers. They have to learn to navigate it. You can put parental controls to stop them having unfiltered access to porn and 18+ sites, but you cant stop them talking about things.
SelkieIntegrated · 01/05/2021 11:54

Somebody upthread said there are many reasons to opt out of femininity and this is really true.
When I was at school there were sporty girls who just opted out of femininity but they didn't make any big statement about it. They were who they were. In some ways the labelling has made things harder. You have to define yourself now!?

Startingagainperson · 01/05/2021 11:53

Whatever a child says from 8 onwards is so, so heavily influenced by their peers and their culture, possibly more so that any other point in their lives, that I would most definitely keep the ‘in trends’ in mind as they expressed their own growing thoughts.

That is it really, I’d listen and notice, allowing their expression.

But I would not be ‘led by the child’ into any action, any extremes and if they seemed to be getting quite intense then I’d steer them back to ‘well, you’ve plenty of time... just enjoy your childhood, explore... no I don’t think actions of this and this yet... ‘etc.

Most children will go a bit extreme whilst they struggle to find themselves in all of our cultural norms. Going into teenage hood the urge to fit in is totally overwhelming. So I would always, always seek the context for my child’s thoughts.

If my child wanted to eat only protein shakes and body build - well obviously they want to look great and are noticing themselves as attractive objects - then I would acknowledge the wish to be attractive but would rein them in from protein shakes, and too much weight training.

If my child wanted to eat less in order to look great in instagram shots I would be advising healthy eating.

If my child said that they hated their body, I would again be trying to help them not hate any part of themselves, if they have uncomfortable feelings that is OK to express, but not OK to demonise themselves as again, that is extreme thinking no matter what any role model on TV says.

It is OK to express feelings that they might be feeling different, but childhood is a growing, where every child should feel safe and secure enough to have time to explore all their feelings. But extreme action and damaging extreme thoughts are not healthy for a child and are the product of people whipping up hysteria around children.

I believe it is my job as a parent to help them to feel safe enough to journey through this time in the most sensible, secure way possible. As we all know, young kids are not very sensible and are often intense! They’ve got the rest of their adult lives to make proper, adult decisions about themselves. Childhood is their one safe place to grow into that.