Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that your if daughter tells you she feels the same as Elliot Page

207 replies

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 08:46

... To please explore all the reasons why she might feel intensely uncomfortable with her growing female body, and not just assume she's transgender?

There's such an epidemic of sexual assault, harassment and sexualised bullying towards girls of all ages. Kids are exposed to violent porn from the moment they can use a phone. Eating disorders are exploding, further evidence that hatred of bodies is rife among young people. Adolescence has always been a storm of hormones and emotions, girls have always discovered that their bodies are treated as public property but that is so much worse now.

If your daughter hates her female body please don't assume she's transgender. She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. She needs your help to discover how women throughout time have helped each other navigate this experience, looked after each other, and organised together to change things.

OP posts:
IEat · 01/05/2021 14:11

My DD hates her boobs, but we all have big ones in my family, I’m teaching her body confidence... something my mother did to me

supermoonrising · 01/05/2021 14:03

"She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. "

Pretty big claim. Any research to back that up?

Anycrispsleft · 01/05/2021 14:01

When I came out as bisexual when I was in my early 20s, I met a few trans people, and questioned whether I might be trans myself. The conclusion I came to, and I stick by it, is that if I could take a pill and wake up male tomorrow I might consider it, but not if it meant taking hormones and doing surgery to end up with a body that wasn't actually male anyway. I looked at it this way: if I am/was literally a bloke in a woman's body, like I just woke up in a woman's body, would my next thought be "I need surgery to sort this out?" Probably in that situation I would think, well, this is weird, but not so weird that I would necessarily prefer surgery to just... getting used to it?

I have never really learned to love my female body. I'm more resigned to it than anything else. But I'm 45 and I doubt that I am the only 45 year old that looks at their body in the mirror and thinks "oh well, you're healthy, that's the main thing." I am glad I didn't have to have any medical treatment. I look back and can now join the dots from my shitty childhood - my mother is horrible, emotionally and physically abusive to both me and my dad - and it doesn't take a genius to see that maybe I had very good reasons for not wanting to grow into a woman.

What worries me though, is how easy it seems to be to get treatment these days. I have a friend who is trans and back in the 90s when they were thinking about getting treatment, you had to live for 2 years "as the opposite gender" without hormones or anything, which means you would need to have a pretty thick skin, as in every encounter it would be clear you were not the sex you were presenting as. And attitudes weren't as tolerant to trans people in those days either. But it served a purpose. Appearance is the tip of the iceberg, but at least it forced people to confront some of the really drastic changes that transitioning would put them through. Now, it sounds as if it's got a lot easier, at least to get on puberty blockers, that "pause button" that actually usually is just the first step in going on to cross sex hormones. When you think how difficult it is as an adult woman just to get your GP to prescribe long term contraception, never mind sterilisation, it seems so messed up that taking a step like that, that can cause infertility, is open for young girls.

TableFlowerss · 01/05/2021 13:57

@terfinginthevoid

The increasingly widespread belief that there is such a thing as ‘being genuinely trans’ is a major part of the problem. No one is ‘genuinely trans’, in the sense that no one is born in the wrong body.

Psychiatric illness is cultural. People who experience mental distress express it in culturally available ways. Once it was ‘believing you are made of glass’.

Young people in psychological distress can currently adopt ‘being trans’ as a culturally approved explanation and expression of their pain. And rather than receive appropriate psychological therapy to explore what is really going on, misguided psychologists and doctors are giving them hormones and surgery.

This
persistentwoman · 01/05/2021 13:56

It's worth repeating that nobody hates trans people. Nobody hates children who believe they're "in the wrong body". We are (mainly) women, mothers, parents and some of us work with children.
We are rightly challenging a narrative that encourages children to see their internal distress as being fixed by transitioning. And (as some posters have mentioned schools) those of us who work in education are challenging the way that adult led groups have been allowed to target schools and persuade the children in them that transitioning is the solution to their distress.

We don't allow other political groups to 'persuade' children of their ideologies. We insist on proportion and balance. Schools have been incredibly naive in enabling the narratives 'your parents are transphobic if they don't immediately affirm you', 'we can transition children in secret from their parents', let alone telling teachers they can keep disclosures from children confidential with no recourse to safeguarding guidelines. (All of these approaches can be found in various trans guidelines for schools)

Schools in the grip of this ideology need to start centring the child's needs, not the adult ideology and working with parents, not positioning them as the enemy.

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 13:55

@bonbonours

Yes the problem is, anyone who has teens knows that teenagers believe they know everything and parents know nothing. Any attempt to look at underlying reasons by me results in accusations of not being supportive, being transphobic, or not understanding. All of which results in the teen keeping as much as possible secret from their parent. So it's a very fine line to tread to keep a good parent-teen relationship while not jumping aboard the trans wagon.
Exhausting! But so worth all the balancing and tightrope walking. Lucky teens of parents who can manage it
OP posts:
IsThePopeCatholic · 01/05/2021 13:52

I agree with Moonsick. Radical feminism is the only way to overcome body dysmorphia. I strongly believe that our society is becoming more sexist and gendered, probably due to pervasive pornography.

bonbonours · 01/05/2021 13:52

Yes the problem is, anyone who has teens knows that teenagers believe they know everything and parents know nothing. Any attempt to look at underlying reasons by me results in accusations of not being supportive, being transphobic, or not understanding. All of which results in the teen keeping as much as possible secret from their parent. So it's a very fine line to tread to keep a good parent-teen relationship while not jumping aboard the trans wagon.

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 13:50

@HeadNorth

I am not going to trawl Mumsnet for evidence, do I have to prove the sky is blue? Just go to the FWR board. Debate is important but it cannot start from the assumption that being trans is 'wrong', because it isn't. It just is. I don't think any parent would want their child to be trans and all would want them to take their time. But I am pointing out that some will continue and transition, because that is what they believe is the best way for them to live their life. And in the end, we have to accept adults rights to make those choices for themselves, if we really want to do what is best for our children.
I'm sorry if you've read posts that say being transgender is "wrong", and would encourage you to report them. I don't think anyone on this thread has implied anything like that, but again would urge you to report anything you see that you think is offensive or discriminatory
OP posts:
ViciousJackdaw · 01/05/2021 13:49

Debate is important but it cannot start from the assumption that being trans is 'wrong', because it isn't

Agreed. Trans is not 'wrong'. Should we perhaps consider 'Is trans 'right' for this particular person'?

Tibtom · 01/05/2021 13:46

I am not going to trawl Mumsnet for evidence

The reason why you won't look is because you know you won't find.

On the otherhand there is plenty of actual hatred for women from transactivists: www.terfisaslur.com

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 13:43

I guess what would be really helpful is more information about how parents can respond to daughters who feel highly distressed about their bodies, in ways that are loving and supportive and help girls explore their feelings and the whole range of factors that might be involved.

It so often gets presented as either you accept everything your child says without question or you "hate trans" and your children will die. But there are loving, empathic and supportive ways of exploring and containing kids' feelings with them while they grow

OP posts:
HeadNorth · 01/05/2021 13:40

I am not going to trawl Mumsnet for evidence, do I have to prove the sky is blue? Just go to the FWR board. Debate is important but it cannot start from the assumption that being trans is 'wrong', because it isn't. It just is. I don't think any parent would want their child to be trans and all would want them to take their time. But I am pointing out that some will continue and transition, because that is what they believe is the best way for them to live their life. And in the end, we have to accept adults rights to make those choices for themselves, if we really want to do what is best for our children.

oxalisRed · 01/05/2021 13:37

@HeadNorth
There is a lot of trans hatred on Mumsnet. A lot. It is basically the engine that fuels the FWR board

I disagree. Practically every thread I've ever seen on FWR is centred on women's rights, about protecting the few rights women have carved out for themselves in this society over the last century, about ensuring the safety of women and children.

That may seem like transphobia when transgender activists argue for access or changes that impinges women's safety. That is all. I see no "hatred of trans" (which should of course be reported to MNHQ) just defense of women.

Defending women is so so so unpopular, we are so so overlooked and disregarded - to the extent that many of us have in our past wished to opt out of being a woman. As already expressed by so many posters in this and other threads, our (older) generation experienced this when transitioning was not the automatic Answer and we grew up to accept ourselves. Now our kids are actively encouraged to believe transitioning is The Answer and anyone who disagrees (especially we pesky women) are slurred and threatened.

Trans people exist and they all have parents..... The predominant Mumsnet message is children are wrong to say they are trans and can always be talked out of it for their own good. I am just saying, not necessarily

I have yet to come across any poster on MN saying they deny the existence of transgender people, or that transgender people shouldn't exist. But obviously as a parenting board, we tend to be cautious about treatment that our kids may receive which may have long term ill effects - not always saying we can/ should talk them out of transitioning but always urging caution before making such a defining decision.

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 13:37

The mention of suicide in that interview is so irresponsible. I just really hope parents don't get so scared by this sort of claim that they feel unable to challenge anything their child does

OP posts:
Angelil · 01/05/2021 13:37

@HeadNorth 18 is still very young though - and the brain has not finished developing until age 25.
Young people need to be given more time to feel comfortable in their own skin and to discover what that is - not to rush into surgery, hormonal treatments just because at 18 they're legally adults.
Friends of mine who couldn't accept, for example, their homosexuality found that when they did, a lot of their mental health issues went away (e.g. night terrors/hallucinations, chronic depression inc. suicide attempts etc). Young people need to be given the chance to work it out for themselves and that means being out of their teens before making any major decisions about their bodies. Name changes, what you wear, how you do your hair etc...all reversible. Mastectomies, puberty blockers...very much the opposite.

ArabellaScott · 01/05/2021 13:35

Yes, evidence of 'hatred' would good. Bearing in mind this doesn't just mean 'disagreement'. Show any on this thread, for example?

ArabellaScott · 01/05/2021 13:33

Elliott is entitled to do whatever Elliot pleases.

What is not okay is telling parents that if children aren't given access to surgery it's life threatening.

This is hyperbole, it's not supported by the evidence, and I would go so far as to say it's dangerous.

unwuthering · 01/05/2021 13:32

In years to come we will look back on this time with shame.

Yep, but right now it is a Thought Crime to even question it.

Letsgetreadytocrumble · 01/05/2021 13:32

A wider discussion about the society in which young girls are being raised, and how that might have an effect on their sense of identity and how they see their bodies is not 'hatred' FFS.

Letsgetreadytocrumble · 01/05/2021 13:29

@HeadNorth

Bear in mind, Elliot is an adult in their 30s, so you cannot dismiss their feelings as pubertal angst. I think most/all parents would want their child to take their time and proceed with caution, but once they are 18 they are adults and can make their own decisions. It is then up to you, as a parent, to make peace with those decisions if you want to maintain a loving relationship with your child. If your hatred of trans is stronger than your love for your child, that is a choice for you to live with.
Elliot also said that if trans kids can't play sports with the opposite sex 'children will die'. Elliot is talking specifically about children there, and is basically saying that the only options are complete affirmation from everyone, even if it affects others negatively, or suicide.

It's absolutely horrendous.

HeadNorth · 01/05/2021 13:29

Claiming discussion is hatred is a common tactic used to silence debate.

Who is 'silencing debate'? What are you actually talking about? Mumsnet seems overwhelmingly negative about the existance of trans people, I am providing a counter narrative that they exist and it is not necessarily the worst thing in the world. Providing a counter view is the very opposite of silencing debate - unless you have a very different definition of debate, which is basically everyone reinforcing each others views in an echo chamber.

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 13:28

Happily I've not noticed anyone on this thread being hateful towards anyone, or saying they would tell a child questioning their gender that they are plain wrong or refuse to accept them. But lots of willingness to explore the issues involved in growing up female, which sounds to me like good parenting ❤️ and concern about unquestioned celebrity endorsement of radical medical treatment. Great to be able to discuss all this, from all perspectives.

OP posts:
Tibtom · 01/05/2021 13:27

Thing put forward as hatred of trans people:

Safeguarding
Evidence based medicine
Recognising the importance of sex in oppressing women and girls
International Women's Day
Woman's rights
A child's ability to consent
Acknowledging the existance of detransitioners
Saying a woman's who has been brutally gang raped should be allowed to chose the sex of their forensic examiner
The Equality Act 2010
Female sports

Tibtom · 01/05/2021 13:19

Claiming discussion is hatred is a common tactic used to silence debate.