Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that your if daughter tells you she feels the same as Elliot Page

207 replies

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 08:46

... To please explore all the reasons why she might feel intensely uncomfortable with her growing female body, and not just assume she's transgender?

There's such an epidemic of sexual assault, harassment and sexualised bullying towards girls of all ages. Kids are exposed to violent porn from the moment they can use a phone. Eating disorders are exploding, further evidence that hatred of bodies is rife among young people. Adolescence has always been a storm of hormones and emotions, girls have always discovered that their bodies are treated as public property but that is so much worse now.

If your daughter hates her female body please don't assume she's transgender. She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. She needs your help to discover how women throughout time have helped each other navigate this experience, looked after each other, and organised together to change things.

OP posts:
Butwasitherdriveway · 02/05/2021 14:00

@Notagain20

I don't know about self indulgent but it would be pretty foolish to tell a teenager that "we've all been through it" in the dismissive way you're implying, *@Butwasitherdriveway*. If you want a dialogue you don't tell someone you already know exactly what they're experiencing! You listen, you reflect, you make space, you encourage consideration of all sorts of factors. If you think the options are either 1) unquestioningly accept everything a young person wants to do or 2) tell them you know everything about their experience and have lived it already and know better than them then I think you're sort of missing the point of parenting
But that's what you wrote in your OP, really isn't it...
Butwasitherdriveway · 02/05/2021 13:59

[quote Yorkshirelass04]@Butwasitherdriveway I think it's a mistake to think that being gay is the same as the transgender movement. We are not talking about sexual attraction but something really more fundamental and risky and experimental. And not to mention all sort of contradictory in a purely logical sense.

If teenagers have changed then what has brought on this sudden shift in thinking? Or are you saying that some teenagers always felt the need to be the opposite gender and are only now getting the chance? [/quote]
Yes, that is what I am saying.

Notagain20 · 02/05/2021 13:57

I don't know about self indulgent but it would be pretty foolish to tell a teenager that "we've all been through it" in the dismissive way you're implying, @Butwasitherdriveway. If you want a dialogue you don't tell someone you already know exactly what they're experiencing! You listen, you reflect, you make space, you encourage consideration of all sorts of factors. If you think the options are either 1) unquestioningly accept everything a young person wants to do
or 2) tell them you know everything about their experience and have lived it already and know better than them
then I think you're sort of missing the point of parenting

OP posts:
Wandawomble · 02/05/2021 13:42

It’s self indulgent to tell teenagers that every bit of emotional and mental discomfort they have must be medicalised. It’s self indulgent for some trans adults to project their feelings onto young children, encouraging them to pursue born in the wrong body myths, it’s self indulgent to expect everyone to compelled speech regarding pronouns and it’s incredibly self indulgent to threaten everyone who disagrees with this ideology as being hateful.

Yorkshirelass04 · 02/05/2021 11:30

@Butwasitherdriveway I think it's a mistake to think that being gay is the same as the transgender movement. We are not talking about sexual attraction but something really more fundamental and risky and experimental. And not to mention all sort of contradictory in a purely logical sense.

If teenagers have changed then what has brought on this sudden shift in thinking? Or are you saying that some teenagers always felt the need to be the opposite gender and are only now getting the chance?

Butwasitherdriveway · 02/05/2021 11:19

[quote Yorkshirelass04]@Butwasitherdriveway Respecting of views I get, but we aren't talking that, we are talking about unquestioning medicalisation and surgery if young people feel uncomfortable in their own skin. This isn't something that's easy to accept.

I was a teenager in the 90s. We didn't have to define our pronouns, we didn't have to tell people whether we were cis or trans, we didn't seriously entertain the idea of actually being the opposite gender. I don't know of any child from school that has now grown up and actually chosen to be the opposite gender.

So either teenagers have changed or society has. [/quote]
Both.

In the same way my father is sure there waa no gay men in his school, that there are no gay men in the premier League.

Yorkshirelass04 · 02/05/2021 11:13

@Butwasitherdriveway Respecting of views I get, but we aren't talking that, we are talking about unquestioning medicalisation and surgery if young people feel uncomfortable in their own skin. This isn't something that's easy to accept.

I was a teenager in the 90s. We didn't have to define our pronouns, we didn't have to tell people whether we were cis or trans, we didn't seriously entertain the idea of actually being the opposite gender. I don't know of any child from school that has now grown up and actually chosen to be the opposite gender.

So either teenagers have changed or society has.

Butwasitherdriveway · 02/05/2021 11:06

@Yorkshirelass04

I think it's self indulgent to tell teenagers that this new era of us redefining girlhood and medicalising discomfort and dysphoria is the 'right' way of thinking about it. This is a very new experiment and a very new trend.
But it isn't self indulgent.

It's being respectful of their views without telling them that it's the exact same as your struggles in a sexist society.

Yorkshirelass04 · 02/05/2021 11:05

I think it's self indulgent to tell teenagers that this new era of us redefining girlhood and medicalising discomfort and dysphoria is the 'right' way of thinking about it. This is a very new experiment and a very new trend.

Butwasitherdriveway · 02/05/2021 10:58

@Wandawomble

Wait, it’s self indulgent to encourage girls to understand their own history and power as females but it’s NOT self indulgent to agree with and affirm negative self image statements where a child thinks they are born in the wrong body?

Right....

It's self indulgent to try and tell children we have all been through it.
Wandawomble · 02/05/2021 10:58

Wait, it’s self indulgent to encourage girls to understand their own history and power as females but it’s NOT self indulgent to agree with and affirm negative self image statements where a child thinks they are born in the wrong body?

Right....

Butwasitherdriveway · 02/05/2021 10:45

@Notagain20

... To please explore all the reasons why she might feel intensely uncomfortable with her growing female body, and not just assume she's transgender?

There's such an epidemic of sexual assault, harassment and sexualised bullying towards girls of all ages. Kids are exposed to violent porn from the moment they can use a phone. Eating disorders are exploding, further evidence that hatred of bodies is rife among young people. Adolescence has always been a storm of hormones and emotions, girls have always discovered that their bodies are treated as public property but that is so much worse now.

If your daughter hates her female body please don't assume she's transgender. She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. She needs your help to discover how women throughout time have helped each other navigate this experience, looked after each other, and organised together to change things.

'Yyour daughter hates her female body please don't assume she's transgender. She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. She needs your help to discover how women throughout time have helped each other navigate this experience, looked after each other, and organised together to change things.:

Please don't take on board this self indulgent, ignorant advice.

Yorkshirelass04 · 02/05/2021 10:42

@Wandawomble completely agree 💯

What a master stroke the patriarchy has set up for us - using our own liberalism and desire not to be 'hateful' to make women abandon their own identities and allow men to redefine what womanhood is.

Wandawomble · 02/05/2021 10:37

Let’s not forget the high number of autistic children who are now identifying as trans - this is a wide scale scandal that is being celebrated and encouraged by the Guardian and the BBC - both hard selling the idea that children are born in the wrong body and misrepresenting suicide statistics and the safety of puberty blockers.

Wandawomble · 02/05/2021 10:34

It’s easier for someone to attempt to shut down discussion by crying the word “hate!!!!” than to have a sensible discussion about the fact that more and more young people are presenting with sudden onset gender dysphoria - especially when many of us can see it happening with our own eyes amongst our children’s friend groups as a trend. My daughter was told at her school by a group of twelve year old girls ALL identifying as gay men - that being “cis het” was “evil” - we moved house and when she got to the new school, three of the girls in her new class are now claiming to be male as is a friend’s gang of girls from the year above. These girls are encouraging each other to buy breast binders.
To question this is hate? Nonsense. To not question it is neglect. This generation of young people are going to be looking at us as parents and asking why we didn’t see what was going on and protect them.
Hate isn’t safeguarding.

Yorkshirelass04 · 02/05/2021 10:18

I think it would need a lot more exploration with the teen because quite simply, they don't get to choose whether they are a girl or not. Biology is biology. They can dress and act a certain way if that makes them feel better.

ArabellaScott · 02/05/2021 10:15

Listen to them, not just to their loud declarations, but also to what is going on all around them, to the pressures they are put under, to the sort of lives that women are forced to live, and that they may wish (understandably) to escape.

That's a very insightful point, ArcheryAnnie.

Worth considering that sometimes it's hard for children and young people to analyse their feelings, the cause, impact and context of them. Sometimes they skew them onto something that is more visible and easier to solidify in the mind - see the child fighting over the wrong spoon at breakfast, when in reality they may be dealing with - well, any amount of things - hunger, rejection, fear of abandonment, etc.

In fact, it's not just children, is it? We all do this to an extent. It's like the psychological McGuffin.

TomPinch · 02/05/2021 02:45

Me too. I'm male (ie xy chromosomes) and I felt a lot of angst when growing up about how I didn't seem like a proper boy.

It sucked at the time, but I'm so glad I had the freedom to figure out that I was male anyway without needing anyone's permission. Now I'm a happy enough, married father and how 'manly' I am isn't something I give any thought to.

If I was growing up now I imagine some well-meaning fool would be recommending me to the Tavistock and setting me up for a lifetime of confusion just because I didn't comform to some arbitrary gender norms.

ArcheryAnnie · 01/05/2021 23:53

It's worth repeating that nobody hates trans people. Nobody hates children who believe they're "in the wrong body". We are (mainly) women, mothers, parents and some of us work with children.

And many of us on these boards have been that child, though the language has changed. I feel lucky to be old, and to have had neglectful parents, because if I'd been born decades later and in a less chaotic household, I'd have been marched down the Tavistock pronto. I know many, many other gender critical women who have experienced similar.

ArcheryAnnie · 01/05/2021 23:50

@BanginChoons

Have you ever cared for a teenager? Do you know how being a teenager in this toxic, sexist, lesbophobic society affects girls?

Yes, I have a teen who identifies as trans.

I was that kid who took a male name as a small child, I was that kid who developed an ED during puberty (which delayed it) and who has had a lifetime of questioning gender and sex.

I have more experience than you, because I've lived it, and so I repeat that it's trite, useless sloganeering, and of absolutely no help to your child at all.

Listen to them, not just to their loud declarations, but also to what is going on all around them, to the pressures they are put under, to the sort of lives that women are forced to live, and that they may wish (understandably) to escape.

terfinginthevoid · 01/05/2021 15:50

Eliot Page is an adult, but having watched part of the Oprah interview, I have some doubts as to whether they are currently in the best place emotionally to make irreversible decisions.
I don't 'hate' them, or any other trans people, but I am not convinced that medical/surgical transition is the answer they are looking for.

Helleofabore · 01/05/2021 14:54

This journal article is probably relevant here.

journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/26344041211010777

Published April 22, 2021
Kasia Kozlowska, Georgia McClure et al

Australian children and adolescents with gender dysphoria: Clinical presentations and challenges experienced by a multidisciplinary team and gender service

From the conclusion:

Our findings indicate that engagement with families, a trauma-informed model of mental health care, and ongoing discourse pertaining to the effects of unresolved trauma and loss need to be part of all gender dysphoria clinics and the services with which they collaborate. Because of their impact on subjective well-being and the development of the self, specific loss and trauma events present crucial opportunities for both long-term psychotherapy and more immediate, targeted treatments. The move to a more comprehensive, holistic model of care—one that takes into account the individual’s developmental history and the experiences that make up that history—has also been echoed in the work of other clinician-researchers (D’Angelo, 2020a; Entwistle, 2019; Giovanardi et al., 2018; Kozlowska et al., 2021; Williamson, 2019).

Soontobe60 · 01/05/2021 14:52

@LegoPoliceman

Elliott Page is old enough that the decision is theirs to make. However, like the entirety of the human race, they not of an age that means their judgement is infallible. The prevailing view seems to be that each individual knows themselves entirely and fuck the opinion of everyone else. Any psychologist, social worker, counselor, teacher, probation officer and God knows how many others will be able to tell you that people do not necessarily make the best decisions for themselves. Not just split second, spur of the moment mistakes, but prolonged self destructive behaviour.

I sincerely hope that Elliott Page is happy with their transition and I sincerely hope they avoid peddling the lie that every teenage whim left unpandered will lead to dead children.

I think the interview they released with Oprah seems to do just that
LegoPoliceman · 01/05/2021 14:37

Elliott Page is old enough that the decision is theirs to make. However, like the entirety of the human race, they not of an age that means their judgement is infallible.
The prevailing view seems to be that each individual knows themselves entirely and fuck the opinion of everyone else. Any psychologist, social worker, counselor, teacher, probation officer and God knows how many others will be able to tell you that people do not necessarily make the best decisions for themselves. Not just split second, spur of the moment mistakes, but prolonged self destructive behaviour.

I sincerely hope that Elliott Page is happy with their transition and I sincerely hope they avoid peddling the lie that every teenage whim left unpandered will lead to dead children.

ArabellaScott · 01/05/2021 14:32

A reminder that 'The evidence for using puberty blocking drugs to treat young people struggling with their gender identity is "very low", an official review has found.'

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-56601386