Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that your if daughter tells you she feels the same as Elliot Page

207 replies

Notagain20 · 01/05/2021 08:46

... To please explore all the reasons why she might feel intensely uncomfortable with her growing female body, and not just assume she's transgender?

There's such an epidemic of sexual assault, harassment and sexualised bullying towards girls of all ages. Kids are exposed to violent porn from the moment they can use a phone. Eating disorders are exploding, further evidence that hatred of bodies is rife among young people. Adolescence has always been a storm of hormones and emotions, girls have always discovered that their bodies are treated as public property but that is so much worse now.

If your daughter hates her female body please don't assume she's transgender. She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. She needs your help to discover how women throughout time have helped each other navigate this experience, looked after each other, and organised together to change things.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JayniSummers · 30/11/2021 18:11

You are a ruddy hero . Thankyou x Flowers

lazylinguist · 30/11/2021 13:12

I'm not a trans man now, several years later. I'm non binary but identify more with womanhood in a political sense than I do with manhood, and don't (and never have) taken blockers or T. But I do also think I would still be quite miserable today if I wasn't given the option to explore being a trans man. It helped me understand my gender identity and sexuality on a level that I wouldn't have been able to do, otherwise.

Very interesting, and I'm glad you had tye support you needed . But it makes me wonder how the 'TWAW', 'deadnaming' and 'I was always a woman, I just wasn't able to be open about it until now' narrative fits in with stories like yours and with those of the many detransitioners now coming out of the woodwork.

The fact that some people are absolutely insistent that they 100% factually, and permanently are non-binary or the gender opposite to their sex (and really always were, deep down) to the point of expecting legal recognition of that and howling 'transphobe' at anyone who disagrees, the fact that they can turn around a year later and say 'No actually, I am a man after all' makes an utter mockery of it all. It's really important for teenagers to have the freedom to experiment with their identity (as teenagers always have done), but expecting the whole rest of the world to change the definitions of reality to suit that experimentation is frankly absurd.

EightWheelGirl · 29/11/2021 19:26

@nolongersurprised

But if the trans thing is about misogyny in society why do the vast majority of transgenders want to be female?

They don’t anymore. Originally most children presenting to gender clinics were boys, most of whom, if supported, but not given hormones would end up happy in their male bodies. Many would be gay.

Currently, there’s been a dramatic reversal in the sex of the children presenting to gender clinics, with significantly more girls than boys. There’s been a 4000% increase in the number of girls identifying as trans.

Why is that, so you think?

In the middle aged population men seem more likely to transition than women, but middle aged men have different motivations than child related. I can’t say the acronym though, or those monitoring will have the post deleted

I’m sceptical it’s anything to do with the patriarchy. Just seems like too much of a reach to me. I think there is more stigma with boys being non masculine, in the same way that girls can drunkenly kiss another girl without being ostracised by their peers the way a young male would be.
Hospedia · 28/11/2021 02:12

DS told me earlier this week that he thinks he might want to be a girl. He was really worried I'd be angry with him about it so my first response was to reassure him that I'm not and would never be.

The reasons he feels this way are that he likes things people often think of as girly or feminine - cooking, drawing, painting his nails, anime, boy bands, etc. Most of his friends are girls, his one male friend is gay (DS is also gay and has been open about this since around the age of 9). He doesn't like sports. He doesn't feel like he can relate to the boys at school and that he doesn't have much in common with any of them.

I hope he isn't repeating our conversation to a therapist in ten years time but I basically said to him that there aren't really boy things and girl things, there are only things. If the things he likes are usually associated with girls then that's fine, it doesn't mean he's a girl, just the same as liking boy things doesn't automatically make someone a boy. I said that there are a hundred different ways to be a boy/man and a hundred different ways to be a girl/woman and that most people have a mix of feminine and masculine traits.

I reassured him that I'm not angry, how could I be angry. All I want is for him to be himself and for him to be confident in himself that he is enough. We've agreed to coast along and see how things go, whether these feelings develop or fade and in the meantime he knows he can confide in me about anything.

Welcometothejingles · 28/11/2021 01:52

The Bayswater support group provides support for parent/carers whose children are experiencing gender dysphoria.

Sunshinealligator · 28/11/2021 01:00

@Notagain20

... To please explore all the reasons why she might feel intensely uncomfortable with her growing female body, and not just assume she's transgender?

There's such an epidemic of sexual assault, harassment and sexualised bullying towards girls of all ages. Kids are exposed to violent porn from the moment they can use a phone. Eating disorders are exploding, further evidence that hatred of bodies is rife among young people. Adolescence has always been a storm of hormones and emotions, girls have always discovered that their bodies are treated as public property but that is so much worse now.

If your daughter hates her female body please don't assume she's transgender. She might be, but it's far more likely that she is having a normal response to a really sexist society. She needs your help to discover how women throughout time have helped each other navigate this experience, looked after each other, and organised together to change things.

My DD and I had a similar conversation about 3 months ago, we were shopping. She said I need to talk to you about something, got all clammy and we had to go and sit outside. She said she thought she was a boy. She couldn't give much insight into why or really what her feelings were. The things I remember saying were, please don't think I am minimising your feelings, but I wonder if this is something caused by feelings that you don't fit in with what society tells us women should be? I said I was going to have to let her take the lead on this, as I don't 100% know what she feels or thinks, but that I have always been quite masculine in my thoughts and actions, and so has her grandma, so to please not feel that she doesn't belong as a female because she isn't into pink, or high heels or make up. I followed up with asking her to not try and put herself into any particular box, and that she needs to take time to find out who she really is, free of concern about anyones judgement, and whatever it turns out she feels like, she is always loved and supported.

In the months since she's had support to find out who she is. She's cut her long beautiful hair, it's now a gorgeous bob that she styles beautifully! That seems to have brought her some happiness.
Shes started buying things like face and hair masks and some make up when she shops with friends.
Shes playing with different styles of clothing to wear and seems happier and more confident.

I encourage her frequently. We sometimes stray into her dad's wardrobe for a checked shirt or a mens patterned shirt when shopping, but generally she's happier in women's clothes now she's more confident.

3scape · 27/11/2021 23:47

Please don't presume to patronise other people's parenting and intelligence in these things Hmm

nolongersurprised · 27/11/2021 23:34

But if the trans thing is about misogyny in society why do the vast majority of transgenders want to be female?

They don’t anymore. Originally most children presenting to gender clinics were boys, most of whom, if supported, but not given hormones would end up happy in their male bodies. Many would be gay.

Currently, there’s been a dramatic reversal in the sex of the children presenting to gender clinics, with significantly more girls than boys. There’s been a 4000% increase in the number of girls identifying as trans.

Why is that, so you think?

In the middle aged population men seem more likely to transition than women, but middle aged men have different motivations than child related. I can’t say the acronym though, or those monitoring will have the post deleted

Udouhun · 27/11/2021 21:39

Transitioning is impossible though. You can change your body so it approximates the other sex, but you absolutely cannot become the opposite sex.

EightWheelGirl · 27/11/2021 19:13

But if the trans thing is about misogyny in society why do the vast majority of transgenders want to be female?

OldTotty · 27/11/2021 14:18

My DC is now an adult and the conversation has changed. She uses both names, given female name and male adopted name. She has a boyfriend.
A year ago she asked for a sex change. sometimes she talks about being a man others about getting married and having babies. She was offered a consultation process which she has declined. still wears male clothes but the odd female item has appeared. She has mental health issues but not ASD.

Maggiesfarm · 03/05/2021 23:40

I'd never heard of Elliott Page. I googled and found he is an extremely pretty, effeminate-looking young man.

If my daughter, at a young age, had told me she felt like him I would just accept what she said and see how it goes. Kids change so much over the years and at the moment, it's quite fashionable for school children to want to be the opposite sex. It usually doesn't last; if it does, all a parent can do is be unfazed and supportive.

Rejoiningperson · 03/05/2021 22:51

The issue for me is simply aligning to a weird notion that biological status isn't real or worthwhile and if someone changes their name and hairstyle they suddenly become something else. And suddenly more comfortable- why is that? Can we not examine why?

I completely agree with this. At the very least we ought to be able to question. If someone has been an adult for a while, with some experience, knowledge and self reflection under their belt, then it seems more stable to make that choice. For a growing child, no. Experiment yes, but to take any permanent choices, no.

I remember working with adults a while ago in a healthcare setting who were undergoing gender reassignment. I think it was called that then. It was really interesting chatting to them. Most of them, as a condition of any surgery, had to have had quite extensive counseling and to have lived as the opposite sex full-time for a period of years (with cloths, hair, new name etc) before they would be considered for surgery.

The people I talked to them all thought that was a pretty good idea, and acknowledged that they themselves benefited from a long period of time to see how they felt, whether this was what they really wanted. Also even to get wife’s, husbands or family more used to it, and to test out really how far they wanted to go. Some said that they decided only to have some hormones and not extensive surgery, others decided that they needed a bit more time. None got hung up if people they knew took a while to remember to call them She rather than He. None I talked to were in any way wanting to push for recognition as biologically the other sex at all. As long as they were respect and accepted both by loved ones, and by society in jobs etc. Most I talked with at the time were extremely supportive of women’s rights and very sympathetic to safeguarding of young people and of girls.

I’m not sure what has happened recently I don’t recognise the debate at all. It all seems very pushy and aggressive.

HeadNorth · 03/05/2021 15:28

Any medical intervention would cause problems over her lifetime and you should be absolutely trying to stop it, even if she were adult. In the meantime, opposition is the very stuff of adolescence so try to avoid fights.

Yeah, good luck in squaring that circle. Stop your trans child transitioning, even if they are an adult but avoid fights. So easy! Thank goodness you decided to share your amazing parental insights.

Have you thought about publishing a series of parenting guides?:
How to make your child study and get great exams results - while avoiding fights!
How to choose your child's life partner - while avoiding fights!
How to make your child take up the career and life path you have chosen for them - while avoiding fights!
Such expertise needs to be more widely shared.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 03/05/2021 14:52

Wow what a wonderful insight there. Hope you feel better for posting that Thecatonthemat

its all about how girls are treated - this sentence shows exactly how little you know about it. As does calling Elliot Page 'Ellen'.

How the fuck do you think any of us can stop this, especially with an adult child?

Thecatonthemat · 03/05/2021 11:07

The reality is that your daughter will never change sex or be a boy/ man . Neither will Ellen/Elliott. Yes of course they can present as whatever they like, but after the clothes / hairstyle etc, it is all about how girls are treated, nd who wouldn’t want to identify out of that. Any medical intervention would cause problems over her lifetime and you should be absolutely trying to stop it, even if she were adult. In the meantime, opposition is the very stuff of adolescence so try to avoid fights,.

zzizzer · 03/05/2021 10:37

Agh, meant to put that to Tom. It's great to see some guys posting here too.

zzizzer · 03/05/2021 10:36

I agree, thanks for posting.

ElevenBells · 03/05/2021 08:04

@HeadNorth thanks for such a sensible, balanced post. It’s a rare thing to see on these types of threads.

VashtaNerada · 03/05/2021 05:20

This is a silly post. Of course parents would properly discuss an issue like this. It’s never going to be one conversation but many different ones over the years.

AutomaticMoon · 03/05/2021 05:12

It’s scary being a girl, I used to want to be a boy, I think it’s because of my ptsd & autism, I often thought I’d be better off as a man, even though I know boys are sadly also victims of sexual assault

Waitwhat23 · 03/05/2021 01:29

@SvenandSven you sound like you are approaching the situation in a kind and supportive way and I hope your child is happy whatever they decide.

TomPinch · 03/05/2021 01:18

The comparison with gay rights is misleading.

Acceptance of of same-sex sexual attraction is just a recognition that some people's bodies are just made that way, and there is a clear objective standard for what same-sex attraction is (the clue is in the term).

I don't see how the trans rights movement promotes acceptance of one's body at all. It seems to do the quite the opposite, especially where surgery is involved. And despite reading and reading about being transgender, the closest there is to any objective standard is far short of being biological, like, say, being lesbian. It's a strong feeling that you orient towards a gender stereotype that is not the one normally associated with your chromosones. We rarely set up objective standards on the basis of strong feelings.

A useful historical fact to illustrate the difference is this: in apartheid South Africa, some gay men underwent treatment with the aim to turn them into heterosexual women. Leaving aside the inhumanity of this, we may ask why it was easier to do this than remove their gay orientation.

Also, the comparison with gay rights doesn't take into account how society has changed, particularly since the 1980s. We are much more individualistic now, self-expression is now considered fundamental in a way that it simply wasn't then. Everyone has their own truth now and it's considered much less acceptable to critique it. It's naive to think this hasn't had an effect on gender orientation.

ArcheryAnnie · 02/05/2021 23:25

SvenandSven it sounds like you are taking a very measured approach. I wish you and your child a very calm journey through all of this.

Yorkshirelass04 · 02/05/2021 18:55

@HeadNorth Your uncle seems to have acknowledged the existence of lesbians but was prejudiced and didn't want you to become one. That's not the same as saying they didnt exist in the 1980s as they did.

The issue for me is simply aligning to a weird notion that biological status isn't real or worthwhile and if someone changes their name and hairstyle they suddenly become something else. And suddenly more comfortable- why is that? Can we not examine why? How anyone can believe it's intrinsic and not a socially generated phenomena is beyond me. I agree that teens must be able to come up with their own answers, though would also assume as adults parents have more experience and perspective to be able to guide them.