Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Josh Duggar arrested again for having indecent images of children. AIBU in wondering how the hell a man with his history was allowed to remain in the home with his babies?

108 replies

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 30/04/2021 21:01

For anyone who doesn't know who he is Google is up there ^

I don't even watch the programme but I've been following his case (( well cases)) and I'm astounded by the fact that a man's right to have access to his children seems to come above a child's right to be kept safe from harm. Is this the norm in the states whereby someone with a history like his can remain in the home? 🤔

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Handsnotwands · 01/05/2021 15:22

Contd...

Josh Duggar arrested again for having indecent images of children. AIBU in wondering how the hell a man with his history was allowed to remain in the home with his babies?
Josh Duggar arrested again for having indecent images of children. AIBU in wondering how the hell a man with his history was allowed to remain in the home with his babies?
Handsnotwands · 01/05/2021 15:19

I found this a fascinating (and horrifying) read from Emily Anderson

Josh Duggar arrested again for having indecent images of children. AIBU in wondering how the hell a man with his history was allowed to remain in the home with his babies?
Josh Duggar arrested again for having indecent images of children. AIBU in wondering how the hell a man with his history was allowed to remain in the home with his babies?
Josh Duggar arrested again for having indecent images of children. AIBU in wondering how the hell a man with his history was allowed to remain in the home with his babies?
Tinselandlights · 01/05/2021 14:51

I started watching 19 Kids and Countjng on TLC in about 2015, just before all the stories about Josh surfaced. I found it completely intriguing, not to mention bonkers. Life Isn't All Pickles and Hairspray on Facebook is great at keeping tabs on them all.

Josh always came across very oddly and it's unsurprising. What really sticks in my mind is the episodes when he's planning to marry Anna, and Jim Bob is obviously uncomfortable with it and expresses (in so many words) that Josh needs to think beyond marriage just being a vehicle for having sex. I do feel sorry for Anna, she barely stood a chance and is so brainwashed and trapped by it all - she could leave him, but then she presumably would lose (or fears she would lose) her support network. The whole philosophy is around women being 'barefoot and pregnant' - barefoot so they stay at home. Her family are as bad as the Duggars despite her siblings who left.

My real sympathy is for the five girls Josh abused, as well as the poor children whose sexual abuse he has viewed. I was impressed by Jinger's statement on her Instagram as it is so clear and uncompromising. She and Jeremy seem to be the most well-adjusted now she is free of the Duggar compound. Poor Jill is clearly very damaged and it's ridiculous that she isn't allowed at the house but abuser Josh has continued to be welcomed.

The siblings who have clearly seen through the terrible parenting by Jimbob and Michelle, and their apologist behaviour for Josh, seem to be the better adapted ones.

ShoppingPrecinctPrincess · 01/05/2021 14:41

Men, even ones who sexually abuse their female relatives, must always take precedent over the rights of women and girls. That's the evangelical way.

MorganKitten · 01/05/2021 14:19

Famous, white, religious man with friends in high places. The abuse he committed against his sisters was well known among producers before it came to light. Oprah Winfrey and her production team were tipped off to the situation back in 2006 it came out to the public in 2015. There was even a blog written about it in 2007.

ImJustNotSure · 01/05/2021 14:01

As PP have said I’m confused why it’s taken so long for him to be arrested? God knows what he could have been up to in the last couple of years.

I just pray that he hasn’t touched any more of his sisters or his kids.

As for Anna I hope Jimbob gives her fair maintenance for her to go live her life in peace.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 01/05/2021 13:46

His wife has been offered help - IRC her brother offered to help her and her DC to leave a few years ago.

Unfortunately she's very brainwashed. The whole situation is extremely sad for everyone concerned.

Sendsystemsucks · 01/05/2021 13:38

He has the right friends and has been until now virtually untouchable. His wife, Anna, will be blamed for not meeting his 'needs' not him for his actions

aprilshowers2015 · 01/05/2021 13:30

He's surrounded by enablers and has never had to face consequences for his actions.
Anna will have no choice but to stick by him or risk being totally abandoned and shunned. I'm alternating between pity and anger towards her. I just hope she's getting some support

3scape · 01/05/2021 11:11

His family were quite prepared to throw his own sister's under the proverbial bus to avoid him getting punished for his crimes, girls it any wonder he can't and won't change. He feels entitled to his perversion and crimes. I dread to think what he has brought up his children to think is normal.

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 01/05/2021 11:07

Gluten she has.
But she also has a pretty high media presence and is in contact with other family members who left the cult. She put her children at risk to protect a man.. I can't hold her in any, high regard or have much in the way of sympathy. This isnt the 1950s and she isn't that naive.

OP posts:
Moonwhite · 01/05/2021 10:47

Their whole family are enablers. But yeah, let's abuse the women who are consistently told they are sinful and lower than men practically from birth. I guess their male family members just aren't abusing them enough...

His wife can't be anything but an enabler, it's what she raised to be. Same for his sisters. They are probably all victims of him one way or another. It's an extremely fucked up extremely misogynistic dynamic.

If God is going to welcome the male Duggars into heaven, the rest of us would be safer in hell.

GlutenFreeGingerCake · 01/05/2021 10:45

Didn’t think it would take long till someone defended her. She’s an enabler and a cunt, she’s worse than him
WTF she had nothing to do with his early crimes and is under huge pressure to forgive him and be understanding. There is no proof or allegations that he has abused his own children although he has child pornography which is terrible, but I can believe she didn't know and hoped he had changed. After all she has led a very sheltered life and constantly surrounded by people assuring her that change is possible with the love of Jesus and a good wife.

Whatwouldscullydo · 01/05/2021 10:42

Well let's hope she can.

I think there's alot we probably don't know. And I dread to think.what the mental state of all.of them.is tbh.

I dont know why they were ever given a TV show

MadisonMontgomery · 01/05/2021 10:41

It’s awful. I actually feel so sorry for his wife, I used to watch the show and I don’t believe she would have felt she had any option but to stay with him. What on earth is she going to do now, 7 children and no real education, let alone any kind of job.

Wattleanddaub · 01/05/2021 10:39

@Whatwouldscullydo

Didn’t think it would take long till someone defended her. She’s an enabler and a cunt, she’s worse than him

What do you expect someone who's pregnant with 6 other kids who's family akd community could quite possibly disown her if she divorced or kicked him out and there's no system to help her out.

We have no idea what's gone on at home she could well he an.abuse victim Infact didnt one if the Ashley madison women claim.he was really rough etc.

Where is she supoosed to go?

Anna Duggar has 3 siblings who have left fundamentalism, including a sister who is married to an oil millionaire and who owns a private jet. She wouldn't be out on the street with 6 (soon to be 7) children if she divorced Josh.
Whatwouldscullydo · 01/05/2021 10:37

You do know how grooming and abuse works right ?

If it was that simple to just up and leave it would never happen to anyone would it.

Truth is we actually have no idea what went on behind closed doors, what her involvement is or isn't.

Let's face it a single mum.of even 4 kids with no earning capacity , well its nice gesture that the brother said he'd step up but realistically how long would that have been able to go on for ?

MrsGulDukat · 01/05/2021 10:34

She had a brother willing to support her and the 4 kids she had at the time of the molestation scandal in 2015.

She had at least one out back then, instead she popped more babies.

Whatwouldscullydo · 01/05/2021 10:30

Didn’t think it would take long till someone defended her. She’s an enabler and a cunt, she’s worse than him

What do you expect someone who's pregnant with 6 other kids who's family akd community could quite possibly disown her if she divorced or kicked him out and there's no system to help her out.

We have no idea what's gone on at home she could well he an.abuse victim Infact didnt one if the Ashley madison women claim.he was really rough etc.

Where is she supoosed to go?

pollylocketpickedapocket · 01/05/2021 10:15

@speakout

This poor woman is brainwashed - she should have left long ago.
Didn’t think it would take long till someone defended her. She’s an enabler and a cunt, she’s worse than him
JingsMahBucket · 01/05/2021 09:53

@uhtredsonofuhtred1

This is the part that I don't understand...his business was raided in 2019 and reports suggest that was when the images/videos were found. So why the hell has it taken until now for him to be charged and protection for the children put in place?
He’s friends with Ted Cruz and all those other jokers. His mother was doing political robocalls back in 2015 for anti-trans bathroom bills/legislation knowing full well her straight son had molested her daughters and a niece. He’s likely been protected by Trump people within the justice department (Bill Barr) until Biden’s people moved in three months ago. See also: Matt Gaetz. This is the real shit those idiot QAnon and anti-trans types keep flapping their gums about but I bet they’re pretty fucking silent now.
Candleabra · 01/05/2021 09:28

God I remember following this when it came out about him abusing his sisters. It was all brushed under the carpet then, and the girls were encouraged (forced) to forgive him. I think he and Anna had four kids then. I didn't know they up to seven now. No life for a woman. Makes me so angry and all wrapped up in Christian values. The family (men) are so smug I could punch them. They're just above the law and so protected.

uhtredsonofuhtred1 · 01/05/2021 09:22

This is the part that I don't understand...his business was raided in 2019 and reports suggest that was when the images/videos were found. So why the hell has it taken until now for him to be charged and protection for the children put in place?

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 01/05/2021 09:13

LimeCoconut I was fully aware of that.

But he was first arrested back in 2019. So this man who is obviously a paedophile has been living freely with his own children and doing god knows what for the last two years..... Talk about closing the stable door after the horse has bolted. Hmm

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 01/05/2021 09:11

Vile, just vile. And mummy and daddy knew it had been happening for decades. His poor victims being coerced into forgiveness.

The whole premise of the sex thing seems to be that women and girls are temptation and forbidden fruit. Males being the procreator, masters and unable to resist.