Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shouting at kids, want to stop

130 replies

Ncbecauseselfloathing · 28/04/2021 22:17

I know I ABU.

I can’t stop. I don’t know how.

I am traumatising my DD. She is 3 and so wilful and difficult but she is just 3.

Shouting doesn’t work I know (occasionally it does but mostly it doesn’t).

I am at a loss. I feel like I have been lobotomised and just can’t catch a break between 3 year old and the baby. I have it quite easy compared to others.

I asked GP about help for anger management a while ago and it sounds like you basically have to be seriously fucking up your family and SS involved and then you might be sent to parenting classes. I don’t need that, but my reading books and articles isn’t working.

OP posts:
Kaboomba · 28/04/2021 23:17

You sound like me 2 years ago. I had just had a baby and had a 3 year old (who subsequently has had an ASD diagnosis) who had lots of tantrums and was struggling to adjust to a new baby. DH had just started a brand new job and couldn't take time off or anything. It was tough, I shouted at my 3 year old all the time for things that really didn't matter. I did end up with postnatal depression and the medication really helped me but I used some techniques like thinking what is the worst that's going to happen here? So your chips example, is it really that bad that for one night your daughter just had chips for her dinner? It's not every night and I'm sure she had plenty of healthy things throughout the day.

Even now I take a second to think about the impact my shouting has vs what impact the action has. My now two year old was certainly sent to test my patience but really he's just exploring the world and testing boundaries and it's all part of growing up. He spills a whole basket of toys on the floor, well we'll just clean them up once he's finished.

I've also followed the technique of having the house set up so that the kids can do whatever they please (within reason) I don't have ornaments/breakables out, we use plastic/wooden crockery. Anything we don't want damaged is put away somewhere out of reach. I find this helps minimise my stress levels and I can keep my calm much better.

There's also no shame in admitting that you need you time, your DH needs to step up and look after both children to give you some time to yourself. It's so important to have you time, that doesn't mean going to shops alone or going for bath while they run around down stairs etc but something you do just for you!!

Embracelife · 28/04/2021 23:12

Nect time Stop and breath
So she has few chips on a plate? Her dad was having chips so why not her
The fishcake will keep for another day
One night chips is no big deal
You could have added some fishcake to chips or afterwards

Let it go
She was maybe shouting floor I e the chips on the floor
If someone put food in front of you
Then someone else took it away
And you are three
You would be cross

So dd reaction was understandable
Dad gives me chips
Mum takes away
I confused

Anyway there is clearly more to it
But start by training yourself to pause stop breath and counting to 10

Can you get some time to yourself ?
If dh is wfh take time each day for half hour walk on your own or start c25k

nimbuscloud · 28/04/2021 23:05

Yes you are emotionally abusing her. You must stop. Can you access support tomorrow ? Are you communicating with your dh about your feelings?

Hankunamatata · 28/04/2021 23:05

Incredible years not test 🤦‍♀️

Hankunamatata · 28/04/2021 23:04

Incredible tests programme. Did it via zoom and it was brilliant. Helped me shout so much less and be more positive.

You can also buy book one or audiobook on audible

nanbread · 28/04/2021 23:04

X posted with you... I know those exact feelings!

You haven't talked about your child's actual behaviour, but the explosive child isn't really right for a 3yo IMO.

I would recommend "the book you wish your parents had read" by Phillipa Perry, but the main reframe to make in your mind is that all behaviour is communication, and that a 3 year old CANNOT control having a tantrum. A tantrum is an expression of feelings. I'm sure you want your dd to be able to express her feelings to you.

3 can be a tough age but also her world's been turned upside down with the arrival of baby.

First of all could you commit to a week of early nights instead of browsing. Not like you're getting much out of the browsing, I know from experience...

Second of all can you have half a weekend day to yourself - get DH to take them both out - or use annual leave to take some time off to yourself? You could maybe take a day off fortnightly for a couple of months to help you get back on top of things.

Or can you pay for help to sort the house?

Ncbecauseselfloathing · 28/04/2021 23:03

@nimbuscloud - yes, she is physically safe.

I do think I am traumatising her and damaging her emotionally. I think you are right about different responses to men and women but that’s a bit beyond me at the moment.

OP posts:
Ncbecauseselfloathing · 28/04/2021 23:02

I immediately apologised to her and was trying to calm her down but she was so upset and screaming for me to fix her plate. She deserves so much more. She is not bad, she is really clever and funny she is just so independent and wants things exactly a certain way sometimes - so if a toy drops she wants to pick it up, not you, and if you do or try to help her she loses it.

We have worried that there is something wrong with her but I think it’s normal tantrums plus being modelled entirely the wrong behaviour.

OP posts:
nimbuscloud · 28/04/2021 22:59

Is your dd safe ?

Ncbecauseselfloathing · 28/04/2021 22:57

These messages are really encouraging and giving me hope that I can change, thank you.

A specific example. I’m so ashamed of this.

Tonight DD’s plate ended up getting smashed.

I was putting together her dinner and went to grab something. Because of stressful afternoon, DH had decided he couldn’t even deal with boiling pasta and got himself a takeaway. Dd tore into package and soon wanted some of his chips.

He put some on a little plate for her. I asked him to give me her plate so I could add them to the larger plate I was making up for her so that it would be a more balanced plate of homemade fish cakes, veg, and a yoghurt ‘sauce’ with the small handful of chips he gave her. I knew that otherwise she was liable to just eat the chips and ignore the rest. I was a bit annoyed at him and she was also grabbing at his coke and I don’t want him to drink that in front of her,

She got annoyed and wanted her plate back and the chips ended up on the floor. I scoop them up to get rid of them and then she starts shouting at me about wanting it on the floor. I did try to ask her gently what she wanted and I couldn’t understand and she needed to calm down and tell me, and she kept screaming incomprehensibly so I knocked it to the floor.

I didn’t really mean for it to break but I wasn’t thinking. And then realising it had broken I was annoyed and so I actually smashed it again and shouted.

So entirely counterproductive, scary, and more than angry - actually violent. Happened because I was actually stressed and annoyed about things happening with my DH and other things actually unrelated to DD, it had just built up and tension exploded at dinner time.

OP posts:
nimbuscloud · 28/04/2021 22:57

but other times I also ‘flip the switch’ and just scream

You are lucky you are not a man. If you were you would be told you are an abuser and your partner would be told to leave you and protect the children.

nanbread · 28/04/2021 22:54

What helps me (some of these things will help you to be calmer, others will improve your relationship to make it more fun and maybe less difficult):

Me time. Self care - not long baths or doing my nails, more like getting takeaway so I don't have to cook or wash up, letting my standards slip on washing the DC's hair or housework etc. Making my life easier however I can, really.

Venting. Have someone non judgemental you can let rip to. Maybe counseling if you have stuff to unpick from your childhood.

Playfulness. Be silly and funny with your daughter, find out what makes her laugh beyond tickling, try to make sure there is laughter and fun and connection between you every day.

One on one time - try to have this with her every day, doing what she wants to do, even if it's just for 10 minutes. Give her a sense of control.

Breathing and feeling your feelings. When you want to lose your shit, breathe for a count of three and ask yourself "is this an emergency?" Observe what your anger feels like in your body and try to see it as a thing separate from you that you can let pass.

Repair - everyone loses it sometimes. Just try to make things better afterwards. Don't leave them. Try to do this as soon after as you can do it with grace.

Allow her her feelings. She's allowed to feel angry, annoyed, upset, grumpy. She's NOT allowed to hit, bite, throw things at the baby. You can prevent these things gently and calmly.

Self forgiveness. Beating yourself up is counter productive. You're doing the best you can even if it doesn't feel like it. You recognise you want to find another way and are working on it. You're a good parent wanting to do better.

Needcoffeecoffeecoffee · 28/04/2021 22:53

I dont have any advice for you but just wanted to say I feel/act the same and need to try to change so you are not alone.
If I promise myself I will try hard to be calm and then get cross or frustrated and end up shouting I'm cross with myself and then it becomes a circle because I take that out on the dds and then it circles round Sad

AntiSocialDistancer · 28/04/2021 22:52

I feel you.

What helped was setting boundaries, realising they were going to test them and having a structure that I put in place to keep myself calm. I liked the book 123 Magic for consequences and moving through them emotionless.

I also listened to Calm Parents, Happy Kids. It was tough to listen to at times but on reflection it helped.

Also being fair to myself and thinking, I was going through a lot and trying to put more supportive strategies and self care in for myself.

Ultimately I was screaming at my kid because I felt out of control and unable to get them to do what I wanted. That of course, is why most kids scream at us too.

Ncbecauseselfloathing · 28/04/2021 22:47

@nanbread my childhood wasn’t shouty - I have always been a bit shouty with my family. I don’t remember my mum and dad shouting though I did get spanked and told off.

Right now - or indeed since DD born I don’t get much time for myself. I only had childcare for when at work and I work long hours and DH doesn’t drive so I had to do all the logistics of drop off etc. Now while wfh it’s different but we moved into...the house situation is not straightforward and I can’t keep on top of anything. But there just doesn’t seem to be a way to get time for myself. If I get a window that should be spent on cleaning etc or the pile of things to be done.

I end up stealing time from myself by being on my phone late at night to sort of get back some breathing space and I end up more tired because I’ve robbed myself of sleep.

DH finds my daughter tough too, he is more involved now that he is wfh but somehow it doesn’t help overall. Probably being im looking after the baby when he had DD.

I don’t think I’m peri menopausal. I am knackered but have always had a hot temper.

I sometimes try the getting down at her level thing and sometimes I am able to control my temper but other times I also ‘flip the switch’ and just scream.

I have read the explosive child and various articles online about dealing with tantrums. Basically I seem to react to her tantrum with a tantrum.

OP posts:
rulesofthecar · 28/04/2021 22:46

I found myself like this, and I was so annoyed with myself that I kept shouting, and felt like we (I) were really stuck in a rut. I made a massive massive effort to stop shouting and be calm even when I felt wound up, and within a week, my DC had responded to that with so much better behaviour. It was really tough to change my mindset, but I had no idea it would work as fast as it did. I do still very occasionally shout at them, but it is definitely more as a one off these days, and we communicate a lot better now.

Notable · 28/04/2021 22:44

I recommend the Waking Up app.

GreenSlide · 28/04/2021 22:44

Jo Frosts confident toddler care is good. Gives you alternative techniques to use so you don't just shout all the time. I was quite shouty before starting the naughty step, now I just give the warning and if he keeps doing the naughty thing he goes on the naughty step. No shouting and drama required. I'll also say 'I'm getting cross' before actually getting cross as it's only fair to warn them that they're pushing it.

Notable · 28/04/2021 22:44

Meditation and sertraline helped me.

I was a shouter. My eldest had huge difficulties managing his emotions too. Now I never shout and I can see his behaviour emotional regulation improving too.

merrygoround88 · 28/04/2021 22:42

I went through a phase of this and really when I think back I am so disgusted with myself . What you are describing is a temper and a short fuse and you just have to train yourself to manage it.

What helped me was 2 things
You need to develop the ‘pause’ so basically when you feel that anger well up, take a deep breath and (provided it’s safe) walk away and count to ten. In that 10 seconds think of how you will impact your beautiful child and don’t think about how you are feeling. Your reaction is because you are feeling angry for yourself - less focus on you and more on them.

Secondly I committed (to myself) to parenting for one week like there was always someone in the room watching me. After each day I noted what went well and after a week I found I was starting to develop positive habits. When I feel myself slipping I go back to this.

On an ongoing basis i think some alone time to replenish is key as well as nice activities with your children.

Good luck and do try your best, life will be so much better for all of you

Laggartha · 28/04/2021 22:40

Can you describe a specific example?

RandomMess · 28/04/2021 22:39

Slowing down your breathing helps calm your flight/fight response.

nanbread · 28/04/2021 22:38

You can't pour from an empty cup.

How do you look after yourself? What do you do that's for you in the average week? What was your childhood like? Was it shouty?

Userg1234 · 28/04/2021 22:36

Try actually talking asking "why are you doing that" a lot of kids I have seen do things to actually get a response from their parents...even shouting....do you spend more time on your phone than talking to your daughter? Do realise she is saying mum, mum, mum often? Do you sit her in front of a tv, laptop, tablet for a bit of quite!?

AnneLovesGilbert · 28/04/2021 22:35

Which books have you read?