Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shouting at kids, want to stop

130 replies

Ncbecauseselfloathing · 28/04/2021 22:17

I know I ABU.

I can’t stop. I don’t know how.

I am traumatising my DD. She is 3 and so wilful and difficult but she is just 3.

Shouting doesn’t work I know (occasionally it does but mostly it doesn’t).

I am at a loss. I feel like I have been lobotomised and just can’t catch a break between 3 year old and the baby. I have it quite easy compared to others.

I asked GP about help for anger management a while ago and it sounds like you basically have to be seriously fucking up your family and SS involved and then you might be sent to parenting classes. I don’t need that, but my reading books and articles isn’t working.

OP posts:
merrygoround88 · 29/04/2021 10:36

I second @PerspicaciousGreen suggestion re easy food. I am a big believer in cooking from scratch but there are plenty of times I left overwhelmed and opted for one of the following

M&S pre prepared chicken Kiev and mash potato and carrot/turnip mash . Perfect for adults and toddlers
They also do a good value lasagne tray or fish pie and this with a bag of salad is fine
That’s 2 days when you don’t have meal pressure hanging over you.
Other options are butchers who do nice stir fry’s in sauces or flavoured meats.
Again buy in the prepped veg to go alongside and your toddler will be happy.

Meal times are a stress so you need to make them as easy on you as possible

Ilikecheeseontoast · 29/04/2021 10:24

This was me 2 months ago. Shouty, irritable and then feeling so guilty. I went to the dr and she sent me for me some blood tests. Turns out I have post partum thyroiditis. Baby is 6 months old. She put me on some meds (propranolol) and it instantly calmed me down. I literally can't get angry!

PerspicaciousGreen · 29/04/2021 09:48

I really really disagree with the posters who are calling you abusive. Not because I think what you're doing is OK and you can just carry on as is, but because I think it's a hugely unhelpful label for you right now. You sound incredibly stressed and like you hate being Shout Mummy and you're asking on here for some help to change. I just think "abusive" is not going to be a remotely helpful thing for you to think about yourself and is just going to make you feel even more terrible without actually helping you to change.

Couple of things have jumped out at me from your posts:

It's great that your daughter has started at nursery. If she's only just started you won't be seeing the benefit yet, but give it a little time and it'll do you good to get a break from each other.

There are lots of medications you can take while breastfeeding. I really think you could do with going back to your GP and asking about it. You might choose not to in the end, but breastfeeding is not an insurmountable barrier.

Your home situation sounds really stressful. Your husband working a lot and not appreciating you. (I can't believe he got a takeaway for just him !!!) And you've got a young baby, you're breastfeeding, you're not sleeping well... I'm not surprised you're finding things hard. I often feel guilty about things like easy food etc, so one technique I use is to set a time limit on it. For the next month (or whatever) I'm just going to pick the easy way out every time, then on X date I'll pick myself up and have another go at doing things "properly". It means I can relax knowing it's not going to be forever and I have a fixed-time free pass to be "lazy".

If you can vocalise your escalating anger, you can be aware yourself of when you're about to tip over the edge. Our son doesn't tantrum in a typical angry way but he just dissolves into loud hysterical tears on a little puddle of desolation on the floor. Sometimes I can sympathise... sometimes it enrages me. To avoid shouting, I say, "I am going to go somewhere else now. When you have finished crying and can tell me using words, come and find me in the kitchen." Then I walk out and seethe somewhere else for a bit. If he follows me crying and I'm still that cross, I go somewhere else. Usually I do end up calming down and going back to him before he finishes crying and finds me, but I do need that breathing space somewhere away from the max-volume howling.

My favourite toddler book is How To Talk So Little Kids Will Listen. It's not really aimed at your problems, but you might enjoy it anyway. One thing it does have which is helpful is the "rewind" technique. You say: "Pause mummy! That wasn't very good. Let's try again. Rewind mummy! Ready? And...play mummy!" And then say/do the thing you wish you had. It's a very explicit way of having another go. I can't always stop myself shouting, but I can always apologise and have another go.

tempnamechange98765 · 29/04/2021 09:42

I don’t post much these days but I resonate with your OP so much.

I was just like this, 2 years ago or so, when my DC were 3 and a baby. I found my 3 year old so so hard to manage, and was also having problems with his childcare setting at the time. I would flip and absolutely scream at him, I’m so ashamed now.

I was without a doubt suffering with PND and anxiety. Like you I have always had a short fuse and was a shouty child, but had chilled out a lot as an adult. Kids push your buttons, but if you’re not reacting how you want to, I think it’s worth exploring deeper. I started taking 50g daily Sertraline when my eldest was nearly 4 and it was a game changer, I felt like the old me again. Only then was I able to clearly see that I’d been depressed/suffering post natally, as it had all started just before my baby was born.

I would really recommend exploring that. I was VERY against anti depressants as in my mind I wasn’t depressed, but it saved my relationship with my eldest child who is now 5. I’ve tapered down the medication so I’m currently taking 25mg every other day, and plan on eventually stopping.

I still get cross and impatient, I do still occasionally shout/snap, but it’s not out of my control. I have a really good relationship with my eldest DC now, as much as he can still push my buttons! But I can see clearly now that he is just a child. I can’t believe the expectations I had of his behaviour when he was just 3 and had a baby sibling in the house.

Books wise How To Talk So Little Kids Listen is also excellent and helped me adapt my parenting.

PerspicaciousGreen · 29/04/2021 09:29

@spittycup

I also recommend the book "When Mum Turned Into A Monster" as an conversation starter where you can apologise for shouting. I sometimes use the "turning into a monster" as a way to describe my escalating crossness in a more fun way.

@PerspicaciousGreen

Thank you for mentioning this! I read this book as a child and have been trying to remember the name. Off to buy it lol

Yay! Toddler, uh, liked it so much that sometimes he ASKS me to turn into a monster and stomp around and growl at him and tell him not to do things ("Grrrr! Are you sitting down, you naughty boy? No! Don't stand up! Roar!"), then to turn back into a mummy and give him cuddles. I find it a bit weird but rationalise it as psychologically positive role playing...
LBTM · 29/04/2021 09:27

I had really similar problems with shoutingat my toddler when I was on mat leave with my youngest. I started taking st John's wort and find it helps a quite bit. And telling my toddler when I was starting to feel cross and getting better at walking out for a few seconds. Good luck!

Notable · 29/04/2021 08:57

I'd really love to explore medication to just take the edge of slightly. I feel I have slightly heightened anxiety which could be helped. Haven't the first idea how to raise this with the doctor tho.

@headintheproverbial you might actually find it easier to talk about this with a doctor now that face to face appointments are a rare thing. I filled out a form describing my symptoms online and then my doctor phoned me for a chat. I think I had a tendency to minimise my problems when in a face to face situation.

Meditation and medication Grin I am a calmer more patient and tolerant person now and it’s literally been life changing.

FrozenVag · 29/04/2021 07:35

Are you depressed?
Forget about the shouting part for a second - are you struggling ?

Saltyslug · 29/04/2021 07:29

Do you shout in front of friends? Or in public? Best either pretend you’re being filmed or watched when dealing with situations or put the kids somewhere safe and have 5 minutes away to calm down

Quincie · 29/04/2021 07:26

(mostly involving other people - people having problems that I have promised to help them with and I can’t get things done. I know - sounds mad but I do the kind of job that involves people turning to me for help usually. I’m on leave at the moment but friends and family come fir advice

Unless you are handing out money does the help you give actually make a difference? I used to 'help' a useless family member - but in fact none of the help, even the money , made a difference - they half followed whatever advice the last person gave them (not mine), and blew the money. Taking a step back and saying 'Oh, that's a shame' but offering no advice actually did them a favour - they had to start to take responisbility for themselves. And was like a heavy cloud rising off my shoulders.
Try to pre empt stuff with DH, plan the food more together.
Can you manage to get outside - I dont' know where you are in the country but sit and watch DD play, admire the nice daisies she's picked, baby can be in buggy. Getting out of the house at anytime is much better than indoors all day.

Cowbells · 29/04/2021 07:23

I agree - avoid Supernanny. She likes battles of wills and punishments.

Cowbells · 29/04/2021 07:22

Seriously read this book and just do what it says even if it feels artificial. It turned me pretty much overnight from a screamer to a calm mum and DC rarely tantrummed from then on. It's all about avoiding battles of wills, offering choices both of which work for you and agreeing with how they feel even if you don't agree with what they want. (Which is a weirdly successful technique.)

Countrygirl2021 · 29/04/2021 07:17

If you think about co-regulation the more you shout and are wound up, the more she is wound up.

Don't watch super nanny. She advocates time out and naughty step as I remember it which teaches shame and is terrible for children's attachment.

Is your husband calmer? Can he take over when you are stressed. Have you you got consistent rules, boundaries, bedtimes, good nutritious diet and limited screen time?

You are right this isn't good for her. Is she at nursery when you work? What do they say about her?

OverTheRubicon · 29/04/2021 07:16

Another vote for Incredible Years. My council has very little help for SEN without years of waiting, but one thing they do to almost anyone who seeks help is offer an Incredible Years based parenting course to shut us up about the total lack of any other meaningful support and I was sceptical but it really was very good. I'd see another GP and try to get proper help - I bet that your concerns were minimised because you were a nicely presented white middle class woman, if you were a man or from a different background they'd be calling ss - it's not fair to you or to your DCs.

I am generally very placid but when my relationship was falling apart and my dc2 was younger (now also diagnosed with ASD), I used to get grumpy as well. It's got easier with age, also when then-DH moved out I did get more tired but also there was so much less tension that in many ways it was easier. Unfortunately my ex has a real temper and I do think it's very bad for children to see, it was a big cause of me wanting to live separately. It's so good that you have identified it now and are committed to working on it.

It sounds like you and your DH are not on the same page, him sitting at the table with a takeaway while you eat something feels like it's representative of a big undercurrent. Is he feeling like you're not cooking enough? Can you take turns cooking and freezing meals that are satisfying and filling for everyone? Or otherwise have her eat sometimes and the two of you have an adult takeaway together later? Also, how are you sharing things otherwise?

You do need to get this sorted, as in my experience it gets more and not less stressful when you go back to work and have more to juggle. Good on you for identifying the issue, and good luck.

Ncbecauseselfloathing · 29/04/2021 07:12

@RestingPandaFace Yes, a lot of it is because of DH but it was also a reaction to his stress.

He didn’t invite his mum over, she turned up in our part of town. She lives on the other side of town. She actually turned up at DD’s nursery gates but timed it wrong - not sure what she was intending, but probably to force a visit from lunchtime onwards (and use/ manipulate DD to achieve that). If DH says no to MIL she will harass him by text/ phone. I am very annoyed about how MIL is but powerless to change - I don’t want to stop DD seeing her, and I don’t want to make it more stressful for DH by banning visits. I did say she can’t come in here but then it was raining heavily outside so the weather wasn’t on my side.

With the chips it wasn’t his fault in the moment. She pounced on the package. It is his fault for letting her open things for him and not training her that it’s not ok to go into bags. She doesn’t just dive into my shopping or my handbag, but she will into DH’s or MIL’s - who of course gives her an unwelcome piece of tat or in appropriate toy each time she sees her and ignores me when I say that I don’t want her to let her root around in her handbag.

They both say things like ‘she wanted it’ or ‘she just did it’ as if they are not the adults in the situation. For example, I saw another kinder egg toy piece on the floor - and we have agreed to not buy those because the toys are annoying - cheap plastic which breaks easily and DD gets upset and she leaves them on the floor which creates a risk for our feet and the baby who is at grabbing things on the floor stage. So we’ve said no more but when I found a new one on the baby’s playmat yesterday, DH just said ‘she wanted it’. I read that to mean ‘she wanted it and I was too overwhelmed also having to put up with my mother to fight the 3 year old’.

So, yes, a lot of it comes from DH but he does help out with DD a lot more now (I am making him in anticipation of return to work) and he is very overwhelmed himself and I can see he is at close to burnout/ breaking point. There is also little that I can do to change him. I don’t feel heard or listened to a lot but shouting doesn’t change that.

There is usually a lot of stress if MIL has been around.

OP posts:
Luckystar1 · 29/04/2021 07:03

OP I can see a lot of myself in your posts. I too can be very hot headed. I don’t like it either.

I have 3 DCs,’ (one is a baby still), DH works very long hours and we have zero other help. My DH was absolutely useless with the first 2 DC and it honestly nearly drove me insane. He is much more hands on now, and the difference is striking.

You know what, you have my deepest sympathies. It’s so, so hard. The worst parts of becoming a mother are that your feelings are completely invalidated or de-prioritised.

You are no doubt stuck in the cycle of ‘completely exhausted/stressed, get cross, lose it, feel guilty’ and round and round you go. I absolutely know how you feel, I have been there (and occasionally go there, but much less).

I actually think what your husband did with the take away, was a complete kick in the teeth for you and no doubt you felt completely undermined and upset that the work you are putting in to the family is being completely overlooked.

I understand.

I’m not condoning your behaviour, we both know it should be better (mine too by the way, when I act like a dick), but I just wanted you to know that I see your situation for what it likely is and I understand how you feel.

Best of luck, it’s hard, but you can do it.

Mincepiesallyearround · 29/04/2021 07:01

We’ve all had moments of this. I read something once that before you open your mouth to yell imagine that your toddler is your elderly relative who has dementia and is being annoying. I guess the idea is you wouldn’t shout at them because they can’t help it and in a way neither can your young child (depends what they’ve been up to of course!)

RestingPandaFace · 29/04/2021 06:43

How much of your stress is actually rooted in how your DH behaves?

From what you have said he had your MIL over which is a sore point and was messing around for hours whilst you did housework and looked after baby. Even though he was in charge of DD he wasn’t looking after her properly so she ended up wet and you had to change her. He didn’t fancy cooking so he got himself a takeaway and left you looking cooking instead. He then started eating in front of a hungry 3 yo and gave her chips instead of giving them to you to add to her dinner.

I am not for a second condoning shouting at DD or throwing her plate, but it’s no wonder you were stressed out.

Ncbecauseselfloathing · 29/04/2021 06:43

I know it was abusive. That realisation is prompting me to reach out for help.

Reading further updates (thank you) I think I do need to work on me, and certainly before I go back to work - whether medication or CBT etc. I have been waking up in the night just thinking about disaster scenarios and just feeling angry or miserable a lot of the time so I think it’s been bubbling under the surface without me really realising. The fact that my DH is so miserable at the moment speaking to the stress of life at the moment. He isn’t usually a shouter but has been shouting a lot more recently. My behaviour isn’t ok for him either.

(My MIL’s visit was unplanned, she had to come inside because it was raining. Taking baby for a walk when she is here is a good suggestion, I just didn’t think to do it in the moment.)

Helping me to see that I think there are some underlying reasons for behaviour - being knackered primarily - but not pretending these are excuses. It has to stop.

OP posts:
merrygoround88 · 29/04/2021 06:23

Reading through your updated OP I am struck by a couple of things

  1. Your DD is a normal 3 year old, I don’t think anything you have said makes me think otherwise so I wouldn’t be rushing to diagnose here
  2. Food is an issue so your DH needs to tow the line. Can’t you all eat one meal?
  3. Can’t you leave for a walk whilst your MIL is there . Use everyone you can to get some time
  4. Walk with the baby whilst your toddler is in pre school
ClareBlue · 29/04/2021 00:54

Reacting this way is nearly always because of other issues

Partner not doing fair share
Not enough sleep
Financial stress
Work stress

If those are sorted you won't yell at your children

BurbageBrook · 29/04/2021 00:38

The dinner incident really was abusive. It is abusive. I can't sugar-coat it because you do have to stop.

BurbageBrook · 29/04/2021 00:37

You do sound very angry and it's not nice for the kids, I agree. I do think that if you keep shouting a lot, you will end up either with emotionally insecure/damaged kids or very loud, angry kids.
Just take a deep breath, count to 5/10, and make the choice not to shout.
You are the adult here. You are in control of your reactions.
If still struggling maybe go back to GP for CBT.

Mowly75 · 29/04/2021 00:34

This is a really helpful thread. I struggle too. I’ve been reading up on maternal anger and how it’s such a taboo and trying to understand it. Also another vote for Perry here.

nanbread · 29/04/2021 00:23

Don't beat yourself up. It will get better. Mine are older now (at least one autistic too, interestingly) and while I can still find their behaviour infuriating I find it so much easier to deal with these days.