Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask which new build houses you would avoid

239 replies

bridgetreilly · 28/04/2021 10:40

Looking for a house and there are several new build developments we’re interested in, but I’m finding it hard to get honest reviews. Are there builders with truly awful reputations that I shouldn’t even bother looking at?

And, conversely, has anyone got experience of a good quality new home that you love?

OP posts:
Theladyinpurple · 28/04/2021 18:34

I can imagine it varies by development but we are pleased with our Barratt home. Great size with a big garden (with decent turf too). All houses on our development have 2 parking spaces on their drive.
Our site manager has been quick to rectify the issues we've had.
Imo any house you buy will have issues, at least with a new build you don't need to pay to fix it!

SwimBaby · 28/04/2021 18:20

I would most definitely recommend Redrow. My Redrow home is my third new build house and it’s the best by far.

PenfoldPenny · 28/04/2021 18:18

Local to me they are building new homes on areas that routinely flood - knee deep in water every year.
And on higher up land that is resulting in areas closer to the town centre flooding that didnt previously as a result of the new builds.
Hence new builds of all varieties are a nope from me - especially as there are several empty houses within a five minute walk of my house!

KensingtonKate · 28/04/2021 17:31

"@MrsSprogett Not builders but I would find out about the land it's built on before I consider one. Near us they are building on everything, locals avoid them because they know the history"

Yes, this. Good point @mrs There are brown field sites and green field sites. Brown field
sites have had previous industrial usage. Anything from a former shoe shop to an oil depot/ production plant or worse.

KensingtonKate · 28/04/2021 17:23

Basically, most, not all but most developers; pack as many new houses in as they can, on a small space land area and spend as little as possible building them , in order to maximise their financial return.

Do not be taken in by "sales show homes " as they are usually higher spec , if detached plotted with greater space between properties and larger gardens and not representative of what you will actually end up with. Especially if you buy off plan. The show homes are eventually sold off later at a higher price as they are ultimately higher spec'd, more space around them and there to entice.

GetTheStartyParted · 28/04/2021 17:18

We moved into a St Modwens house just over 2 years ago. We had quite a bit of snagging but it was all done without fuss. We were the end of phase one and very happy overall.

Now the project is on phase 2b, many of phase 2a have commented on the community page that they have numerous problems that are not being resolved. I think the combination of covid, the site manager moving to another project and other factors have led to many issues being ignored. I feel sorry for them as our experience so was so positive.

KensingtonKate · 28/04/2021 17:00

Tbh OP i would not touch a new home anymore ever! Had 3 in total, yrs ago, my 1st, 2nd and 3rd homes. 2 , 2 bed flats in a new developments, then a new house. The last one of which a David Wilson home, but applies to all . Appalling shoddy build quality. Wooden framed structures with breeze block and brick outer skin. Dividing walls basically as thin as paper! Erected in record time and very packed together. Detached by only inches! Floors not level, walls not level, gas leaks, water leaks. Radiators falling off walls. Too hot in summer. Found sandwich packs, twix wrappers, coke bottles and crisp packs in the wall cavity, when opened up to extend the kitchen, builders had shoved daily their rubbish in there. Bath waste pipe fitted upside down, slow draining water . Only discovered when we had plumber in to find out what was going on, the bathroom floor had not enough recess , so rather than fix the floor, they bodged the waste. Ensuite shower leaked through tiles as pipework behind not tightened properly. Only noticed when tiles started to fall off and plumber discovered. Central heating system worked when it felt like it, discovered not recommended for the size of house i had. Needed bigger system. Garden soil was basically mashed up building rubble covered in turf. I have learnt so much about property but the hard way!

I have an older traditionally built house now and love it. Great walls to hang stuff, stays cool in summer. Feels solid and well built. Is detached in a true sense, not "on top" of neighbours. Renovated it from top to bottom and it has never given me a days hassle. Did everything over time and properly. Garden also established and lovely as previous owners planted much over 70 years. It was just a case of me jet washing patio, putting a garden seating set in and garden done.

I am downsizing in a few yrs to be mortgage free etc now only 1 DC at home but , will buy another smaller but older property like this . Older houses have a lovely history too and often when gardening i find old bits of pottery and coins. It is lovely to remember others who may have lived here hundreds of yrs ago.

The best thing about older homes are the cool proper walls in the summer. Keeps the house lovely and cool. You need a masonry drill to hang anything up but worth it. I also think older properties with original features have a better resale value if you are looking to move up the property ladder. New homes also depreciate in value immediately in the early yrs, a bit like brand new cars as soon as you drive off the forecourt.

ABCDEF1234 · 28/04/2021 16:22

Live in a Charles Church home and only had a few minor issues, all of which were rectified quickly (this includes an issue as soon as we moved in and an issue almost 2 years to the day that we moved in).

LadyPoison · 28/04/2021 16:09

I'm currently watching the black stains creeping over the rendering already on the estate currently being built on the other side of the village by Wimpey and Bovis.

They look awful and the estate isn't even finished yet

TheLoveOfMoney · 28/04/2021 16:05

I moved into a new build 6 years ago and it's been constant issues. It's a Barratts. I will never buy a new build again, and even thought it came with 5 years fixtures and fittings guarantee it's not worth it.

JediGnot · 28/04/2021 16:04

@bridgetreilly

Looking for a house and there are several new build developments we’re interested in, but I’m finding it hard to get honest reviews. Are there builders with truly awful reputations that I shouldn’t even bother looking at?

And, conversely, has anyone got experience of a good quality new home that you love?

I would avoid all new builds personally, and I work in property. All are overpriced (in my experience) and many can be problematic. At the very least insist on freehold and dont use the developers recommended solicitor.
noblegreenk · 28/04/2021 15:58

Funnily enough I was talking to my husband about new build homes the other day. He works in the building trade and he said he wouldn't touch Persimmon or Bellway with a barge pole. Although he doesn't rate new builds at all. He said they're massively overpriced and he'd prefer to buy a house that's around 10-20 years old because then it would have fully settled.

LarsErickssong · 28/04/2021 15:57

I think it really depends on the area manager so it's hard to tar them all with the same brush, however I would never touch one and no I'm not jealous as a posted suggested up thread...

I know someone who works for Bellway in North Yorkshire who says even though he would never buy one they are relatively good quality but when he worked on a Bellway site further south with a different area manager they were absolutely shocking.

A lot of the ones in my area are being built on flood planes and areas of moss which is the natural run off for the towns water so I am really concerned about drainage in years to come.

notalwaysalondoner · 28/04/2021 15:36

We have a new build flat in London built by the Berkely Group, we bought it 5 years ago and it's been wonderful. We've never had a single issue. I do think the 'angle' of the development makes a difference - even though ours is shared ownership, it's one of only a few, in a development of multiple buildings that are definitely aimed at the upper end of the market, not just first time buyers etc. So I think that meant they went for higher build quality.

lljkk · 28/04/2021 15:21

any estate with inadequate parking. Very popular here. Twisty little roads without pavements. The roads lead nowhere but are unsafe for children to play on, not least because parked cars are on every it of space.

I'm an ecofreak & love idea of minimal car-areas. But reality intrudes.

DorisFlies · 28/04/2021 15:20

No to Persimmon but yes to Hoggs.

TableFlowerss · 28/04/2021 15:16

I’ve had a joiner come to lay some wooden flooring for me and he told me that as well as working for himself, he also contacts himself out to local building developers.

There’s a developer near me that used to get awards here there and everywhere for the high quality standards, but as the company grew, the standards seemed to fall. It certainly doesn’t have the same prestige as it originally did.

Joiner told me that he went to lay flooring in a couple of these expensive houses and the floors were shocking.

The same contractors will work on different developments, so I wouldn’t necessarily assume that ones deemed more expensive are representation of better build quality, because the sabe workmen are likely to work across different company’s.

I assume the more expensive ones have more expensive fixtures/fittings etc, larger windows, real wood doors etc...and things that add value, as oppose to a set of superior builders/joiners etc - because again, many of them work on different developments!

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 28/04/2021 15:03

That’s in response to CervixHaver

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 28/04/2021 15:02

Mine too!

justtryingtogeton · 28/04/2021 15:02

Avoid timber frames, and ensure the build is traditional.

I've lived in 2 Taylor Wimpey, they're not very sound proofed, and being timber framed noise travelled well.

CervixHaver · 28/04/2021 14:57

@DGRossetti

If you wanted quality, you wouldn't be looking at new builds, really.
Mine is extremely good quality Hmm
CervixHaver · 28/04/2021 14:54

@bridgetreilly I live in a Bellway home and it's fab! No issues whatsoever. Really good build quality. In North Yorkshire

ToryStelling · 28/04/2021 14:52

Recently friends of ours have all bought from Redrow, Bloor and Wainhomes.

Our friends’ Redrow is beautiful. They had some snagging issues but it’s a lovely house and looks really well finished.

Our friends who bought from Bloor and Wainhomes haven’t had such a great experience! The houses just look a bit shoddy in comparison.

We used to live in a David Wilson and hated it. Semi detached and the soundproofing was non-existent. The boiler packed in after 6 years and for some reason they’d designed the house so that the boiler pipe work went through 2 floors, it was an absolute nightmare (and very expensive!!) to sort out (and yes we did contact DW under the 10 year warranty and they fobbed us off).

GiantKitten · 28/04/2021 14:36

There's a new Taylor Wimpey estate here which is anecdotally better than most.
A friend has a Linden house which has been atrocious.
These posts were interesting earlier this year:

KevinTheBird Tue 09-Feb-21 18:19:03

user85963842 I don’t know if it always generates experts. I guess house building is a massive business, so many different trades employed either full time or on an adhoc basis. Personally I was part of a sales team for Linden Homes and we’d get shunted from one development to another for 2-3 months at a time as they neared completion. This was over a decade ago so things may have changed now but absolutely every single tradesman on these developments told us they were built to an awful standard and were all completely open about it. I remember showing one couple round a home, I was struggling with the lock on the door and the entire handle fell off in my hand 🤦‍♀️. They didn’t buy it for some reason.

I’m sure it varies from developer to developer and hopefully standards are higher these days. It put me off ever wanting to buy a new build though!

KevinTheBird Tue 09-Feb-21 22:43:56

certainly when I was working there Linden and Persimmon were well known as being the absolute worst. I was part of the personalised sales team so you’d have one contact to lead you through the entire sale and then be the contact for any snagging issues afterwards. As soon as we finished on one development all calls and emails from the buyers of homes from that development were rerouted to a generic customer service one that, as far as I know, had a couple of people working there for the entire company. It was appalling.

Whammyyammy · 28/04/2021 14:34

All of them. I wouldn't ever consider a new build house. Poorly built, crammed in, over looking each house, lack of parking.....

Swipe left for the next trending thread