Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask which new build houses you would avoid

239 replies

bridgetreilly · 28/04/2021 10:40

Looking for a house and there are several new build developments we’re interested in, but I’m finding it hard to get honest reviews. Are there builders with truly awful reputations that I shouldn’t even bother looking at?

And, conversely, has anyone got experience of a good quality new home that you love?

OP posts:
StoneofDestiny · 28/04/2021 20:42

We've lived in houses of many ages - 17th/18th Century cottage, Victorian Manse, Edwardian detached 1930's, 1970's Semi and two new builds.
The only properties that hasn't cost us any money are the new-builds. Currently we are in an energy efficient large new build with big gardens on a very small development, large driveway and some great design features (I say that as so many new-builds are criticised for not having those features).
Every other older 'character filled' property we have owned cost a fortune to heat, a ton of money to restore and each problem seemed to take a bucket of money to resolve.
Nothing will get me back into an older property. I had enough of beams, panelling, deep skirtings, stained glass and feature fireplaces, good to look at as they are. I like my big glass walls, energy efficient insulation and heating, garages big enough for 21 Century cars and repair free living. I like my low bills.
Choose your builder wisely. Get one with a long house builder guarantee for 'snags' to be resolved - we actually had none over the 2 Years we could call them back) with the 10 year warranty on top. Choose a builder with a good reputation - Charles Church, Spitfire, Crest Nicholson.

Above all choose the house that suits your needs and is in the right location.

CervixHaver · 28/04/2021 20:41

@APurpleSquirrel

I really don't understand this aversion to new builds? Yes some have problems, but so do many older houses. & tbh ALL houses at one point were new builds. There are advantages to new builds - you can get good deals/discounts on the price; extras thrown in for the sale; good internal layouts; decent heating & modern conveniences. We're in a Redrow house, bought new 9 years ago. It's a smallish estate of 150 homes or so. Every house has either a drive or allocated parking. Most houses have garages. All have gardens. They may not be huge; but they are fine. We had a few snags at the start, but all sorted within a few months. Houses on our estate sell quickly, but most houses haven't been sold since they were first moved into. We were able to haggle with the builders over the sale price & got a big discount because we asked & that enabled us to buy a much nicer, larger house than we could have afforded on the open market. One of my bugbears though is the garden in that this estate was built on a brownfield site (ex plant nursery) & there is a lot of rubble etc but if it was built on a greenfield site local people would complain about it concreting over green fields etc! You can't say new housing would only go on brownfield sites, then complain about the site. Some people seem to romanticise older houses yet seem to ignore the bad points of them. Many don't have allocated parking/drives so you have to play car musical chairs everyday - how many threads are started due to parking? Victorian Terraces etc are identical houses, all packed together. I grew up in a 1930s house where there were at least 6 streets of exactly the same house, one after the other. Buying an older house means you don't know about what's wrong with it; how much has been done to it (or not) over the years. Layouts are often not to modern living standards & require additional work to make them more comfortable. & you may find that all 'character' has been ripped out. A friend has a Victorian terrace - she didn't want a 'featureless' new build - instead she has an open chimney which means her house is usually freezing & costs ££ to heat. They moved into their house the same year we did & are still renovating it. They have to go through their neighbours garden to get their bins out etc. They've had problems with black mould, issues over parking & having to add an extension as soon as they moved in to replace the kitchen. The list goes on. New builds have their problems; but so do all houses. Visit the properties; do your homework; ask around etc but ultimately choose a house you like & can afford.
Well said!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
MrsLangOnionsMcWeetabix · 28/04/2021 20:41

I wouldn’t touch anything built by a large/national developer. Small to medium local developers are generally much better. The larger the company the more they rely on sub-contractors who they pay as little as possible. Inevitably leading to stuff like this www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/persimmon-homes-fire-barriers-safety-risk-report-a9250411.html

Amanduh · 28/04/2021 20:39

Oh and we paid £20k less than an ex council property here and the house has +30k in two years. The normal ‘old house’ roads probably 50% have drives and you can park on some roads. We have a double driveway and a double garage. Basically - it entirely depends on the house and the road!! New development or old house.. I could live on one of the most expensive roads in the area, 900k for a terraced house with no parking on a tiny, narrow road, costs a bomb to heat and the roof needs replacing... no double glazing.. rising damp and an outside loo...but the 300k less, huge and airy new build with all snagging and repairs is the bad choice?!

StatisticallyChallenged · 28/04/2021 20:35

Ours is Cala and seems pretty good - we do have some snags which we're waiting to be dealt with (bloody lockdown here has meant they were only allowed access for emergencies, can't blame them for that!) but nothing serious. Mainly small paintwork issues, a pair of totally mismatched internal doors, some scratched glass and a leaking shower (which they fixed, but now need to fix the wall/skirting damage!)...

I have a total of 53 items on my list, which sounds a lot but it's a fairly large 5 bedroom house and these are things I've noticed over 8 months and some are fairly minor. Biggest issue is the shitty topsoil and turf actually.

However, it's warm, well insulated, good soundproofing, big rooms, every house has at least a 2 car driveway plus garage so parking doesn't seem to be causing an issue so far.

Amanduh · 28/04/2021 20:32

I wouldn’t touch Persimmon with a barge pole.
Bovis have been amazing for us. Makes me laugh when people say they wouldnt touch a new build due to snagging etc. Do they realise the problems that older houses have?! Love a blank canvas too. Anyway. Bovis have been great. Big houses, no box rooms, big gardens, 2 years guarantee on everything! So even if you have a personally caused plumbing problem, oven breaks (nothing to do with bovis technically) etc etc, they will fix it.
Want to buy new forever! Most houses round here with problems are 70’s builds.. please realise they did the same things then!

Giraffey1 · 28/04/2021 20:32

It’s unfair to say all new builds are rubbish - it simply isn’t true.
It does seem to differ from development to development and I’d recommend you do your homework before signing up. Things like ground rents, don’t put stuff in attics etc should be picked up. Fore you decided.

I lived in a Taylor Wimpy house and was pretty decent. The build quality of Barrett Homes where I used to live was very poor but a friend who has one says hers is excellent.

I’m currently in what was a new build when we bought, built by a a local builder. So many snags you wouldn’t believe it, poor electrics and plumbing, terrible customer care.

Flowerlane · 28/04/2021 20:30

Always amazed that people have so many problems when buying a new build. I work in this sector and all our work is to a very high standard. If any trade does make a error some where along the way it is picked up very quickly and rectified Asap. Everything has to be signed off and a house is not signed off if all checks are not done.

Thisnamewasnttaken123 · 28/04/2021 20:25

I have a Taylor Wimpey home and I am really happy with it, I think you are better off enquiring about the specific sites rather than builder because it all depends how they are run too.
Some have Facebook pages for the development That the new residents create so you can join them and ask questions from home owners already living there to see how they are.
I would definitely buy a newbuild again it's absolutely lovely walking into a brand new home that you know you don't have to do any work on.

Fimofriend · 28/04/2021 20:18

We went to look at a newly built Bloor home. Luckily I was downstairs as my husband was upstairs or we might not have noticed the ceiling moving up and down with approximately 10 cm when he walked above. I thought the lamp would fall down! The floors upstairs did feel very soft.

NatalieH2220 · 28/04/2021 20:17

@Spanielsarepainless

A new barracks-block of a development I used to drive past had a sheet hanging over the twee balcony with 'DON'T BUY BOVIS' painted on it...
There was a car parked outside the Bovis sales office with a similar note in the window by us for a while too 🙊
name674398 · 28/04/2021 20:15

(Though there's also shared ownership which I think is another 200,000ish)

NatalieH2220 · 28/04/2021 20:14

We live on a new build estate and bought with Barratt Homes. There were various issues with snagging initially but they sorted everything and overall not too bad. Taylor Wimpey are also quite reasonable based on family members experiences. We do have a builder here called Bovis homes who lots of people seem to have had issues with so I definitely wouldn't use them.

name674398 · 28/04/2021 20:14

@WombatChocolate not as many as you think, only 260,000ish have been bought with HTB between 2013-2019, roughly 200,000 houses have been built a year in that time period (very roughly, 2013 was the lowest at 125,000ish)

WombatChocolate · 28/04/2021 19:57

I wonder what proportion if new builds are sold via a scheme like Help to Buy or Part Buy/Part -rent or where the builder takes your current house off you?

I think these schemes are propping up the new build market and often people using the schemes can only access the size or value if property because of the scheme....in itself this pushes up the price, so they actually pay more than genuine market value and often see 3-5 years with price dropping or certainly not rising.

Perhaps because many of these buyers have less choices, this has resulted in builders doing a poor job and feeling they can get away with it. People keep buyi g these properties, despite ongoing reports of problems, so it’s clearly true that they can get away with it,

LimeCoconut · 28/04/2021 19:56

@Ragiam

Were in a Taylor wimpey, on the whole it is absolutely fine! We did have some snagging when moved in but they were very quick to fix them or replace things we weren't happy with! We have had one or two issues in the 6 years but generally is expect some issues in any house as things aren't designed to last for ever!
I mentioned above how happy we are with our taylor wimpey too, they’ve been fantastic with minor issues that have cropped up but on the whole the quality has been excellent. So much sneering about new builds, often by people who haven’t actually experienced living in one.
Ragiam · 28/04/2021 19:49

Were in a Taylor wimpey, on the whole it is absolutely fine! We did have some snagging when moved in but they were very quick to fix them or replace things we weren't happy with! We have had one or two issues in the 6 years but generally is expect some issues in any house as things aren't designed to last for ever!

hulahooper2 · 28/04/2021 19:42

I’m in a persimmon , a few snagging issues , to be expected in any new build , all quickly dealt with , I am very happy with mine.

purplepoppet92 · 28/04/2021 19:02

We're in a Berkley home and loving it!

name674398 · 28/04/2021 19:00

We've had a very smooth experience with Barratt, that said it's important to research the actual building site as it is entirely dependent on how competent the local site manager is, ours has won national awards for the last 2 years so has a lot riding on remaining top of his game.

Freehold, no maintenance charges, traditional built house, and a budget that could afford a good sized house on a good plot with ample parking (double garage plus a driveway for 4 cars) the estate has all large houses so thankfully ample parking for all, people actually use their driveways unusually! Also over looks countryside and isn't badly overlooked.

We brought a snagger in, he found 60 snags but he was clutching at straws tbh, 95% of them I wouldn't have noticed, report went to Barratt and they were dealt with within 2 weeks (thank goodness I was working from home so I could just let people come and go, this would have been hard work if I was in the office admittedly!) the snagger said himself if all new builds were built like that he'd be out of a job.

The one issue we've had is lack of drainage in the garden, they've done it with all the houses, very frustrating but they've put in drainage since with no fight so it's not been an issue but annoying as a common issue with new builds.

The other really stressful part was how quickly we had to exchange and the pressure around that, wouldn't want to go through that again.

But all in all I absolutely love our house, it's solid, no paper thin walls here, extremely energy efficient. I don't need character in a home, I work in the heritage sector, I get it at work! I'm sure lots of people have said avoid, but you can't generalise about new builds any more than you can old houses. Research the local site, if it's already well established see if there is a Facebook page of residents already living there, find out how they've gotten on.

Okbye · 28/04/2021 18:55

I’ve lived in my Redrow house for 7 years and bought it brand new. No complaints, would recommend 😃👍 I’ve always said if we ever moved I would only want another Redrow.

Sleepisoverrated150 · 28/04/2021 18:53

We have a new build that’s a small local builder to our area. They have been pretty good at sorting any snagging and they build to a high quality.

I would definitely buy from them again, we have a large private driveway, decent sized back garden (not massive) and they allow changes to the house internally before you move in. We took out a bathroom and got credit of 2k to then use to upgrade the kitchen.

ZenNudist · 28/04/2021 18:50

I lie, my friend is in a linden. Bigger rooms, still a bit overlooked in the garden but its not tiny. Sadly sound carries everywhere and the kitchen cupboards are already buckling. She doesn't like it.

Nonononomaybe · 28/04/2021 18:49

I work in the industry and would say that the majority of large housebuilders are plcs, with shareholders to keep happy.... so have a cut throat mentality when it comes to costs, profits, staff etc - which doesn’t result in a great quality build. Redrow are probably the best in my experience.
Privately owned generally better. I personally don’t like new builds and have never lived in one, but from those I’ve seen Bloor (non plc) are well built and nicely designed.
I have never worked for either of these btw, so no bias!

ZenNudist · 28/04/2021 18:47

Not jealous of new build house owners. My house is 120 years old and I wouldn't go much past 1930s. I have a friend in a 1970s box which looks ugly but has lovely square big rooms (unlike my narrower smaller rooms). So any solidly built older house would do. Mine is not grand but nowhere near the no storage space tiny rooms of all the new builds I've ever been to. I have cellars and a loft a big private garden with established trees and insude i have some original features. In my porch there is a mosaic which the houses here retained (4 semis). Why dont they build house with pretty attention to detail like that any more?

It's a shame that the government dont legislate to enforce good standards. Better than the shoddy state some are going to be in in 2 decades time. Not built to last.

Don't get me started on my poor work colleagues in their new build city centre flats with cladding issues. It's scandalous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread