Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask which new build houses you would avoid

239 replies

bridgetreilly · 28/04/2021 10:40

Looking for a house and there are several new build developments we’re interested in, but I’m finding it hard to get honest reviews. Are there builders with truly awful reputations that I shouldn’t even bother looking at?

And, conversely, has anyone got experience of a good quality new home that you love?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhenWillISleepThroughTheNight · 26/11/2021 13:40

Our flat was built by David Wilson in 2006. We drilled to put a curtain pole in the usual place 😆 and hit a plastic heating pipe going diagonally through the wall. Black water all over the new telly.

JunoMcDuff · 26/11/2021 13:33

@Proudboomer

This is the land that they are building on.
Yeah, some new ones being built near my work on flood plains. Seems a really stupid idea to me!
Proudboomer · 26/11/2021 13:25

This is the land that they are building on.

To ask which new build houses you would avoid
Proudboomer · 26/11/2021 13:22

There is a new housing development not far from me of 600 new homes. It is being built by Cala and a two bed will set you back £365k which is about £65k over an older 2 bed in the same area. The builds look ok if you want to live amongst 600 houses that pretty much are all identical to each other. The rooms are small even though they are advertised they will fit a king size bed and they will if you only have a small waldrobe and not much else. But the main draw back is they are built on a flood plane. The development even contains a pumping station for this but with that many houses I don’t see it coping and one big flood will mean the homes won’t be insurable. When it was fields it flooded every winter so it will only be worse now it has been concreted over.

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 26/11/2021 12:48

Ours is. Berkeley and I don’t recognise the tales of tiny gardens and garages. We have a good sized back garden and reasonable front garden. The garage is used for DH’s tools and storage, but also houses a car every day. It will fit a small SUV.

The windows are large in every room, except the cloakroom and the room sizes are generous. We have a kitchen/diner, that has an extra seating area and another living room.

How often do people talk about where to park when they live in Edwardian or Victorian houses. They don’t have drives and garages in general. How often do people complain about how cold their older style house is- little insulation and draughts. Thirties houses with rounded bay windows all look the same and they usually have two bedrooms and a box room.

In the end, people buy what suits their budget and style. It’s not necessary to be unpleasant about other choices.

JunoMcDuff · 26/11/2021 11:57

The Bellway ones near us are awful. 2 friends have bought them on 2 different schemes and they build quality is dreadful. One has a permanent soggy back garden due to insufficient drainage and this is now causing damp on the property and the others can't plug things in at night as the noise amplifies up the wall and wakes the kids!

LucentBlade · 26/11/2021 10:24

Quality is what is being mentioned but what about the neighbourhood? It’s not established at all. When looking for a home though neighbours can move at any time you can at least visit and get a feel as to what it’s like at the time of buying. Okay the lovely couple next door may move and you could get awful neighbours just like awful neighbours can move and you get lovely neighbours. But you get a snapshot. Also crime stats won’t mean a thing as it’s brand new.

I just don’t like the look of estates they can look quite uniform. The road I live in is a mixture of Edwardian and 1920’s houses.

LakieLady · 26/11/2021 10:09

@MrsSprogett

Not builders but I would find out about the land it's built on before I consider one. Near us they are building on everything, locals avoid them because they know the history
A development of nearly 100 flats and 20-odd houses has been built not far from me. The site was under several feet of water for the best part of a week 20 years ago, when a large part of the town was flooded.

I certainly wouldn't buy one of those.

And everyone I know who's bought a new-build has had no end of problems. I think the only new-build I'd buy was one my builder BIL built, because I know that he does everything to an incredibly high standard.

RosettaR · 26/11/2021 10:04

One i would consider are Crest Nicholson. No direct experience but I've looked round some and they look beautiful and age well, lots of thought into the positioning of the houses etc.

Rubyupbeat · 26/11/2021 09:57

My son has been in a persimmon house from new for 7 years, not one problem at all. In fact 2 lots of his friends live on the same estate and as far as I know, no problems too.

Skysblue · 26/11/2021 09:12

There’s a Berkeley Homes development on the next road from me, and I only hear good things about it from people who live there. It feels very ‘high end’ walking about there, they put in lovely kids playgrounds and fountains and ponds and stuff as part of the development.

Christmasbutmakeitspooky · 26/11/2021 09:10

We are Keepmoat at the houses are just a bit… meh. Like not much thought has gone into them, they’ve just thrown them up. We found lots of cracks and crappy plastering when we moved in, floor laid a bit wonky, things like that.

MarkWingfieldsucks · 25/11/2021 23:36

Looks like Harlequin Homes is his latest venture, don't touch them with a barge pole.

MarkWingfieldsucks · 25/11/2021 23:32

Avoid anything by Tayfield Homes. They set up a new company for each development so are known by different names. I would go so far as to say the managing director is a sociopath, the way he delayed, lied to and gaslighted residents on our development.

Spagoot224 · 25/11/2021 22:42

We bought a Bellway new build last year. There has been some snagging issues but they’ve fixed them in fair enough time considering the pandemic. Room size in our build is very good, as is the garden size. Soil in the garden (or clay and rubble) is shite but this seems to be the case on most estates

housemaus · 24/11/2021 22:47

Semi-outing so I've namechanged, but I'm a property journalist and short of a very small local developer with exceptional feedback, I'd avoid new builds.

Estate fees, ridiculous covenants as PPs have mentioned like no pets/vans/sheds/conservatories/washing lines/Sky dishes, lots of them are leasehold which is a pain in the arse, non-standard construction making selling harder as lenders are pickier, timber frames making house insurance potentially more expensive, the endless horrendous mistakes (), smaller rooms, potential initial drop in value (a 2 year old new build with 1 previous owner can be worth less than, say, a brand new one as people get that 'first owner' feel, so not good if you're not planning to stay), generally shite gardens, overpricing because of Help to Buy, problems reselling as according to a study this year two thirds would never buy a new build, land prices are expensive so the construction has to be cheap for them to make a profit with the resulting quality issues...

More than half of new build buyers in Britain had 'major problems with construction, unfinished fittings and faults with utilities' according to Shelter.

There are countless Facebook groups dedicated to complaints and poor experiences with builders - these are worth checking if you find a builder and a development you're interested in.

I've had a look at St Modwen and 42% of their reviews on Trustpilot are shocking, which is a worryingly high percentage even if you consider a bias towards complaining (and as many of the reviews point out, they do ask for positive reviews too, so perhaps this bias is countered slightly).

I know this sounds very doom and gloom. But honestly, the quality of most new builds in the UK is not great, and that plus the other issues on top... I would just swerve them altogether.

Peacocking · 21/11/2021 11:54

I havent read the whole thread, but just wanted to put my experience forward. I bought a new build about ten years ago. A huge financial investment and I was stressed out during the purchase as many people are. My house had snags. In hindsight they were no big deal. Minor scratches on the windows, bits of tiling, bits of woodwork. Because I was so stressed and on edge still they seemed like a HUGE deal to me and I kicked up a lot of fuss. If my housebuilding had trustpilot I would have left them angry reviews. They wouldn't have been deserved.

I think reviews of housebuilding are valuable, but should be looked at in the context that quite a lot are from stressed people who have just made the biggest purchase of their life and their perspective may be skewed. I'm sure many reviews are fair...but many more may not be.

RVN123 · 21/11/2021 10:37

We are in a new detached 4 bedroomed Miller Home in Scotland. We've been in for nearly two years, and we bought off plan before it was finished.

We have had a few snags but they were mainly decorative, like scratched window panes, and poor paint work. The main snag we had was a leak from the upstairs bathroom sink in the first week, which came through to the kitchen ceiling, so that part of the kitchen ceiling had to be cut out, left to dry and replastered. The repair was a shoddy job. We eventually had the whole ceiling cladded in pvc with recessed lights anyway so it is entirely hidden now.

When I read about home with 400 snags etc, I am always inclined to believe that a lot of these are minor decorative things like nail pops as the house dries out, rubbish paintwork etc. I know there are some with major flaws and that is terrible, but don't buy a new build expecting that it's going to be perfect, especially as the house dries out over the first two years. You WILL get nail pops and cracks appearing as the house shifts. You are told not to decorate for two years while this happens (I did as I was too impatient).

In terms of covenants, we were told not to change the look of the house at the front, so no changing the front door, garage door, or planting bushes, erecting fences or hedges etc. This is to keep the estate looking 'nice' for prospective buyers. No parking works vans in your driveway.
In reality, people have already converted their garages, changed their front doors, ripped up their lawns to extend their driveways, planted hedges etc.
They don't enforce it, and I don't think they really care.

We were also told that the attic is not meant to support any true weight and not to use it to store anything other than Christmas decorations etc. However, some people on the estate have had theirs floored for further storage, BUT - this invalidates the NHBC warranty - if anything were to go wrong and the floor was to collapse they would not be covered.

The houses are extremely well spaced apart from each other, the roads are wide, the gardens are large. The rooms are spacious. The master bedroom has a superking bed in in and there is still five feet space on all sides of the bed at least. The kitchen and bathroom are very large. So not all new builds are cramped with tiny gardens, this is a myth that has sprung up that accompanies these stories of terrible new builds.

Miller have been okay with fixing snags although during covid obviously they have been unable to fix thing as fast as we would like.

I have been pretty pleased with the house. Yes we have had to fix a few things, but so does everyone who buys a house. Our estate has a Facebook page and there is no-one who has experienced what I would call major snags.

If you get a good site manager, it also makes a huge difference!
The roads are not 'adopted' by the council until the estate is finished too, so we don't get gritted in the winter and have to deal with that.
There is a yearly fee to a 'factor' who look after the communal green areas etc. Its about £10 a month and covers them cutting the grass etc .
Can't think of anything else, my advice would be to actually visit the houses, talk to the people on the estate, and not go by the horror stories you hear in the press.

InstantHorlicks · 21/11/2021 10:37

I live in a new build Morrish home and love everything about it.

InFiveMins · 21/11/2021 10:11

I've had a Barratts and it was great, didn't have a single issue and neither did my neighbours (to my knowledge). Would buy a Barratt home again.

Darl1111 · 21/11/2021 10:07

Hi, we are about to buy a bovis home and only just looked at the reviews on trustpilot which are really awful (not even 2) compared to others which are 4+. Bovis only has a couple of hundred reviews and others have thousands. When I read the others bad reviews they’re actually all similar to the bad bovis ones. We are now really nervous to buy our house and we were so so excited, due to exchange and move in before Christmas. Does anyone have any experience of Bovis they can share please? Thanks

Theloftmonster · 29/04/2021 18:12

Beware the estate rent charges. Its not just a maintenance fee. Lots of new builders have set them up using more or less forgotten historic laws. The result is that you have less rights than leasehold properties and also risk the rent charge owner being able to grant a 99 year lease out of your property making it virtually worthless to you. Lots of mortgage lenders won't touch them.

Also they are often badly built. One scandal involved the houses having insufficient fire protection measures in the loft. Something that was only discovered when one burnt down!

You know the lovely lakes they build around? They are often balancing pond because the properties are built on land liable to flood.

The NHBC offer limited protection, remember that the builders are their clients, not you. There are other similar schemes so NHBC have to compete for business and you don't get that if you favour the homeowners Wink

LostBlanket · 29/04/2021 18:09

I live in a Redrow build and it's amazing. Very good quality and not one problem has been experienced by me or my neighbours.

BraveBraveMouse · 29/04/2021 17:46

Tayfield Homes should be avoided like the plague. They are a small developer and have started various subsidiary companies for different projects that go by other names, that should have been a clue for me that they were going to be a nightmare to deal with.

Nirnroot · 29/04/2021 17:33

We recently purchased a new build and our home is an Avant home. We have had a great experience with them as a whole and with our new house. We do have snags, but our list is currently sitting at about 12 snags total, none of which have any detriment to everyday quality of life. Our snags are things like "Door has small chip at bottom corner" and another is "touch drawer is harder to open than should be" etc. Some of the snags people have described earlier are pretty shocking! Oh it's also worth saying that like a similar poster we moved into the estate while it's still being built, so our snags were addressed about 3 weeks after move in. I'd highly recommend doing that if you can.

We bought this house as it had good size rooms, was detached, and this was my number one "thing": A big enough sitting room. I have no idea who designs some new builds but some sitting rooms are like wee shoeboxes, and I'd avoid those if you can. Avant homes are very nice looking too, and the bi-fold doors are worth it alone...even if it rains all the time where I live Grin

The new build hatred doesn't surprise me as some ARE terrible (Persimmon- I have heard horror stories verging on bad to "danger to life") but Avant I can recommend. I do love old houses and their character but I previously rented old houses and one thing that's never left me is the cold from them! That's one thing the insulation in new builds is something I love, and the lack of damp problems!