Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mil claiming to be a orphan at 54.

287 replies

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 21/04/2021 15:35

Sorry, I’m really annoyed and upset.

I’m 30 and my mum died when I was 19. My dad had a life changing stroke when I was 16, which caused him to lose his voice, leg, arm and gave him slight brain damage. He lives in assisted living now.

My husbands grandad died before Xmas, I completely understand it’s her dad and she would be devastated but she’s been wishing him dead for years.

Aibu to think that 1, you are lucky to have many years with your parents and 2, you aren’t a fucking orphan.

Argh.

OP posts:
that1970shouse · 21/04/2021 16:59

When my gran died, my mum kept saying "I'm an orphan now." It struck me as a bit tactless saying it in front of my dad who was orphaned young, but I guess it's how she felt.

Don't make this about you, OP.

sunflowerstory · 21/04/2021 16:58

You're not an orphan yourself so I'm not sure why the word has elicited such a strong response.

She doesn't have living parents anymore. Let her feel how she feels, it's literally nothing to do with you or your circumstances.

RedcurrantPuff · 21/04/2021 16:58

YANBU, that’s ridiculous, she could be doing with being a bit more sensitive

Pinkbrush · 21/04/2021 16:54

Not sure why it’s bothering you so much. Leave people to grieve how they want.

YellowGlasses · 21/04/2021 16:54

Grief isn’t a competition.

I can’t imagine you would take kindly to someone telling you that you got almost two decades longer with your mum than they did with theirs, which is quite plausible.

YouokHun · 21/04/2021 16:53

I’m pushing 54 and my DF died a month ago. In the face of the loss I feel like a small child. Am I lucky to have got 54 years with him? Yes of course but that’s a rational assessment and grief isn’t necessarily rational. I had a good relationship with my father but your MiL perhaps has more complicated feelings about her father’s death?

It must be so hard to lose a parent so young @Thedarksideofthemoon30 and so tough to see a parent’s health decline like your DF’s so that you are essentially having to make your own way in the world when others still have the security of parents (depending on the type and quality of parents of course). I get that it might be irritating and sound dramatic to says she’s an orphan (even if technically true), but I don’t think you can do anything about the way someone responds to this kind of loss, nor can we really say that one loss is worse than another. Of course objectively losing a young DH is more shocking than losing an elderly DF (for example) but grief is subjective and there is no hierarchy of loss.

When my father died someone said to me “at least he was old”, it was a spectacularly unhelpful thing to say because it didn’t make it easier for me just because he was 82, he was still my dad. It’s been a feature I hadn’t considered - how many people would comment along the lines of it not being a big deal because he was 82 and how being 54 I should be totally pragmatic about it (though I note this sort of comment has come from those who haven’t lost a parent yet). It does make you feel lost at any age and you’re own ability to cope OP has no bearing on hers so you’ll have to cut her some slack.

BiBabbles · 21/04/2021 16:52

As described, it's unreasonable, but understandably so. Grief is complicated, so are relationships & sometimes it's the little things like this sort of comments and mixed relationships that hurt the most.

My spouse's step-father, mother, and father died within a year of each other in his early thirties. He had only seen his father a handful of time since he was 6. He once said in the lead up to the last funeral, reflectively, that he was an orphan now - similar to how magicstar1 said of her father. Maybe some would see that as dramatic, but I viewed as part of him processing in his grief.

I've no idea if my mother is alive or dead. I've had that 'is she alive or dead' question hanging over me most of the time since I was 15 (younger if we count the times I wasn't sure she'd wake up). I'm not sure how to quantify how many years I had with her or my father - that's hard when your parents are addicts - and while I've never called myself an orphan, I know others in similar positions who do. It's part of how they process not having that parent-child connection as a child, accepting that they probably don't have those memories and other things people have spoken about from their parents. It might not be entirely accurate, but we don't really words for describing the many different ways to lose that relationship.

BrilliantBetty · 21/04/2021 16:52

She's lucky to have got to her age with both parents still around.

She's an adult not an orphan.

Guavafish · 21/04/2021 16:51

The lose of parents are any stage in life is hard

PatrickBatemann · 21/04/2021 16:50

I don't see how she's being insensitive to you, really. I have a lot of sympathy for your situation, but she's also allowed to grieve no matter what her age.

And for what it's worth, my DM also had an extremely turbulent relationship with her father (lots of abuse in childhood) and she wished him dead many times too. However, grief is complex, and his death definitely still did affect her.

Xenia · 21/04/2021 16:49

I am the oldest in the family now (my parents died in their 70s). I would not tend to call myself an orphan as that usually means a little child where both parents have died although I suppose it might be technically correct.

SweatyBetty20 · 21/04/2021 16:49

YANBU. My mum died when I was 23 and my dad when I was 34, and then my sibling a month ago. It's always awful when people lose a parent, but particularly when you are young, because you mourn the things that they will miss out on; your wedding, grandchildren, graduations, etc.

I have a step auntie who plays bereavement top trumps to the nth degree. With the death of my brother I now have no parents, grandparents, or siblings - I'm the top of the tree at 48, and as I don't have kids and a lot of my family either died early or didn't have kids, there are very few left - just some of my mum's cousins, and a couple of first cousins, only one of whom I see. I said that I felt very alone, and had lost a lot of memories when my brother died. She said "yes, I've lost all my brothers I know just how you feel". She's got kids, grandkids, a husband and two sisters, lost her brothers in her sixties and she's 78 - she really doesn't have a fucking clue how I feel. But, if I go to the moon she's been there twice.

EnoughnowIthink · 21/04/2021 16:49

Wow. You’re pissed off at someone because they have lost both parents? Have a word with your self

IbrahimaRedTwo · 21/04/2021 16:48

MIL is being way too dramatic. Orphan is reserved for children who have lost both parents. Not someone in their 50s. It sounds ridiculous

It's not, adult orphan is a well known and well used term, and we don't tend to call people whose parents die "dramatic and ridiculous". Unless we're twats anyway.

AmyDudley · 21/04/2021 16:46

I'm sorry you lost your mother when you were so young - that must have been terribly hard for you. And I agree using the term orphan is a little unusual for someone in your MIL's position.

But she is grieving too - human relationships are complicated - and the fact that you didn't get on with someone when they were alive further complicates things - you don't have happy memories to comfort you, and a part of the grief will be for the relationship you wish you had had with them.

BrumBoo · 21/04/2021 16:45

I get this, I was fortunate enough to have both my parents until I was in my fifties. I am an only child of only children so no aunts/ uncles etc and when my dad died I did suddenly realise that there was no one left that remembered me as a child/ teenager and it really gave me a right jolt !!

Absolutely. Your past becomes just your memories, no one to fondly remember you when you were young and 'perfect' in their eyes. Someone's baby. You don't realise what it is to be someones child until they're gone. It can be worse when you had a bad relationship, not only you're grieving a loss of a parent, you're grieving the relationship you never had, and often the lack of closure that comes with it. It's not top trumps of heartache of course, just different.

drpet49 · 21/04/2021 16:45

MIL is being way too dramatic. Orphan is reserved for children who have lost both parents. Not someone in their 50s. It sounds ridiculous.

Maggiesfarm · 21/04/2021 16:45

@imalmostthere

I don't think it needs to be a competition... both her parents have passed and she's understandably upset, it doesn't really matter what ages, it's still a horrible loss. As is yours.
Yes.
Idontlikethatnameanymore · 21/04/2021 16:44

The death of a parent you had a difficult or complex relationship with can be harder to process sometimes than if you'd been close, as there's a lot of extra emotional baggage involved. For that alone YABU. Her dad has died. Let the poor woman deal with it as she wishes, it takes nothing away from you or your experiences

This in a nutshell, and I'm sorry for your losses too OP

fizzyp0p · 21/04/2021 16:43

MIL sounds over dramatic.
Just ignore her.
If that's how she describes it then OK. I wouldn't call her an orphan,.

Josette77 · 21/04/2021 16:42

It sounds like she had an awful time with her dad.Why would you consider her lucky?

Amumtomyson · 21/04/2021 16:39

It sounds as though you are projecting your pain onto her. It is not a competition.

magicstar1 · 21/04/2021 16:38

It depends on how she's saying it. Is it all the time, trying to make people feel sorry for her, or was it a one off remark? My dad was 56 when his mother died, and I remember him saying sadly, "I'm an orphan now". It was a one off thought.

Twinkie01 · 21/04/2021 16:37

No matter how old you are when you lose your parents it's somewhat unsettling when they are both dead. I hate my father and actively wish him dead but it will be weird when he's not alive as my mother has been dead for years.

It's the same when friends' mothers pass away, I feel affronted that they are so upset as I feel at least they knew their mothers but that's my problem and their grief is understandable but does not diminish mine and how I feel about their loss.

icdtap · 21/04/2021 16:37

You've had a lot to deal with and lost your Mum at a young age.
But I still think YABU. It doesn't matter how many years someone has their parent for, it's never long enough. It's always too soon.

When my second parent died when I was 42, I was absolutely bereft. I found the feeling of being alone without parents terrifying. I felt orphaned. It's going to take me a very long time to adjust to the new situation without either parent.

Nothing prepared me for the loss of the second parent and that aloneness.

You object to her use of the word orphan which is normally used for children who have lost both parents. But I think you are being far too harsh on her. She wished him dead but that doesn't mean she wouldn't mourn his loss.
You don't sound very pleasant at all to be honest with you. You seem to lack empathy.

Grief is not a competition.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.