Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mil claiming to be a orphan at 54.

287 replies

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 21/04/2021 15:35

Sorry, I’m really annoyed and upset.

I’m 30 and my mum died when I was 19. My dad had a life changing stroke when I was 16, which caused him to lose his voice, leg, arm and gave him slight brain damage. He lives in assisted living now.

My husbands grandad died before Xmas, I completely understand it’s her dad and she would be devastated but she’s been wishing him dead for years.

Aibu to think that 1, you are lucky to have many years with your parents and 2, you aren’t a fucking orphan.

Argh.

OP posts:
Alsohuman · 21/04/2021 18:00

And I will be even less affected when my dad dies because he's had a good 80 years on the planet and I really don't see the point falling apart over something inevitable happening fairly deep into old age

You have absolutely no idea how you’ll feel. Nobody does until it happens. And whether you can see the point of it or not, a lot of people fall apart when their very old parents die and it’s perfectly natural and normal.

poppycat10 · 21/04/2021 18:00

A friend of mine said this yesterday. His mother died last week (his father died some years ago). He's nearly 60! It's not that strange a thing to say, even if it's not technically accurate.

Spidey66 · 21/04/2021 17:59

I was an 'orphan at 44, so not a child, but 10 years later many of my peers have at least one parent still living. Ok I wasn't a child,but getting tobbthe st age where you've lost both parents is difficult. No-one to clarify history with, no generation between me and death......

I'm quite pragmatic and one of the 'death happens to all of us' brigade but I took as while to adapt. I

midsomermurderess · 21/04/2021 17:57

Being an orphan is a psychological state as much as anything. ButI agree, it's a bit daft. My parents were dead by the time I was 26. I found it odd then to be called an orphan, despite it being a matter of fact.

MiriamMargo · 21/04/2021 17:56

What a delight you are !!!

acrossthebrooklynbridge · 21/04/2021 17:53

Am surprised by the split of the vote, she's ridiculous to call herself an orphan at her age, I would find it annoying and dramatic

I agree it may sound ridiculous, which is one of the reasons I would never use the word myself. However, it is not perhaps so ridiculous to feel that way. As I explained in an earlier post at aged 54 I have silently felt totally alone in the world since my mum passed away. If anyone ever asked me I would say how lucky I was to have her for so long, but inside I now feel alone in the world. Or maybe I am being ridiculous to feel that way as well? Either way I would never let anyone know my feelings because that would be unkind to others who have suffered far more earlier losses.

JediGnot · 21/04/2021 17:50

OP

I think you're getting a harder time from some on here than you should.

She's not an orphan and whilst she has every right to be sad and grieving it is very insentive to bang on about the death of her detested father when she was 54, to someone who lost a fully fit dad at 16 and a mum at 19.

I would not be surprised if seeing your father post-stroke is in many ways worse than had he died.

You were left "parentless" (pretty much) when you were barely into adulthood - she is misdescribing herself as an orphan despite being nearly into old age and having kid(s) and grandkid(s) to console herself with.

I have every sympathy with you and little to none for her, and that's without thinking about the fact she detested him anyway.

And FWIW I am pretty damn certain that I would have been MUCH more hurt and affected if my mother had died when I was a child than I was when she did die. And I will be even less affected when my dad dies because he's had a good 80 years on the planet and I really don't see the point falling apart over something inevitable happening fairly deep into old age.

acrossthebrooklynbridge · 21/04/2021 17:48

I am so sorry you lost your parents so young. My dad died when I was quite young also and I have suffered other losses as I failed to have birth children.

I am not your MIL but I lost my mum when I was 54 too, and was so grateful to have had her in my life for so long. However, I have felt "orphaned" - although I would never tell anyone because as I say I was so lucky to have her beside me for 54 years. As an only child with no biological family at all, I have felt completely alone since then. There is no one who I look like, no one I can do the "do you remembers" with, or no one who knew me as a child. I had no idea of the intense loneliness I would feel, and how disconnected from the human race as everyone I know seems to have biological relatives. So although I have not voiced it to anyone, and I wouldn't ever do that, and would not use the word orphaned, I do understand a little of how your MIL may feel.

rwalker · 21/04/2021 17:47

To me an orphan is someone who lost both parents and still need to be cared / adpoted and provided for not a 54 year old .
Each to there own

52andblue · 21/04/2021 17:45

Your MIL isn't a child, so she cannot be an 'orphan'.
She may feel like one but she isn't technically.
But if you actually have been and have never received kindness / even acknowledgement of it and then your MIL starts saying she is one aged 50 odd I can see how that would stick in your throat somewhat.
Perhaps she just isn't very sensitive in general?
Ultimately you have to let her get on with grieving however she sees fit.

Bluntness100 · 21/04/2021 17:41

I’m sorry you’re going through this, but grief is a complex thing and you cannot dictate or judge someone on how they react on someone’s death op nor can you make it about you. 💐

MrsAvocet · 21/04/2021 17:40

My parents both died when I was in my 40s. I don't think I've ever described myself as an orphan as I do tend to think of a small child when I hear that word, but I did feel a real sense of loss when I no longer had parents. Then when my last surviving aunts died soon afterwards the realisation that I was part of the "senior" tier of our family, that a whole generation was gone was quite upsetting, both because it meant that anything we didn't know about them now was gone forever and because it meant that the next funeral was likely to be one of my siblings or cousins. I'm sure it isn't the same as losing your parents as a child but it doesn't make it a trivial loss and people grieve differently.

mcmooberry · 21/04/2021 17:39

Am surprised by the split of the vote, she's ridiculous to call herself an orphan at her age, I would find it annoying and dramatic.

TheGlassBlowersDaughter · 21/04/2021 17:39

Maybe you'd benefit from counselling to process your loss and deal with your DF's condition because none of this is about your MIL. It's all about you and your unresolved grief.

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 21/04/2021 17:38

It wasn’t even that she said it in a sad way, she was joking and laughing. When it’s been the anniversary of my mums death or her birthday she’s always said she lost her mum at a young age so knows how it feels. She was 40 so I suppose it is young still.

I’m not a horrible person.

OP posts:
MixedUpFiles · 21/04/2021 17:35

Her grief is real, but calling herself an orphan is offensive.

An orphan has lost the person guiding them through childhood and into adulthood and independence. She was already independent.

It’s funny, I never thought it would hurt quite so much to lose a parent as adult. Years later and you still feel the empty space, still wish you could seek their counsel. There are so many questions I wish I had known to ask her. So much I wish I had known to learn about her, but I wasn’t old enough yet to know which stories hadn’t been told.

Devlesko · 21/04/2021 17:35

I think this is insensitive, especially as I'm sure she knows your story.
But she's grieving so I'd ignore it, unless it became the topic of every conversation and continues for some time.
Then I'd have to tell her what I felt.

Tal45 · 21/04/2021 17:33

I'm with you OP, just sounds attention seeking to me to go round calling yourself an orphan at 54 as a lot of people have lost both parents by that age. Not that it's not just as devastating but the word orphan would grate on me too.

milveycrohn · 21/04/2021 17:31

I think this highlights that we don't actually have a word for being an adult when your parents die - 'orphan', obviously sounded insensitive to the OP.
I guess it was the MiL's way of trying to express her grief, without having the appropriate language to use. Yes, she may not have liked her father, but as someone else said, you still grieve, maybe for the father wou wished you had.

Alsohuman · 21/04/2021 17:31

My parents’ combined age was 196 when they died within six months of each other. Obviously I was pretty old when that happened and I was on my knees. Perhaps I should have just shrugged it off because I had so much time with them? You sound pretty heartless, OP.

SlightlyJaded · 21/04/2021 17:30

@Thedarksideofthemoon30

I think you are both in a fair amount of pain.

MILs pain is new
Yours is something you've been carrying for a long time. MILs doesn't feel as valid to you because she is older/the death was more timely/she might generally irritate you....would you say that's fair?

I've lost both my parents in the past three years. I am 50. So not a small child orphan, BUT I felt like an orphan after my mum died. I have no siblings/aunts/uncles/grandparents/cousins - nobody at all. Not One Adult. And knowing I have to Adult forever now - that noone is going to be running round after me if I"m not well, or checking I've got Christmas plans etc made me feel terrifyingly alone.

I understand your jealousy - I do. But you have to allow her to grieve in any way she wants.

Plumbear2 · 21/04/2021 17:29

Crikey OP could you be anymore insensitive? Losing at parent at any age is traumatic. Just look at Prince Charles in his 70s,,I couldn't watch tbe funeral because his broken face was to upsetting. Your MIL is grieving, if calling herself an orphan is how she is dealing with this then so be it. Saying how upset and angry you are about it is pure selfishness.

CutieBear · 21/04/2021 17:28

I think you should only be classed as an orphan if your parents die when you’re young and they are also too young. Your MIL sounds very insensitive.

OnTheBrink1 · 21/04/2021 17:28

I know this is utterly unreasonable but my mum died very suddenly when I was 16. My MIL lost her mum 1 year ago aged 94. MIL is 68. She can’t move on really even a year later - deep in grief and feels it’s unfair.
Of course it’s very sad but I feel an irrational anger and keep thinking you’ve had so many years I could have given anything to have had my mum for even 10 more years let alone into my 60’s!! You are bloody lucky!
I know it’s irrational and it’s not a competition but it’s just how I feel

ravenmum · 21/04/2021 17:27

Did you get any help at the time OP? It must have been a very hard time.
Have you tried contacting your remaining family or are they not interested?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.