Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mil claiming to be a orphan at 54.

287 replies

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 21/04/2021 15:35

Sorry, I’m really annoyed and upset.

I’m 30 and my mum died when I was 19. My dad had a life changing stroke when I was 16, which caused him to lose his voice, leg, arm and gave him slight brain damage. He lives in assisted living now.

My husbands grandad died before Xmas, I completely understand it’s her dad and she would be devastated but she’s been wishing him dead for years.

Aibu to think that 1, you are lucky to have many years with your parents and 2, you aren’t a fucking orphan.

Argh.

OP posts:
Mistressinthetulips · 21/04/2021 22:16

Well that's ok then Confused

PurpleRainDancer · 21/04/2021 22:16

Grief isn’t a competition OP, you’re a peach aren’t you Hmm

Thatisnotwhatisaid · 21/04/2021 22:13

She isn’t an orphan because an orphan is a child. All adults lose both parents eventually if they’re fortunate enough to live to at least middle age anyway.

StripyHorse · 21/04/2021 22:11

YABU. A few years ago when my grandad died my dad commented that he is an orphan now. He was about 66 at the time. I didn't belittle his grief to point out that as he is an adult (with grandchildren let alone children) he can't be an orphan.

Cameleongirl · 21/04/2021 21:27

Losing a parent at a life stage when you actually need to be parented is not comparable to losing a parent in late middle age.

I agree that it's a very different experience, @canary1. It doesn't mean that a middle-aged adult won't grieve profoundly, but they don't "need" their parent in the same way that a child or very young adult (as the OP was) does.

ancientgran · 21/04/2021 20:53

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

ancientgran I still think it’s a ridiculous comment sorry I do. To lose a parent as a child, maybe more so a mother isn’t just about the loss (which will be hard at all ages) but the profound impact on all the Years to come, so many missed moments, fucks you up for life in many ways.
Thank you for correcting how I feel. I will try to change my feelings just for you. I didn't realise I wasn't allowed to feel what I feel. I realise my mistake and will check in regularly to make sure I'm allowed to feel what I feel.

Ok now?

MrsAvocet · 21/04/2021 20:50

@newnortherner111

Being upset, unhappy, bereft, any other sadness when you lose your last parent is normal, indeed if you don't miss them in any way it is sad that your relationship with them ended that way.

An orphan is a child without parents, not an adult. YANBU OP to be annoyed.

But the OP is also an adult and her father is still alive, yet she says she "feels like an orphan". Which is her prerogative, she feels how she feels and that is nobody else's business. I didn't feel like I had no mother until she had actually died despite having "lost" her, or at least a real relationship with her, to Alzheimer's a good number of years earlier. But that doesn't make me right and the OP wrong - just different. So shouldn't tbe OP's MIL be afforded the same courtesy? Nobody can truly know how they would feel in someone else's circumstances as we are all influenced by our own experiences of loss and everyone grieves differently.
PurpleWh1teGreen · 21/04/2021 20:42

I’m not a horrible person.

You are someone who has started a thread about someone else grieving wrong.

Hothammock · 21/04/2021 20:39

I see what you are saying and why your MIL might be irritating but your loss isn't more important than her loss and you don't have the right to deny anyone their sense of grief. It is not a competition.

DeepThinkingGirl · 21/04/2021 20:37

I would reckon she wants attention from you DH and she thinks she can draw his empathy if she uses terminology that he uses to describe the woman he loves the most- you.

HotelCaliforniaOnRepeat · 21/04/2021 20:35

You don't get to decide how she feels. I know someone that was hit really hard losing their mother that they didn't really get on with, she described it in a similar way despite being 60 herself.
You can also grieve the relative / relationship you wanted rather than the one you had, if that makes sense.
Having no living parents does make people feel differently in my experience, and their age isn't relevant. You don't get to your fifties and disown them because you don't need them any more.

BoredOfCbeebies · 21/04/2021 20:22

OP I know exactly how you feel.
I suppose she was technically correct but I think it was incredibly insensitive of her to say it to you.
I disagree with all these people saying the age doesn't matter. There's a massive difference between being in your twenties to in your fifties when your parents die, for example.
I lost my mum before my wedding and my dad a few years later, so I'm an 'orphan' at 40. I'm painfully aware that all my friends still have both parents, and quite prepared to admit I'm jealous! And terribly sad that my mum never met my children.

newnortherner111 · 21/04/2021 20:21

Being upset, unhappy, bereft, any other sadness when you lose your last parent is normal, indeed if you don't miss them in any way it is sad that your relationship with them ended that way.

An orphan is a child without parents, not an adult. YANBU OP to be annoyed.

flippertygibbit · 21/04/2021 20:12

It isn't a competition. She feels how she feels and you should respect that.

CornishLover · 21/04/2021 20:04

I am a lurker and I swear there was a thread a while ago about someone at school saying they are an orphan and the op feeling offended about it. Op have you posted this before?

StrangeLookingParasite · 21/04/2021 20:00

I have as a joke called myself an orphan, but rarely and definitely not as a serious thing. My father died when I was nineteen and my mother seven years ago.
I think the MIL is being a bit dramatic if she's serious.

I haven't seen any evidence the OP is telling anyone how to grieve, or what age you should be.

steff13 · 21/04/2021 19:50

Unless she's trying to get someone to adopt her, I think you're being unreasonable.

Thistimelastyear · 21/04/2021 19:49

It doesn't matter if she didn't like her Dad, death stirs up all sorts of feelings and can be extremely tough if you had a rocky relationship with them. Orphaned is the wrong term but it probably just expresses how she feels.

I understand how you feel, I lost my Dad very young and I do find it hard to watch others who are lucky enough to have elderly parents. However, that does not make my loss worse than someone who loses their parents older. Grief is not a competition and not related to the age of the person who died.

JediGnot · 21/04/2021 19:40

[quote JosephineBaker]**@JediGnot* despite being nearly into old age*

Fuck that!!! How bloody rude. She’s in her fifties, not 70s.[/quote]
Just googled and it would seem that mid-50s is the middle of middle aged, and 10 years off old age.

"Nearly into old age" was laying it on a bit thick but not that accurate.

On the other hand, by that definition I was young a year or two back, which is patently nonsense!

Mistressinthetulips · 21/04/2021 19:38

Not that you get over a loss as such, but it can become easier to bear

Mistressinthetulips · 21/04/2021 19:37

One loss is far more recent though and therefore raw, an open wound if you like.

canary1 · 21/04/2021 19:26

My response was to ‘alsohuman’

canary1 · 21/04/2021 19:25

But it isn’t a competitive sport- there is no competition. Losing a parent at a life stage when you actually need to be parented is not comparable to losing a parent in late middle age.

saoirse31 · 21/04/2021 19:25

It sounds a bit like you're annoyed she's upstaging u in the grief stakes op tbh. I really don't see why , especially with your understanding of loss, you seem to have no empathy for her.

aprilanne · 21/04/2021 19:23

I think when lose both parents no matter your age you can feel orphaned .I lost both my parents before I was 50 and as an only child it was devastating. Because there I was with no one of shared childhood history and the eldest of my blood line I was actually very scared and upset ..I clung to my children probably was a right pain in the arse because I was terrified of dying and leaving them devastated as I was
So if she wants to call her self an orphan so what .you obviously dont like her that's probably more the problem than her grief

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.