Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mil claiming to be a orphan at 54.

287 replies

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 21/04/2021 15:35

Sorry, I’m really annoyed and upset.

I’m 30 and my mum died when I was 19. My dad had a life changing stroke when I was 16, which caused him to lose his voice, leg, arm and gave him slight brain damage. He lives in assisted living now.

My husbands grandad died before Xmas, I completely understand it’s her dad and she would be devastated but she’s been wishing him dead for years.

Aibu to think that 1, you are lucky to have many years with your parents and 2, you aren’t a fucking orphan.

Argh.

OP posts:
EL8888 · 21/04/2021 16:10

Technically she is an orphan so yes YABU. It’s not a competition. An ex of mine was an orphan by 32 but never mentioned, obviously he acknowledged it was a fact but never really talked about it

Redjumper1 · 21/04/2021 16:08

Death of a family member is hard. I think when you don't have a good relationship with the parent it can be just as difficult as if you did have a good relationship as any hope that you could one day have a good relationship is gone. It is a different type of grieving but one nonetheless. If you want to get technical about matters she is not an orphan nor indeed are you. Your pain and her pain are different.

EmbarrassingAdmissions · 21/04/2021 16:06

@Thedarksideofthemoon30

Sorry should have added, she really didn’t like her dad. As I said she wished him dead for years.
Both of my parents died when they were young. Even in circumstances such as those you describe, a death can be an emotional ambush.
ivykaty44 · 21/04/2021 16:06

its strange not having any parents after 50 odd years, that part of life has gone and the realisation of our own mortality

but stating your an orphan at 50 odd is a bit odd, orphan is a word to describe a child. could fit be that MIL is badly describing the above?

Meowchickameowmeow · 21/04/2021 16:06

I lost both my parents within the last two years, I genuinely feel orphaned. I had a complicated relationship with my mum but it doesn't mean that those feeling are any less real. Let people grieve however they want, it's not a competition, and trying to one-up in the grief stakes just makes you look like a dick.

NativityDreaming · 21/04/2021 16:05

She isn’t a child so she isn’t an orphan.

She is grieving though, even if she had a hard, complicated relationship with her parents.

FireflyRainbow · 21/04/2021 16:04

An orphan is a child whose parents are dead. Not adult. I know this as my son asked me the other day and we googled it😂

ancientgran · 21/04/2021 16:02

@ZaZathecat

ancientgran but if you had actually been orphaned as a child, as in both of your parents died by the time you were 13, don't you think that would have had a bigger effect on your life?
In practical terms yes because I'd have had to leave my home, hope someone would take me in but mentally I'm not sure, my mother and I were close as adults, we were friends as well as parent/child so totally different but what is the value of deciding who should be upset and how and who is allowed to be the most upset? We feel what we feel as we are human and not programmed robots.
BrumBoo · 21/04/2021 16:01

I think I know where you're coming from op, though I think you may be focusing on the wrong thing. The fact is, you feel like you've had to grow up very quickly, actually losing one parent fully when still technically a child, and another being so very unwell. It must be grating hearing someone use what must have sounded like a somewhat juvenile term about losing a parent, when one can assume from the ages mentioned her parents lived to an 'accepted' age.

Ultimately though, she's lost a parent. People deal with it in different ways, and she's reflective of her self - no longer someone's child. I think at any age, that is a difficult feeling to deal with. Even if you didn't like the parent, you always on some level want to be someone's child and feel 'looked after' by a parent. Any of us who've lost a parent under any circumstance can understand that, how vulnerable you can feel when you realise you mum/dad isn't coming back. So whilst I don't think you're unreasonable about the term 'orphan', I do think some understanding about the feelings behind it is needed here.

ZaZathecat · 21/04/2021 15:59

ancientgran but if you had actually been orphaned as a child, as in both of your parents died by the time you were 13, don't you think that would have had a bigger effect on your life?

IbrahimaRedTwo · 21/04/2021 15:59

An orphan is a child whose parents are dead. An adult whose parents are dead, that doesn't have a word, because it doesn't need one, it's what happens to all of us eventually unless we are unlucky and die young

That's pretty insensitive. I was an adult when my parents died, in that I was 18 and 22 respectively. I guess to you that's nothing of note though and I should not have thought of myself as an orphan and should have just got on with it. Hmm

ancientgran · 21/04/2021 15:57

@ZaZathecat

As someone who was 'orphaned' at 54, I would say that is totally different from losing your parents as a child or young adult. Of course it's sad and painful, but it is the natural order of things and something you know you are likely to have to deal with in your 50s/60s. Also, at this age, you have plenty of life experience and maturity to help you deal with it, and very often your parent has become dependent on you, rather than the other way round.

You MIL deserves sympathy on the loss of her parents, but it is very insensitive of her if she is comparing her experience to yours, imo.

I found the opposite, my dad died when I was 13, was horrible I was upset still miss him but when my mum died I was 48 and devastated. My husband was a baby when his dad died so has no memory of him.
AliasGrape · 21/04/2021 15:56

I couldn't get wound up about her using the word to describe herself - it's a strange feeling to suddenly realise you're the oldest generation and theres noone 'above you' as it were. I think it can feel disconcerting even if you didn't have a close relationship with your parents and whatever age you are.

I was actually orphaned- lost my birth mum at birth and my dad at 12, though the parents who brought me up (I say adopted but I wasn't ever actually, just brought up by other family members who I thought of as my parents as well as my actual parents) stuck around a bit longer - till I was 22 and 32 respectively, but when I lost my mum at 32 that was the first time i thought of myself as an orphan really. I didn't describe myself as that to all and sundry but I had that feeling of being adrift even though I was technically an adult.

Whether you're being unreasonable depends on a whole host of things, but she can still be grieving even if the relationship wasn't good. In some ways that's harder.

RoseMalone · 21/04/2021 15:53

They say that when you lose a parent you had a poor relationship with or who wasn't a good parent, you grieve the parent you wish you'd had. Maybe she's sad about that

Trixie78 · 21/04/2021 15:52

It doesn't matter how old you are when you lose your parents, it bloody hurts. Having a poor relationship makes the loss harder not easier. I'm sorry you lost your mum do young but you really do need to get over yourself. This post isn't one of your finest moments.

FinallyFluid · 21/04/2021 15:52

You sound delightful.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 21/04/2021 15:52

She should be more sensitive to your situation but it's hard to lose a parent no matter what age you are.
When people lose parents they don't get on with they often grieve for that lost relationship as much as their death.
As PP said, it's not a competition. Cut her some slack and show her some support.

ZaZathecat · 21/04/2021 15:51

As someone who was 'orphaned' at 54, I would say that is totally different from losing your parents as a child or young adult. Of course it's sad and painful, but it is the natural order of things and something you know you are likely to have to deal with in your 50s/60s.
Also, at this age, you have plenty of life experience and maturity to help you deal with it, and very often your parent has become dependent on you, rather than the other way round.

You MIL deserves sympathy on the loss of her parents, but it is very insensitive of her if she is comparing her experience to yours, imo.

CMOTDibbler · 21/04/2021 15:51

I'm 48 and lost both of my parents last year. Even though my mum had severe dementia, and my dad had been ill for ages, it still kind of rocked my world to now have no parents or older relatives. I wouldn't have described myself as an orphan, but when someone used that the other day it did really resonate.
Give your MIL a break

Garliccoriander · 21/04/2021 15:50

My dad died when I was 13 (lung cancer) he had been ill for some time.
My mother died 3 days before my DD was born then 18 months later a miscarriage at 15 weeks. Life is a rollercoaster as the song goes. I did grieve but felt I had to get on with things.

PacificState · 21/04/2021 15:50
  1. If she really did hate her dad but is making a fuss now, that is probably annoying. However the death of family member you had a bad relationship with can be weirdly upsetting in itself, so bear that in mind.

  2. You've had a very rough time of it, but you might want to think about counselling or something to reconcile/deal with your feelings. It's not really healthy to get furious over other people's bereavements. (It may be understandable. But not healthy.)

  3. Age really has nothing to do with it. I'm nearly 50, my dad (sole surviving member of my birth family) is in his 80s. I'll be on the fucking floor when he dies, however old I am when it happens.

DioneTheDiabolist · 21/04/2021 15:50

I have voted YABU OP. Losing parents is a horrendous time, no matter what your age. She is entitled to her grief.

Asterales · 21/04/2021 15:49

The death of a parent you had a difficult or complex relationship with can be harder to process sometimes than if you'd been close, as there's a lot of extra emotional baggage involved. For that alone YABU. Her dad has died. Let the poor woman deal with it as she wishes, it takes nothing away from you or your experiences.

ancientgran · 21/04/2021 15:49

@Anycrispsleft

An orphan is a child whose parents are dead. An adult whose parents are dead, that doesn't have a word, because it doesn't need one, it's what happens to all of us eventually unless we are unlucky and die young.

I mean you're not going to say that to her, right? But I can see how that must get right up your nose.

But lots of people do actually feel like that and when they are grieving is anyone going to start an argument about how they are allowed to feel?
BettysCardigan · 21/04/2021 15:48

@Thedarksideofthemoon30

Sorry should have added, she really didn’t like her dad. As I said she wished him dead for years.
This is really about the fact you don't like your MIL, I think.
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.