Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

17 and 20 are very different

59 replies

Swordfish1 · 19/04/2021 10:55

What would you think if a 27 year old man started dating a 17 year old (with quite severe health issues and considered vulnerable) girl.

So essentially she is still at school.
Its apparently no different than if she was 20 or 21. But I think it is quite a bit different.

I know the age gap is only 10 years and lots of relationships have large age gaps. But for me 17 and 27 is a lot different to say 30 and 40.
AIBU to be a bit concerned here?
For a little more context, she is a 'young' 17, very lovely and politie girl but comes over quite naive.
He is unemployed since quite a while, living with mother, does occasional drugs, is in debt and is into watching and sharing porn.

OP posts:
x2boys · 19/04/2021 12:16

I suppose it depends on the people involved ,sadly my sil passed away suddenly six years ago leaving three children a daughter of 18 and two sons of nine and two ,her daughter got full residency of both boys ,whilst she was 18 she was only four months past her 18th birthday.

MintyMabel · 19/04/2021 12:06

I don’t think there is a massive difference between 17 and 20, I’d be just as concerned for a 20 year vulnerable person being in such a relationship.

Maggiesfarm · 19/04/2021 12:02

Swordfish: He is unemployed since quite a while, living with mother, does occasional drugs, is in debt and is into watching and sharing porn.
......
Dreadful! They would be red flags regardless of his age.

I imagine he is one of those lazy, unmotivated, rather thick chaps with tattoos, that used to appear on Jeremy Kyle. He probably doesn't give your daughter's age a second thought.

Do all you can to discourage this relationship without going in hard. Try to get her to mix with younger people and be interested in other things.

Dontcallmewifey · 19/04/2021 11:56

I think there are bigger problems with him than just his age.

Inaquandry19 · 19/04/2021 11:54

When I was 16/17 I dated a 25 year old man. He mentally and physically abused me, then stalked me. I was not 'vulnerable' but very naive for my age. I would not like this one bit.

babbaloushka · 19/04/2021 11:52

I just can't imagine in what situation a normal 30 year old would be interested in a minor.

Angrypregnantlady · 19/04/2021 11:48

The unemployed and drug user would be my issue, no matter anyone's age.

I do think you change alot in 17-20. I was 18 when I met my DH who was 40. I think my family would consider me immature/naive because I didn't go out, get drunk, mess about with a load of lads and stuff.
But I was sensible and independent, at uni, he was a hard worker, decent man. It did me a world of good and kept me focused on work and achieving rather than getting pissed at student nights. I saved, I worked hard, paid for my driving lessons, bought a car, then we bought a house. I can't imagine what my life would be like if I'd been dating some 18yo joker.

All relationships are unique, most fail, all for different reasons, some are abusive, for different reasons. I don't think you can judge the success of a relationship on people's ages.

But I wouldn't want anyone I care about about date an unemployed druggie, no matter anyone's ages, they're not going to lift you up are they?

NameChangedForThisFeb21 · 19/04/2021 11:47

@Greygreenblue

It fails the half your age plus 7 test. According to that he should not be dating anyone under 20. where as if they were 30 and 40 it would not be icky and pass the half your age plus 7 test (she’d need to be over 27 in that instance). I find it works in almost every situation, if it feels a bit icky they probably are not passing said test. If it is a large age gap but still seems ok to you, they’re probably older and it makes more sense/passes the test.

If I knew her parents I would work his age into the conversation. Just to be sure they knew. Not that there is a lot you can do when your child makes questionable dating choices.

I’m not sure that the half your age plus seven rule is at all appropriate for children under 18 Hmm
Greygreenblue · 19/04/2021 11:45

It fails the half your age plus 7 test. According to that he should not be dating anyone under 20. where as if they were 30 and 40 it would not be icky and pass the half your age plus 7 test (she’d need to be over 27 in that instance).
I find it works in almost every situation, if it feels a bit icky they probably are not passing said test. If it is a large age gap but still seems ok to you, they’re probably older and it makes more sense/passes the test.

If I knew her parents I would work his age into the conversation. Just to be sure they knew. Not that there is a lot you can do when your child makes questionable dating choices.

DdraigGoch · 19/04/2021 11:40

He is unemployed since quite a while, living with mother, does occasional drugs, is in debt and is into watching and sharing porn.
What on earth does she see in this loser?

There's not a lot that you can do OP. Teenagers don't like being told what they can or can't do and her parents going nuclear would just make her run into his arms. The important thing is that she must know that she has someone to go to when she sees sense who isn't going to go "I told you so".

LittleGwyneth · 19/04/2021 11:40

Nothing wrong with ten years difference, but if you're under 18 it's very weird, and ideally I think you'd be post university by the time you dated some one that much older than you.

EileenGC · 19/04/2021 11:40

It’s the last sentence in your OP that would worry me, more than the age difference.

greyspottedgoose · 19/04/2021 11:38

If you're friends with his mother how on earth does she know his porn watching and sharing habits and why is she sharing that information with you?

Thatisnotwhatisaid · 19/04/2021 11:37

I think it’s grim personally. DH and I are 28 and I can’t imagine either of us finding a teenager even remotely attractive. They aren’t on our radar at all. I teach 17 year old’s and they aren’t appealing, they’re extremely immature and often a pain in the arse!

10 year age gaps aren’t usually an issue but I think dating a young teenager when you’re in your late 20s is weird.

FireflyRainbow · 19/04/2021 11:37

Back in the day though mine was so at 17 I'd been working full time for over a year, so wasn't a naive school girl.

skirk64 · 19/04/2021 11:36

Sorry I didn't read your update. (I mean, there were 16 posts in the thread... Blush) Obviously if she's not your daughter there's nothing you can do. If the parents don't care then they don't care.

Helenahandkart · 19/04/2021 11:35

When I was 16 I had a relationship with a 25 year old man who was overly keen on the idea that I had only very recently lost my virginity. When I look back on it he was creepy as fuck, but at the time I just felt really grown up and special to be receiving attention from an older man. When I was 17 I had a relationship for several years with a 26 year old. He was a loser with drug problems and no hope of a relationship with an equal, and was very controlling and coercive with me. Again, at the time I felt very adult, having an adult relationship, but in hindsight it was really damaging to my self esteem, and I was too young to know what I was getting in to. My parents were blind to his faults, and actually chastised me when I finally managed to extricate myself from the relationship, by which time he’d done a lot of damage to my self esteem and mental health.
I don’t know what your role is in this girl’s life OP, whether or not you have any influence on her, but I guess it would be good if you can keep an eye on her and perhaps be someone she knows she can talk to.

FireflyRainbow · 19/04/2021 11:34

If my son was 27 and went out with a 17 year old I'd be having words. But I started dating his dad on my 17th bday and he was 22, so I'd be being a hypocrite.

skirk64 · 19/04/2021 11:34

It's legal, so there's not much you can do. My advice would be to be supportive of her, anything else will mean she is likely to feel you are pushing her away and she will move further towards him.

When he's finished with her, which will be once the fun has gone out of things, she will need your support. It will easier if she feels you have always been supportive than if she thinks you didn't approve of her relationship.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 19/04/2021 11:30

If that was my daughter at 17 I would step right in I'm afraid.
My sister did similar, went out with a bloke 12 years older than her at 17. It was not healthy. She made all sorts of wrong decisions that made a fundamental difference to her life as am adult. My parents said not one word.
One of my dds was off down a similar path. I had many Frank discussions with her about it and she made sensible choices.

Regularsizedrudy · 19/04/2021 11:29

Id think he was a total creep. A 27 year old should have no interest in a teenager. I think it’s sick.

Swordfish1 · 19/04/2021 11:20

@TomHardyAndMe I'm glad that works out for you and good to see an example of what could work.
However the situation here is different like you say. She lives at home, is at school. She is unable to work fulltime due to health issues so she is 100% dependant on parents, and him, right now. And he has no savings, as far as I am aware as I know he is in debt. And does not even pay rent to his mother.
I am a friend of the mans mother in this scenario. She thinks the relationship is fine.

OP posts:
Swordfish1 · 19/04/2021 11:15

He's not in a position of power, no. So it is legal and there is nothing I can do to get involved. And it is none of my business, but it just makes me really uneasy. She is besotted, with the attention and the fact hes so mature Hmm
Her parents seem fine with it, but I'm wondering if they know how actually old he really is, and of his dubious background.
Glad i'm not the only one who thinks its a bit sick for a man that age to be interested in someone who, for me, is really still a child.
And I think if he was only 22 or 23 even, i'd still raise an eyebrow as to why a schoolgirl would interest him.

OP posts:
TheThingsWeAdmitOnMN · 19/04/2021 11:15

Age aside, he'd be nowhere near my 17yo vulnerable daughter

At 27, even if he was the perfect gentleman he'd be nowhere near my vulnerable daughter.

Combining the two I'd move heaven & earth to ensure he was nowhere near my 17yo vulnerable daughter.

Probably even if she wasn't 'vulnerable' in any other way than being just 17 too.

TomHardyAndMe · 19/04/2021 11:10

Whether there’s a difference in behaviour/maturity between 17 and 20 (and there is in my opinion, at 17 I was at school dependent on parents for a home and money and at 20 I was living on the other side of the country at drama school working to support myself) is completely irrelevant because she is not 20. She’s 17.

I moved out at 17 and lived with a bloke 10 years older. I still went to school but was self-sufficient financially and this meant I worked long hours at a pub for about £3.25 an hour to pay my way (had worked pretty much full time since 15 so had savings etc). I bought a house of my own at 19 and left him.

Clearly the OP has different concerns, and my situation is likely out of the norm, but that’s not to say it can’t happen positively in some cases.