Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair of new neighbours' shrieking children?

340 replies

saraclara · 17/04/2021 19:08

It's been a glorious afternoon, but I've had to spend it indoors, and even with my doors closed I can hear them. I don't know how they can shriek for this long without having really sore throats. It's not ordinary play shouting, it's just pointless daft shrieking as far as I can tell. They've been out there for at least four hours. There was a break for about 20 minutes, then it started up again. I'm guessing from the tone of the shrieks that they're about 7-9 years old?

There's nothing I can do about it, is there? This is it for the spring and summer.

I could weep.

OP posts:
FOJN · 17/04/2021 21:47

agentnully

She took the post down, refused to apologise, officer said there was nothing they could do.

Sounds like the police didn't want to get involved in a neighbour argument but if her FB post implied that the neighbour was a paedophile then surely it meets the threshold for libel. People have wound up in court for less under the Malicious Communications Act. Hope the rest of the village were put straight about her disgusting behaviour.

DoubleTweenQueen · 17/04/2021 21:45

Earplugs?

GreyhoundG1rl · 17/04/2021 21:43

Mummytemping again, you weren't in my garden this afternoon, so you can't "assure" me of anything either.
Dear God, the utter brass neck of someone trying to tell you what you heard and assure you it's perfectly normal.
Words fail me on this site, sometimes.

saraclara · 17/04/2021 21:40

Of course it's great for kids to be out playing in the garden or with friends. I encouraged my kids to be out too. What I didn't let them do is shriek to the point that it was annoying for neighbours (or me)

Again, there is a multitude of options that lie between lolling on the sofa in front of the Tv or screens for five hours, and high decibel shrieking in the garden for five hours.

@Mummytemping again, you weren't in my garden this afternoon, so you can't "assure" me of anything either.

OP posts:
Mintjulia · 17/04/2021 21:39

I'm with you bakedtattie

It's the first warm weekend, most children have been cooped up during lockdown, so they're energetic and excited to see their friends. They may be a bit high pitched but it's good to hear them play.

Mummytemping · 17/04/2021 21:35

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

I assure it almost certainly is ordinary play shrieking. Children have higher pitched voices than adults and squeal etc with excitement, its totally normal.

Unless you choose to live in the middle of nowhere, hearing children play outside on a lovely summer afternoon is pretty standard. Or would you rather they be indoors glued to the tv? They should be out playing with siblings/friends.

Totally agree.
EmeraldShamrock · 17/04/2021 21:34

But some of us are capable of bringing up kids who don't impact on others' lives. That's a bit mean, not all DC are the same as mentioned by many parents of DC with sensory overload. My DD is quite as a mouse DS is like banshees on steroids. I don't let him out before 10am he is in at 6pm with breaks in throughout the day I'm not incapable he is what he is.

SylHellais · 17/04/2021 21:33

But also, as this topic is raised every fucking year, you’d think there was some kind of MN approved response.

BakedTattie · 17/04/2021 21:32

To all those righteous enough to say they don’t bring their kids up to impact of others lives., what’s your secret?

I hate noise and I am constantly telling mine to be quiet, bringing them in to calm down etc. I’m hardly ignoring it!

My kids are clearly feral. The wee arseholes 😂

lilyblue5 · 17/04/2021 21:30

@TheMoth love this! I’m yet to perfect the withered look. Oldest asked if I have something in my eye today - not really what I was going for.

BakedTattie · 17/04/2021 21:30

I think you might be my neighbour.

It’s sunny, the kids are playing outside and having fun. 🤷🏼‍♀️

LockdownCheeseToastie · 17/04/2021 21:28

So clear from the answers who are the decent people and who are the parents of the shriekers. Normal kids playing noise is fine, screaming and shrieking really really isn’t. Dd left brownies because of one girl who shrieked in a hall every two minutes for the full session. Not remotely necessary and shit parenting if allowed to continue.

TheMoth · 17/04/2021 21:26

But some of us are capable of bringing up kids who don't impact on others' lives. There's playing... and There's screaming. Mine don't scream because at the first attempt, they were actively discouraged. My method is withering scorn, a reminder to said child that I know it's all fake and attention seeking, followed by withdrawal of any attention, but I'm sure people have their own methods.

EmeraldShamrock · 17/04/2021 21:22

I personally love to hear DC playing, especially this year, the streets were bare and quiet last year.
I genuinely think people with grown up DC forget how DC are. I still live close to the street I grew up on, most neighbour's moan about the DC on the green when all their DC played there and weren't angelically behaved just because they want a quiet life now. Well tough it's the circle of life.

TheMoth · 17/04/2021 21:21

I grew up in a 1930s semi. Tiny gardens and houses crammed together. Lots of kids our age. Parents didn't let other kids in the garden. Generally we played in the street or the park round the corner. The only screaming I remember was if we had water fights in the summer. Def no screaming in the garden.

InsanelyPregnantAndSore · 17/04/2021 21:19

Oh god I was in a shop with a shrieking for fun child the other day. She wanted the mums attention; mum wanted to shop. Kid was shrieking as loudly and high pitched as she could then laughing when her mum shouted at her. It went on for ages.

The whole shop hated that mum.

I have a toddler, I know what they’re like but when they’re making that level of noise and behaving that awfully you either give up and leave or distract them with something; you do not simply inflict it on everyone else endlessly.

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 17/04/2021 21:18

There’s a big difference between the lighthearted shrieks of joy & sound of laughter, and the continuous bellowing shriek that comes of parents failing to teach their children how to respect each other & those around him.

Ex-teacher with SEN experience too. I’ve never known a continuous shrieker, outside the remit of joy, laughter, frustration or pain. Even then, those shrieks have differing volumes & pitches which can be recognised.

The children next to us are of the high pitched, bellowing shrieking variety. Most often peppered with fighting/crying/tantrums (they’re neuro-typical & well above an age where tantrums are usual). Unfortunately, the children on the other side are also shriekers.

It’s interesting to note, in our stereo shrieking hell, that both families are of the shouty mother & loud music variety, so I can only conclude that the children shriek simply to be heard over the BOOM BOOM BOOM of the stereo & the countless on speaker phone arguments the parents seem to think everyone needs to hear, usually bemoaning their latest conquest’s lack of prowess in bed.

Such inattention to the small detail of their children shouting loudly concludes with one neighbours child (of around 3) being dangled out of the 1st storey bedroom window by one of her older siblings. It’s only by the grace of some deity I saw them & dashed round. Mother was utterly oblivious.

My 2 weren’t angels by any means, but I taught them if they shrieked all the time, they’d be put on a timeout inside, because (and I’m partially deaf) I would just dismiss any true shriek for help. A signal to noise ratio thing. And to be considerate of everyone around us (elderly & grumpy bastard neighbours). Which is why, in the field a few metres from us, I heard clearly my daughter’s shriek of fear & pain as she fell from a tree & broke her arm. (See? Not an utter playing outside fun sponge).

We all live in tiny houses with tiny gardens. We all have a right to enjoy our homes. But we can only achieve that if we are considerate of others. Kids really don’t need to scream like banshees all day.

lilyblue5 · 17/04/2021 21:15

@GreyhoundG1rl I’m not sure if there is anything I can do. My neighbour sits out in the morning so I wait until he goes in before I let the kids out, they don’t go out for hours and hours but they are loud. I do try but they are just SO loud, even when they are playing nicely. Anyway, they thread isn’t about me but there we go.

PivotPivotPivottt · 17/04/2021 21:14

My 9 year old is a shrieker. Always has been. As soon as she starts she gets a warning that if she keeps doing it she'll be coming in. The parents of the children she plays with have been given my permission to tell her to shut up. One time could hear her screaming in someone's garden at the top of my street from my living room ffs. It drives me insane never mind the neighbours. I really wouldn't be offended if my neighbours mentioned it to me in fact I'm surprised they haven't perhaps they are more tolerant than me Grin. She's getting better now thanks goodness she was bad last year but I haven't had to warn her so far this year.......

poolofvipers · 17/04/2021 21:12

YANBU - when my new neighbours moved in they let the kids make unlimited noise, including angry and upset screaming and fighting - actually it was mostly upset screaming.
There was no parental input for several hours, just let the kids shout and scream.
Happy contented playing - lovely to hear. Cross, angry and upset children screaming and shouting for hours - not lovely at all.

It abated for a few months when one of them seemed to injure themselves unsupervised on a massive trampoline. Now there are bad days again.

Some parents are just shitty people with no regard for others.

lynsey91 · 17/04/2021 21:12

@ZeroFuchsGiven

I find these threads really sad tbh, dogs barking would piss me off,neighbours arguing would piss me off but kids playing?
If you read the post properly you would see it is not about children playing but children screeching.

My neighbour has a daughter who screeches non stop. She was 4 when they moved in so I thought it was because she was young. She is now 7 and still screeches and, no, she is not SEN.

On any fairly nice dry day she will be in the garden from around 9am (although sometimes earlier) until 8pm or later. If we are lucky there will be a short break when she presumably eats but other than that she shrieks and screeches almost the whole time.

It drives me mad. I don't mind the sound of children playing and would expect some shrieking but not non bloody stop. When she talks she talks at the top of her voice but then so does the mum.

I don't really bother even trying to sit in the garden because of her. But even indoors with the doors and windows closed (which is not great when it is warm) I can hear her clearly. She even drowns out the tv. My living room is at the front of the house and she is in her back garden but that is how loud she is

LibertyLue · 17/04/2021 21:11

Totally agree with you OP. We’re surrounded by families and I really don’t mind hearing the children playing, I like hearing them laughing and having fun. What I don’t like is the family next door who allow their two children to scream, shriek and yell from first thing to last thing on a sunny day. Their parenting style appears to be never being allowed to tell the children not to do anything. I heard the father once tell them to stop it and the mother went crazy at him saying he wasn’t allowed to talk to them like that 🙄. These children make it a pretty unpleasant experience to sit in the garden. Drive me crazy. When my children were that age they would be told to stop shrieking/ fighting and if they didn’t they’d be taken inside.
The mother of these children seems to think that singing loudly at them whilst they fight is the best way to deal with it, so you get screaming accompanied by off key warbling of nursery rhymes. A bit of consideration from everyone would be very welcome,sadly some parents seem to think it’s their garden and they can be as obnoxious as they like.

EmpressSuiko · 17/04/2021 21:11

I think it’s unreasonable for you to assume there’s no learning difficulties l/condition like adhd or autism
Autism is vastly different for each individual and some are extremely articulate but will still have sensory needs. My son can communicate very well but he is a shrieker and loves to be very vocal, he will have random out bursts and sometimes he is very high pitched and it is not easy to stop him.
Luckily my neighbours are amazing and they know how I hard I work looking after my children and they are from teaching backgrounds so also understand how tricky it can be to manage challenging behaviour.

GreyhoundG1rl · 17/04/2021 21:11

[quote lilyblue5]@Pottedpalm unfortunately too young at the moment. The oldest is the only one who understands. Thankfully when I have spoken to/apologised to the neighbours they apparently enjoy the sound of children playing Confused[/quote]
They're being polite, lilyblue Confused. More polite than I could manage...

Babyroobs · 17/04/2021 21:10

Our ndn's kids are exactly like this too. It used to really wind me up but recently their dad has left and mum has a new partner and they are always out doing activities so it doesn't happen very often.