Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair of new neighbours' shrieking children?

340 replies

saraclara · 17/04/2021 19:08

It's been a glorious afternoon, but I've had to spend it indoors, and even with my doors closed I can hear them. I don't know how they can shriek for this long without having really sore throats. It's not ordinary play shouting, it's just pointless daft shrieking as far as I can tell. They've been out there for at least four hours. There was a break for about 20 minutes, then it started up again. I'm guessing from the tone of the shrieks that they're about 7-9 years old?

There's nothing I can do about it, is there? This is it for the spring and summer.

I could weep.

OP posts:
AliceMcK · 18/04/2021 11:41

@saraclara semi. None of my neighbours have issues with children being children, they have all had their own children and most have grandchildren. My children are inside from 5.30-6 every night for dinner then bed unlike the neighbours who stay in their gardens having smoky bbqs and drinks. I don’t complain about the noise they make, including dogs barking, as they are enjoying their homes and they don’t complain about the noise my children make. We all live together perfectly happy.

rosesinmygarden · 18/04/2021 11:31

YANBU

We have neighbours like this. It is slightly less frequent now lockdown has more or less ended but we've had a year now of listening to very very loud screaming from 8 in the morning until 11 pm some days. It's not normal playing noise. It's very, very loud screaming and it's really selfish. It means we cannot relax in our garden.

I've posted on here about them and was told by quite a lot of people I was being very unreasonable and that everyone should just enjoy hearing children playing.

I teach online and my students could hear the screaming over Zoom with the double glazed windows closed and me wearing a headset with microphone which minimises background noise. The other day we were treated to an hour of one of the boys screaming the words "penis" and "butthole" over and over while he bounced on the trampoline.

I've asked them to be quiet and they told me to fuck off. This is in a "nice" area and the parents are very well to do and think they are better than everyone else.

You are not being unreasonable but there's probably not much you can do about it. The parents know it is happening and obviously don't care.

The thing to bear in mind though is that children do grow up and change the way they play. It won't be an issue forever.

GreyhoundG1rl · 18/04/2021 11:31

YABVU if someone complained that my DCs were making too much noise playing in their own garden I would respond telling them when they start paying my mortgage then they can dictate what happens in my home.
How utterly charmless you sound. Nightmare neighbour personified.

saraclara · 18/04/2021 11:29

@AliceMcK

What do you consider ordinary play shouting?

YABVU if someone complained that my DCs were making too much noise playing in their own garden I would respond telling them when they start paying my mortgage then they can dictate what happens in my home.

Children have also been impacted by covid, they have not been able to spend times at parks, swimming, sports clubs, after school clubs, not been able to go on holidays, days out, so for a lot their garden if they are lucky enough to have one is their only place they can let off steam and be children. I’m certainly not going to police that.

What happens in your home affects no-one else (I hope you're detached). Noise in your garden does not remain within its borders. It can affect people half a dozen houses away in every direction.
OP posts:
lynsey91 · 18/04/2021 11:27

@Thiscantreallybehappening

OP YANBU. I totally understand where you are coming from. For all those posters saying, they are just children etc, let them make as much noise as they want to. What are we all supposed to do, sit it our houses with our doors and windows closed?

Yes, of course, children should play outside and have fun in their gardens. We have children around us and I absolutely do not mind hearing them play outside and, of course, there is going to be the odd bit of crying/arguing etc. However, all we are getting at the moment is hours and hours everyday of screaming, shrieking in my opinion this is not fair on other neighbours.

Surely, we are all allowed to enjoy our gardens. My children are all past that stage now but when they were small they used to play outside and enjoy their garden but I didn't let them scream for hours on end and if they were playing basketball or football I put a time limit on the time so there wasn't constant ball banging noise for hours.

This total unawareness of other neighbours and the entitled assumption that they can make as much noise as they want to for as long as they want to is totally unreasonable.

Last summer I did sit in my house with the doors and windows closed and I could still hear Little Miss Screech. I tried turning the radio or tv on but she could be heard above them even with them almost at full volume.

My living room is at the front of the house and she is in the back garden plus our houses are semis so not that close together. Just shows how loud she is.

I suffer from migraines and the only thing I can do if I get one is try to sleep it off. Fat chance with madam next door.

No point trying to talk to the neighbours as they are as ignorant as shit. They also have 2 barking dogs and have had numerous complaints but take no notice.

We don't talk to them now as their previous dog got into our garden and attacked one of our dogs leaving him needing 20 stitches in his face and lucky not to have lost his sight

Thiscantreallybehappening · 18/04/2021 11:25

@AliceMcK

You sound charming Smile. Do you not have any consideration for other people who are also paying mortgages/rent. Are they not allowed to enjoy their gardens?

There is normal noise from children playing, diy, lawn cutting etc. I don't think anyone minds that at all. What people are finding unacceptable is parents that let their children scream in high pitched voices for hours on end and have absolutely no awareness that other neighbours are also allowed to use and enjoy their gardens too.

Yes, children have been impacted by Covid but so have a lot of adults and they need to be able to enjoy their outside space too. My A Level studying DCs are also entitled to have a break from revision and to be able to read/relax in the garden.

lynsey91 · 18/04/2021 11:23

@AliceMcK

What do you consider ordinary play shouting?

YABVU if someone complained that my DCs were making too much noise playing in their own garden I would respond telling them when they start paying my mortgage then they can dictate what happens in my home.

Children have also been impacted by covid, they have not been able to spend times at parks, swimming, sports clubs, after school clubs, not been able to go on holidays, days out, so for a lot their garden if they are lucky enough to have one is their only place they can let off steam and be children. I’m certainly not going to police that.

Wow you sound like a considerate neighbour - not.

Have you even bothered to read the thread? We are NOT talking about ordinary play shouting. I am pretty sure the vast majority of people would expect that from children playing.

We are talking the screeching and shrieking that some children do more or less non stop for hours. The girl next door to me, aged 7 and definitely not SN shrieks and screeches literally all day when it is nice enough for her and her siblings to be in the garden.

The first few times I heard her I honestly thought something must have happened such as her falling and breaking her leg but no she is always fine.

Yes children have been impacted by covid but so have just about everyone else. They have been able to play in their gardens the whole time so that is a really pathetic excuse

EastWestWhosBest · 18/04/2021 11:16

YABVU if someone complained that my DCs were making too much noise playing in their own garden I would respond telling them when they start paying my mortgage then they can dictate what happens in my home.

Fab. I’ll start my DIY at 3am then. My house, my rules.

santorinisal · 18/04/2021 11:14

AliceMcK - exactly that attitude that annoys me... why should your kids enjoyment of their garden be to the detriment of the 20+ households living around them? We’ve all had a tough time in lockdown for various reasons, that doesn’t excuse wild inconsiderate behaviour that impacts on other people! Our outside space is equally precious.

AngeloMysterioso · 18/04/2021 11:04

You have my sympathy OP. I used to live in a U-shaped block of flats with a play area outside so all the noise the kids made was amplified. Those kids only had one volume, and that volume was scream. Sometimes til 10pm in summer. I fucking hated it.

AliceMcK · 18/04/2021 11:02

What do you consider ordinary play shouting?

YABVU if someone complained that my DCs were making too much noise playing in their own garden I would respond telling them when they start paying my mortgage then they can dictate what happens in my home.

Children have also been impacted by covid, they have not been able to spend times at parks, swimming, sports clubs, after school clubs, not been able to go on holidays, days out, so for a lot their garden if they are lucky enough to have one is their only place they can let off steam and be children. I’m certainly not going to police that.

fluffysocks89 · 18/04/2021 11:01

I sympathise Op. Not all kids do pointless shrieking, regardless of what some posters seem to think. You’d think it’d drive the parents mad too.

oakleaffy · 18/04/2021 10:57

Oh OP I empathise hugely.
some families don't even attempt to moderate noise.
Trampolines are ''Screechathon'' devices, as are anything that involves water in summer.

There is a family locally whose DC are just so so loud. One of them has an especially annoying giggle. High pitched and manic.

A friend moved {He has two well behaved DC's} precisely because of screeching neighbours DC.

I dread the summer, too, because of the high pitched manic yelling.

It isn't ''Lovely to hear kids enjoying themselves''....Enjoying yourselves doesn't mean screaming til the throat bleeds.

There are two children next door who are the polar opposite of the Screechers..All you hear is the murmur of their voices..Not that manic shrill ragged sound.

Thiscantreallybehappening · 18/04/2021 10:54

OP YANBU. I totally understand where you are coming from. For all those posters saying, they are just children etc, let them make as much noise as they want to. What are we all supposed to do, sit it our houses with our doors and windows closed?

Yes, of course, children should play outside and have fun in their gardens. We have children around us and I absolutely do not mind hearing them play outside and, of course, there is going to be the odd bit of crying/arguing etc. However, all we are getting at the moment is hours and hours everyday of screaming, shrieking in my opinion this is not fair on other neighbours.

Surely, we are all allowed to enjoy our gardens. My children are all past that stage now but when they were small they used to play outside and enjoy their garden but I didn't let them scream for hours on end and if they were playing basketball or football I put a time limit on the time so there wasn't constant ball banging noise for hours.

This total unawareness of other neighbours and the entitled assumption that they can make as much noise as they want to for as long as they want to is totally unreasonable.

santorinisal · 18/04/2021 10:35

YANBU! We also have 1 set of neighbours with kids who do this... as others have said I live in a built up village so fully expect to hear my neighbours from time to time.... kids playing, DIY, lawn mowing, occasional dog bark or garden gathering.... all fine. It’s constant, repetitive excessive noise I have issue with.... I think it’s rude and inconsiderate to have such intrusion into others lives. The family near me are well aware they are doing it... may well be stood in road watching with a cuppa, but make no attempt at all to bring down noise levels. Some people seem to live in a bubble and are oblivious to the others around them, some just don’t care and think their kids are just ‘being kids’ and the sound of them having fun is a joy to all, some may have SEN or personal issues that justifies any behaviour in their eyes.... honestly I don’t think there are any circumstances that make this okay.

Flowers24 · 18/04/2021 10:30

My neighours have very loud boys but luckily not all the time! Children playing noise is expected of course but if it were mine I would not let them shriek loudly , thats very unfair on the neighbours.

LindaEllen · 18/04/2021 10:28

@QueenPaw

There's normal play and there's screaming/shrieking. I've told this one before but they really need to know not to do it. Next door had a child who shrieked all the time/shouted help/mum constantly. One day it went on for ages as usual and eventually I went out to tell her to shut up only to find her hanging from the window upstairs. She lost her grip and fell as I stepped out, landed on the concrete and broke her pelvis and both her legs If she hadn't constantly shrieked, I would have gone to look earlier and could have shoved stuff on the floor or dragged her in If they're constantly shrieking and then a bloke tries to drag them off, who's going to know?
...and the award for 'posts about things that didn't happen' goes tooooo... !
Livelovebehappy · 18/04/2021 10:15

Just be equally shouty after their bedtime. It might then ensure they have little sleep, and they will then be quieter next day.

Blerg · 18/04/2021 10:00

Neighbour noise is awful. We are in a terrace with tiny gardens so I’m conscious of keeping the kids quiet and not going out in the garden too early. But when neighbours are routinely playing loud music, swearing loudly and crashing in and out smoking until 4am you might find yourself saying ‘Be as loud as you want’ to the kids. They aren’t really though and don’t shriek thank goodness because that would drive me insane.

We are moving soon, a lot due to noise, and will have a much bigger garden in a rural area. Really hoping it will be peaceful and will be very mindful of noise for the neighbours in the hope that they return the favour.

MatildaTheCat · 18/04/2021 09:59

@saraclara we had this exact problem last year. Hour after hour of shouting. It really got me down. Eventually we made contact and asked really, really nicely if they could reduce the time the kids were shouting for. Not stop using the garden, not stop playing, just try to keep it down.

They improved massively and straight away. In fact the whole family, parents included, have autism and they simply didn’t realise.

We’ve stayed on friendly terms and when the shouting does start up I can be fairly confident it won’t last all day.

Pop round with a small welcome gift and just ask. It might just work.

SpringtimeSummertime · 18/04/2021 09:58

@torquewench

My ndn's spawn are screamers. Eight constant hours of it yesterday. And the oldest one (about 9yo) had the nerve to try to tell me off for making a noise after I fired up the lawnmower HmmAngry
Wow. Did you tell them that you will stop mowing your lawn only when they stop screaming day in day out?
Seymour5 · 18/04/2021 09:58

Some people really don't understand 'consideration' do they? Children learn reasonable behaviour from considerate parents. I have no issues with children being noisy, they have higher pitched voices which carry. But shrill, mindless shrieking is another level. My sympathies OP.

I was in the park with youngest GD yesterday. She waited her turn to go on a popular, high piece of equipment, but adults were pushing in front to lift much smaller children on to it. She told me she had said excuse me, I was waiting my turn, but she was ignored. Later I went with her to try again, and there was another reasonable adult who ensured her child also got a turn.

WalkersAreNotTheOnlyCrisps · 18/04/2021 09:55

I have every sympathy with you. I know how hard it can be. A lot of the parents of the children I taught got very distressed about neighbour relationships and their children's problems. It sounds as though you are doing a great job balancing the two.

Yeah he can drive me to distraction at times, so I’m acutely aware it will probably be intolerable to others after a while.
I wouldn’t have allowed his NT sibling to scream like that outside either though.

SpringtimeSummertime · 18/04/2021 09:55

I assure it almost certainly is ordinary play shrieking. Children have higher pitched voices than adults and squeal etc with excitement, its totally normal.

I assure you it’s not normal for children to shriek for 4 hours non stop.
They can be really loud, shout instead of talking, shriek & squeal intermittently but if, as the OP says, it is non stop for hours at a time, they need to be told to pipe down.

EastWestWhosBest · 18/04/2021 09:54

We have a child two doors away who is the same.

She has older brothers and not only shrieks but fake cries all the time.
It goes like this:

‘It’s my turn on the swing now’
‘No it isn’t I’ve only just got on. You need to wait’
scream and fake cry
Mum stick head out of windows and shouts and child.
Repeat.

The really annoying thing is that because of the layout of our houses you can’t access the garden from the house directly. And the house is much higher than the garden. Therefore it’s much easier to shout from the living room window, which is about 10ft up, then it is to go out.
The only saving grace is that this household seem to have spent the last year filling the alley that goes from their back door to the garden with crap so I don’t think they will be able to access the garden at all.