Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair of new neighbours' shrieking children?

340 replies

saraclara · 17/04/2021 19:08

It's been a glorious afternoon, but I've had to spend it indoors, and even with my doors closed I can hear them. I don't know how they can shriek for this long without having really sore throats. It's not ordinary play shouting, it's just pointless daft shrieking as far as I can tell. They've been out there for at least four hours. There was a break for about 20 minutes, then it started up again. I'm guessing from the tone of the shrieks that they're about 7-9 years old?

There's nothing I can do about it, is there? This is it for the spring and summer.

I could weep.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fitzwilliamdarcy · 10/08/2023 13:37

Reported for trolling. There’s already enough ill feeling towards those without kids on here without trolls creating more.

xILikeJamx · 10/08/2023 13:27

Only 2 years old this thread - must try harder!

YoureNotBetterForSqeezingOneOut · 10/08/2023 13:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

GSC103 · 08/06/2021 20:47

Just to offer a view from the other side. I have 2 children, one very polite quiet well behaved respectful child who does everything she is asked and one screeching, high pitched screaming boisterous angry, tantrum thrower. Both children have been parented in exactly the same way. They both have boundaries they are both loved and cared for. It adds huge stress on top of an already very stressful situation knowing we are being judged by everyone, we have recently moved home and are clearly disliked. I totally appreciate it’s disruptive, extremely disruptive. What I would ask all the judgers to consider is how many of you parented a toddler through a lockdown when you were stuck in 4 walls and garden day after day with 2 parents who were working from home with no outside support from family or childcare and had another child to homeschool. Do people think honestly think this hasn’t affected children. Lots and lots of children are struggling, my child is clearly affected despite our best efforts, we have sought all the available help but short of putting tape over his mouth what would you like us to do. Let me assure you, you may be hating it all from your homes and gardens, try living with it day after day when your trying your best to support your child in every way possible when all you get is slamming doors and disapproving looks. Mull that over.

DenisetheMenace · 29/04/2021 20:40

wejammin. To some people though (me included), shrieking is just as awful as the cat scare thing 🤷‍♀️
Laughing, talking, ball games, trampoline etc. no problem at all. It’s the awful, high pitched, pretty continuous shrieking. Like fingernails on a blackboard to me.

What’s unreasonable is subjective and personal, I guess. You think your neighbours are, they think you are.

Sorehandsandfeet · 28/04/2021 14:55

Weejammin I hear you! None of us have been in OPs place so it is hard to judge that particular instance but to those of us with children with SN, posts like this can be upsetting. I even saw upthread that a poster said 20 mins outside for a child with Tourettes was too much for the neighbours. There is a big difference between children being noisy because the parents are neglectful and disrespecting of their neighbours and children who find it difficult/impossible to control their volume and their parents who struggle every day to ensure their children aren't causing a problem for others. It can be exhausting and very upsetting. All I say is that you shouldn't judge others without knowledge of their situation.

AlanSinclair · 28/04/2021 13:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

stayathomer · 21/04/2021 10:29

wejamminFlowers Sorry your neighbours did that (thinks of lots of bad words in head)

wejammin · 21/04/2021 07:11

I have shriekers. My oldest is autistic and, despite what OP said previously, shrieking is not limited to the non verbal or distressed autistic child! He is hyposensitive to noise, so he also has a very loud voice that he does not regulate well. Despite our best efforts, the younger 2 are also quite loud, when they play together, presumably modelling his play.
We do send them in when it's excessive, and we have a sensory tent in the garden to try and regulate overwhelm.
Having said that, we moved into our house November 2019. Last spring/summer we were both working full time and try to manage the kids as best as possible, and there was NO WHERE to go except the garden. Our neighbours at the back (who both work with children professionally) made our lives even more miserable than lockdown had, by constantly shouting at them to shut up, and then installed a "cat scare" alarm which they turned on when the kids stepped outside. This emitted a noise that they thought adults couldn't hear but we very much could, and for my children it was agony. I went round and very nicely asked them to turn it off and they denied all knowledge - I had to (nicely) suggest that environmental health would need to investigate and it stopped.
What I'm trying to say (in a long winded way) is that some children are louder than others, lots of parents try their best to manage this but it's exhausting being hypervigilant, the last 12 months have been a bit of an extreme example of how often children play out in their gardens, and neighbours can also be unreasonable.

CharlotteRose90 · 21/04/2021 00:11

It’s awful isn’t it. Next door to me have 2 kids that they let scream day and night. Especially if it’s in the garden they shriek while jumping on the trampoline or swing sends me absolutely crazy. A little bit you can tolerate but don’t let your kids do it all day it’s not fair.

EastWestWhosBest · 20/04/2021 22:44

That’s so bad @Cosmos45. It goes to show though that money doesn’t buy class.
Sadly it also shows that you can get problems like this in any kind of neighbourhood.

Thiscantreallybehappening · 20/04/2021 15:13

@Gothichouse40 I understand your point and it is something we have considered. It is a really difficult decision and we have spent hours discussing whether we should stay, the children will get older, they may move on etc. It is precisely the fact that we could end up with the same or even a bigger problem that we haven't yet put our house on the market. However, with this family it isn't just the children shrieking for hours on end there are other issues. We also don't think they will move on. Unless your budget is massive, I don't think anywhere can be 100% perfect and I don't expect that. Like I said earlier, normal neighbour noise is absolutely to be expected: children playing, DIY, visitors, garden machinery etc but this is different. There have been a number of issues in the last couple of years but we have always thought the positives outweigh the negatives that and the fact that we love the property and what we have achieved with it led us to believe that we would stay. However, I think we all feel that the negatives now outweigh the positives and it is time to look for another property.

I don't think it is going to be straightforward and like @Cosmos45 said there are no guarantees.

Cosmos45 · 20/04/2021 14:20

@Gothichouse40 I guess my thoughts are I do as much due diligence as I can not to be in this situation again. There are some other factors within my situation which I could not have controlled (bit difficult to explain). Thankfully we have a decent budget and every house I look up on rightmove I do a google earth view and street view and satellite view to see what is around the house and surrounding areas. I have discounted probably 70% of houses I was interested in due to external factors like neighbours too close or near schools, pubs etc. Of course there is no guarantee in life.

Gothichouse40 · 20/04/2021 13:39

To the people that are moving house, do you think that is the answer? How do you know you are not going to end up beside worse? Ive often wondered if people who do move because of neighbour/noise/screaming children issues find it does work out, or have they ended up in worse situations?

trixies · 20/04/2021 13:06

Round my way, it's 50% shrieking and 50% kicking balls off garden walls, cars and front doors. My letterbox flap was broken by this, and when I mentioned it (politely) to the parents, they shrugged and said it was just kids playing, too bad. My NDN bypassed the parents altogether, and told the kids off directly when they hit her car. The parents then turned up to give her an earful.

When some people respond to property damage like this, it's not rocket science to see why their neighbours wouldn't bother mentioning shrieking.

I dread the nice weather, which is depressing in itself as I have SAD and so could use the opportunity to enjoy my outdoor space and the sunshine.

All of which to say, OP, I'm really sorry and YANBU. Some people take "it takes a village" to mean "the village is my child's playground and nobody is allowed to say otherwise".

Thiscantreallybehappening · 20/04/2021 11:45

@Cosmos45 You are right, these families do behave like they own the road. There is zero awareness, consideration and respect for other neighbours. The level of entitlement and "I'll do what I want, when I want" attitude causes so much stress. I understand exactly how you feel Flowers.

Cosmos45 · 20/04/2021 10:00

[quote Thiscantreallybehappening]@Cosmos45 @Jennifer2021
So sorry to hear that you are both, along with other posters, going through this. We have been here years and invested a lot of time and money in the property because we hadn't planned to move. I expect to hear normal children noise, DIY, gardening etc but this noise is something else, the parents join in too. This afternoon has been awful. I've been searching on Rightmove for a couple of weeks, like you I think we are now resigned to having to move.[/quote]
@Thiscantreallybehappening it is scarily similar to my situation - we were here 5 years before our neighbours moved in. They were a youngish couple and he arrived with a very big flash sports car. From day one he ragged that car out of the village and we could hear him up to 4 miles away. It shook peoples gates and windows as it flew past at speeds of upto 90 miles an hour on a rural lane. That really told us all we needed to know and they have slowly got worse and worse. Now with having the two screeching kids (not normal playing noise at all, I know my kids didn't do it and none of my friends kids do it). He also has the hot tub, full size bouncy castles, pools and thinks he owns the road. Just last week him and his friend got pissed out of their heads and were shouting in the hot tub at 1.00am - My husband went round to ask them to tone it down a bit and was met with a 45 min rant with lots of swearing and threatening behaviour and a promise to make our lives hell. This guy is a solicitor and runs his own law firm. This was our dream home, it is Grade 11 listed and we lovingly renovated it going through all sorts of hoops with the council and getting granted all sorts of special permissions etc. Now I have to walk away from it and honestly I am devastated.

Jennifer2021 · 20/04/2021 06:33

Children have also been impacted by covid, they have not been able to spend times at parks, swimming, sports clubs, after school clubs, not been able to go on holidays, days out, so for a lot their garden if they are lucky enough to have one is their only place they can let off steam and be children. I’m certainly not going to police that.”

A neighbour who lives behind us works at the hospital couldn't get her car out because the gang of visiting hoarded were blocking the road and being verbally abusive to anyone who asked them nicely to move. The other neighbour who is a carer had done a night shift and was disturbed and everyone else has been trying to work from home and the other couple still have work the next morning after everyone got treated to a loud party as punishment for daring to disrespect her by asking her quite reasonably to supervise her children and visiting children better. It's not about policing it it's about having basic consideration for others.

The parks were only closed during the first lockdown, our delightful Asbo Annie is a full on Covid denialist who's continually broke lockdown with gatherings through all three and still had her feral DCs in school during the last one under the keyworker provision even though she don't work whilst DC1 who is doing their GCSEs wasn't granted the same opportunity so I don't think it's fair to say all children have suffered. Some have done alright out of it. The park is literally across the road on our street and she's not taken them on there once to run off their energy since she's had them.

Delphinium20 · 19/04/2021 23:55

@FourTeaFallOut

I'll do you one better, I'm a few doors away from a mother who shrieks alongside playing with her children in the garden in the most emphatic display of performance parenting that you could ever have the misfortune to hear. The entire crew of cbeebies have nothing on her.
I choked with laughter at this one!
Delphinium20 · 19/04/2021 23:49

We live on a block with lots of kids who run through yards (our youngest joins in). But, there's one family of shriekers...the other kids from the other families don't shriek. My kids don't shriek...though, to be fair, I don't think I had to teach them not to shriek (sorry, OP, it might be genetic).

Last summer, my rather mild-mannered sister called in to wish my dad a happy birthday - we all were sitting in the back yard (garden). When we put her on speaker, she spoke a bit and then stopped to say, "What the hell is that?"

It was the shriekers a full house away...we must be Stockholmed and can't realize how bad it is anymore...except every Spring, we are sadly reminded.

Pinkyavocado · 19/04/2021 23:34

I hate it too. Screaming children drive me bonkers. I’ve got three of my own. They’ve never screamed in the garden. They used to get loud and excited on the trampoline but nothing major, definitely no screeching or screaming.

StoneofDestiny · 19/04/2021 22:37

If someone complained that my DCs were making too much noise playing in their own garden I would respond telling them when they start paying my mortgage then they can dictate what happens in my home

You deserve to live next door to neighbours who think like you - playing loud music in their gardens at all hours, having drinks parties and setting off fireworks randomly during the week or who decide to break motors on their front lawn and let the spares parts pile up. They pay their mortgage so it's ok. Geez - what a world some people live in.

StoneofDestiny · 19/04/2021 22:29

Everyone has been impacted by Covid. If your neighbour had just finished the last in a long line of 12 hour shifts on ward and just wanted an hour’s peace in their garden, why does your kids’ need to shriek supersede that?
Take them to the park if that’s what you’re happy for them to do. Or tell them not to. Which is what most people do

There appears to be a group of parents who think their darlings behaviour can never be challenged or corrected. They feel their needs to do as they want outweighs the rights of everybody else. Teachers meet these parents daily - fortunately they are in a minority.

Actually heard a parent say that they taught their children to shout in the street so they could hear them inside the house and knew they were safe 🤬. Seriously lazy parenting - lord knows how they distinguished the child screaming for help of just screaming for fun. Idiot parent thought that the neighbours should put up with that! Thankfully, they were not my neighbour.

comingintomyown · 19/04/2021 22:21

It’s the screaming like you would if you encountered a mutilated corpse that I can’t stand and you never hear an adult say Stop it . Thank god near door but ones kids are teens now

Jennifer2021 · 19/04/2021 22:20

@ItsAHardKn0ckLife1 I think you may live on my street. The Alexa screeches to play more shit music at stupid o clock at night with no regards for the adjoining neighbours who still have work in the morning sound somewhat familiar.