Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you walk across someone else's fields?

268 replies

hotpatooties1 · 17/04/2021 11:45

Just that really. I've been surprised since moving to a farm just how many people are willing to walk across other peoples land and allow their dogs to run all over it too. Some of the fields have just been sewn and are sprayed with fertiliser regularly..they don't seem to care.

I wouldn't do it, was brought up on and around farms and was told not to walk over other peoples land. I understand the right to roam and that lawfully, they are doing nothing wrong. It just doesn't seem right.

This morning I drove past one of our fields that is gated. A woman had gone into it with her dog, let it off lead and had a kid on a bike in it..AIBU? Would you do that?

OP posts:
FuzzyPuffling · 17/04/2021 14:24

A field, council property? Oh come on! 😁😁

I was born a townie but now live rurally, and I have always known not to wander willy nilly over fields.

Dollhousedoor · 17/04/2021 14:21

No I wouldn't walk on someone else's land, not unless following a signposted public footpath, even in that scenario id expect to put dog on a lead and any children with me would also be asked to follow the path too so we do not stray away from the path we are supposed to follow. Out of respect - I'd be rather annoyed if someone decided to wander through my own garden.

OolieMacdoolie · 17/04/2021 14:21

I do think a lot of the hostility to my posts is coming from English people who are used to different laws. I totally understand why you would want to avoid walking in fields where you don’t have that right and it’s not the custom. I’m just saying that it’s different in Scotland where we do have that right, but also that it’s a really good thing. There is something really wonderful about a nation recognising that the land ought to be a commonwealth that benefits us all, and taking steps to facilitate that. I think it’s especially true in a nation like Scotland where land acquisition was historically such a deeply unfair and immoral process.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 17/04/2021 14:18

@Angrypregnantlady

If there was just a grass field and no signs then I would assume it was council property, just a normal grassy patch of land. If there's crops or signs then we stick to footpaths.

You should put signs up saying private property and that pesticide is regularly sprayed there.

Council property in the countryside?

That's not a thing is it? All rural files belong to a private landowner ime

krustykittens · 17/04/2021 14:18

If grass is high enough to be above your ankle, it is being grown as a crop, so you should not go into the field. Scottish right to roam is meant to be with mutual respect ie, you do nothing to interfere with someone's lawful use of their land, not a case of go where you like and do what you like. I wish more tourists understood this subtle difference.

OolieMacdoolie · 17/04/2021 14:17

@Clymene

Personally I'm keen on supporting farmers to be able to farm *@OolieMacdoolie*
In what way does me walking round a field prevent this? Genuinely?
OolieMacdoolie · 17/04/2021 14:17

@sunflowersandbuttercups

I would obviously not enjoy people using my garden, but gardens are excluded from right to roam and are also quite clearly different from a field in the countryside.

You say yourself fields growing crops are excluded - how can you tell the difference just by sight? Grass is also a crop - if keeps the animals fed.

It’s usually pretty obvious, especially if you’ve grown up in the country as I have. There are clues - straight lines of plants, tractor lines, plough grooves, regular attendance by tractors doing spraying etc, identification of crops by sight. If you grow up rurally it’s hard to imagine how someone couldn’t look at a field and immediately identify that it had crops growing.

Grass isn’t a cultivated crop in the same way that something like wheat is. It isn’t destroyed by people walking across it. You don’t damage a grazing field by walking across it (and you certainly won’t do any damage at all the registers compared to the herd of hooved animals walking around in it...)

It’s mostly just common sense. For example, around my house are several huge fields used for the cultivation of crops. Usually it’s wheat, and I don’t walk on them when the crop is growing. But once it’s been harvested and is stubble for two or three weeks in the late summer, I happily walk my dog or ride my horse around the edge of it.

There is also lots of land used for sheep and cattle grazing, and I’ll walk around the edges of these fields if necessary to get to the nearby hills as long as the sheep and cows don’t have lambs or calves.

There are also a few fields where the farmer has left a wide strip of grass around the edge for his sons to play on their quad bikes. I’ll happily walk on those edges when the quad bikes aren’t around.

EastWestWhosBest · 17/04/2021 14:13

@OolieMacdoolie

Yes, I would. I wouldn’t walk over crops and wouldn’t let a dog off the lead, but I would otherwise use the space.

We have the right to roam, and sometimes it’s not practical to avoid a particular field. I’m respectful of the space though - leave gates as I find them, avoid crops, steer clear of animals etc. I don’t feel bad about it tbh.

Not practical to avoid a field? Yes it is. You don’t walk across it. Just like you don’t walk across your neighbours garden.
Hyacinth88 · 17/04/2021 14:13

As long as no animals in it or working going on. I wouldn't let my dog off the lead and it would be to get somewhere else not to use as recreation.
Here in Scotland there's a right to roam

TustedFormula · 17/04/2021 14:13

What makes people think we have the right to roam on farms? Generally, we don't.

Angrypregnantlady · 17/04/2021 14:12

If there was just a grass field and no signs then I would assume it was council property, just a normal grassy patch of land. If there's crops or signs then we stick to footpaths.

You should put signs up saying private property and that pesticide is regularly sprayed there.

Clymene · 17/04/2021 14:11

Personally I'm keen on supporting farmers to be able to farm @OolieMacdoolie

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 17/04/2021 14:10

@upsydaisyssinging

I would and have done if it's a right of way. I shut gates etc... We have right to roam in the UK and I think that's important.
I don't think we do, that's only in Scotland afaik. Do you have a link?
TillyTopper · 17/04/2021 14:09

No I wouldn't, I'd only walk if there was a marked footpath.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 17/04/2021 14:06

I would obviously not enjoy people using my garden, but gardens are excluded from right to roam and are also quite clearly different from a field in the countryside.

You say yourself fields growing crops are excluded - how can you tell the difference just by sight? Grass is also a crop - if keeps the animals fed.

ginoclocksomewhere · 17/04/2021 14:05

You're not being unreasonable, nor do you have to justify yourself.

Right to roam doesn't apply to private property in England (though I believe it does in Scotland?)

I'll never forget hearing about a lady who found picnicers in her field who soon scarpered when she brought over her bull 😂

Bvop · 17/04/2021 14:03

Yanbu. But some people aren’t brought up knowing this. DH thought that when it snowed it’d be a good idea to go sledging on a nearby farmer’s field and was taken aback when I said of course we can’t do that - he had no idea.

OolieMacdoolie · 17/04/2021 14:02

Summary of the rules in Scotland: www.apidura.com/journal/freedom-to-roam-in-scotland-everything-you-need-to-know/

Clearly England has a much more restrictive set of rules. I think that’s a shame. Scotland has made deliberate attempts to democratise land use over the last couple of decades, since so much of the land is owned by such a tiny group of people. I personally think that’s a very positive thing, but I see I’m in the minority!

OolieMacdoolie · 17/04/2021 13:59

@sunflowersandbuttercups I live in Scotland so the rules may be different to those in England, but up here right to roam allows you to access most areas of land. There are limited exceptions - the immediate vicinity of buildings and farmyards, quarries, railway property and airfields, and private gardens. I think fields with crops growing are also excluded. But other than that the public have a right to access and use the land.

I would obviously not enjoy people using my garden, but gardens are excluded from right to roam and are also quite clearly different from a field in the countryside.

Onairjunkie · 17/04/2021 13:58

@OolieMacdoolie

Yes, I would. I wouldn’t walk over crops and wouldn’t let a dog off the lead, but I would otherwise use the space.

We have the right to roam, and sometimes it’s not practical to avoid a particular field. I’m respectful of the space though - leave gates as I find them, avoid crops, steer clear of animals etc. I don’t feel bad about it tbh.

This is the ignorant entitlement I was talking about. 🙄
Onairjunkie · 17/04/2021 13:57

@OolieMacdoolie

Yes, I would. I wouldn’t walk over crops and wouldn’t let a dog off the lead, but I would otherwise use the space.

We have the right to roam, and sometimes it’s not practical to avoid a particular field. I’m respectful of the space though - leave gates as I find them, avoid crops, steer clear of animals etc. I don’t feel bad about it tbh.

You don’t have the right to access ‘excepted land’, even if it’s shown in an open access map. And much private farmland is excepted, so you can only access via marked footpaths.
Clymene · 17/04/2021 13:55

@OolieMacdoolie

Yes, I would. I wouldn’t walk over crops and wouldn’t let a dog off the lead, but I would otherwise use the space.

We have the right to roam, and sometimes it’s not practical to avoid a particular field. I’m respectful of the space though - leave gates as I find them, avoid crops, steer clear of animals etc. I don’t feel bad about it tbh.

No, we don't - not over fields. Where does this shit come from?

www.gov.uk/right-of-way-open-access-land/use-your-right-to-roam

sunflowersandbuttercups · 17/04/2021 13:54

@OolieMacdoolie

Yes, I would. I wouldn’t walk over crops and wouldn’t let a dog off the lead, but I would otherwise use the space.

We have the right to roam, and sometimes it’s not practical to avoid a particular field. I’m respectful of the space though - leave gates as I find them, avoid crops, steer clear of animals etc. I don’t feel bad about it tbh.

You only have the "right to roam" on public access land, and even then, only on public rights of way.

Or would you be happy if hordes of people started trampling through your private garden?

Onairjunkie · 17/04/2021 13:53

Had people digging up my wild flowers bulbs too and having campfires too.

It’s awful because sometimes they’re genuinely unaware of what they’re doing wrong, so when you see a small family trying to have a nice time you feel such an arsehole for asking them to leave. It’s easier when they’re obnoxious twats.

OolieMacdoolie · 17/04/2021 13:51

Yes, I would. I wouldn’t walk over crops and wouldn’t let a dog off the lead, but I would otherwise use the space.

We have the right to roam, and sometimes it’s not practical to avoid a particular field. I’m respectful of the space though - leave gates as I find them, avoid crops, steer clear of animals etc. I don’t feel bad about it tbh.