Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you walk across someone else's fields?

268 replies

hotpatooties1 · 17/04/2021 11:45

Just that really. I've been surprised since moving to a farm just how many people are willing to walk across other peoples land and allow their dogs to run all over it too. Some of the fields have just been sewn and are sprayed with fertiliser regularly..they don't seem to care.

I wouldn't do it, was brought up on and around farms and was told not to walk over other peoples land. I understand the right to roam and that lawfully, they are doing nothing wrong. It just doesn't seem right.

This morning I drove past one of our fields that is gated. A woman had gone into it with her dog, let it off lead and had a kid on a bike in it..AIBU? Would you do that?

OP posts:
Weebitawks · 18/04/2021 08:28

I would go in fields that have public right of way. I would never walk across crops and I would never loose my dog in a field with livestock. It's about a balance, if people respected the countryside, there's no reason why we can't all enjoy it.

My husband's family are all farmers and the entitled fuckwit Walkers ruin it for everyone. One wanker walked through a field bashing the crops down with a stick yelling that the middle of the field was a public footpath and the crops were in the way. Walk round the edge like a decent person dickhead.

LakieLady · 18/04/2021 08:21

I agree that the countryside code needs to be better publicised. I think if I was a farmer, I'd put laminated copies on every gate and stile.

When I was a child (1960s), there were short public information films about it (along with Keeping Britain Tidy, not blowing yourself up with fireworks etc) broadcast between programmes on tv. We need to reintroduce that imo.

LakieLady · 18/04/2021 08:15

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

I find it really irritating when public footpaths and rights of way have barbed wire fences erected

I'm amazed this is happening. I've lived in 3 rural parts of the UK and been on holiday in loads more and literally never once seen this happen on a prow

Oh, I have. And plenty of places where the RoW has became terribly overgrown, to the point where it's impassable.

Around my way, there is a local footpaths group who go out for rambles every other weekend, pretty much year round. They report every obstruction, broken stike etc to the council's RoW officers, who tell the landowner to get it sorted. The council has the power to sort it out themselves and charge the landowner if the landowner fails to rectify it.

Mind you, this is the county where a blocked footpath made national news in the 1990s, thanks to Nicholas Hoogstraten. The footpath, designated "Framfield 7", became quite famous and you could buy t-shirts with the slogan "Free the Framfield 7". The legal action cost the council 10s of thousands. The "palace" he was building on the land the path runs through is now an unfinished ruin. Security guards patrol the estate, and I have no idea if it's possible to walk the Framfield 7 without being accosted by them.

Thebirdstbeseathebirds · 18/04/2021 08:05

The country code needs to be promoted and advertised more. I’m farming family and none of us have an issue with people using paths or bridle ways, we look after the land for future generations and it’ll be here long after we’re gone. Most people do seem to respect the guidance when it comes to dogs, crops, kids etc. and most people popping up in the middle of somewhere they shouldn’t be are lost.

Thebirdstbeseathebirds · 18/04/2021 08:01

She sounds a bit thick, but I would walk on the edge of fields for access or on a marked path. I wouldn’t just kick my kids into someone’s field for a play, that’s ridiculous.

Scrowy · 18/04/2021 07:53

So sick of having to explain to people that just because a footpath goes through a field it doesn't make the whole field fair game to exercise the dog, have a picnic etc.

Many farmers can also tell you tales of members of the public seeming to believe that farms generally are open to the public. We regularly have people on the (completely private but adjacent to a footpath) piece of grass outside the farm house to have picnics. At this time of year it's not unusual to see people going off the path to go into a shed to look at the lambs. People going for a nosey drive down the (private) farm lane and parking up and having their sandwiches in the farm yard.

Too many people have lost all understanding that farms are work places and that farm animals aren't cuddly pets at a petting farm.

I'm flabbergasted at the number of people on this thread who openly admit to letting dogs run around off lead etc but 'it's fine because...'

No it's not fine, you aren't a special exception to the Countryside Code and no matter how good you think your dogs recall is your dog shouldn't need recalling on someone else's property in the first place.

If any of you are using open access land to exercise your dogs please remember that at this time of year they need to be on a lead and on footpaths at all times to protect groundnesting birds. It's the law.

MzHz · 18/04/2021 00:07

We only ever walk on the footpaths round here and have maps etc, many people don’t do their research or follow the signs

MzHz · 18/04/2021 00:06

Think lockdown has made it worse! We had people running fucking laps round the enormous field but including right by the fence at the bottom of our garden, so intrusive!

We had one women and her dc on a sodding pony lunging it in the field next to us when they have their own sodding field, dog free range, running into our drive, not a thought to how annoying that would be

Thinking foot paths are bridleways and not getting why the locals don’t like the footpaths being churned up.

Let’s hope when people have to get back to work, it’ll go back to how it was

There are huge amounts of footpaths around and there is no need to walk around fields that don’t belong to you

LakieLady · 17/04/2021 23:34

I would if it was a right of way or access land.

There's a lot of access land near where I live, and the farmers bloody hate it. One of them got one field de-designated, and tried to do the same with several more, but didn't succeed.

Teddyandsuzie · 17/04/2021 23:32

YANBU. There are plenty of rights of way for people to use.

That said, I walk my dog off lead on designated footpaths paths (where there is clearly no livestock) as her recall is excellent. The footpaths are so narrow that to walk (even on a short fixed lead) next to me she is on the crops anyway, it makes little difference if she’s running around.

anonynonynon · 17/04/2021 23:15

A lot of farmers might be Tories (subsidies being the main reason I think) but they certainly aren't rich. It's a stressful and very hard job and just isn't appreciated. There's a high rate of suicides among farmers. Like a previous poster said, there's a few farming businesses doing well but the vast majority of farmers live from year to year, just about clinging on and a lot of them have second jobs.

The disrespect farmers get is baffling to me.

Heyha · 17/04/2021 22:57

I don't think the majority of people realise that grass is a crop just as much as any cereals, either.

Waitwhat23 · 17/04/2021 22:53

I used to work for a governmental body which was reclaiming subsidies from farmers as a result of the foot and mouth crisis. From what I saw, there are some large farming companies who do make money but the vast majority of ordinary farmers really don't and live from year to year, hoping that there isn't a crisis (whether disease, weather/climate related or similar). The crops grown in their fields or the animals kept there are their livelihoods and it beggars belief that people would justify destroying crops or allowing the opportunity for their dogs to worry sheep or other livestock because they believe that the farmer is a 'rich tory'.

minniemomo · 17/04/2021 22:52

I've walked around the edge of fields which aren't strictly rights of way in areas I know well, you tend to know the places locally it's ok

hotpatooties1 · 17/04/2021 22:49

Farmers aren't generally rich tories who just so happen to own a few fields..

Those fields are our business and income, they aren't abandoned bits of land. They are ploughed, sewn, sprayed, fertilised, harvested etc. A lot of work goes into it.. it's not like I'm sat in a mansion house surrounded by fields that I don't use but just so happen to own and I'm unhappy because people are walking on them just for the sake of it.

OP posts:
MsAwesomeDragon · 17/04/2021 22:49

I would go across a field if there was a public footpath across it. I wouldn't let a dog off lead in a farmer's field, as they may worry the livestock or trample the crops depending which sort of field it is. I'd stick to the footpath and cross as quickly as I could.

My friend is a farmer and she had an argument with a very entitled woman recently. Apparently this woman uses the field to train her dog in, and my friend had no business telling her to leave. The fact the field belongs to my friend and there is no footpath going through it made no difference. Neither did the sheep and lambs who are now living in that field. My friend had to threaten to call the police before the woman finally left.

booksandnooks · 17/04/2021 22:42

@PangolinPenguin

I do it sometimes. I wouldn’t go in a field if there were animals or crops other than grass or if I had to climb over a gate to get in. But sometimes I let my dog run away from the path if Theres a path going through the field and sometimes take shortcuts around edges of fields or through tractor tracks. I don’t feel bad about it tbh. I doubt it causes noticeable damage and I don’t leave litter or poo. I can’t exercise my dog around other dogs so need quiet places. I think the comparisons to gardens are ridiculous. Gardens are smaller and right by someone’s house. The field owner isn’t anywhere near 99% of the time so why not enjoy the countryside even if it annoys the rich Tory who happens to own some of the fields.
I think you'll find people tend to do it precisely BECAUSE of that last point.
hotpatooties1 · 17/04/2021 22:41

@booksandnooks your post wasn't really anything to do with the OP, it was more to do with generalising about people from the countryside v city..

OP posts:
hotpatooties1 · 17/04/2021 22:39

The field owner isn’t anywhere near 99% of the time so why not enjoy the countryside even if it annoys the rich Tory who happens to own some of the fields.

Are you saying that all farmers are rich tories? We are the field owners, we live right next to our fields, I can see the dogs and people playing in them from my house 🤦🏼‍♀️ if you or anyone else need somewhere to exercise a dog in open space that can't be around others then go to a dog park.

OP posts:
Figgygal · 17/04/2021 22:33

No I will cross using public footpaths but even then sometimes I’m paranoid about being perceived to have strayed off the path

PangolinPenguin · 17/04/2021 22:31

I do it sometimes. I wouldn’t go in a field if there were animals or crops other than grass or if I had to climb over a gate to get in. But sometimes I let my dog run away from the path if Theres a path going through the field and sometimes take shortcuts around edges of fields or through tractor tracks. I don’t feel bad about it tbh. I doubt it causes noticeable damage and I don’t leave litter or poo. I can’t exercise my dog around other dogs so need quiet places. I think the comparisons to gardens are ridiculous. Gardens are smaller and right by someone’s house. The field owner isn’t anywhere near 99% of the time so why not enjoy the countryside even if it annoys the rich Tory who happens to own some of the fields.

LockdownCheeseToastie · 17/04/2021 22:29

We’re on the edge of a small town with lots of privately owned land very close. Have seen local land referred to as ‘the dog walking field’ etc on the local Facebook. Even local friends who are very aware don’t realise that all the land is private property. Annoying when it ends up covered in litter, nitrous oxide cylinders, dog poo bags, bike ramps (built by the tresspassers), “wild campers” mess etc. Honestly don’t think most people realise that it’s private farm land and not a public park.

Saz12 · 17/04/2021 22:17

Right to roam is not as clear cut as some would make out. I’m hugely in favour of it BUT some people utterly take the piss and ruin things for everyone else. It’s all well and good to talk about the iniquities of the past, but the notion that people, several generations later, shouldn’t really own what they’ve bought is a leap: I’m not including common grazings & areas / activities where the Crofting Act applies, I just mean the notion that because “it’s rural” anyone and everyone can do whatever they want whenever they want as often as they want. It’s not the majority of quiet, normal people who want to visit wild places, it’s the total fuckwits who think they should have rights over land worked by others.

In Scotland cultivated ground (including gardens) is excluded. Which sounds sensible, but surprisingly few people respect that.
Then you have numpties who think “wild camping” means pitching a tent at midday within a few metres of their car and staying for the weekend, even if it’s close beside someone’s house, spending every evening getting pissed and swearing whilst the kids wake up and need rescued from the loch whilst parents sleep off the hangover.

Then what counts as “cultivated”? Farmland... including hill sheep? Managed grouse moors? Forestry? Deer stalking? How much “garden” is allowed - is it square metres or acres?

booksandnooks · 17/04/2021 22:16

Your dog is as welcome in our pubs as ours are on your field

I was joking but now I think you're a tosser

TrainspottingWelsh · 17/04/2021 22:02

Yanbu, but then again I'm obviously a selfish toffee nosed horsey bitch because I seem to think my horses and land aren't a public commodity for people to do as they please with. I'm also only arsed about my neighbours land and livestock because apparently I want it clear for that well known summer pastime, common to all rural dwellers and horse owners, of fox hunting through cows and calves.

It's not really a rural vs urban issue, more decent human being vs entitled twat one