Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you walk across someone else's fields?

268 replies

hotpatooties1 · 17/04/2021 11:45

Just that really. I've been surprised since moving to a farm just how many people are willing to walk across other peoples land and allow their dogs to run all over it too. Some of the fields have just been sewn and are sprayed with fertiliser regularly..they don't seem to care.

I wouldn't do it, was brought up on and around farms and was told not to walk over other peoples land. I understand the right to roam and that lawfully, they are doing nothing wrong. It just doesn't seem right.

This morning I drove past one of our fields that is gated. A woman had gone into it with her dog, let it off lead and had a kid on a bike in it..AIBU? Would you do that?

OP posts:
ConsuelaHammock · 18/04/2021 17:11

Sunflowers - I wasn’t specifically referring to you as being furloughed but I imagine the number of people walking on actual ROW and those just walking wherever they please has increased hugely during lockdown. It might be the law but that doesn’t mean the farmers will comply. As you have noticed yourself . Who’s going to make them?
I am so thankful that we don’t have an issue with walkers on our land. I’d follow them home and let my dogs shit in their garden!

Ravenclawsome · 18/04/2021 17:07

We have a fair few rights of way through fields round our way.
For other fields I would use the buffer strip round the edge of I needed to go through an agricultural field but would absolutely avoid livestock fields.

1Morewineplease · 18/04/2021 17:01

I'm amazed at people who, without knowing whether a field is private land , or not, think that , just because the field has just grass in it that it's ok to walk through it with their dogs.

Often, fields of grass are to make hay from and dog poo contaminates it. It shouldn't even be trampled on.

SofiaMichelle · 18/04/2021 16:49

@PangolinPenguin

I do it sometimes. I wouldn’t go in a field if there were animals or crops other than grass or if I had to climb over a gate to get in. But sometimes I let my dog run away from the path if Theres a path going through the field and sometimes take shortcuts around edges of fields or through tractor tracks. I don’t feel bad about it tbh. I doubt it causes noticeable damage and I don’t leave litter or poo. I can’t exercise my dog around other dogs so need quiet places. I think the comparisons to gardens are ridiculous. Gardens are smaller and right by someone’s house. The field owner isn’t anywhere near 99% of the time so why not enjoy the countryside even if it annoys the rich Tory who happens to own some of the fields.
Well what a delight you are! It's not your property. If there is a footpath then you, and your dog, must stay on it.

If you 'need quiet places' to exercise your dog, you'll have to buy your own.

I've lived out in the sticks all my life and am constantly appalled by dog owners' selfishness. There are fields all around our house and the one at the front has a very clearly signed public footpath between 2 stiles. Without a word of exaggeration, at least 90% of dog owners who go into the field let their dogs off the lead and they immediately run around well off the path. There are currently cows and young calves in there, too..

Angry
sunflowersandbuttercups · 18/04/2021 16:37

[quote hotpatooties1]@sunflowersandbuttercups but it isn't up to me to make things easier for you! If you are coming to the countryside to enjoy it then do your research and find out where you can and can't go first.

I don't know how it could be more clear that the fields have been sewn or the grass fields are off limits unless I was to actually stand at the side of them telling people. There are gates and fences, tractor lines, often a big fuck off sprayer about 20 metres wide going up and down the field..[/quote]
I'm referring to fields with rights of way through them, not ones that are off-limits.

The law says that landowners have an obligation to keep public pathways clear and useable, though. So, if you have those running through your land, it kind of is up to you.

I mean, I found out where I could go, but the routes were impassable, and that shouldn't be happening in the first place.

hotpatooties1 · 18/04/2021 16:34

@sunflowersandbuttercups but it isn't up to me to make things easier for you! If you are coming to the countryside to enjoy it then do your research and find out where you can and can't go first.

I don't know how it could be more clear that the fields have been sewn or the grass fields are off limits unless I was to actually stand at the side of them telling people. There are gates and fences, tractor lines, often a big fuck off sprayer about 20 metres wide going up and down the field..

OP posts:
sunflowersandbuttercups · 18/04/2021 16:32

@ConsuelaHammock

Sunflowers- the majority of farmers have better things to do that make signposts for furloughed walkers.
What has furlough got to do with anything? Hmm I've never been furloughed once, btw.

But anyway, your odd assumptions aside, farmers have a duty to keep them clear (in England, anyway, Scotland is different):

www.fwi.co.uk/business/compliance/farming-near-footpaths-the-law-for-arable-farmers

Farmers or landowners are required to keep rights of way open and useable; this includes providing and maintaining stiles and gates and making sure they are safe and easy to use.

Cut vegetation that could obstruct the route (at least 3m is required for bridleways and 1.5m for footpaths unless they are crossing a field – see below).

Paths that run on the field edge must not be cultivated and cross-field paths must be reinstated correctly after field operations

Landowners must meet all their legal obligations regarding maintenance of public rights of way to claim Basic Payment Scheme (BPS) payments under cross-compliance.

So, it really doesn't matter that they have "better things to do". It's the law.

Cherrysoup · 18/04/2021 16:16

I’d be very cross and tempted to put a bull in there. We have had huge issues with ‘randomers’’ coming onto the yard since covid started, wanting to feed/stroke the horses. Just no! You want to stroke a horse, go buy your own! I’ve just spent a grand on my sick horse, I don’t want someone feeding him and making him sick again!

I asked someone to leave yesterday who had wandered in past multiple private/do not touch the horses signs and was going up to all the horses. We have strangles currently so nobody bar the owner should be touching the horses. Drives me nuts. Horses die from strangles.

PS: not a rich Tory but a broke school teacher.

ConsuelaHammock · 18/04/2021 16:15

Sunflowers- the majority of farmers have better things to do that make signposts for furloughed walkers.

Macncheeseballs · 18/04/2021 16:11

Absolutely, there is no way I want to be walking across a hostile land owners field if I don't have too

sunflowersandbuttercups · 18/04/2021 16:07

@Macncheeseballs

Sometimes public walk signposting is not very clear
I do think this is a big part of the issue. Also, lots of public footpaths are signposted but totally blocked by brambles and undergrowth. I went out with my dog yesterday - lots of well-signposted farm tracks until suddenly...they stopped.

There was a signpost through a field that was just a lumpy, boggy mess. No path to follow, no way you could just walk around the edges as they were covered in brambles, and no clear exit on the other side. We got about halfway across and I was forced to give up and turn back.

We tried another one. This one was well-signposted but there were two gates at the end of the field - and no signpost. So it wasn't at all obvious which one to take and I didn't want to piss off a farmer by going through the "wrong" field. So again, we turned back.

Clear signing and clear paths would make it all a LOT easier.

Macncheeseballs · 18/04/2021 15:58

Sometimes public walk signposting is not very clear

ConsuelaHammock · 18/04/2021 15:56

Thankfully I live in a part of the U.K. with some of the most Draconian laws with regards to rights of way. No one dares walk across someone else’s land.
Follow her home the next time and let your dog loose in her garden? Take your children and their bicycles and scooters too. I would be livid if anyone thought they could take their dog onto our land. People really are entitled dicks!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 18/04/2021 15:42

Also, since lockdown the walkers on my narrow lane appear to think they have automatic right of way. They walk three abreast, right across the middle of it, where in places there is barely room for two vehicles to pass. The speed limit on this road is 60 mph and it's on a steep hill so not always possible to see walkers ahead. They have no idea how vulnerable they are making themselves.

I'm betting some of those walk uninvited over the farmland.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 18/04/2021 15:38

No. There's a farm on my lane I'd love to take walks over, there's what looks like a path there with beautiful views. The signs say 'private property'. I respect that.

RobertaSloth · 18/04/2021 15:20

If you tried that in my fields, I would set my working dog on you. Or my unpredictable longhorn bull.

So much weird fake bravado from landowners here. ‘Setting a dog’ on someone is a criminal offence (unlike walking through someone else’s field) so let’s not pretend this is something you would actually do when the reality is you would probably stew crossly about it and then write a post on mumsnet instead.

80sMum · 18/04/2021 14:58

One wanker walked through a field bashing the crops down with a stick yelling that the middle of the field was a public footpath and the crops were in the way

But if there actually is a public right of way through the middle of the field, then the landowner is supposed to ensure that the right of way is not obscured by planted crops.

I've walked through the middles of countless crop fields where there is a right of way - and in almost all of them, the farmer has made a clear and obvious space through the field, indicating the route of the RoW.

If people walk around the edge of the field when the RoW is through the middle, then technically they are trespassing, as they only have a right to walk through the middle, not around the edge.

Crustybreadandbutter · 18/04/2021 14:43

No, generally I wouldn’t.

Once or twice I have got lost running and cut across to get back. I’d never bring a dog off lead! That’s terrible!

sipsmith1 · 18/04/2021 14:40

It’s such a shame people are so uneducated about it all. I watch people’s dogs chasing roosting birds out of hedgerows and trample field margins that are specifically grown as habitats for grey partridges or yellowhammers. It’s just ignorant.

nickymanchester · 18/04/2021 13:21

@LakieLady

The footpath, designated "Framfield 7", became quite famous and you could buy t-shirts with the slogan "Free the Framfield 7". The legal action cost the council 10s of thousands. The "palace" he was building on the land the path runs through is now an unfinished ruin. Security guards patrol the estate, and I have no idea if it's possible to walk the Framfield 7 without being accosted by them.

Your post prompted me to have a look and it is indeed a really interesting story.

Although, one little point, it's actually Framfield 9.

campaignerkate.wordpress.com/the-framfield-footpath-story/

Above is the story from the woman that took this all the way to the Court of Appeal (actually the Appeal judgment is a very interesting read and very relevant if anybody is in a similar situation). It's a really interesting story.

I have no idea if it's possible to walk the Framfield 7 without being accosted by them.

You can actually go out and specifically walk "Framfield 9". This website gives some more history and also the route to follow:-

odddaysout.co.uk/framfieldnine

MzHz · 18/04/2021 12:41

@LakieLady

I agree that the countryside code needs to be better publicised. I think if I was a farmer, I'd put laminated copies on every gate and stile.

When I was a child (1960s), there were short public information films about it (along with Keeping Britain Tidy, not blowing yourself up with fireworks etc) broadcast between programmes on tv. We need to reintroduce that imo.

I remember the he public service announcements

It’s more relevant now than ever before

Dog ownership has increased, there are more people walking than ever before, more cycling, more mountain biking and we all have to know what we can and can’t do.

MaxNormal · 18/04/2021 11:09

The field owner isn’t anywhere near 99% of the time so why not enjoy the countryside even if it annoys the rich Tory who happens to own some of the fields

Farming is a backbreakingly hard job with very slim margins. Its an industry people leave in droves every year.

Since you presumably enjoy being able to purchase and consume food you should probably think this one through a bit.

Onairjunkie · 18/04/2021 11:05

@PangolinPenguin

I do it sometimes. I wouldn’t go in a field if there were animals or crops other than grass or if I had to climb over a gate to get in. But sometimes I let my dog run away from the path if Theres a path going through the field and sometimes take shortcuts around edges of fields or through tractor tracks. I don’t feel bad about it tbh. I doubt it causes noticeable damage and I don’t leave litter or poo. I can’t exercise my dog around other dogs so need quiet places. I think the comparisons to gardens are ridiculous. Gardens are smaller and right by someone’s house. The field owner isn’t anywhere near 99% of the time so why not enjoy the countryside even if it annoys the rich Tory who happens to own some of the fields.
If you tried that in my fields, I would set my working dog on you. Or my unpredictable longhorn bull.

You’re a moron. 🙄

FindingMeno · 18/04/2021 08:36

People shouldn't go on cultivated land, leave gates open or leave litter, and I've seen way too much of this.
As for an open grassy area, I can understand it doesn't cross some people's minds that it's owned, and I wonder if signage may be the solution, even wondering if there should even be some duty of care to display warning signs if there is active chemical treatment on the land.

Bluntness100 · 18/04/2021 08:29

we border a field and the owners are fine for us to cross it. they even put a gate in at their own expense so we could walk the dog there and just bo through our garden, and not have to climb the fence, as they were redoing the fencing anyway and my husband walked the dog there, so they decided to make it easier for him. Which was lovely of them.