Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you walk across someone else's fields?

268 replies

hotpatooties1 · 17/04/2021 11:45

Just that really. I've been surprised since moving to a farm just how many people are willing to walk across other peoples land and allow their dogs to run all over it too. Some of the fields have just been sewn and are sprayed with fertiliser regularly..they don't seem to care.

I wouldn't do it, was brought up on and around farms and was told not to walk over other peoples land. I understand the right to roam and that lawfully, they are doing nothing wrong. It just doesn't seem right.

This morning I drove past one of our fields that is gated. A woman had gone into it with her dog, let it off lead and had a kid on a bike in it..AIBU? Would you do that?

OP posts:
OhGiveUp · 30/07/2021 13:05

Well, where else am I going to eat my flake OP?

Joking btw before you set a mad cow on me 🙂

Onairjunkie · 30/07/2021 13:04

@davidstuart

indeed the land owners do it on purpose, if they had their way wed all be caged in our own gardens if we have one and the only walks would be if you owned your own estate
What are you talking about? You’ve left lots of very angry posts to no one in particular on a relatively old thread.

The farmer you mentioned just sounds like a cunt. Not all farmers are desperate to shoot people’s dogs dead. My land is forever invaded by families with dogs, children, and god knows who else. My gates are left open, my crops trampled, my animals worried, and I have yet to shoot anyone or anything dead. Not only that, there are no rights of way across my land that I have to honour.

Some people are just twats, be they farmers or civvies. If people were educated in respecting the countryside, we wouldn’t have these problems.

LuxOlente · 30/07/2021 12:59

A lot of people simply don't have a clue. They never go to the country and have never heard of the country code. They see grass - 'it's a free country'.

You'll need a big sign explaining about pesticides or weed killers. You have to convince them it's a risk. Tell them you've sown crops and they won't care, they'll still let their dog shit on it, but tell them your field will give them cancer and kill the dog, they might pay attention.

BarkingUpTheWrongRoseBush · 30/07/2021 12:45

Right to Roam is a bit of a misnomer - you can't just go anywhere...

^People in Scotland enjoy what is colloquially known as the "right to roam" but this is a misnomer.

It is set out in Section 1 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 that in Scotland everyone has the right to be on land for recreational purposes and to cross land for such purposes. However, as with any ‘right’, there are limitations and restrictions.

The so called “right to roam” must be exercised reasonably and helpfully, very good guidance is provided in the expertly drafted Scottish Outdoor Access Code. This Code highlights that the right needs to be exercised responsibly. The law also sets boundaries on the extent of the right so that the benefits of private ownership are still respected. Thus, for example, the “right to roam” will not extend to include land that is adjacent to dwelling houses, farm buildings, compounds, schools, and the like."

But no, I wouldn't walk through a field unless it had a footpath over it. I'm also paranoid about cows so am really careful about even ones with footpaths on ....

TheGenealogist · 30/07/2021 12:41

In Scotland so we have right to roam.

But common courtesy (and common sense) means you don't walk through a field with either crops or livestock.

ShortBacknSides · 30/07/2021 12:40

There were no other options than to walk on the road with fast traffic inches away from me. I dont know whose responsibility it is to maintain the footpaths but i felt I was in danger because i didnt have safe access to a path around the farm land.

It's not the farmer's responsibility to enable you to go for a leisure walk.

Paths were rights of way for people to get from one place to another before cars were invented.

ShortBacknSides · 30/07/2021 12:38

Also, lots of public footpaths are signposted but totally blocked by brambles and undergrowth. I went out with my dog yesterday - lots of well-signposted farm tracks until suddenly...they stopped.

There was a signpost through a field that was just a lumpy, boggy mess. No path to follow, no way you could just walk around the edges as they were covered in brambles, and no clear exit on the other side. We got about halfway across and I was forced to give up and turn back.

Public rights of way are historic footpaths, developed over years of use, generally a long time ago when most people's main form of transport was walking. They were about utility - use.

If they are blocked by undergrowth, this might suggest that that particular path is no longer used & so no longer needed as a right of way.

Public footpaths & rights of way aren't therefor leisure purposes. If a field's boggy, it's boggy. There's no compunction on the owner to drain it so you can have a leisure walk.

davidstuart · 30/07/2021 11:37

indeed the land owners do it on purpose, if they had their way wed all be caged in our own gardens if we have one and the only walks would be if you owned your own estate

Rocket1982 · 30/07/2021 07:22

Well I wouldn't normally do this but actually yesterday I dropped my daughter at a scout hut for a holiday club. It was on a road with fast traffic and no pavement, not even a tiny verge. It was 2 lanes with hedges right next to the road on both sides. The bus dropped us near the scout hut but even going 20m to get to it was scary! I had to go somewhere to wait for my daughter and followed a sign for a public footpath on to farm land. I saw one further very non-obvious sign on the land but it was not clear where the footpath went. After 45 mins I was lost and had to go back out the same gate. There were no other options than to walk on the road with fast traffic inches away from me. I dont know whose responsibility it is to maintain the footpaths but i felt I was in danger because i didnt have safe access to a path around the farm land.

MayorGundersonsDogRufus · 30/07/2021 07:08

I dunno OP. I mean, you're not wrong, but this is a small country and I wouldn't begrudge people a bit of space to exercise or escape from things, as long as they're not doing any damage.

ShortBacknSides · 30/07/2021 07:05

I admit to wandering a up to a few metres in from the fence to avoid mud and poo, dog on short lead. If it was anything but grass absolutely no way, would never go into a field that wasn't a public footpath

YABU to do this. It contributes to further erosion of the turf and grassland.

The only place where you’re ASKED to do this is on Dartmoor and that’s a different case.

Thursa · 30/07/2021 04:20

I was brought up in the country and I would not cross someone else’s land.

Ozanj · 30/07/2021 04:10

[quote hotpatooties1]@sunflowersandbuttercups but it isn't up to me to make things easier for you! If you are coming to the countryside to enjoy it then do your research and find out where you can and can't go first.

I don't know how it could be more clear that the fields have been sewn or the grass fields are off limits unless I was to actually stand at the side of them telling people. There are gates and fences, tractor lines, often a big fuck off sprayer about 20 metres wide going up and down the field..[/quote]
We have local fields like this & to put tresspassers off farmers have started putting up big prominent signs saying the fertiliser used is toxic to children and dogs. Yry that?

davidstuart · 30/07/2021 02:39

wow thats pathetic was wondering the other day why they dont have posters and tv campaigns

davidstuart · 30/07/2021 02:35

rubbish, I pick up my dog poo others dog poo and rubbish but farmers here in the Brecon Beecons take down signs, hide footpaths, put up styles instead of gates to make it hard for us dog walkers, if the two sides dont work together it will be war, we need food but farmers also need customers and those customers cant all buy a few thousand acres to go for a walk

HappyDays40 · 30/07/2021 02:34

I would walk over a path but keep the dog on a lead and close gates every time.

davidstuart · 30/07/2021 02:28

And farmers need to learn PR skills as well if you think land should only be for farming and anyone that wants a walk what do you suggest we do walk round out gardens or on a pavement, land was actually made millions of years ago and once owned by no one except dinosaurs

davidstuart · 30/07/2021 02:24

If you own land you know their is a right of way, are you suggesting that all rights of way be withdrawn im sure landlowners would love that but as a dog owner I wouldnt, farmers do not maintain signs and in fact take them down, put up styles instead of gates so dog walkers cant use them, neither do they maintain fences and are trigger happy to get the chance to shoot a dog and the law always backs them up when in one case the dog had run away when he hit an electric fence, the owner ran to get her little springer back, when she got to the field it was running back to her, no animals harmed and the evil farmer shot the dog dead evil w*nker , land owners and dog owner hate each other

Profiterolegirl · 19/04/2021 21:47

No, I love rurally and walk my dog in the country every day. We never walk on other people's fields.

StoneofDestiny · 19/04/2021 21:42

In Scotland yes, mindful of the requirement to not harms crops etc. In England, no - unless there was a public footpath.

MzHz · 19/04/2021 21:31

[quote LeopardSheet]@MzHz
you’re not allowed to have aggressive dogs running around endangering people on your property. At the very least you need a sign warning of guard dogs at every entrance to the property (including areas that aren’t official entrances but places where trespassers could access). This wouldn’t reduce your liability if your dog threatened or attacked someone though. The fact that your dogs are ‘trained’ to behave aggressively would not be looked on favourably at all by a judge if there was an incident and would increase your liability as you wouldn’t have the defence that the dog was acting out of character. This could mean you would be charged with assault not just having a dangerously out of control dog.
www.inbrief.co.uk/animal-law/guard-dogs-and-the-law/

I’m amazed that someone would keep a potentially dangerous animal on their property and not familiarise themselves with the laws surrounding dog ownership and their responsibilities (and then come on a forum and call other people morons).[/quote]
I don’t actually HAVE any pets

I was just asking about guard dogs

Who said morons? Nowt to do with me... Hmm

DenisetheMenace · 19/04/2021 21:05

Being a moron/admitting to occasionally walking round the edge of a field is a lot better than sending messages threatening to personally harm strangers on the internet. I’m sure that’s a lot more illegal than trespassing? You should be careful what you say.“

You should. I was ticked off and had posts deleted twice for calling someone in the public eye a m...n” Not sure why you haven’t been. Maybe they just don’t like me 🥺

(Tells herself, just because you’re paranoid, doesn’t mean they’re not watching you ..... Grin)

derxa · 19/04/2021 13:08

I think it takes common sense A quality sadly lacking in the people who walk their dogs near my sheep.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 19/04/2021 13:02

I’m amazed that someone would keep a potentially dangerous animal on their property and not familiarise themselves with the laws surrounding dog ownership and their responsibilities (and then come on a forum and call other people morons).

Sadly lots of people are oblivious to the law surrounding dogs in this country.

Lots of people also allow their dogs to growl, snarl and aggressively guard their homes and gardens, and don't realise it could get them into trouble.

People think if the dog doesn't bite, it's not dangerous, and that's not the case at all.

LeopardSheet · 19/04/2021 12:55

@ConsuelaHammock thanks that’s interesting. People absolutely shouldn’t walk on wheat and other crops. It does seem that the main problem is the massive increase in walkers due to lockdown. I’m not sure that this is anyone’s fault and hopefully there will be less damage to crops near paths when there are fewer walkers again. I’m lucky that I walk where there are very few people even in lockdown. In areas where there are few walkers I still think it can’t be much of an issue if once or twice a week someone skirts round a field or through a tire track as long as no poo or litter is left and no gates are opened. I can appreciate that if lots of people do it it could cause damage so I see why people get annoyed. I think it takes common sense on both sides-you should avoid going on people’s property and absolutely shouldn’t cause damage and should leave if asked but equally if someone does walk across your property you shouldn’t threaten them, especially if no damage is done.