Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Driving accident

61 replies

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 11:25

Probably a little outing but my DSis had an accident that wasn’t her fault. Car speeding and not paying attention went into the side of her at an island from the left. Car flipped a few times and she was very lucky to come out basically unharmed.

Police on scene breathalysed the other driver etc.

Will she get charged with anything? I’d like to think so. This was on a quiet street, literally outside a nursery.

OP posts:
raeroe · 16/04/2021 13:03

A family member died as a result of an accident and 3 other passengers severely injured. The driver of the other vehicle came into their lane and was completely at fault didn't even lose their licence so I wouldn't get your sister to hold her breath! Glad she is ok, that must have been terrifying for her.

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 13:02

@Aprilx - Hmm clearly apologised and said that it was my fault for the confusion, but thank you for your input.

OP posts:
DeclineandFall · 16/04/2021 13:00

I'd hope the other woman would be charged. She hits another car on a mini roundabout so hard the other car ends up flips a few times. In an urban area as well. That's atrocious driving.

Urban mini roundabouts are accident blackspots in our area. People going straight on never seem to adjust their speed when coming up to them, they just fly straight through at speed.

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 12:59

@Lou98 thank you that’s really helpful. And to all the other replies that can understand my rambling thank you all too.

Seems such a shame that you have to severely injure/ kill someone before your bad driving will get you out on a course/ points or conviction.

This could well be a one off and she could be a good driver usually, that and I’m obviously biased as it’s my little sister but it just seems surreal to me that you can put someone in so much danger and the worst that happens is your insurance might go up!

OP posts:
Aprilx · 16/04/2021 12:59

[quote LetsGoChamp]@slashlover sorry I meant the other driver. They’re both ‘she’ so it’s my own fault for causing the confusion. I’ll call the other driver Mary from now on 😂[/quote]
You don’t need to call anyone Mary, but if you had referred to your sister as “my sister” and the other driver as “the other driver” instead of calling them both “she” from the start and not differentiating in any way, then your post and subsequent posts might have made a hell of a lot more sense. 🙄

murbblurb · 16/04/2021 12:57

Omg - lucky escape for your sister who seems absolutely the innocent party. Hopefully the book will be thrown, but drivers as bad as this other woman usually don't trouble themselves with insurance etc. Still, that might add to the evidence.

LadyJaye · 16/04/2021 12:57

@TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross

I'm amazed at the posters who seem quite relaxed about the other driver's part in this. How fast do you have to be going to actually hit a car hard enough to barrel-roll it?! It must have been terrifying.
Bizarrely, not as fast as you'd think: if you clip the other vehicle at the right angle, physics does the rest for you.
LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 12:55

@slashlover sorry I meant the other driver. They’re both ‘she’ so it’s my own fault for causing the confusion. I’ll call the other driver Mary from now on 😂

OP posts:
LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 12:53

Sorry for any confusion in my OP. Yes it was the other driver coming from the left (I knew I should of drawn a picture for it)!

Sister checked before pulling off and said the car was far enough away when she was pulling off, she obviously didn’t realise the car was going so fast it’s a 20mph road I think (might be 30mph).

She must of been speeding and not paying attention in my eyes as someone who is aware of the road. You can’t normally even go 20mph coming from the left as there are parked cars along the road and you have to let some out to get though and a zebra crossing and small junction before the mini roundabout. So to hit a car with so much speed it rolls 2 times and then land on its roof is surely too bloody fast!

OP posts:
Darkstar4855 · 16/04/2021 12:52

@slashlover OP means will the other driver be charged.

Lou98 · 16/04/2021 12:51

From my experience working in motor claims where there were no injuries and no alcohol etc involved, it was usually left with insurance to deal with.

The car shouldn't have been speeding but it's incredibly hard to prove speeding unless she's went through a speed camera or similar. There may be witnesses but the fact is all they can say is it "looks" like she was speeding, none of them will know exactly what speed she was doing as it would be impossible for them to be able to see her speedometer. This is why these cases often go uncharged as if it was to go to court and the driver claimed they were within the speed limit, there's no evidence to say otherwise. There are of course exceptions but the majority of the time this is the case. Not saying it's right but I seen it time and time again.

slashlover · 16/04/2021 12:48

@LetsGoChamp

We know she is at fault as she is coming from the left. I just wondered the likelihood of her being charged with anything for driving so carelessly. DSIS is only young really and sometimes has my DS in the car right where it hit so I think she is thinking ‘what if’ so would like to see something done but doesn’t want to chase police incase they’re busy.

Yes sorry for confusing anyone, it is a mini roundabout. Locals call it the ‘shop’ island and I didn’t think to change it.

Thanks for all the replies so far!

How was your sister driving carelessly? She wasn't speeding and looks like she was pulling off of the mini roundabout.
KatherineOfGaunt · 16/04/2021 12:42

Ah, I understand now. In your OP you ask if "she" will be charged, then you say "she" came from the left so is at fault. I think people (me included) assumed the she was your sister, but you mean the driver of the other car.

Yes, it may be that the other driver will be charged with dangerous driving if police can prove they were speeding (witness accounts, why/how your sister'scar flipped over etc).

WiddlinDiddlin · 16/04/2021 12:38

They will deal with the driver appropriately - you can ring and ask but whether you or your DS will find out all the finer details I don't know.

We were in a similar accident years ago, the driver of the car that hit us slammed into the passenger side door where I was sitting. We stopped, I got out to talk to her... and..... she disappeared off into the distance, front end of her car crumpled, metal hanging off it..... never to be seen again.

Be thankful the driver of the car in this case didn't just do a runner!

Jessbow · 16/04/2021 12:37

I doubt you car was at fault, unless they changed course at the last minute.

The only thing I wouldnt assume, is the other car was speeding- It could be said, whatever the rights of way, he shouldn't have crossed the path of a speeding car.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 16/04/2021 12:35

I'm amazed at the posters who seem quite relaxed about the other driver's part in this. How fast do you have to be going to actually hit a car hard enough to barrel-roll it?! It must have been terrifying.

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 12:22

Thanks everyone for clarifying - I am in the Midlands @DappledThings so it’s just an island to me 🤷🏻‍♀️

The other driver was speeding, not DS.

DS had very nearly exited the island before the car hit her. So it is definitely not her fault the accident occurred.

OP posts:
murbblurb · 16/04/2021 12:12

I'm puzzled - who was speeding? To do that many barrel rolls someone was clearly driving at a stupid speed. Not an accident, the consequence of dangerous driving. Whoever was going that fast needs prosecuting and banning. Probably won't happen though, causing injury or death with a car gets lightly treated.

malmi · 16/04/2021 12:12

Islands are the pedestrian refuges that you use when you're crossing the road, so you can cross one half at a time. But for some reason lots of people call roundabouts "islands".

DappledThings · 16/04/2021 12:09

@HaveringWavering

Ah OK. That’s a mini roundabout, not an island.
All roundabouts are called islands in the Midlands
Clymene · 16/04/2021 12:07

Well she'll probably get charged with driving without due care and attention

Tibtab · 16/04/2021 12:05

But she’s not at fault if she entered the island before the other car, if they hit her on the side then she must have been?

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 12:04

@Angrypregnantlady I get what you’re saying but she absolutely could of been seriously injured as the impact was very hard. Car ended up on a pavement outside a nursery. I know it’s a lot of ‘what ifs’ but surely the fact she was speeding is what caused the impact to be so severe. You can’t really speed by accident. Lots of witnesses that say she was in fact speeding.

I’m not saying she is a criminal, it might well be a mistake but it’s a dangerous one isn’t it? She could of absolutely killed someone so surely she deserves some kind of punishment? Points, a driving course?

OP posts:
LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 12:00

We know she is at fault as she is coming from the left. I just wondered the likelihood of her being charged with anything for driving so carelessly. DSIS is only young really and sometimes has my DS in the car right where it hit so I think she is thinking ‘what if’ so would like to see something done but doesn’t want to chase police incase they’re busy.

Yes sorry for confusing anyone, it is a mini roundabout. Locals call it the ‘shop’ island and I didn’t think to change it.

Thanks for all the replies so far!

OP posts:
Angrypregnantlady · 16/04/2021 11:57

Just looks like an accident. Probably looking at oncoming traffic and expected your DS to be out of the way quicker. No one was seriously injured or driving illegally. She may get driving without due care and attention but I'd be surprised, most accidents are caused by driving without due care and attention but the police don't get involved in them all.

She made a mistake, she doesn't sound like a criminal.