Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Driving accident

61 replies

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 11:25

Probably a little outing but my DSis had an accident that wasn’t her fault. Car speeding and not paying attention went into the side of her at an island from the left. Car flipped a few times and she was very lucky to come out basically unharmed.

Police on scene breathalysed the other driver etc.

Will she get charged with anything? I’d like to think so. This was on a quiet street, literally outside a nursery.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rose19911991x · 16/07/2021 12:13

Any news on this op? I was makin my way across a yelloe box and speedinfmg driver went into me. He claims because i was in box as he hit me he, i was stationary in the box (wasn't at all) was driving through to a clear exit. Hes wrote my car off and his is fine. Insurance won't investigate speed so ill be going to a financial ombudsmen to fight it harder.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 16/04/2021 14:40

@BagORats

You might speed up on entry to a roundabout but you should be slowing on the approach - the give way lines aren't painted there for fun
Oh, I know that.

But all it takes is for someone to be going at just the wrong speed at he wrong angle for a potentially minor crash to be 10x worse.

Cloudyview · 16/04/2021 14:38

[quote LetsGoChamp]@sunflowersandbuttercups do you know why that is? She’s had to have a few days off work her side and arm have been sore but no serious injuries, thank god! Car is a write off. She was legal to drive but my DS car flipped 2/3 times she was obviously giving it some welly.

Surely if we’re not charging these drivers/ giving them points for speeding and causing accidents then next time they could seriously harm/ kill someone.[/quote]
I was in a RTA (road traffic accident) nearly 5 years ago. Totally not my fault, I was driving along a long straight road at about 50mph. Other driver didn’t stop at a “Give Way” sign and came out of a side road, hit my car on the drivers side and I was shunted straight into a telegraph pole.

Other driver was completely unharmed, whereas I had several broken ribs, concussion and exacerbated an old spinal injury. I ended up unable to return to work and having to give up my job which I loved. 😥 I am now in constant pain (on Morphine), unable to walk more than about 20m with a stick, registered disabled and been unable to work at all since!

The police officer who attended the accident did put the case through to the Procurator Fiscal (Scotland), as he thought that I was very lucky to survive the accident. However, despite this being her 3rd RTA, they decided not to charge the other driver!

In effect my life has been pretty much destroyed (had to give up sporting hobbies as well as my job) and I need assistance with so many things and her life wasn’t really impacted! You may have gathered that I do feel quite bitter about things!

BagORats · 16/04/2021 14:31

You might speed up on entry to a roundabout but you should be slowing on the approach - the give way lines aren't painted there for fun

sunflowersandbuttercups · 16/04/2021 14:21

@SarsonsWine

They must have been going very fast, I do hope they get charged.
Not necessarily - most people speed up on entry to a roundabout anyway, and like a PP said, it depends on the angle of both vehicles too.
Blindstupid · 16/04/2021 14:15

Not necessarily sarsons ... they were entering a roundabout, so probably speeding up on entry ... you only need to hit a car at the ‘wrong’ angle, in the ‘wrong’ place ... depends also on makes, models, sizes of both cars.

SarsonsWine · 16/04/2021 14:10

They must have been going very fast, I do hope they get charged.

safariboot · 16/04/2021 14:07

Oof. Hope there's no serious injuries.

Unfortunately if there aren't any serious injuries or deaths then I doubt the police will investigate much. The at fault driver will be caught if they were unlicensed or uninsured, or if their own vehicle was obviously unroadworthy eg bald tyres, or if they were wanted for anything else. (Or if they had been drunk, but they weren't.) But otherwise I doubt there will be any charges. Yes a crime probably occurred but the chance of proving it is nearly zero.

Blindstupid · 16/04/2021 14:03

Whilst it was all undoubtedly terrifying .. the insurance companies and police will deal with it accordingly. The thing I would take away from it all, is that the other driver will most probably now drive very differently in future, will have had the wake up call she needed.

As others have said, it doesn’t necessarily take speed to flip a car, just the correct angles and impact points. The driver however, will no doubt be much more aware and vigilant in future.

I’m pleased your sister is okay, she’ll probably feel very rough over the next few days, and should get herself checked over, and continue to do so if she feels worse or doesn’t improve.

Neonprint · 16/04/2021 14:03

[quote LetsGoChamp]@Aprilx - Hmm clearly apologised and said that it was my fault for the confusion, but thank you for your input.[/quote]
@Aprilx
jesus are you this rude in real life?

Neonprint · 16/04/2021 13:59

Sounds scary. Glad she's OK. Your sister is effectively a victim of a crime, therfore I'd expect the police to share what has happened to the perpetrator. Its quite important to get over something psychologically that she knows what caused the crash and what has happened to the other driver. Make sure she empasises this when she deals with the police.

Tommika · 16/04/2021 13:51

@TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross

I'm amazed at the posters who seem quite relaxed about the other driver's part in this. How fast do you have to be going to actually hit a car hard enough to barrel-roll it?! It must have been terrifying.
You don’t need to be going very fast

I hit the side of an elderly ladies car when she drove straight across a junction

My speed limit was 60mph, but I had slowed as I know that junction enough.
I don’t know what my speed was and told the police that I had slowed from 60 and would still be above 50.
They had my skid marks to do their thing and confirm that.

With the force of my full size car into the side of a small granny car hers was pushed sideways and lifted.
If it wasn’t for the opposite car waiting on the giveaway line then I’m certain that I would have flipped her car

Instead we had the front of my car totalled, a corner of the awaiting car and a giant dent in the side of the small car, with her suspended at an angle between us

In the OPs case, we can’t say that the police will prosecute but there was certainly plenty of force involved
If the car from the left just drove straight ahead with momentum assuming the car on the roundabout had cleared then they may not need to have been speeding, (looking to their right and assuming she had passed clear on the left) but if they stopped at the line and then drove then they had slammed their foot down with high acceleration - again not necessarily speeding but at low gear with a lot of force

Moondust001 · 16/04/2021 13:50

[quote LetsGoChamp]@Moondust001 is doesn’t ‘matter so much’. I asked a question about whether it was likely.

Everyone that has come to tell me the importance of my sister being okay can stop. I am aware.[/quote]
Wow, rude. You perhaps aren't aware of it - although it has been pointed out by others - but you came across as looking for vengeance. It really doesn't matter - the police will determine whether action needs to be taken. The way you posted sounded like you wanted them to. You do not know whether she was driving badly or not. There can be reasons - as I explained - why something goes wrong. Being at fault is not the same thing as driving dangerously. Perhaps you may be overly sensitive because of your past history, but that is no reason to tell people what they can and cannot say!

Bunglemom · 16/04/2021 13:49

@LetsGoChamp

Not a problem 😉

a car is a piece of metal and can be replaced, im just happy your sister is ok..

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 13:47

@Bunglemom

Thank you. I appreciate the time for your reply. It’s not the end of the world if nothing comes of it, she’s ok that’s the main thing to the family.

OP posts:
JustSleepAlready · 16/04/2021 13:45

Can’t imagine her being charged. What with? Being in the wrong place at the wrong time? Other driver is at fault. Should have yielded but didn’t.

Bunglemom · 16/04/2021 13:44

Speaking as someone with over 10 years experience in the car claims dept, you cant prove the other driver was speeding (although we can agree that they most probably were to cause the car to flip) you have no proof and with regards to her being charged that would be down to the police, and how they see fit as it would be a criminal case not a civil case which a car claim is.

picklemewalnuts · 16/04/2021 13:41

I was in an accident where the other driver hit me head on, at speed, on the wrong side of the road. She took the corner too fast. Her small car shunted my big one backwards, up the pavement, snapping the rear wheel off. She must have been doing some speed. We were both carted off to hospital, she being cut out of her car.

She went on a driver re-education course. 🤷🏼‍♀️

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 13:36

@Moondust001 is doesn’t ‘matter so much’. I asked a question about whether it was likely.

Everyone that has come to tell me the importance of my sister being okay can stop. I am aware.

OP posts:
sunflowersandbuttercups · 16/04/2021 13:36

[quote LetsGoChamp]@sunflowersandbuttercups do you know why that is? She’s had to have a few days off work her side and arm have been sore but no serious injuries, thank god! Car is a write off. She was legal to drive but my DS car flipped 2/3 times she was obviously giving it some welly.

Surely if we’re not charging these drivers/ giving them points for speeding and causing accidents then next time they could seriously harm/ kill someone.[/quote]
I'm not sure, I'm just going off my own experience. It guess could be different depending on area and whether there's any concrete evidence like CCTV or dashcam footage.

I've rang the police twice after accidents and they've never been remotely interested. The first time I was hit and the other driver didn't stop - they basically said "well, it will just be your word against theirs so there's nothing we can do even if they did stop". Hmm Luckily I didn't need to claim on my insurance.

The second time my car was written off - the police attended and both drivers were breathalysed. Again, no injuries or any witnesses (just my word against his) and nothing happened. My insurance dealt with everything and I never heard a thing from the police.

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 13:33

@Angrypregnantlady rather than get into a debate about all the things that aren’t correct and aren’t relevant in your post I’m just going to say ok and wish you a happy Friday Grin

Thank you to everyone who took the time to reply, I think we know where we stand now with it all and won’t bother chasing it down. Whilst it is a shame IMO this is the common practice, as I’ve said above, the most important thing to us is that she’s well physically and mentally, which she mostly is. We’re also glad the other driver didn’t suffer any injuries as we know too well how costly mistakes can be since losing my DB.

OP posts:
Moondust001 · 16/04/2021 13:25

Why does it matter so much? If the police think she was driving badly they'll deal with it. But your sister is OK and that's the important thing.

This happened to me years ago. The other driver was blinded by the sun and didn't see me. She was at fault, but it wasn't her fault.

Angrypregnantlady · 16/04/2021 13:19

She has hit at a perfect angle to roll the car. My BIL rolled his crashing into a gate, it just flicked him over.

She may get a fine or something for driving without due care and attention, perhaps dangerous driving if there's proof she was speeding. But it kinda seems like you want her to "pay for it".

Yes, someone could have died, but someone could die by standing in the wrong place at most accidents. No body did die, or was even properly injured.

It will have been scary for both parties involved but she misjudged your sisters speed and clipped her back end. It happens thousands of times a day. I'd just be glad everyone was OK.

LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 13:07

@raeroe - also I’m very sorry to hear about your family member and the other passengers.

OP posts:
LetsGoChamp · 16/04/2021 13:06

Thank you @raeroe

The most important thing to us all is that she is okay physically and mentally. Our DM happened to be driving past not long after and after losing our older brother in an accident when he was only young (he was a pedestrian and driver was not at fault at all) I can’t imagine the worry she too must of felt. So we are definitely more grateful that she is okay than wanting anything to come of it, it just seems so unfair that people can get away with it sometimes.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread