Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe the Mumsnet High Earners?

747 replies

LigPatin · 16/04/2021 10:49

Every time there's a thread about earnings, there's always multiple posters who claim that most people on the thread must be inflating or plain lying about their salaries.

Whilst I recognise that people lie, especially on anonymous forums, I find it quite sad that people prefer to dismiss these posts as lies rather than take inspiration/education from them (or just not care).

I come from a poor background - we never had enough money to the point that food and electricity use was rationed. We weren't on the streets, but that was a looming possibility. We lived (mostly) within the midlands.

I fell into nannying as a career (having dreamed of being a primary school teacher) and my first job was in Kensington. The housekeeper had been gossiping about the rent on the house we worked in - it was £3k a WEEK. This was 2012-ish. I remember wondering how on Earth anyone could afford paying £200k+ a year on rent alone, when - in my mind - earning just £50k was amazingly rich.

I remember walking through Kensington and Knightsbridge and Chelsea and seeing thousands and thousands and thousands of these houses, all huge and grand and all presumably commanding similar rent or sale value than the one I worked in. They were all clearly lived in and used.

Perhaps it was arrogance, or naivety, but I figured that if there were enough people who could afford to pay £1k, £2k, £5k+ a week on rent (or buy million pound houses), then there must be a lot of money out there to be earned, and I couldn't see any reason as to why I couldn't find a way to get a share of that money.

That's sort of how I feel about these earning threads - hundreds of people are posting about their high salaries and instead of scoffing that they must be sad-sacks who hang out on Mumsnet to lie about their lifestyles - I think it's inspiring and encouraging to see so many women out there making amazing money and securing their futures.

FWIW - I was 21 back in Kensington, amazed at the £3k a week rent. I'm coming up to 30 now and my average yearly income is about £120k. I remind myself every day of how lucky I am, and how 21 year old me would have been incredulous. Though I'm, of course, absolutely nowhere near being able to rent a £3k a week house Grin

OP posts:
Devlesko · 18/04/2021 23:18

@StayingHere

I believe them because threads about money attract people who want to tell everyone how much they've got. Middle and low earners aren't as excited about rushing onto the internet to disclose their average/low income.
I'll teii you about our low household income about 16k. I can tell you how we got here, how happy we are, how hard we worked to get here. Not sure people would be inspired though. Grin
Inneedoflifeadvice · 18/04/2021 23:15

@TheSilence

This thread is pretty depressing to read if you’re on long term sickness benefits and know that you’ve got no hope of ever ‘making it’, despite being ambitious, driven, motivated, hard working etc. Life seems so unfair sometimes.
I agree :)

It's not just like that for us though, most people who are well enough to work but who are all of the above (ambitious, driven, motivated, hard-working) do not earn more than £40 or £50k and people who do earn more than £70k are not more motivated, ambitious or hardworking than those earning £30k (NHS nurses, teachers etc.).

Inneedoflifeadvice · 18/04/2021 23:09

@Aleric

Totally agree sofa and it's a point I'm always making on these threads, but you put it better than me because actually believing that women earning six figures are somehow squeezed in every other area of their lives is damaging for other women and our daughters. Yes it's true that some are working very long hours (just the same as men and people of both sexes earning less than six figures) but it's just not true for all jobs.

I'm not a lawyer or doctor or any kind of "profession", i work in a bog standard industry, 100% from home for the last 5 years. I get the kids up, to school, collect them, make dinner, all that jazz. I don't work over time, i never work weekends. I am not squeezed in the slightest. I earn £175k pa. Ludicrous amount, and not something i ever thought I'd earn, particularly because I'm from a background of poverty, but it happens to be what my job pays. There are plenty of men doing equivalent to my role at the place I work and you can be sure they are also earning at least that. Neither are they "squeezed". We just log on have our meetings make some decisions log off.

What do you do?
wesowereonabreak · 18/04/2021 22:28

MrsKoala

You conveniently miss out that you loose personal allowance over £125k...

If you want to pay more tax, no one is stopping you. You can make voluntary donations, why not doing so if you think tax rates should be higher?

Or is it just easier to expect "others" to have a higher tax rate...

Alsohuman · 18/04/2021 22:25

@wesowereonabreak

complain about how unfair it is to be taxed at a higher rater.

People are always so generous with other people's money.
The day you will lose 50% of your income in tax you will change your mind. It's outrageous, and the reason why high earners don't stay on PAYE. So it's completely counter-productive anyway!

I was a higher tax payer for over a decade. It isn’t outrageous at all. It’s not as if I wasn’t left with enough money for a very nice lifestyle. My objection wasn’t to the amount of tax I paid, it was to how it was spent.
MrsKoala · 18/04/2021 22:12

People are always so generous with other people's money.
The day you will lose 50% of your income in tax you will change your mind. It's outrageous, and the reason why high earners don't stay on PAYE. So it's completely counter-productive anyway!

Higher rate tax payers are taxed 40% over £50k, then 45% over £150k. I am not personally a higher rate tax payer but H is and as a family he is the breadwinner (I earn £30k) and actually we both think tax should be higher. The idea that everyone who pays higher rate is anti tax is bollocks. I know loads who think it should be higher.

Movinghouseatlast · 18/04/2021 21:37

Among my friends we have the lowest income- around £70k between us.

Other people I know earn up to £320k a year.

gwenneh · 18/04/2021 21:33

[quote whataboutbob]@professorpootle not being purposefully dense, but if your company is worth 17m why have you had to take on massive debt to keep it going? Why not cash in some of that money that it’s worth? As you can probably tell I know nothing about running businesses.[/quote]
Valuations don't always mean liquid assets. For example, DH's company is worth £42m -- but lots of that is tied up in real estate, the website, hardware, etc.

Winecrispschocolatecats · 18/04/2021 21:13

My husband and I both earn significantly more than £100k a year. Doesn't mean we've worked harder for it (a nurse or care home worker, for example, does far more work for far less reward). Doesn't mean we're brighter than others either - I know many, many people who are just as intelligent, if not more so, who earn much less. Also doesn't mean we have a great work/life balance - my DH loves (to complain about) his job but I'm totally bored with mine and don't see a way out - it's all I'm qualified for. In both cases we fell into roles that ended up paying extremely well, with little planning or preparation. That, to my thinking, is just dumb luck and nothing to be either proud or boastful of, and is why we give a very substantial chunk of our earnings to charity every month.

Flowers24 · 18/04/2021 20:36

Wow well done you, no one cares you earn 120k!

whataboutbob · 18/04/2021 20:34

@professorpootle not being purposefully dense, but if your company is worth 17m why have you had to take on massive debt to keep it going? Why not cash in some of that money that it’s worth? As you can probably tell I know nothing about running businesses.

XingMing · 18/04/2021 16:36

If I may refine the task I set above, teachers should find a job earning as much as they do teaching....

XingMing · 18/04/2021 16:31

I congratulate LigPatin on her achievements, and her common sense and on her courage revisiting the thread she started and clarifying some points, and elaborating some answers. Good on you and delighted with your success.

But we should get down to the nitty-gritty. IME of schools, state and private (DS attended both, so I saw both sides) your average bog standard community college in most of the country (Cornwall here) needs to buck up their aspirations for most of their students. Locally, where my DH has a small manufacturing engineering company, there are three analytic laboratories (forensic, metal research and dental) and among the technical staff with degrees, not one was born locally (most are east/central European). So from that you might conclude that the local population is universally SEN... how daft is that?

There is a culture among comprehensive school teachers that they are there to nurse the failures to competence, rather than giving the majority of average students a sense of what is possible in their community. If I could design an INSET day, I would like to set them a task: write a CV this morning, and have a job offer (outside teaching) by 5.00 pm. Teachers, who have gone from school to university and teaching, back into schools have little idea of the reality of life outside the education game, hence they beguile themselves and their students with unrealistic follow your dreams cajolery, or they let them down with the idea that the best you can be is a till operator at the supermarket.

I did a PGCE (teaching secondary) after my real career, at 50, in the hope that some head would think I had something to offer, but no, they prefer easily managed and manipulated 23 year olds with endless stamina. I can see why too. Teaching is hard work.

wesowereonabreak · 18/04/2021 16:31

complain about how unfair it is to be taxed at a higher rater.

People are always so generous with other people's money.
The day you will lose 50% of your income in tax you will change your mind. It's outrageous, and the reason why high earners don't stay on PAYE. So it's completely counter-productive anyway!

MakingPlans21 · 18/04/2021 15:27

There will be a mixture of genuine high earners and pure fantasists on here. I thought I was a high earner and my partner too until I started reading some of the posts about 200k being chicken fodder in the SE

SmudgeButt · 18/04/2021 15:24

Nice to know you are thriving. What bugs me about those who do boast is that they think £100k+ is average when it's far from it. Or complain about how unfair it is to be taxed at a higher rater.

doadeer · 18/04/2021 15:10

Now charge *

doadeer · 18/04/2021 15:09

Unfortunately I worked far more hours when I was on a lower salary and starting out or "learning my trade". I know charge the same for a job that takes me two hours when years ago it would have taken me five/six hours. The reason I say unfortunately is that often how hard you work has very little to do with what you earn.
My partner works for a big company and those who have been promoted often don't work the hardest, aren't the best they just fit culturally and are confident and accomplished at self promotion. I find it quite obscene that in my industry, to be on £60k doesn't even make you very senior, there's just a lot of money to be had and as a society we don't value anyone in a supportive role. A cleaner can absolutely work her arse off... But there isn't mobility there.

Moomin12345 · 18/04/2021 13:03

Yes, I think it's a self preservation mechanism. I once watched a vlog by a school teacher who was talking about her job and was at one point quite snarky about people who claim to make over £40k per year. Confused

PegasusReturns · 18/04/2021 12:19

Honestly I think there is a degree of self preservation in the comments around high earners not having time for MN.

I think for those working 12 hour shifts with 90 min each way commutes; no help at home and juggling childcare it helps reconcile their own position by imagining that those who earn big salaries have to work horribly long hours and never see their children.

And as people keep saying it’s really important that women understand this is not necessarily true.

Mreggsworth · 18/04/2021 11:42

@TheLastLotus

I meant "the vast majority" within the already disadvantaged not the whole society. Just to clarify.

I get the OPs point, I was more speaking how it can be interpreted. The idea of working hard equalling success is a sensitive subject to many and the opening post was not overly clear in making the distint difference between what shes clarified in later posts.

greatauntfanny · 18/04/2021 11:39

@deardia

I'll tell you why I don't believe a lot of the high earners on mn. If someone is earning so much, there life and work must be very full on, busy, coming back from work and if there's children, regardless of age of the children, they would be busy with that aspect of their life. How then do they have time to come on mn so frequently. I am not a high earner, and days or even weeks will go by where I have not had a chance to come on to mn.
I'm a high earner and I spaff about on Mumsnet all the time.

As plenty of people have said, there are plenty of high paying jobs that don't require constant hard work. Case in point: mine (technology sector).

The idea that all high paying jobs are 'so hard' or 'so stressful' or have 'such long hours' is way off the mark.

When I was in my early twenties I was in a data entry role. It was long hours, stressful and tiring. I noticed that the consultants seemed to be more cheery and had more control over what they did. I got to know them. Turned out they also earned a more. I took note of what skills and attitude they had. I started to copy them. I got a grounding in the skills. I applied for a new role closer to what I wanted to do. I did it again. I kept doing it. Fast forward five years, I'm earning over £100K.

The thing that frustrates me is that I'm not particularly intelligent or hard-working. I didn't have a private education. I don't come from a wealthy background. But when I got to know some of the people I aspired to be, I realised that although some were geniuses, others just had a solid set of core skills and said the right thing at the right time. And I realised I could do that, too. The OP had a similar epiphany walking through Chelsea.

People (women especially) have an enormous tendency to underestimate themselves, what they are capable of. I'm not saying everyone can do it (or even would want to if they could), all I'm saying is a damn sight more people can than think.

It's such a shame so many people on here think it's unattainable. That attitude must surely be filtering down to your kids, to your daughters. They'll grow up 'knowing their limits,' and thinking big houses and fancy cars are for 'other people' you know, 'lucky people', 'rich people', people who 'work their lives away' and it just isn't the case.

TheLastLotus · 18/04/2021 11:22

@Thelnebriati

Some accents can be modulated but not lost, I have a marked accent even after years of toning it down. No one who can afford a nanny would want me to pass on my accent to their kids.

The myth that social mobility is based on hard work creates a culture of blaming people who don't manage to climb the ladder.

It definitely is not - but also because our schools and higher educational institutions do fuck all to prepare people for a career.
sassbott · 18/04/2021 11:21

@deardia have you actually read the posts from people who are high earners explaining why and how they have the time? I have more time now than I had 5-10 years ago.

Bluntly the reason I also post is I have experienced certain personal difficulties. I don’t talk about them in RL for two reasons.
Firstly at work I talk very little about my personal circumstances/ personal life. Secondly none of my friends in RL have been through what I have (as a female).

Just because I’m a high earner, why does that preclude me needing Mnet any more than any other poster?

TheLastLotus · 18/04/2021 11:20

@Mreggsworth

I kind of saw the OPs point to a degree, that sometimes it does take seeing what other people have to realise that there are more options out there. However, while this could apply to a portion of society, theres going to be many people where dreaming big will never be more than a dream. Therefore can be disheartening to think that societies view of them is that they just need to work a little harder.

The ones who it may potentially be unobtainable to are those who come from such poverty that they can't afford to pay their bills or buy food, in that situation doing additional costly training courses wouldn't be possible, nor would travel expenses to get to and from training facilities or potentially more lucrative job interviews that are further afield. That and if they are already working all hours under the sun to make ends meat and looking after a family, they may be too time poor that getting further qualifications just isnt possible.

There are those with significant caring responsibilities, that it wouldn't be possible to manage a professional career while you have a child, parent or close relative who has complex round the clock care needs.

Or if you yourself has health conditions or learning difficulties. Or your mental health isnt stable enough to have a high responsibility job.

And of course, there are general societal issues that individuals have grown up perhaps dangerous and traumatic house holds, or in communities where thefts, drug use and a certain life style is the norm, breaking from that is extremely hard. I've worked with youth offenders and in mental health, with the upbringing and general life experiences they've had being a highly successful corporate six figure earner is a million miles away. Yes you always hear the odd inspirational story of someone breaking the mould, but for the vast majority it's a battle to just function in society 'normally'.

The OP's point isn't that 'anyone can do it though'. The OP's point is that 'enough people have done it - so why are they disbelieved and/or attacked?' Also is it really true that it's a battle to survive for the 'vast majority' of people? Maybe 20/30% - but not 'most people'.

The reality is that a lot of the privileges of the 'advantaged' come from knowing how to look for opportunity - families full of professionals/tradespeople give their children good career advice based on inside experience.

Meanwhile outsiders are sold a lie that a 'degree opens doors to any profession' - people come out with a generic degree and no plan, apply to lots of admin jobs etc and find that every other applicant has a degree. Or that their peers while doing a completely unrelated degree have done research/work experience for a specific profession even before graduating and are poised for a career - because they had been TOLD to do so by parents!

We as a society need to take responsibility for helping direct people's paths - through schools, universities, whatever. We can't just wash our hands off people.

Again nobody is saying that EVERYONE can walk into a something, there will always be people with limited abilities due to life circumstances etc but we have a problem when the talent of a large number of people who are 'capable' of better is wasted because of a lack of support.

Swipe left for the next trending thread