Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe the Mumsnet High Earners?

747 replies

LigPatin · 16/04/2021 10:49

Every time there's a thread about earnings, there's always multiple posters who claim that most people on the thread must be inflating or plain lying about their salaries.

Whilst I recognise that people lie, especially on anonymous forums, I find it quite sad that people prefer to dismiss these posts as lies rather than take inspiration/education from them (or just not care).

I come from a poor background - we never had enough money to the point that food and electricity use was rationed. We weren't on the streets, but that was a looming possibility. We lived (mostly) within the midlands.

I fell into nannying as a career (having dreamed of being a primary school teacher) and my first job was in Kensington. The housekeeper had been gossiping about the rent on the house we worked in - it was £3k a WEEK. This was 2012-ish. I remember wondering how on Earth anyone could afford paying £200k+ a year on rent alone, when - in my mind - earning just £50k was amazingly rich.

I remember walking through Kensington and Knightsbridge and Chelsea and seeing thousands and thousands and thousands of these houses, all huge and grand and all presumably commanding similar rent or sale value than the one I worked in. They were all clearly lived in and used.

Perhaps it was arrogance, or naivety, but I figured that if there were enough people who could afford to pay £1k, £2k, £5k+ a week on rent (or buy million pound houses), then there must be a lot of money out there to be earned, and I couldn't see any reason as to why I couldn't find a way to get a share of that money.

That's sort of how I feel about these earning threads - hundreds of people are posting about their high salaries and instead of scoffing that they must be sad-sacks who hang out on Mumsnet to lie about their lifestyles - I think it's inspiring and encouraging to see so many women out there making amazing money and securing their futures.

FWIW - I was 21 back in Kensington, amazed at the £3k a week rent. I'm coming up to 30 now and my average yearly income is about £120k. I remind myself every day of how lucky I am, and how 21 year old me would have been incredulous. Though I'm, of course, absolutely nowhere near being able to rent a £3k a week house Grin

OP posts:
BastionsOfLowerMiddleClasses · 16/04/2021 12:38

@CHIRIBAYA

The contributions to MN that I find inspiring and encouraging don't tend to relate to income but rather values and attitudes. Income on its own doesn't reveal much about someone's qualities or lack of. I couldn't care less what someone earns, how big their house is, what they drive or where they holiday. What I AM interested in is who they are as a person.
Spot on!
OneTimeAdvocate · 16/04/2021 12:38

@TheWaif

Wow, what a fucking horrible thread.
Wow, can see why you shouldn’t get paid much
DespairingHomeowner · 16/04/2021 12:38

@Blyatiful

What do you do now, OP, and how did you get there? I only know two people who earn over £100,000. One is a very senior civil servant and the other is a surgeon.
@LigPatin: I'm also interested to know what you do to earn £120K in your late 20s?

I am in my 40s, and earn a good salary but not that - working for a large multinational. My friends earn similar after Oxbridge, further study/professional training and 20 years of work... (most are between 60-100K in London, with the few earning more than that in Finance)

I would like to know as I am open to a change Grin

HaveringWavering · 16/04/2021 12:37

@Artichokepiglet

I’m always amazed by the salaries on those threads and I agree with others that it would be really great to know how people are getting 60k+ jobs?

It can’t just be hard work/education? Clearly some fields pay better than others but I also wonder if some people are just in the right place at the right time?

Yes, London.
OneTimeAdvocate · 16/04/2021 12:37

Seriously the level of jealousy by MN people on here is astonishingly high.

Just because you earn £100k+ doesn’t mean you don’t have time to do things others do.

Why don’t those who criticise so much work smarter instead of just slinging mud? Perhaps that’s why you don’t earn much.

HaveringWavering · 16/04/2021 12:37

We NEED women to say that they are in high level roles, in high paid roles and that's it's NORMAL.

And also to bust the myth that it is not achievable without making intolerable sacrifices such as being massively stressed, never seeing your kids or having no time to post on Mumsnet!

wesowereonabreak · 16/04/2021 12:36

I don't think anyone who doesn't believe is automatically a low income earner who needs to be inspired by MN success stories, as you assume.

it's less about inspiration as such than normalising what is ... normal.

Nothing wrong with choosing to become a SAHM or a part-time working mum at all. But it's good to see that if you chose differently, your gender doesn't matter as much as people pretend.

Just look at the posters pretending it's WFH women who suffered during the lockdown Hmm.

Enidblyton1 · 16/04/2021 12:36

OP, I’m sure there are some very high earners on here and some fantasists.

I don’t think that many people are really inspired by salary alone. Many of the people who inspire me the most do difficult jobs for very little pay. For example, I am far more impressed and inspired by my friend who works night shifts in a care home for people with dementia than my own cousin who went to public school/Oxford/banking and now earns £300k plus (a lot more in a good year).

Artichokepiglet · 16/04/2021 12:36

I’m always amazed by the salaries on those threads and I agree with others that it would be really great to know how people are getting 60k+ jobs?

It can’t just be hard work/education? Clearly some fields pay better than others but I also wonder if some people are just in the right place at the right time?

SeaTurtles92 · 16/04/2021 12:35

Also can't work out what the picture says. Why is it so blurry?

notalwaysalondoner · 16/04/2021 12:34

I think there are two reasons and it’s not that people are lying: first, these threads are self selecting so high earners are more likely to comment whereas low earners might feel ashamed or embarrassed so not comment. Second, mumsnet skews toward a middle class, middle income demographic.

For what it’s worth, I am a very high earner and don’t lie on these threads...

TheLastLotus · 16/04/2021 12:34

@EmbarrassingMama

Isn't the point of the thread that when people give their salary, half the people on here kick off and accuse the high earners of lying?

Which is...exactly what has happened here, proving the OP's point?

Exactly... oh sweet irony The upshot of this is that while being able to earn well IS a privilege - it’s also used as a stick to beat ambitious women over the head with. Men make no secret of their desire for money. They deliberately go into high paying roles that they don’t hate. Women on the other hand are told to ‘do what they love’, ‘prioritise job satisfaction’ blah. Also ambition seems to be a dirty word. We need to change this. I picked my career for pure £££ and I’m not ashamed to say so. Everyone else who’s judgy or jealous can fuck off.
SeaTurtles92 · 16/04/2021 12:34

I'm confused why do we have picture of a blank email?

BastionsOfLowerMiddleClasses · 16/04/2021 12:33

I don't think anyone who doesn't believe is automatically a low income earner who needs to be inspired by MN success stories, as you assume.

I also think some of the disbelief comes from posters on MN going on about their high-income life, then on most other threads, they're having a race to the bottom - with everyone trying to show just how hard they have it with £200 pounds a year earnings for a family of 5, living on one chicken carcass a month.

Granted, it may not be the same posters but it's just weird! Taking everything with a pinch of salt is safer than believing everything you read online.

SeaTurtles92 · 16/04/2021 12:32

@UrAWizHarry

"Proof"
😂😂 brilliant.
wesowereonabreak · 16/04/2021 12:32

@TheWaif

I expect there are people who don't believe others who post about their salaries on here because it beggars belief that anyone with half a brain cell would post about their large salary on a site where so many are poor or on benefits. I mean really, what kind of shitty person would do that? Someone with precisely zero self or social awareness. The only plausible answer is that they're making it up for attention.
Hmm

if you are feeling so insecure, you should stay away from social medial.

People don't have to lie or hide their life to protect someone who might be offended.

We NEED women to say that they are in high level roles, in high paid roles and that's it's NORMAL.

Lampzade · 16/04/2021 12:31

@MapleMay11

Any career that pays £100K+ a year, would permit very little spare time/leisure time.

This simply isn't true. There are many people earning six figures who run their own businesses and have lots of free time and very little stress. We need to stop perpetuating this myth that earning a high salary involves working ridiculously long hours.

Absolutely
UrAWizHarry · 16/04/2021 12:31

"Proof"

to believe the Mumsnet High Earners?
TheWaif · 16/04/2021 12:30

It didn't offend me, I was trying to do you a favour by pointing out that you're making a complete fool of yourself on a public forum.

MiddleParking · 16/04/2021 12:30

I believe that some of the people that post on MN to say they earn over £100k do, but statistically some of them are lying. I’m more inclined to disbelieve the ones from posters who sound thick as two short planks, but it’s not an exact science.

However, the cringiest thing of all is when people boast about their husband’s career/achievements as if it reflects on them.

TheWaif · 16/04/2021 12:29

I expect there are people who don't believe others who post about their salaries on here because it beggars belief that anyone with half a brain cell would post about their large salary on a site where so many are poor or on benefits. I mean really, what kind of shitty person would do that? Someone with precisely zero self or social awareness. The only plausible answer is that they're making it up for attention.

MrPickles73 · 16/04/2021 12:29

HaveringWavering thank you.

Here we go, only 17% of the top 1% of UK earners are women:
www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/comment/article-7357395/Who-1-Britain-one-them.html

wesowereonabreak · 16/04/2021 12:29

@EmbarrassingMama

Isn't the point of the thread that when people give their salary, half the people on here kick off and accuse the high earners of lying?

Which is...exactly what has happened here, proving the OP's point?

yeap Grin
Lampzade · 16/04/2021 12:28

@Freshprincess

On those how much do you earn/how much is your mortgage threads it’s always always super high earners with massive mortgages. Rarely is there a carer on NMW with a tiny house. It’s easy to see why you’d assume people are lying because in real life the people on £100k plus are few and far between and probably not posting MN in the middle of the working day.
I don’t actually agree with your point that people on £100k wouldn’t be on mumsnet in the middle of the day I often find that many high earners have a great deal of flexibility because most of their work is office based. There is ample time to post on MN particularly when most of these people are in jobs which involve the use technology. My sister has a high powered job and often phones my mother in the middle of the day to chat about nothing in particular

I do agree with the Op to an extent, because whether posters want to believe it or not, there are individuals earning huge sums of money. How do I know this?My husband is an accountant and manages their accounts.
I have been house hunting in recent months and have been shocked by the number of one million pound plus house that have been sold.
Obviously, someone must be earning the big bucks and why shouldn’t they be posters on MN?

GreyhoundG1rl · 16/04/2021 12:28

Sorry to offend your fragile eyes. I frankly couldn't GAF.
You clearly do. You care very very much about impressing randoms on the Internet, and you're getting flouncy when they remain unimpressed. Shame.

Swipe left for the next trending thread