Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair house valuation - WWYD?

241 replies

Klaudiagal · 13/04/2021 21:32

We have bought a 4 bed property less than 2 years ago in Teddington for 550k. It was in a very bad state, but since then we insulated the house from outside, insulated the attic, changed roof over extension, rewired, changed Lino flooring into oak wood and porcelain tiles, new bathrooms, new kitchen, replastered walls and ceilings and put a beautiful bifold doors to patio.. according to property price index, the value of property went up to 588k (did not take into account any work we did), but in the meantime we had 3 estate agent valuations between 680k to 735k (this one last week).
As we are planning to remortgage soon, we requested property valuation from our current mortgage providers, for which we were charged over £500, and we estimated the property value at 700k based on previous valuations. They sent a 20-sth year old girl who obviously was very inexperienced (she asked whether the house was built in 1998, when it is built in 70s and previous surveyor even gave us an exact year based on the specific way it was constructed). I can add that the house is in Teddington 5 minutes from Thames and bushy park, so definitely not an area that decreased in value recently. We got valuation updated today to 580k!! Less than what property price index would suggest!!! And after all the extensive renovations we did.
I called the bank and asked whether they can request a reasoning behind going that low, especially that the house next door is on the market for over 700k, but they refused to do anything or provide any details behind this valuation.
AIBU thinking that since I paid £500 for this valuation, I should have a document showing the reasoning behind it?
What do I do now? Can I put a complaint? I think it is just a blatant incompetence OR bank trying to get more expensive mortgage out of me. Anybody can advice ? Mumsnetters, please help, I am just gobsmacked!

OP posts:
toconclude · 14/04/2021 14:46

@PremiumRoll

£700k gets you a 4 bed house in Teddington?! Let’s all move to Teddington!
You assume we 'all' have that kind of money...
TatianaBis · 14/04/2021 14:44

You can query the valuation but I can tell you all mortgage valuations are coming in low at the moment. I’m currently buying an investment property in SW London, not far from Teddington but further in. And the valuation has come back very low. That’s actually in my interest as a buyer & I have used it to negotiate the price down. But there’s a reason mortgage rates are rising and valuations are low - economic downturn and price falls are expected due to Covid + Brexit.

So you might go through the whole process again with the same result.

Bluntness100 · 14/04/2021 14:42

I think the issue here is firstly it’s less than two years since you bought it. Secondly you habe spent 60k, and looking at recent sold prices (which is what you need to look at not prices property is marketed at, it would seem your property is valued correctly or at the low end of correct, but you paid far too much for it less than two years ago, if it was in that bad condition.

So for example in the condition you describe, if you’d paid 475 which was in line with other property sales at the time, then spent sixty k and it was valued at 580 you’d have made a profit and made your money back on the renovations. But because you paid so high it is not working out that way

You need to base it on what the recent sold prices are, not what someone is marketing their property for. Nothing has sold at that price in your area. The fact a neighbour is marketing at that, doesn’t mean that’s the properties value. It could be highly over priced.

However on saying that there is nothing coming up for having sold for 550 in the last five years so something is adrift here, or I’m missing it?

ClarasZoo · 14/04/2021 14:40

If it’s BTL (is it?) given how hard it is to remove tenants now they probably value them like old “sitting tenant” properties, 30-50% discount...

Confusedandshaken · 14/04/2021 14:38

[quote SofiaMichelle]@Klaudiagal

I am merely saying the the house on my estate next door is for sale for £700k so I need evidence why she thinks it is irrelevant.

Put your house up for sale at £800k. In fact, put it up for £1m!

You can advertise a house for sale at absolutely any price you choose.

Why would a surveyor value your house based on what someone has decided to advertise theirs at?[/quote]
Assuming this person wasn't actually surveying the property but valuing it for the loan, they will routinely compare it with the prices being asked and obtained for similar local properties.

ClarasZoo · 14/04/2021 14:37

If they are lending you more money now, they have to build in the mega market drop coming in the next two years....

Confusedandshaken · 14/04/2021 14:35

The valuation sounds very low and I hope you get it sorted out.

That being said I really want to point out that a 20-something individual is not a 'girl'. She is a young woman. It's very patronising to refer to young adults as girls and boys.

I am particularly touchy about this as I am petite and round faced so people assume I am younger than I am. That's fine now I'm 60 but when I was a young looking but experienced and highly qualified building society manager it was irritating to have people assume I didn't know what I was talking about. However it was always a pleasure when they would try to go over my head to the one of the older, male , assistants only to be corrected and referred back to me.

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 14:34

@Viviennemary

I think you've been treated unfairly. You could request a return of say £250. They might agree to this especially if you threaten to take all your custom elsewhere. If you get nowhere complain to the bank ombudsman.
Natwest has:
  • stopped me to query the valuation, which I am entitled to as I paid for it, but I need them to send me the form to fill and start the procedure (as they commissioned the valuation) and they are Refusing to do so
  • they tried to tell me that I am not eligible to see the valuation report even though I paid for this report. It took 3 calls and finally they said that of course I should have it

Based on that I am not even going to try to ask them for any refund and my business is as lost for them as the fate of dodo birds..;)
I will also be taking them to ombudsman as they are breaking my consumer rights to disabling me from querying the valuation

OP posts:
RedMarauder · 14/04/2021 14:32

@Africa2go you clearly don't know the range about the range of ex-council housing in London then.

I know people who live in ex-council housing that is Georgian, Victorian and Edwardian as well as from different decades in the 20th Century.

Part of the problem surveyors have in parts of London is that some of ex-council properties are unique in their design, so when they do a valuation it is hard to find comparators.

Sittingonabench · 14/04/2021 14:21

I don’t think the OP is getting a hard time for disagreeing with the valuation but her attitude to the surveyor is IMO inappropriate. Disagree with the valuation, get another, examine the justification for errors- all good. Assume someone is incompetent based on age and sex and a comment on brickwork - then seemingly try to justify being patronising - is simply bad behaviour IMO.

MindGrapes · 14/04/2021 14:14

OP you're coming across as very reasonable with reasonable questions! I'd also be p'd off if I coughed up £500 for a figure with no rationale - thanks to this thread if I'm ever in this position I'll check first what my money is buying wrt surveys.

Sleepdeprivedmama1 · 14/04/2021 14:10

I recently had this issue with my house. The bank (halifax) provided me a form to compare my house with 3 others of a similar spec that have sold within the last couple years.

Their reason for the under valuation is due to covid. We also had estate agents give us much higher valuations but because their surveyors are not able to go inside the property to see the spec, they go off the sale images (unfair I know).

If you paid for the survey you should have the right to see it. They sent us our surveyors assessment. It was basic (halifax also admitted to doing drive by surveys too).

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 14:08

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER

I’m not far away from there, OP, and I agree, it does sound very low.

Looks to me as if they’ve simply added the local percentage increase to the previous sold price. Which doesn’t work if you’ve undertaken major renovations.

Just because someone’s well qualified, BTW, it doesn’t necessarily follow that they’ve got much common sense.

Thank you !

She actually went below the local price increase (ie property index price) which I find really unreasonable without any validation.

OP posts:
Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 14:05

@Hettar

I think the OP is getting a harsh time here. Ots perfectly reasonable to query the value as it will affect her mortgage. I'm a valuer and do think that value is low. The old saying for valuing property is that it's an art as well as a science.

The valuation will be based on comparable data. The better the comps the more reliable and more comfortable the value will be. In a situation like this, where there is somewhat limited evidence, the value needs to use more if their own judgement. As all values are different you'll often have them provide different values for the same property. None of these are necessary right or wrong as long as the rationale used by the valuer is reasonable.

In terms if evidence, sold prices are the nest but asking prices for properties on the market can be taken into account.

Best of luck OP

Thank you very much!
OP posts:
fistasledge · 14/04/2021 14:05

I really don't understand why the OP is getting such a hard time here?

She's not a ' greedy landlord' she's not trying to 'flip it', she's not trying to 'turn a profit'. She just wants the bank to recognise an increase in the value of her property to increase her LTV ratio and get better mortgage rates.

Our road is also a mix of newer houses, Victorian and Edwardian. You absolutely cannot play armchair detective and compare two 3 bedroom houses. Or even a 3 and 4 bed house. The rooms will be different sizes, some will only have one toilet and the gardens will be massively different.

The house next door to us is a 4 bed and recently sold for £600k. We bought ours 2 years ago as a 4 bed for £750k. But they're both 4 bed?

Well yes but the one next door is 4 bed as they've gone into the loft and now got two box rooms ont he first floor. Ours have 4 double rooms without the loft. We've got an extra reception room and one more bathroom. They don't have a downstairs loo. Our garden is twice the size. And ours had new windows and flooring whilst next doors will need new windows and a roof soon by the looks of it

None of the above could you get from looking at the sold prices.

If the Op is in the area she may be a little more well versed on what has contributed to sold prices of houses in her estate.

allaboutthecrisps · 14/04/2021 14:00

*Hi, you are right and I fully agree, but the house I am comparing to is the same estate, similar style and age, and similar size (a bit smaller actually) so it is a fair comparison..

Just making a point that I am not expecting mine to be any similar to a pretty Victorian in the next street, I am well aware of this difference and it is not at all source of my moaning*

I know you're not don't worry! If it's the house in Addision Road you're referring to I think that is actually quite a lot more attractive than yours (please don't take offence, our house is also not attractive, we don't all have the cash to buy pretty!). I don't think it's a good comparison TBH and I would expect it to be worth more than yours. It's also on the market for 700k. Our neighbours a while back put thier house on the market for what we thought was 100K over what it was worth. They got an offer 90K less than marketing price. We live in a slightly cheaper area too. You really can't judge value by what others are marketing theirs at.

Notoriouslynotnotious · 14/04/2021 14:00

This may or not apply to your house OP but we wanted to get a better LTV rate on our mortgage and we were planning to do some renovations to our 1950s home. We sank about 60k in but the surveyor told us it was only likely to add 20k to the value of the home. We did some of what you did re insulation and opening up the garden with doors and then made the downstairs open plan and did some patios etc

We didn’t care because we have no intention of selling ever but in his opinion a lot of modernising work does not reap a significant financial return relative to what is put in. Maybe there might be an element of that in your valuation too.

Muchasgracias · 14/04/2021 13:52

@Hfjshdhs

4 bedroom renovated house in Teddington, I am genuinely shocked at how low your own valuation of £700k is. Surely it would be more like £900k+?! And definitely definitely not £588k.
Same, I know this area well. I’ll buy it at that price!!
CeibaTree · 14/04/2021 13:48

@Africa2go

The house you're comparing it to OP is on the market. Having worked with surveyors, they can only use completed sales as comparables, so the fact that there's a house on for £700k makes no difference because it may not sell at all / sell for a much lower figure.

If you're convinced it is priced correctly at £700k, then delay your remortgage until its exchanged at the very least, get the estate agent to put in writing the offer and submit that to the surveyor / bank tto challenge the valuation.

Also the house OP is comparing hers to was on the market last year and didn't sell, so there's no guarantee it will sell at this price this time round anyway.
Africa2go · 14/04/2021 13:44

The house you're comparing it to OP is on the market. Having worked with surveyors, they can only use completed sales as comparables, so the fact that there's a house on for £700k makes no difference because it may not sell at all / sell for a much lower figure.

If you're convinced it is priced correctly at £700k, then delay your remortgage until its exchanged at the very least, get the estate agent to put in writing the offer and submit that to the surveyor / bank tto challenge the valuation.

bathmatty · 14/04/2021 13:44

www.zoopla.co.uk/for-sale/details/58181763/?search_identifier=b379bbb6b0d497f7829c84ea2ba1ec71

This is a 3 bed for 530k, why would a 4 bedroom cost 170k more?

Viviennemary · 14/04/2021 13:43

I think you've been treated unfairly. You could request a return of say £250. They might agree to this especially if you threaten to take all your custom elsewhere. If you get nowhere complain to the bank ombudsman.

LesserBother · 14/04/2021 13:43

I know when we remortgaged with NatWest we had 3 choices - remortgage for original value, remortgage based on desktop valuation (basically just based on property index) but this wasn't binding, or have a new valuation but that was binding and we were warned could go up or down.

Justgorgeous · 14/04/2021 13:43

@masterofthechef I want that house

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/04/2021 13:41

I’m not far away from there, OP, and I agree, it does sound very low.

Looks to me as if they’ve simply added the local percentage increase to the previous sold price. Which doesn’t work if you’ve undertaken major renovations.

Just because someone’s well qualified, BTW, it doesn’t necessarily follow that they’ve got much common sense.