Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair house valuation - WWYD?

241 replies

Klaudiagal · 13/04/2021 21:32

We have bought a 4 bed property less than 2 years ago in Teddington for 550k. It was in a very bad state, but since then we insulated the house from outside, insulated the attic, changed roof over extension, rewired, changed Lino flooring into oak wood and porcelain tiles, new bathrooms, new kitchen, replastered walls and ceilings and put a beautiful bifold doors to patio.. according to property price index, the value of property went up to 588k (did not take into account any work we did), but in the meantime we had 3 estate agent valuations between 680k to 735k (this one last week).
As we are planning to remortgage soon, we requested property valuation from our current mortgage providers, for which we were charged over £500, and we estimated the property value at 700k based on previous valuations. They sent a 20-sth year old girl who obviously was very inexperienced (she asked whether the house was built in 1998, when it is built in 70s and previous surveyor even gave us an exact year based on the specific way it was constructed). I can add that the house is in Teddington 5 minutes from Thames and bushy park, so definitely not an area that decreased in value recently. We got valuation updated today to 580k!! Less than what property price index would suggest!!! And after all the extensive renovations we did.
I called the bank and asked whether they can request a reasoning behind going that low, especially that the house next door is on the market for over 700k, but they refused to do anything or provide any details behind this valuation.
AIBU thinking that since I paid £500 for this valuation, I should have a document showing the reasoning behind it?
What do I do now? Can I put a complaint? I think it is just a blatant incompetence OR bank trying to get more expensive mortgage out of me. Anybody can advice ? Mumsnetters, please help, I am just gobsmacked!

OP posts:
Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 15:30

@Handsnotwands

OP I’m not sure if anyone else has said this so apologies if so. When we remortgaged with NatWest we were around 60% ltv. They said it was pointless revaluing as we were already on the lowest rate. Ie even if the property had increased by £50k it wouldn’t make a difference to the rate we’d get. Perhaps this is why they won’t send you the form?
The lowest valuation pushed us below 20%. The valuation of 640 (let alone 700) would give us over 30%, so in terms of rates difference it is massive at all account, and very beneficial to the bank... We did evaluate if it worth for us to have it valuaed higher, and yes, it was...
OP posts:
Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 15:26

@Sleepdeprivedmama1

You can only go to the ombudsman when you disagree with the findings of an informal complaint. Put in a complaint over the phone or writing, they'll assign someone to investigate and then you'll probably get a "goodwill" partial refund.

If you disagree with their investigations, then they'll provide you next steps on how to contact the ombudsman.

Yup:) went thorough the info and already put formal complaint. 5 days to resolve. Thank you for pointing it out though:)
OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 14/04/2021 15:25

@bathmatty,,sorry, missed that,,

fistasledge · 14/04/2021 15:25

@Bluntness100

I’m still not really sure why you get a better mortgage offer if it’s worth more? It tends not to work like that. But as you’re not selling you’ll eventually get your money back so I’d not worry

The only reason I could understand is if you wished to remortgage and take money out, so needed it to be worth more. You don’t get better “deals” the more your house is worth.

You do if it affects your LTV ratio

As OP said earlier, it'll unlock better deals

We went through exactly the same process as OP. The valuation added £50k to the original price. This meant we had £50k more equity. This meant we got down to the next band had 0.05 interest reduced just like that.

LesserBother · 14/04/2021 15:24

You don’t get better “deals” the more your house is worth.

Of course you do, if your house becomes worth more but the loan amount remains the same your LTV improves. Beyond a certain point it doesn't matter, but the rates that are available to you at 60% LTV are much better than those available at 90%.

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 15:23

@Blimeyoreilly2020

To be honest the fact that the surveyor didn’t recognise the house (& estate) as 70s is shocking but actually, more shocking, is that surveyors are meant to do pre-survey checks which should have easily highlighted the property’s era to them. Issue #2 is that the corporate survey companies expect their surveyors to do 6 in a day - it is not compatible with doing a good job!! You should definitely take this further with both Natwest, who are indeed violating your consumer rights, and also L&G who should be answerable for questions pertaining to their work. Finally why are you getting a VAL done before agreeing a mortgage? Always shop around first.
Thank you, exactly my point!

And to answer your question, I wanted to stay with the current mortgage provider (Natwest) and wanted to have fair valuation considering work that has been done as otherwise they would be using Property price index to evaluate my property which came up with higher price ironically:)

OP posts:
bathmatty · 14/04/2021 15:22

@Klaudiagal

Is this the same estate?

www.zoopla.co.uk/for-sale/details/58181763/?search_identifier=b379bbb6b0d497f7829c84ea2ba1ec71

Curioushorse · 14/04/2021 15:21

We had similar in Ealing. It was ex-council and right next to the station. Spacious, bright, extremely convenient. Roughly £200,000 less than anything of a similar size. We were shocked, complained, but withdrew from the sale (we were buying) because we figured anyone we sold it to would have the same problem.
6 weeks later they phoned us back to say they’d made a mistake. We had a gift of about £500 from them.....but it didn’t change that we’d lost the property.

No advice- but our experience!

bathmatty · 14/04/2021 15:20

However on saying that there is nothing coming up for having sold for 550 in the last five years so something is adrift here, or I’m missing it?

I linked one earlier @Bluntness100

Bluntness100 · 14/04/2021 15:19

I’m still not really sure why you get a better mortgage offer if it’s worth more? It tends not to work like that. But as you’re not selling you’ll eventually get your money back so I’d not worry

The only reason I could understand is if you wished to remortgage and take money out, so needed it to be worth more. You don’t get better “deals” the more your house is worth.

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 15:17

@TatianaBis

You can query the valuation but I can tell you all mortgage valuations are coming in low at the moment. I’m currently buying an investment property in SW London, not far from Teddington but further in. And the valuation has come back very low. That’s actually in my interest as a buyer & I have used it to negotiate the price down. But there’s a reason mortgage rates are rising and valuations are low - economic downturn and price falls are expected due to Covid + Brexit.

So you might go through the whole process again with the same result.

Fine, but Natwest is blocking me from querying the valuation. They actually refused to submit the query form.
OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 14/04/2021 15:16

All I would say is the fact that you have spent money on it doesnt necessarily translate to resale value. It depends on whether the money you spent was what buyers want etc.

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 15:15

@Bluntness100

I think the issue here is firstly it’s less than two years since you bought it. Secondly you habe spent 60k, and looking at recent sold prices (which is what you need to look at not prices property is marketed at, it would seem your property is valued correctly or at the low end of correct, but you paid far too much for it less than two years ago, if it was in that bad condition.

So for example in the condition you describe, if you’d paid 475 which was in line with other property sales at the time, then spent sixty k and it was valued at 580 you’d have made a profit and made your money back on the renovations. But because you paid so high it is not working out that way

You need to base it on what the recent sold prices are, not what someone is marketing their property for. Nothing has sold at that price in your area. The fact a neighbour is marketing at that, doesn’t mean that’s the properties value. It could be highly over priced.

However on saying that there is nothing coming up for having sold for 550 in the last five years so something is adrift here, or I’m missing it?

There is nothing that sold on my estate that is comparable as the other house was run down student house - hence the low price. And there is more to take into account t than just one other price - otherwise what would be the point of her actually setting her foot here??
OP posts:
Handsnotwands · 14/04/2021 15:14

OP I’m not sure if anyone else has said this so apologies if so. When we remortgaged with NatWest we were around 60% ltv. They said it was pointless revaluing as we were already on the lowest rate. Ie even if the property had increased by £50k it wouldn’t make a difference to the rate we’d get. Perhaps this is why they won’t send you the form?

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 15:11

@ClarasZoo

If it’s BTL (is it?) given how hard it is to remove tenants now they probably value them like old “sitting tenant” properties, 30-50% discount...
No it is not. I live here with my partner and child and it is not changing. It's the other house that people brought up as cheaper that had students in it.
OP posts:
SohoOrigami · 14/04/2021 15:11

I'd be annoyed if I'd been charged 500 pounds for something I wasn't then allowed to see or properly challenge! So I get that bit of it.

But....lender valuations are risk averse, and they are based on comparable properties in your area that have sold, not asking prices. While it's possible the valuer made a mistake, I think it's more likely that you won't get a substantial change in valuation until something very similar to yours sells for a higher price.

I had a similar issue when our ex-council flat, which we'd renovated throughout, didn't have any comparable sales nearby - like a lot of London the area is a big muddle of ex council flats next to high spec new build flats next to Victorian terraced houses, so while we were low rise, other flats were high rise, we had a big garden, other flats nearby didn't, we were solidly built with low service charge, newer builds were pretty flimsy and high monthly service charges, etc etc. We got offers we were happy with, but both our first and then our second buyers had to pull out as their mortgage lenders wouldn't value it at the price they were willing to pay. In the end we were able to wait for a buyer with a much higher deposit (think they had about 40%), which made the lender more reassured. It was a nightmare (really fun 18 months for us...) but it was valued by three different mortgage lenders and one independent and they all said the same thing, that they had to base on square footage and recent comparable sales and couldn't take into account renovation work on its own.

Good luck with the remortgage, hope it works out

Sleepdeprivedmama1 · 14/04/2021 15:04

You can only go to the ombudsman when you disagree with the findings of an informal complaint. Put in a complaint over the phone or writing, they'll assign someone to investigate and then you'll probably get a "goodwill" partial refund.

If you disagree with their investigations, then they'll provide you next steps on how to contact the ombudsman.

SofiaMichelle · 14/04/2021 15:03

@Confusedandshaken

Assuming this person wasn't actually surveying the property but valuing it for the loan, they will routinely compare it with the prices being asked and obtained for similar local properties.

"Obtained" is ok. "Asked" is not.

As I said, anyone can ask any price they want for their property. It has no bearing on its value, whatsoever.

And @Bluedeblue why do you say "No you can't" in response to my statement that you can ask whatever price you like?

Who is stopping you? No one.

It doesn't matter what mortgage anyone can get. Asking price has no connection to mortgage valuation. That all comes later when someone tries to buy or mortgage the property.

And there we are, back at OP's predicament...

chocaholic73 · 14/04/2021 15:00

Valuations which are provided out by mortgage companies etc are not the resale value which depends on supply and demand in a particular area. They are usually done on the cost of rebuilding which, particularly in your type of area, will be a lot lower than the market value.

Blimeyoreilly2020 · 14/04/2021 14:58

To be honest the fact that the surveyor didn’t recognise the house (& estate) as 70s is shocking but actually, more shocking, is that surveyors are meant to do pre-survey checks which should have easily highlighted the property’s era to them. Issue #2 is that the corporate survey companies expect their surveyors to do 6 in a day - it is not compatible with doing a good job!! You should definitely take this further with both Natwest, who are indeed violating your consumer rights, and also L&G who should be answerable for questions pertaining to their work. Finally why are you getting a VAL done before agreeing a mortgage? Always shop around first.

Allergictoironing · 14/04/2021 14:57

Interesting how many comments that updating etc makes very little difference to the value, when I've been told by local estate agents that poor decorative order will drop around 10% off the market value of my house. Either the cosmetic state of a house makes a difference to the value, or it doesn't - can't have it both ways!

TatianaBis · 14/04/2021 14:55

60k is a hell of a lot of money to spend on a house that size and value full stop but particularly without extending. It’s 10% of the total value, but you’re not adding 10% to the size.

Those kind of modern boxes on modern box roads tend to have a ceiling. It’s always worth considering the ceiling when looking at developing the property.

Bythemillpond · 14/04/2021 14:54

I think what is happening is in your area there are 2 different sizes of house but in the pictures you can’t necessarily see the difference as they look very similar and people and the surveyor are getting confused.

Having looked around there are houses like yours that are around 1300sq ft and are up for sale for around the £700,000 mark and then there are houses that look very similar that are around the 800-900 square feet that have been sold for a lot less.

CeibaTree · 14/04/2021 14:52

@Bluntness100

I think the issue here is firstly it’s less than two years since you bought it. Secondly you habe spent 60k, and looking at recent sold prices (which is what you need to look at not prices property is marketed at, it would seem your property is valued correctly or at the low end of correct, but you paid far too much for it less than two years ago, if it was in that bad condition.

So for example in the condition you describe, if you’d paid 475 which was in line with other property sales at the time, then spent sixty k and it was valued at 580 you’d have made a profit and made your money back on the renovations. But because you paid so high it is not working out that way

You need to base it on what the recent sold prices are, not what someone is marketing their property for. Nothing has sold at that price in your area. The fact a neighbour is marketing at that, doesn’t mean that’s the properties value. It could be highly over priced.

However on saying that there is nothing coming up for having sold for 550 in the last five years so something is adrift here, or I’m missing it?

It's been linked upthread already. I think you are right about the OP paying too much if it was in the state that they have described, this one seems to have been more in line with what would be expected for a bit of a wreck on that estate. But I think prices have started to drop anyway since 2019, so it's not a case of houses automatically increasing in value as they have been doing in recent years, and if banks are expecting a potential property crash then it makes sense that they are valuing at the low end.

OP if they are now valuing at £580k then it's still an increase of £30k in less than two years which is not bad at all. It's a shame all the work you have done isn't reflected in the valuation by the bank, but if you haven't done any structural work/extended it makes sense that it has been valued like that. It does seem odd that you aren't being allowed to see the valuation though.

Jangle33 · 14/04/2021 14:48

Some sense of this thread! In a stagnant/decreasing market the OP thinks just because her house is in Teddington it should have gone up around £150k in 2 years...