Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair house valuation - WWYD?

241 replies

Klaudiagal · 13/04/2021 21:32

We have bought a 4 bed property less than 2 years ago in Teddington for 550k. It was in a very bad state, but since then we insulated the house from outside, insulated the attic, changed roof over extension, rewired, changed Lino flooring into oak wood and porcelain tiles, new bathrooms, new kitchen, replastered walls and ceilings and put a beautiful bifold doors to patio.. according to property price index, the value of property went up to 588k (did not take into account any work we did), but in the meantime we had 3 estate agent valuations between 680k to 735k (this one last week).
As we are planning to remortgage soon, we requested property valuation from our current mortgage providers, for which we were charged over £500, and we estimated the property value at 700k based on previous valuations. They sent a 20-sth year old girl who obviously was very inexperienced (she asked whether the house was built in 1998, when it is built in 70s and previous surveyor even gave us an exact year based on the specific way it was constructed). I can add that the house is in Teddington 5 minutes from Thames and bushy park, so definitely not an area that decreased in value recently. We got valuation updated today to 580k!! Less than what property price index would suggest!!! And after all the extensive renovations we did.
I called the bank and asked whether they can request a reasoning behind going that low, especially that the house next door is on the market for over 700k, but they refused to do anything or provide any details behind this valuation.
AIBU thinking that since I paid £500 for this valuation, I should have a document showing the reasoning behind it?
What do I do now? Can I put a complaint? I think it is just a blatant incompetence OR bank trying to get more expensive mortgage out of me. Anybody can advice ? Mumsnetters, please help, I am just gobsmacked!

OP posts:
Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 19:14

[quote fairydustandsparkle]@Klaudiagal - I can see you replied to me on the other thread but you’ve created your own so I’m replying on here instead so as not to derail the other thread.

I understand entirely why you’d like to see the valuation report, especially since you have paid for it. And it’s natural to want to see how and what information the surveyors used to reach their property valuation figure. However, the valuation was instructed by Natwest for the sole purpose of considering whether to grant a remortgage on the security of the property. It isn’t clear whether NatWest are your current lender i.e. you’re changing your deal or if you are remortgaging. But there is no obligation on NatWest or the surveyors to provide details, as you were not the party instructing the surveyors in this instance. This is the issue and why I suspect NatWest haven’t been forthcoming. But I think I read earlier in the thread that you may have the option to appeal so if it was me I’d go down that route first.

If it helps, I’ve remortgaged five times and I don’t think I’ve ever seen the valuation report for the lenders purposes.[/quote]
Hey, thanks for replying.
Yeah, I got a confirmation from valuators that since I actually paid for it this documentation should be legally provided to me (it is different when bank pays for it). Also I already talked to one of the managers in Natwest after I raised complaint about that and he was apologising for this very fact and agreed I should have been given it in the first place. So yes, if you pay for valuation and you don't get valuation report, it is not legal..

OP posts:
hibbledibble · 14/04/2021 18:58

I'm surprised a 4 bed ex council house so far from London is worth that much. I live in zone 2 and it's cheaper here.

fairydustandsparkle · 14/04/2021 18:22

@Klaudiagal - I can see you replied to me on the other thread but you’ve created your own so I’m replying on here instead so as not to derail the other thread.

I understand entirely why you’d like to see the valuation report, especially since you have paid for it. And it’s natural to want to see how and what information the surveyors used to reach their property valuation figure. However, the valuation was instructed by Natwest for the sole purpose of considering whether to grant a remortgage on the security of the property. It isn’t clear whether NatWest are your current lender i.e. you’re changing your deal or if you are remortgaging. But there is no obligation on NatWest or the surveyors to provide details, as you were not the party instructing the surveyors in this instance. This is the issue and why I suspect NatWest haven’t been forthcoming. But I think I read earlier in the thread that you may have the option to appeal so if it was me I’d go down that route first.

If it helps, I’ve remortgaged five times and I don’t think I’ve ever seen the valuation report for the lenders purposes.

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 18:12

@Bluntness100

Ah ok, thanks op, I didn’t realise that on mortgages and have had one or the other for nearly thirty years 🤯

Could the decline in values that the pp posted, of 15 percent be impacting.

So if you paid 550 , take away say just under ten percent takes you to five hundred, add you’re improvements, ans she’s valued at 580? If you’d done nothing it would be worth about 475 to 500?

The property price index reflects all that, so basically shows the average price increase in area. And it does not include obviously any improvement done to it. So - just based on that I should have higher valuation than what I got.
OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 14/04/2021 18:05

That valuation is ludicrous.

I sold a flat right by you 6 years ago and a house where you are was up for sale for £650k. I wanted to stay in the area but we just couldn’t stretch to it.

Utterly bonkers.

LesserBother · 14/04/2021 16:57

I do wonder if it's quite common with these sorts of valuations - we were strongly encouraged to stick with the desktop valuation rather than a full survey even though we'd done a reasonable amount of structural work, and it was emphasised that if we had an actual valuation we had to stick with that figure, up or down, whereas if we had a desktop valuation we could go with that or use our existing valuation

MindGrapes · 14/04/2021 16:50

@Blimeyoreilly2020

I’m actually quite amazed at the number of people who aren’t aware that your mortgage interest rate will be better (/lower) the more equity in your property you own, obv totally understandable for those who’ve never had a mortgage though. Our best ever rate tracked 0.5% below base rate - was a true gift when rates plunged post 2008 crisis🤣....but when I complain these days my Mum reminds me that way back when they were paying 17%😱...
Me too - it's simply LTV and it's how they differentiate between what mortgage you can get.
Bluntness100 · 14/04/2021 16:37

Ah ok, thanks op, I didn’t realise that on mortgages and have had one or the other for nearly thirty years 🤯

Could the decline in values that the pp posted, of 15 percent be impacting.

So if you paid 550 , take away say just under ten percent takes you to five hundred, add you’re improvements, ans she’s valued at 580? If you’d done nothing it would be worth about 475 to 500?

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 16:35

@Africa2go

Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors
Thanks!
OP posts:
peachgreen · 14/04/2021 16:33

I realise I'm just adding to the chorus but it's absolutely insane that you can get a 4 bed in Teddington for under £600k. I just don't believe it. Like @Frannyhy, we sold my Nanna's 3 bedroom terrace in Teddington (admittedly a nice area) for £650k and that was 15 years ago!

Africa2go · 14/04/2021 16:27

Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 16:23

@sipsmith1

If you want to complain all surveyors must follow the their complaints handling procedure as set out by RICS. Ask them for a copy of it, if you feel it isn’t being followed complain directly to RICS.
What is RICS?
OP posts:
sipsmith1 · 14/04/2021 16:19

If you want to complain all surveyors must follow the their complaints handling procedure as set out by RICS. Ask them for a copy of it, if you feel it isn’t being followed complain directly to RICS.

GreyhoundG1rl · 14/04/2021 16:16

Not wanting to diss your house, op, but there will absolutely be a ceiling price on that street.

Africa2go · 14/04/2021 16:12

[quote RedMarauder]@Africa2go you clearly don't know the range about the range of ex-council housing in London then.

I know people who live in ex-council housing that is Georgian, Victorian and Edwardian as well as from different decades in the 20th Century.

Part of the problem surveyors have in parts of London is that some of ex-council properties are unique in their design, so when they do a valuation it is hard to find comparators.[/quote]
Well, I lived in an ex-council house in London (as a rental) whilst I was looking to buy. Watched property prices pretty much daily. I stand by my comment that location is key, an ex-council property on a council estate regardless of whether it's Georgian, Victorian or whatever isn't comparable to a non-ex council / council estate property.

TatianaBis · 14/04/2021 16:06

Said an experienced valuator;)

Do yourself a favour and read few comments here of people who actually do this job.

I know London property. Better than some valuers. A modern box in Teddington will not increase in mortgage survey value terms by nearly 100k in 2 years with no extra floorspace.

I’m just trying being realistic so you’re not disappointed.

BoverWithAHover · 14/04/2021 16:01

OP, I sympathise. We had a similar problem a few years ago when remortgaging with Nationwide, a new lender to us.

We paid a product fee upfront of £200 for a seemingly competitive mortage deal. The valuer did a "drive-by" valuation and undervalued by a significant amount. By which I mean significantly less than we paid for the house several years previously. We live in a "tourist" town where the house prices have sky-rocketed since we moved here 20+ years ago, so we knew that market value and lender value would likely be very different but even so we were pretty shocked.

At the time, the most recent property sale in our road was five years previously. This was a house owned by a hoarder which was in a terrible state, unmodernised, much smaller than ours, garden a third the size. Our valuation from Nationwide was even less than the amount this house sold for.

Nationwide then declared that the low valuation meant we were no longer eligible for the great deal and had the choice to either lose our £200 and go elsewhere or choose their next-best deal which was rather less financially attractive. We had spent a lot of time sourcing the mortgage and waiting for them to faff about with the valuation and so decided to stick with Nationwide and take the next-best deal. Turned out this had no product fee attached to it but they still refused to refund our £200. So we had a more expensive mortgage and a £200 loss. Win-win for Nationwide!

They too refused to provide any detailed information about or reasoning for the low valuation. We pushed very hard for them to send a valuer in person, which they also refused to do. I even discovered, during one of many irate phone calls, that nobody even actually "drove-by". They just sat on their arse looking at Zoopla!

We were advised that this was not an uncommon practice and that we should pursue it with the ombudsman but, frankly, as full-time workers with young kids, we didn't have the time or the energy.

allaboutthecrisps · 14/04/2021 15:57

Sorry, misread it! It is around 15K average reduction, not 15%. Still making mortgage companies nervous though and if you think your house is work more than the average in your postcode than the k reduction will also be more.

allaboutthecrisps · 14/04/2021 15:55

OP zoopla says prices in your specific area have dropped 15% in the last year.

www.zoopla.co.uk/house-prices/london/teddington/down-road/tw11-9ha/?pn=2

How much do you actually need the house to be valued at to get a better rate? Is it 625?

Sorry for missing earlier that you had spent 60K on it. I do think that for a house not in a massively poor state (which you said about your house as compared to the student let) then that is a lot for no structural work. This means you have gone higher spec and why not if it's what you want but I don't think that means you can expect to recuperate the cost if you sell (which is what the value is). I wonder if you've specked higher than the area usually commands? In which case it is value for you but not cash value. In a falling house market I think you might have to put up with a lower value than you want. Hugely frustrating if it makes £260 a month difference on your mortgage but hopefully in the future that will improve.

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 15:48

@TatianaBis

The valuation of 640

You're not likely to get a valuation of that full stop.

Said an experienced valuator;)

Do yourself a favour and read few comments here of people who actually do this job.

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 14/04/2021 15:42

The valuation of 640

You're not likely to get a valuation of that full stop.

Blimeyoreilly2020 · 14/04/2021 15:38

I’m actually quite amazed at the number of people who aren’t aware that your mortgage interest rate will be better (/lower) the more equity in your property you own, obv totally understandable for those who’ve never had a mortgage though. Our best ever rate tracked 0.5% below base rate - was a true gift when rates plunged post 2008 crisis🤣....but when I complain these days my Mum reminds me that way back when they were paying 17%😱...

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 15:32

@Bluntness100

I’m still not really sure why you get a better mortgage offer if it’s worth more? It tends not to work like that. But as you’re not selling you’ll eventually get your money back so I’d not worry

The only reason I could understand is if you wished to remortgage and take money out, so needed it to be worth more. You don’t get better “deals” the more your house is worth.

If the property is more expensive, they will give me better rate. With this price (580) change they will be taking £260 a month more in my monthly mortgage payment than if it it was valued as 700, or even 625...
OP posts:
bathmatty · 14/04/2021 15:32

If the OP has a high LTV eg 90% she won't have access to the best rates.

endofthelinefinally · 14/04/2021 15:31

A mortgage valuation is always much lower than a sales valuation. It is usual, IME, to be charged for a mortgage valuation, but not for a valuation by an estate agent. The estate agent valuation is normally artificially high.