Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair house valuation - WWYD?

241 replies

Klaudiagal · 13/04/2021 21:32

We have bought a 4 bed property less than 2 years ago in Teddington for 550k. It was in a very bad state, but since then we insulated the house from outside, insulated the attic, changed roof over extension, rewired, changed Lino flooring into oak wood and porcelain tiles, new bathrooms, new kitchen, replastered walls and ceilings and put a beautiful bifold doors to patio.. according to property price index, the value of property went up to 588k (did not take into account any work we did), but in the meantime we had 3 estate agent valuations between 680k to 735k (this one last week).
As we are planning to remortgage soon, we requested property valuation from our current mortgage providers, for which we were charged over £500, and we estimated the property value at 700k based on previous valuations. They sent a 20-sth year old girl who obviously was very inexperienced (she asked whether the house was built in 1998, when it is built in 70s and previous surveyor even gave us an exact year based on the specific way it was constructed). I can add that the house is in Teddington 5 minutes from Thames and bushy park, so definitely not an area that decreased in value recently. We got valuation updated today to 580k!! Less than what property price index would suggest!!! And after all the extensive renovations we did.
I called the bank and asked whether they can request a reasoning behind going that low, especially that the house next door is on the market for over 700k, but they refused to do anything or provide any details behind this valuation.
AIBU thinking that since I paid £500 for this valuation, I should have a document showing the reasoning behind it?
What do I do now? Can I put a complaint? I think it is just a blatant incompetence OR bank trying to get more expensive mortgage out of me. Anybody can advice ? Mumsnetters, please help, I am just gobsmacked!

OP posts:
rarari · 15/04/2021 11:00

Affordability here is not the issue as I am borrowing the same amount of money regardless of valuation.

So, as much as what you are saying is correct, it has no relevance here

But won't a better LTV give you a better rate? I think the banks are tightening everything up, after all they look after themselves first.

Africa2go · 15/04/2021 10:47

[quote RedMarauder]@Africa2go you have made the mistake of presuming the properties are on "council estates". They aren't.[/quote]
The OP says "The property is part of ex council estate"

Klaudiagal · 15/04/2021 10:09

@Itisasecret

Yes it really has. Mortgage affordability rules are tight. They are also reaching the cap in a lot of places on salary multiples. Some places are running hot (like I referred to in my post). A lot aren’t. Which is why banks are refusing to lend and it’s why the new mortgage GTE is coming out. The government are taking the risk of negative equity and the banks will not in the current market.

Which is why chains, etc in a lot of areas are collapsing. The banks will not lend and for the most part, they are the ones who dictate the housing market for the majority of people. Unless you’re a cash buyer of course or have a significant salary where it’s really not relevant.

I live in the SW and houses are not selling and coming back on the market for significantly less than they went on for. (Not Devon but rural).

Affordability here is not the issue as I am borrowing the same amount of money regardless of valuation.

So, as much as what you are saying is correct, it has no relevance here

OP posts:
Klaudiagal · 15/04/2021 10:07

@allaboutthecrisps

Well, if you treat those website as such a valid indicator, Rightmove estimated value of my property at 621kz

They seem to be a reasonable estimate of general price increase or decrease in the specific areas even if their actual prices are sometimes a little off. Do you think prices are not falling in your area?

According to property index price which is government measure to not only the area but the price of property - no, they are not. And it is the official measure that gives you a view on specific property, not Zoopla general area estimate, which includes a lot of multi million houses in the are, and I bet they are falling..
OP posts:
Klaudiagal · 15/04/2021 10:03

@GrumpyHoonMain

You aren’t the only one I’ve heard of who’s having a problem with Natwest re: undervaluations. They seem to be wanting to put all mortgages in higher LTV categories to make more money. Try HSBC - I don’t recommend them usually but during the pandemic their size has ensured they have remained fairer than others and their valuers seem to understand larger properties.
Yes, that literally seems to be it sadly...
OP posts:
Itisasecret · 15/04/2021 09:46

Yes it really has. Mortgage affordability rules are tight. They are also reaching the cap in a lot of places on salary multiples. Some places are running hot (like I referred to in my post). A lot aren’t. Which is why banks are refusing to lend and it’s why the new mortgage GTE is coming out. The government are taking the risk of negative equity and the banks will not in the current market.

Which is why chains, etc in a lot of areas are collapsing. The banks will not lend and for the most part, they are the ones who dictate the housing market for the majority of people. Unless you’re a cash buyer of course or have a significant salary where it’s really not relevant.

I live in the SW and houses are not selling and coming back on the market for significantly less than they went on for. (Not Devon but rural).

hettie · 15/04/2021 09:38

Itisasecret has it, there are many places that are definitely in a bubble (which will always crash). I am Devonian, don't currently live there but family do. Currently crackers, 24 hours online to sell and people are buying getting in bidding wars without actually seeing the property Shock. It is beautiful but infrastructure is not that great (good luck multi household zoom meetings and training it to London twice a week) and local stable well paid work is very hard to come by. A hard winter and some job losses/ actually we want you back in the office more could well have a big impact on people's ability to live the Devon idyll and a likely correction in prices...

Itisasecret · 15/04/2021 09:03

Absolutely. Banks don’t want to lend higher LTV as it’s risky. Especially now when mortgage affordability is so tight. House prices are xxxx salary when banks will only lend, for the most part 4.49x salary. There are ceiling caps. Particularly now there are issues with banks lending on people who’ve been on furlough, taken seiss etc. Banks can see a correction coming which is why they don’t want to lend at 95%. To say they are trying to force people into higher ltv is daft. They don’t want the risk. The FTB market is drying up and the next rung of medium size houses has too. Partly because of all the above and partly because the new HTB schemes rules out 2nd movers and enforced a regional price cap.

Banks don’t care what you spent on it, they care how much it’s actually worth in sold prices. So if you don’t pay, how much will they get back. Some places are running hot. A lot of places are seeing house prices fall. EA and sellers haven’t cottoned on to this yet. The banks have and it is that which is stopping houses moving. People then find themselves needing a high LTV and banks won’t lend on it for those moving on. Or in the case of FTB they can’t get another 10% quickly enough.

There is a reason the new 5% mortgage gte is coming. In our area houses are staying around for months and not selling. This that do sell often come back on the market with a slapped down value because banks won’t lend what the EA and seller said they should get.

TatianaBis · 15/04/2021 08:53

You cannot rely on Zoopla for estimated values, it’s done on algorithms.

Itisasecret · 15/04/2021 08:35

This is why the new mortgage gte is coming out. People have unrealistic ideas about how much their house is worth and the bank is slapping that right down on valuation and won’t lend.

GrumpyHoonMain · 15/04/2021 08:24

You aren’t the only one I’ve heard of who’s having a problem with Natwest re: undervaluations. They seem to be wanting to put all mortgages in higher LTV categories to make more money. Try HSBC - I don’t recommend them usually but during the pandemic their size has ensured they have remained fairer than others and their valuers seem to understand larger properties.

Planty13 · 15/04/2021 08:01

YANBU. I wanted to remortgage recently and paid hundreds for a valuation and why, I have no idea, as they didn’t even see the house so I can only assume someone hopped online and got a valuation within seconds which don’t take into account any improvements we’ve actually done in the house. Infuriating OP and yes I would push further if I were you.

Bluntness100 · 15/04/2021 07:54

Zoopla gives a range though? It doesn’t just give one figure.

allaboutthecrisps · 15/04/2021 07:52

Well, if you treat those website as such a valid indicator, Rightmove estimated value of my property at 621kz

They seem to be a reasonable estimate of general price increase or decrease in the specific areas even if their actual prices are sometimes a little off. Do you think prices are not falling in your area?

Klaudiagal · 15/04/2021 05:25

@allaboutthecrisps

The question is where did you get the info that the prices went down by 17k?

Zoopla. It said that average prices went down by average of 15K in your postcode but your house is above average value in that postcode hence my estimate of 17K.

Well, if you treat those website as such a valid indicator, Rightmove estimated value of my property at 621kz Go figure.
OP posts:
RedMarauder · 15/04/2021 02:13

@Africa2go you have made the mistake of presuming the properties are on "council estates". They aren't.

allaboutthecrisps · 14/04/2021 23:50

The question is where did you get the info that the prices went down by 17k?

Zoopla. It said that average prices went down by average of 15K in your postcode but your house is above average value in that postcode hence my estimate of 17K.

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 23:29

@allaboutthecrisps

The property price index reflects all that, so basically shows the average price increase in area. And it does not include obviously any improvement done to it. So - just based on that I should have higher valuation than what I got.

I don't really understand this. Prices went down by probably around 17K for your home last year. So you think it went up by 55K in the 9 months before that in order to have still gone up by 38K after recent value decrease. Is that right? And then you're hoping to get around 60K or more of increased value related to the house improvements too. Is that right? Was the market really buoyant enough to achieve a 10% value increase in the first 9 months after you bought it? What's the source of your info for that increase?

The question is where did you get the info that the prices went down by 17k?
OP posts:
allaboutthecrisps · 14/04/2021 21:26

The property price index reflects all that, so basically shows the average price increase in area. And it does not include obviously any improvement done to it. So - just based on that I should have higher valuation than what I got.

I don't really understand this. Prices went down by probably around 17K for your home last year. So you think it went up by 55K in the 9 months before that in order to have still gone up by 38K after recent value decrease. Is that right? And then you're hoping to get around 60K or more of increased value related to the house improvements too. Is that right? Was the market really buoyant enough to achieve a 10% value increase in the first 9 months after you bought it? What's the source of your info for that increase?

Merryoldgoat · 14/04/2021 20:49

@BorlandRd

That’s very interesting - maybe I can afford to move back one day if that’s the case!

BorlandRd · 14/04/2021 20:26

I've named changed for this - I live on your estate OP (although not on the road of my username). We have a 3 bed, and although we have done some decorative work, replaced the conservatory for a more modern one, and floor boarded the loft so we can use it as an office/extra living space, we would not spend any more that this as there is absolutely a ceiling price on these properties - despite how the rest of Teddington properties have risen. Having said that though, I do think prices in Teddington are falling - friends of ours bought on York Road for almost £700k in 2016/7, and a house identical to theirs is now on for £629k. I've noticed properties in Teddington get reduced quite a lot from their initial listing on Rightmove - particularly if they are on with Dexters who seem to over value. So your bank's valuation may not been too off. An uplift of £30k in two years seems fair to me.
But you do still have the right to see their valuation!

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 19:26

@LesserBother

I do wonder if it's quite common with these sorts of valuations - we were strongly encouraged to stick with the desktop valuation rather than a full survey even though we'd done a reasonable amount of structural work, and it was emphasised that if we had an actual valuation we had to stick with that figure, up or down, whereas if we had a desktop valuation we could go with that or use our existing valuation
In my case the 2 options were: 1. Rely on property purchase price bumped by property price index or 2. Get the valuation done. Since we did the work on property we wanted that to be included in the valuation, hence we went for option 2. They did say that I have to accept the price given by specialists but I still have right to query it and they have to validate even outside of what they provided in standard report.
OP posts:
Zampa · 14/04/2021 19:23

@Africa2go

Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors

Had that drummed into me before I sat my APC.

Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 19:18

[quote fairydustandsparkle]@Klaudiagal - I can see you replied to me on the other thread but you’ve created your own so I’m replying on here instead so as not to derail the other thread.

I understand entirely why you’d like to see the valuation report, especially since you have paid for it. And it’s natural to want to see how and what information the surveyors used to reach their property valuation figure. However, the valuation was instructed by Natwest for the sole purpose of considering whether to grant a remortgage on the security of the property. It isn’t clear whether NatWest are your current lender i.e. you’re changing your deal or if you are remortgaging. But there is no obligation on NatWest or the surveyors to provide details, as you were not the party instructing the surveyors in this instance. This is the issue and why I suspect NatWest haven’t been forthcoming. But I think I read earlier in the thread that you may have the option to appeal so if it was me I’d go down that route first.

If it helps, I’ve remortgaged five times and I don’t think I’ve ever seen the valuation report for the lenders purposes.[/quote]
And thank you for coming to this thread- I never meant to post in other one, it was a mistake:)

OP posts:
Klaudiagal · 14/04/2021 19:17

@hibbledibble

I'm surprised a 4 bed ex council house so far from London is worth that much. I live in zone 2 and it's cheaper here.
Teddington is very expensive sadly... I am not commenting on where you live, but I also lived in zone 2, and it was cheaper than here. Also - Teddington is still part of Richmond Borough and it is therefore part of London (at least theoretically, as my personal rule of thumb is: if it has Tube, it is London, and we are just outside of it:)
OP posts: