Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend is rude, yes or no? AIBU?

308 replies

provencegal · 11/04/2021 17:46

Please help me work out if I am being over sensitive.

Friendship group from children's primary school initially, but now very good friends of four years. We have lots of nights out, coffees and lunches at each other's houses. We have supported each other a lot over the years, and it has been great.

Four weeks ago I invited everyone to my garden for a late lunch at the end of this month - it is a delayed birthday celebration/ good excuse to get together. Everyone accepted and was really excited, it took some time to organise a good day for everyone.

Friend A calls me last night and tells me she can't make it, fine no worries. She then goes on to tell me she has organised a dinner the very same evening for twelve people. She has invited one half of the group (plus a few extras that are not part of our group) but not the others. And she hasn't included me either Shock which was awkward on the phone to say the least! I am not sure what she wanted me to say, I was just quite gobsmacked, so I said no worries, lets reschedule and left it at that.

I have since cancelled my lunch on that date, as it is going to be too awkward with half the group going to the 'after party' at friend A's house, and the other half left uninvited! The others do not know about the evening dinner yet.

I will meet them individually instead now I think.

To think she is a CF? Or is this okay?

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 12/04/2021 01:13

You’ve spectacularly missed the point —or not rtft, or even just the op’s updates—The lunch goes on into the evening, so it IS a clash and a challenge by Friend A.

But the OP can still have the friends (that she likes more) at the lunch because they're NOT invited to the dinner.

So I don't understand why she's cancelled

RogueMNerKnowsNoShame · 12/04/2021 01:06

@Phrenologist

It sounds to me like an awful lot of strangely indirect assumptions are being made, and there are some strange things going on.

For one thing, I would have no compunction at all about accepting lunch and dinner invitations for the same day, because a lunch wouldn’t normally clash with a dinner — it’s only a ‘pick me’ issue if you’ve set it up that way. For another, I think it’s incredibly poor form to cancel a lunch because of some teenage rivalry drama — it signals to the other guests that you see their presence as less important than being seen to be ‘dignified’ in your dynamic with A.

Absolutely, she has behaved with breathtaking rudeness, but she appears to be allowed to do so by you acting like a doormat. Anyone would say ‘Let me be sure I’m getting this right. You’re cancelling on me because you’ve suddenly decided that only one night in 2021 is possible for a dinner party?’ That’s not confrontation, a ‘pick me’ dance, or a pitched battle, that’s being an adult and communicating. But you’re hoping your mutual friends will communicate what you seem unable to, which is pretty juvenile.

Cancelling your lunch isn’t ‘dignified’, it’s the equivalent of a teenage flounce while imagining how sad everyone will be at your funeral.

But the real issue here is that you don’t actually seem to like the majority of the people involved at all!

You’ve spectacularly missed the point —or not rtft, or even just the op’s updates— The lunch goes on into the evening, so it IS a clash and a challenge by Friend A.

@provencegal I think you’ve handled this perfectly, I am in awe.
And - joyfully - free and available for whenever you reschedule....

(I will bring wine!)

Lalliella · 12/04/2021 00:40

You should uncancel your lunch.

TatianaBis · 12/04/2021 00:06

Yeah I don’t get the whole rival tit for tat thing.

Enidblyton1 · 11/04/2021 23:59

She sounds mean OP, but like many others on this thread I find your reaction OTT. Why on earth would you cancel your lunch? You say you don’t want to have rival events or engage in games, but you wouldn’t be doing either of these things by having your lunch.
YABU to cancel your lunch.

SD1978 · 11/04/2021 23:48

I don't see why you cancelled- that was entirely your choice to not host. What was/ is going on afterwards is none of your concern. She's being ignorant, you've now sulk cancelled. Ultimately that doesn't affect her and her plans at all.

Gobbeldegook · 11/04/2021 23:43

You need to rearrange same date and time, apologize for the confusion and explain the situation to everyone. Let them make their own minds up. They might already think she's a bitch and you might confirm it for them.

Cipot · 11/04/2021 23:43

She sounds horrible.

Osirus · 11/04/2021 23:30

@katy1213

Well, you're silly to cancel - it's only awkward if you make it awkward. She's not obliged to invite everyone she knows for dinner - 12 sounds as many as most people could cope with. You had a nice lunch with a crowd of friends who were - all but one - happy to accept. And now you've got nothing.
I agree with this, so voted YABU.

It’s not unreasonable to feel disappointed though.

Phrenologist · 11/04/2021 23:28

It sounds to me like an awful lot of strangely indirect assumptions are being made, and there are some strange things going on.

For one thing, I would have no compunction at all about accepting lunch and dinner invitations for the same day, because a lunch wouldn’t normally clash with a dinner — it’s only a ‘pick me’ issue if you’ve set it up that way. For another, I think it’s incredibly poor form to cancel a lunch because of some teenage rivalry drama — it signals to the other guests that you see their presence as less important than being seen to be ‘dignified’ in your dynamic with A.

Absolutely, she has behaved with breathtaking rudeness, but she appears to be allowed to do so by you acting like a doormat. Anyone would say ‘Let me be sure I’m getting this right. You’re cancelling on me because you’ve suddenly decided that only one night in 2021 is possible for a dinner party?’ That’s not confrontation, a ‘pick me’ dance, or a pitched battle, that’s being an adult and communicating. But you’re hoping your mutual friends will communicate what you seem unable to, which is pretty juvenile.

Cancelling your lunch isn’t ‘dignified’, it’s the equivalent of a teenage flounce while imagining how sad everyone will be at your funeral.

But the real issue here is that you don’t actually seem to like the majority of the people involved at all!

Peachesarepeach · 11/04/2021 23:04

Do you think she is aware you're upset?

It sounds like she's in touch a lot, I'm assuming that will continue. Have you decided how you'll respond to her messages? I'm guessing if she relies on you for support her messages/calls might well get more frequent and demanding if she feels you pulling back.

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 11/04/2021 22:44

Op I would do the same as you are.

Step back gracefully and rearrange but only with the smaller eclectic group you really want there and don't mention it to the others.

No drama then is there and at least it's a good excuse to step away from twat friend now

SomebodyThatIUsedToKnow3 · 11/04/2021 22:30

@Notoriouslynotnotious

If I was invited to your lunch and not invited to her dinner I’d be a teeny bit miffed that you cancelled. If I was invited to your lunch also invited to hers, I would not have gone to hers because I already had plans.

I really don’t think you needed to cancel.

I'm wondering if this is why she told you. She expected you to cancel so that those that said they couldn't make it to hers will go now. I don't get the cancelling. If I'd accepted yours and said no to her on that basis or if I'd been left out of hers I'd probably feel a bit hurt by your cancellation.
provencegal · 11/04/2021 22:27

Thank you everyone, feel so much better for talking about this.
I will keep you updated, but happy just to let it play out, however they like, and I will check out.

The old saying on here is to avoid the pick me dance, and I am definitely choosing to do that rather than get embroiled in a nasty tit for tat. Sometimes it is better just to draw a line, and walk away. Some people are damaged way more than we see, or have private battles that are not obvious. Whatever is happening now, best to step away I feel.

Thank you for the support everyone - love this forum xxxx

OP posts:
LactoseTheIntolerant · 11/04/2021 22:26

Well done op, it sounds like your doing the right thing. I've had this sort of thing happen before (also with mum friends) strangely I can't remember this ever happening before children. It's such a shame that some people have to play a popularity game within friendship groups. Instead of proving themselves the most popular they just succeed in imploding the group and ruining what could have been great friendships, but you are well and truly better off out of it and just giving your friendship to the kind ones.

babbaloushka · 11/04/2021 21:57

Are D and E invited? Could you do something low-key with them that evening instead?

jobsagudden · 11/04/2021 21:54

@provencegal sounds like you have the right idea, step away from the friendship. What an absolutely bizarre thing to do? Just see the friends you really get on with separately, who has got time for this kind of thing?

Ianrankinfan · 11/04/2021 21:46

provencegal you are doing the right thing.. the game playing is awful.

Chickychickydodah · 11/04/2021 21:46

I would cool it a bit with her and let her do her thing. You see your friends and be “ busy” if she wants you to do stuff.

Figgygal · 11/04/2021 21:35

You rock OP
Completely the adult and dignified way to deal with such nonsense

CandyLeBonBon · 11/04/2021 21:25

How utterly bizarre

provencegal · 11/04/2021 21:20

I think she calls twice a week, but messages more regularly by text and whatsapp. Not a casual friendship at all, which would be more understandable.

OP posts:
provencegal · 11/04/2021 21:19

The friendship not the thread obviously! Grin

I am a good friend, I actually expect a lot from her.

OP posts:
KickAssAngel · 11/04/2021 21:19

So she phones you several times a week to emotionally dump her problems on you, but forgot to mention the problem of finding a dinner date that wouldn't impact on you?

Well, she said it, you're all so busy. Shame you won't be able to listen to her problems any more.

provencegal · 11/04/2021 21:17

Thank you all, well I agree it is pretty shitty behaviour, but for whatever reason she felt this was a good move.

Who cares about looking weak? The objective is to heed the sign and get fucking rid. No one needs a showdown for that to happen

^ 100% this. pictish I am not getting involved in battles, and trying to win anything. I could not care less if she thinks she has 'won' good for her - but in my world friendships and good manners do not work like this. I am doing the running for the hills moment friendship wise.

I am not going to pitch myself against her, asking the whole group to take their pick. No way. Not because I am weak, but because I absolutely detest game playing and dishonesty.

To me, she has shown herself to be weak and desperate, wasting good friendships to score points. So good luck to her. I am not playing.

I am not fifteen, but properly grounded in middle age. I am trying to be a strong model to my own dc.

So better to quietly rearrange the nice friends. Fade out the friendship. No drama, no pitch battles and nothing for Friend A can say now. Low key change of date to me seems to be the best way to go, no one loses. No one is forced to decide what side they will choose. It is not fair on them.

If they were my only friends, maybe this would not be a good situation, but I have so many better friends that I can be spending my time and energy on. It is really low grade in my view. Gutter level.

I am not investing anymore time in this.

OP posts: