Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend is rude, yes or no? AIBU?

308 replies

provencegal · 11/04/2021 17:46

Please help me work out if I am being over sensitive.

Friendship group from children's primary school initially, but now very good friends of four years. We have lots of nights out, coffees and lunches at each other's houses. We have supported each other a lot over the years, and it has been great.

Four weeks ago I invited everyone to my garden for a late lunch at the end of this month - it is a delayed birthday celebration/ good excuse to get together. Everyone accepted and was really excited, it took some time to organise a good day for everyone.

Friend A calls me last night and tells me she can't make it, fine no worries. She then goes on to tell me she has organised a dinner the very same evening for twelve people. She has invited one half of the group (plus a few extras that are not part of our group) but not the others. And she hasn't included me either Shock which was awkward on the phone to say the least! I am not sure what she wanted me to say, I was just quite gobsmacked, so I said no worries, lets reschedule and left it at that.

I have since cancelled my lunch on that date, as it is going to be too awkward with half the group going to the 'after party' at friend A's house, and the other half left uninvited! The others do not know about the evening dinner yet.

I will meet them individually instead now I think.

To think she is a CF? Or is this okay?

OP posts:
stoopider · 11/04/2021 19:15

That was a nasty phone conversation.

Have you actually asked those two friends if they’d rather lunch with you or go to the dinner?

An assumption was made by you that they’d naturally accept her invite? Really they should decline as they’ve already accepted yours?

Is it worth messaging them each individually to have that conversation?

I’m also wondering why her dinner automatically trumps your lunch?

I’m also wondering if she called you to bully you to cancel so those two friends would come to her dinner. Would they maybe have already turned her down due to the lunch? It feels like a power play and you’re being too doormat about it.

provencegal · 11/04/2021 19:15

don't believe your friend is unaware of what she's doing. She's made the group choose between you or her. FWIW i think fading out is probably the best route. No unpleasant arguments, nobody has to take sides and you can still see the nicer ones out of the group. Who needs the drama?

Yes and to save them the pain, I have done it for them. It is just embarrassing and difficult and cringy.
I will take the good ones, and leave the rest to the drama, because this is not for me.

As an aside, the lunches/meals sound fascinating! Lunch as an all day event isn't something i've ever done

I can highly recommend this format! So much fun, and relaxed, and no one is tired the next day.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 11/04/2021 19:14

So nasty and rude.

At least you have a solid excuse to avoid.

Only the dregs of society behave so rudely.

I can well understand you not wishing to have such drama in your life.

She is not a friend and sounds as common as muck to behave in such a way.

Think about who you wish remain in contact with and move forward.

Some women are truly awful the way they have to cause drama.

Flowers
LoudestCat14 · 11/04/2021 19:14

I'm with 1angelic – you should go ahead with the friends who can make the lunch. You're now making it messy by cancelling on them. It really does feel like you're cutting your nose off to spite your face.

Hankunamatata · 11/04/2021 19:13

Are all your kids in school togther still?

Sorry she is a b*tch. Either she doesnt care and went ahead with the date or thought you would be a push over.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 11/04/2021 19:13

It’s like your punishing the friends who were looking forward to it!

Especially the ones who aren't invited to the dinner. Cancelling (after they accepted the invitation) sends the message that you don't consider it worth having people over for lunch if it might just be them.

provencegal · 11/04/2021 19:12

1angelic I will definitely see the others, and arrange something else on another day so no one loses out. I have rearranged one already, and will organise the others. I just can't do this lunch. It will get messy and competitive, and I am not up for that.

OP posts:
provencegal · 11/04/2021 19:09

I don't need her approval
I don't need 'friendship' like this
I thought we were all adults, this is not my thing at all!!

To be complete honest, I think a variation of this has been happening for a while, but because I am so busy and I don't really care if who is meeting who, I haven't noticed it very often. She definitely does top list though, and seems to enjoy the others vying for her attention/invites etc. I have tended to coast along and not get too involved, to now.

OP posts:
1AngelicFruitCake · 11/04/2021 19:09

I don’t think you should cancel. It’s like your punishing the friends who were looking forward to it!

LoudestCat14 · 11/04/2021 19:08

@provencegal

planty I don't want to be part of the group anymore. Far better to cancel and fade out. I am not going to all the trouble of organising a lunch for some of them will no doubt cancel on the day, realising they can't fit both in (as friend A) knows. There is drive involved and the timing will never work.

Our lunches work like this.
We arrive around 2pm - lunch at 3pm and continue for a few hours, drinks and chats finishing usually around 9.30pm. This has been the case since we first started them, so there is no way they can do both. They would have to cut mine short, or turn up at friend A's house at 10pm or later! Which is never going to happen, as Friend A knows.

Ah, that's my kind of lunch, OP!

Your "friend" has pulled a really shitty move if she knows that's how your lunches usually pan out. But don't step away from the group, that's just playing into her mean girls narrative. In fact, I would still stage the lunch with the friends not invited her to shindig. Why should you all miss out on a nice catch up just because she's being a bitch?

Brindisi32 · 11/04/2021 19:08

I don't believe your friend is unaware of what she's doing. She's made the group choose between you or her. FWIW i think fading out is probably the best route. No unpleasant arguments, nobody has to take sides and you can still see the nicer ones out of the group. Who needs the drama?

As an aside, the lunches/meals sound fascinating! Lunch as an all day event isn't something i've ever done.

SuperintendentHastings · 11/04/2021 19:08

Well yes she was being rude, but why on earth would you cancel your lunch? If your lunches go on til late then the people who have been invited would need to excuse themselves early and the rest of you can continue with your own fun.

She's a cheeky bint, but that's on her, not you.

Budsey · 11/04/2021 19:05

mmmmm a bit naughty and you wouldn't be doing tit for tat you had already organised your do .....sounds to me she aint no friend.....start distancing yourself she seems to be creating a spiteful girls group don't be fooled ....aaand don't be excited when she does invite you to another do as in you are in the (top list !)and some are left out to feel isolated...... bullying and very manipulative ! you don't need her approval !

Cherrysoup · 11/04/2021 19:04

I think she’s been really nasty. Phoning you to tell you this is plain weird.

provencegal · 11/04/2021 19:04

Do NOT fade out. That entire group invited accepted your invite. They like you and they are your friends. Reschedule with them without her

Yes some of the others and I are good friends. I thought I would organise seeing them in a very low key way. Very much want to avoid any drama. A lunch here, walk there and fade friend A out altogether. I don't intend to meet as a group again.

This did feel very pointed and very unkind.

For those asking the conversation was up there with the best when it comes to brass neck.
Friend A: 'Really sorry I can't come to your lunch provence, but I had to cancel my dinner in the lockdown and it needs to be rescheduled now as everyone is going away overseas as soon as possible. So it has to be that date'

Me: 'Okay well maybe you can come to the next lunch, no worries these things happen'

Friend ' Yes lets organise lunch another time. Obviously I would have loved to have invited everyone, but the limit is 12 and so only friend B and C are coming'

ME: 'Oh so you invited some of our group, that are coming to my lunch on that day?'

Friend: 'Yes, it was all arranged months ago'

Me: 'Okay well thats quite tricky on the same say Friend A given the distances and times, not sure that is going to work, and what about friend D and E?

Friend A: ' No they are not coming. I am glad I called to explain, you have been so good about this. As I said it really can't be on another day as everyone is so busy [chuckles]

Me: ' I have to go Amazon at the door (thankfully delivery from Amazon arriving and buzzing relentlessly by this stage) Talk soon'

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 11/04/2021 19:01

I think she is being weird organising for the same day but I would not have cancelled my plans - it was awkward for her not for you! I would have got everyone together and had a right all time!

BlackCatShadow · 11/04/2021 19:00

It all sounds a bit childish, but I agree that you were rude to cancel your lunch.

SionnachGlic · 11/04/2021 18:59

I wouldn't have cancelled mine...wd have explained to whomever showed up that half your invitees were poached & then got on with having a great evening. And very unfriend-like of her also hosting half your friends when she is also a 'friend' but didn't think to include you.

SheldonesqueHasTheWeevils · 11/04/2021 18:59

I’d get my lunch back on. Pronto.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 11/04/2021 18:55

Very rude of her, to the point of being intentionally offensive.

But I would not have cancelled, and I think it was a mistake to do so. Your lunch was organised first, and any awkwardness is not your responsibility. There is no reason to assume people would drop out, and this way it sort of looks as if you are flouncing.

BreakfastClub80 · 11/04/2021 18:54

That’s horrible, she’s horrible.
But please do meet up with your other friends, I’m sure you have many genuine lovely people to celebrate with!

RadandMad · 11/04/2021 18:54

Absolutely huge mean girl vibe. What sort of person does that? My advice would be to steer clear of her. No one needs those kinds of games in their life. The very best thing you could say about her is that she's grossly insensitive.

MrsBobDylan · 11/04/2021 18:52

She has more cheek than 10 bums Shock

I would have cancelled too.

Notoriouslynotnotious · 11/04/2021 18:51

In that case OP she is in proper mean girls territory.

stoopider · 11/04/2021 18:50

Do NOT fade out. That entire group invited accepted your invite. They like you and they are your friends. Reschedule with them without her. Do lots excluding her. Invite them individually to a group thing. Don’t let those friendships go, that’s what she wants