Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think calling in sick for no sleep is a good enough reason?

518 replies

Rachelinaa · 11/04/2021 03:16

I work in an office that's been open through most of lockdown due to admin we do being essential.
Recently one of my workmates has been calling in sick a lot because he hasn't been sleeping well as he's got a baby at home that won't sleep. I was shocked to hear other people at work saying they thought it was a ridiculous reason not to come to work and we've all had to come to work tired. But I thought they'd be able to see the difference between being tired and not sleeping at all. His baby has colic and the mum also works.
I've called in sick before for being too tired when my baby was a newborn and didn't sleep. I wondered what everyone else's thoughts on this was? I personally don't want someone driving to work if they're too tired to focus and I can't think that the boss would want someone in more likely to make mistakes.

OP posts:
sashh · 11/04/2021 05:46

What??? I get 10 paid Sick Days and 3 paid Personal Days a year (and I work in a school, so only working 10 months a year). I cant imagine the mentality of 3 sick days a year being a bad thing.

I used to get 6 months full pay and 6 months 1/2 pay. It varies by employer and often on length of service.

NoSquirrels · 11/04/2021 05:45

@AbsentmindedWoman

It’s not that in the UK you can’t have more than 3 days of sickness - many companies use something called the Bradford Factor to look at patterns of time off. Basically if someone takes lots of single days off - maybe in a pattern, like often Fridays or whatever- that can be more symptomatic of problematic absenteeism (‘swinging the lead’, as my late FIL would say) than an employee taking a 3-5 days off in a row once or twice a year.

The Bradford scale is pretty shit when you have a fluctuating condition, when your fitness for work can change by the day.

Oh yeah - I fully agree. My DH suffers with chronic migraine and needs to disclose this at any job offer/new job stage because of the bloody Bradford Factor! The article I linked does go into why it shouldn’t be used on its own for precisely the reason you give.
ElphabaTheGreen · 11/04/2021 05:41

If I call in sick (UK) I have to have a Return To Work interview and they specifically ask me the reason why I was off. I don't know what would happen if I refused to answer but presumably they expect to be told. So this is not quite right. I would love to not be asked the reason.

Yes - I have to do those return to work interviews with my staff. People are asked to provide a reason why they were off - ‘sickness’ is adequate. There is no requirement to go into details, although most people do to show they have nothing to hide.

Catswithflamingos · 11/04/2021 05:40

Why is he giving details are to why he is calling in sick? He just has to call in sick.

AbsentmindedWoman · 11/04/2021 05:39

It’s not that in the UK you can’t have more than 3 days of sickness - many companies use something called the Bradford Factor to look at patterns of time off. Basically if someone takes lots of single days off - maybe in a pattern, like often Fridays or whatever- that can be more symptomatic of problematic absenteeism (‘swinging the lead’, as my late FIL would say) than an employee taking a 3-5 days off in a row once or twice a year.

The Bradford scale is pretty shit when you have a fluctuating condition, when your fitness for work can change by the day.

somuchlaundrytowash · 11/04/2021 05:37

@somuchlaundrytowash

Yabu. The only time I've had extended time off ill was due to severe mh issues after baby was born ( psychiatrist sign off, not just the gp) I think taking time off just because your baby cries a lot is a bitHmm and dramatic My lo cried a lot but I just got on with it dragged up on psychiatrist prescribed medication at the time too.
Drugged of course, not dragged
GordonYaSelfishTwit · 11/04/2021 05:37

Im on the fence about this. Before having a baby with bad colic myself I'd have thought how ridiculous but there were days I honestly thought I was losing my mind after a run of several nights of barely any sleep. It can be absolute torture. I would just go into the other room and scream and throw things sometimes.

I remember once after having about 30 minutes sleep all day and night for about two days on the trot, driving to my husband's work and telling him he needed to get in the car and come home RN because DS was trying to kill me 🤣 (he's SE though tbf). He did come home with me and I slept for about 24hrs whilst he looked after DS. It was the best sleep I've ever had.

somuchlaundrytowash · 11/04/2021 05:36

Yabu. The only time I've had extended time off ill was due to severe mh issues after baby was born ( psychiatrist sign off, not just the gp) I think taking time off just because your baby cries a lot is a bitHmm and dramatic
My lo cried a lot but I just got on with it dragged up on psychiatrist prescribed medication at the time too.

nancywhitehead · 11/04/2021 05:35

@ElphabaTheGreen

I went back to work full time (clinical staff on hospital wards) when non-sleeper DS1 was eight months old and still waking 8+ times a night. He wouldn’t settle for DH so I was doing every one of those night wakings. It was the same all over again for DS2. If being tired/underslept because of a baby was a reason to call in sick, I could have taken three or four years off work. You harden to it, you survive you crack on.

I'm in Australia and over here when you call in sick you don't give the details of your illness. Your manager is not allowed to ask. Most companies offer a certain amount of sick days that you are expected to use. It's a brilliant system.

I’m from Australia originally - it’s really not much different in the UK. I found there was just as much presenteeism in Australia as in the UK - or conversely eyebrows raised when you suspected someone of ‘chucking a sickie’. Sick leave is paid in both countries and you’re not required in the UK to say why you’re calling in sick, although the vast majority of people would disclose so the employer has a reasonable idea of when to expect them back. I never got the sense in Australia that I was ‘expected to take’ sick leave...it’s there if you need it, just like the UK.

If I call in sick (UK) I have to have a Return To Work interview and they specifically ask me the reason why I was off. I don't know what would happen if I refused to answer but presumably they expect to be told. So this is not quite right. I would love to not be asked the reason.
GeronimoHate · 11/04/2021 05:35

When my kids have had a poor night’s sleep - they go into school late - they don’t take the day off. I would not be impressed with a work colleague taking a whole day off in these circumstances but you’ll get people who’ll take a day off for a sneeze.

nancywhitehead · 11/04/2021 05:33

@user7891011

Just because some of you have insomnia and deal with lack of sleep everyday doesn't mean this guy can deal with it as well as you. You should all know the impact it can have on your mental health as well🤔 have some compassion. He has to be fully functioning to look after the baby at night also whereas you can just lie there not using energy. YANBU
This. YANBU. I also agree with the person who said the UK's attitude to sickness is pretty appalling it's like a competition as to who can drag themselves in when they are not fit for work.

It really doesn't matter what other people think, it only matters how he feels. Sounds like he's a generally good employee and not taking the mick - as an adult he can judge for himself if he is capable to work or not.

ElphabaTheGreen · 11/04/2021 05:25

I went back to work full time (clinical staff on hospital wards) when non-sleeper DS1 was eight months old and still waking 8+ times a night. He wouldn’t settle for DH so I was doing every one of those night wakings. It was the same all over again for DS2. If being tired/underslept because of a baby was a reason to call in sick, I could have taken three or four years off work. You harden to it, you survive you crack on.

I'm in Australia and over here when you call in sick you don't give the details of your illness. Your manager is not allowed to ask. Most companies offer a certain amount of sick days that you are expected to use. It's a brilliant system.

I’m from Australia originally - it’s really not much different in the UK. I found there was just as much presenteeism in Australia as in the UK - or conversely eyebrows raised when you suspected someone of ‘chucking a sickie’. Sick leave is paid in both countries and you’re not required in the UK to say why you’re calling in sick, although the vast majority of people would disclose so the employer has a reasonable idea of when to expect them back. I never got the sense in Australia that I was ‘expected to take’ sick leave...it’s there if you need it, just like the UK.

ForwardRanger · 11/04/2021 05:06

@Embracingthechaos

The UK is ridiculous about sickness in the work place. It's like it's a competition to see who can run themselves the most ragged, and the winner is admired as being so dedicated. It's unhealthy and sad.

He is an adult and he decides for himself whether or not he is fit for work that day. It's pathetic to sit around gossiping about the validity of his reason. If he is off sick enough that the company policy dictates some kind of intervention then that is between him and his line manager.

I'm in Australia and over here when you call in sick you don't give the details of your illness. Your manager is not allowed to ask. Most companies offer a certain amount of sick days that you are expected to use. It's a brilliant system.

So, so agree.

The English workplace backstabbery is awful.

GaspingGekko · 11/04/2021 05:04

Curious to know if the babies mum is also needing to call in sick from tiredness.

Pyewackect · 11/04/2021 04:54

We are short staffed as it is ( NHS ). If somebody doesn’t turn-up for a shift we all suffer. If you can’t do the job then you need to move on.

NoSquirrels · 11/04/2021 04:48

It’s not that in the UK you can’t have more than 3 days of sickness - many companies use something called the Bradford Factor to look at patterns of time off. Basically if someone takes lots of single days off - maybe in a pattern, like often Fridays or whatever- that can be more symptomatic of problematic absenteeism (‘swinging the lead’, as my late FIL would say) than an employee taking a 3-5 days off in a row once or twice a year.

This lays it out well
www.brighthr.com/articles/leave-and-absence/the-bradford-factor/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-the-bradford-factor/

UseMyName · 11/04/2021 04:42

This is why the world would be a different place is men had the children and looked after them, women are expected to suffer in silence.

Sleep deprivation is so hard but how many women on here say the night waking is all/mostly left up to them?

Sounds like this guy is doing his share, which is how it should be.

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 11/04/2021 04:37

@Embracingthechaos

The UK is ridiculous about sickness in the work place. It's like it's a competition to see who can run themselves the most ragged, and the winner is admired as being so dedicated. It's unhealthy and sad.

He is an adult and he decides for himself whether or not he is fit for work that day. It's pathetic to sit around gossiping about the validity of his reason. If he is off sick enough that the company policy dictates some kind of intervention then that is between him and his line manager.

I'm in Australia and over here when you call in sick you don't give the details of your illness. Your manager is not allowed to ask. Most companies offer a certain amount of sick days that you are expected to use. It's a brilliant system.

I agree. I'm in the United States, and we get called out on our Health Care System all the time (as we should). But at least we have reasonable Sick Time. @MadMadMadamMim says people would be on an absenteeism plan after 3 sick days IN A YEAR. What??? I get 10 paid Sick Days and 3 paid Personal Days a year (and I work in a school, so only working 10 months a year). I cant imagine the mentality of 3 sick days a year being a bad thing.
NoSquirrels · 11/04/2021 04:30

Recently one of my workmates has been calling in sick a lot because he hasn't been sleeping well as he's got a baby at home that won't sleep. I was shocked to hear other people at work saying they thought it was a ridiculous reason not to come to work and we've all had to come to work tired. But I thought they'd be able to see the difference between being tired and not sleeping at all. His baby has colic and the mum also works.

Well, I’m not sure.

  1. How much is ‘a lot’?
  2. Is his baby very young (colic usually implies this)?

It’s relatively unusual mum would be back at work in the very early days, and the older the baby the less likely it’s ‘colic’ and the more likely just a poor sleeper - like loads of babies. Parents usually cope by sorting shifts to sleep between themselves so both get a decent chunk.

Sleep is vitally important and in an ideal world you’d be able to take time off for this, but it’s not ‘sick leave’, really, is it? Especially where it’s caused by a baby! It’s not unexpected that babies sleep poorly in the first 6 months to a year (or longer - DC1 Shock) so as you know you need to work you need to get a system going as personal responsibility. It’s not your employer’s issue, it’s yours - you can’t expect business to cater absolutely to this.

So if his baby has either a chronic issue (which colic is not, although deeply frustrating and worrying at the time!) or it’s a short term thing to allow them to sort out a sleep pattern/a one-off then fine. But to do it ‘a lot’ is taking the piss and I’m not at all surprised your colleagues aren’t impressed.

I can’t help but think a woman would not be given as much sympathy...

user7891011 · 11/04/2021 04:30

Just because some of you have insomnia and deal with lack of sleep everyday doesn't mean this guy can deal with it as well as you. You should all know the impact it can have on your mental health as well🤔 have some compassion. He has to be fully functioning to look after the baby at night also whereas you can just lie there not using energy.
YANBU

user1481840227 · 11/04/2021 04:19

I'd imagine there is a lot more to this than just simply being tired.
Most of us have had periods of our lives where we're tired for various reasons, obviously having babies is a big one.

But then there are sleep issues like insomnia etc. and for me that is extremely different. When I have periods of chronic insomnia I get very low emotionally to the point of being suicidal, which is not uncommon with insomnia.

There could be more to it and this man is not sleeping for other reasons and just using the baby as an excuse because he doesn't want the whole office to know his business, how did you all find out his reason for calling in sick??

Hoop148 · 11/04/2021 04:11

@Embracingthechaos

The UK is ridiculous about sickness in the work place. It's like it's a competition to see who can run themselves the most ragged, and the winner is admired as being so dedicated. It's unhealthy and sad.

He is an adult and he decides for himself whether or not he is fit for work that day. It's pathetic to sit around gossiping about the validity of his reason. If he is off sick enough that the company policy dictates some kind of intervention then that is between him and his line manager.

I'm in Australia and over here when you call in sick you don't give the details of your illness. Your manager is not allowed to ask. Most companies offer a certain amount of sick days that you are expected to use. It's a brilliant system.

Agree with this!
Hoop148 · 11/04/2021 04:10

Have you read Why We Sleep by Matthew Walker? Sleep is so insanely essential - so I think YANBU.

We need to give sleep more credit and importance.

Bameish · 11/04/2021 04:06

@grapewine

I suffer from insomnia. I sleep on average three hours a night, sometimes not at all, that's how it's looking this morning. It's almost 5am where I am. I still have to be ready for the day in 4 hours. YABU.
Snap. I have to suck it up on three hours' sleep, why should anyone with a baby not have to do the same? Why does he think he deserves special treatment? He's in a two-parent situation; he has options. He's choosing not to exercise any of them.

Is it possible for the man to work from home and/or flex his hours? Did he take paternity leave when his wife gave birth? Could he take paternity leave/an unpaid sabbatical now?

CeeceeBloomingdale · 11/04/2021 04:02

It's not something I would do or indeed expect anyone else to do unless their job risks the safety of others.