Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think calling in sick for no sleep is a good enough reason?

518 replies

Rachelinaa · 11/04/2021 03:16

I work in an office that's been open through most of lockdown due to admin we do being essential.
Recently one of my workmates has been calling in sick a lot because he hasn't been sleeping well as he's got a baby at home that won't sleep. I was shocked to hear other people at work saying they thought it was a ridiculous reason not to come to work and we've all had to come to work tired. But I thought they'd be able to see the difference between being tired and not sleeping at all. His baby has colic and the mum also works.
I've called in sick before for being too tired when my baby was a newborn and didn't sleep. I wondered what everyone else's thoughts on this was? I personally don't want someone driving to work if they're too tired to focus and I can't think that the boss would want someone in more likely to make mistakes.

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 11/04/2021 11:02

I've called in sick before for being too tired when my baby was a newborn and didn't sleep

OP did you not take maternity leave when you had a newborn?

LakieLady · 11/04/2021 11:02

I agree. I'm in the United States, and we get called out on our Health Care System all the time (as we should). But at least we have reasonable Sick Time. @MadMadMadamMim says people would be on an absenteeism plan after 3 sick days IN A YEAR. What??? I get 10 paid Sick Days and 3 paid Personal Days a year (and I work in a school, so only working 10 months a year). I cant imagine the mentality of 3 sick days a year being a bad thing

It's a bit more complicated than that, and even in workplaces that use the Bradford Factor, most people wouldn't even be spoken to if they had a week off with flu. It's more designed to catch out those who are frequently off on a Monday because they're hungover after being out on the piss all weekend.

And most employers are pretty reasonable about longer term sickness that is verified by a doctor. I had 2 months off sick earlier this year following a bereavement, because I was simply too distraught to work (and that followed 3 weeks' compassionate leave on full pay). Later in the year, I'll be having a few more weeks off sick, because I'm having my knee replaced.

All of it will be at full pay (we get 6 months full pay and 6 months half pay per year if off sick, which mirrors what most public sector staff get).

And that's on top of 6 weeks paid holiday (legal minimum in UK is 4 weeks) plus 8 paid public holidays (possibly more in Scotland and NI).
A lot of employers in manufacturing, construction, some non-essential public services and many private companies shut down for 7-10 days over Christmas/New Year as well but continue to pay staff in full.

Ten paid sick days a year would seem really mean to many in the UK.

GeronimoHate · 11/04/2021 11:00

The parents know their baby doesn't sleep well so they should be taking turns and getting enough sleep - they are not working long hours. If they don't want to do this they should be taking parental unpaid leave.

EL8888 · 11/04/2021 10:57

@WeAllHaveWings exactly, my sleep hasn’t been great for the past 6 years but l can’t phone in sick all the time.

Rachelinaa · 11/04/2021 10:55

I think it's a little unfair on those without children

Why? I'm not saying having children is the only reason to call in sick for tiredness. I think being too tired for work is a legitimate reason not to go in if you're too tired to function properly. If someone without children was up all night with anxiety or a sleep disorder or other things then I'd say that's good enough reason too if it's becoming a daily issue.

OP posts:
TheGoogleMum · 11/04/2021 10:54

I've done it before when my insomnia was awful. I have to drive on the motorway to get get work and wouldn't feel safe driving on no sleep. Also hard to perform well. Not sure why so many have voted YABU really!

housemdwaswrong · 11/04/2021 10:54

I think it depends. A poor nights sleep for most people is just a suck it up situation, so with no underlying conditions I'dsay it's unreasonable.

It depends on how it affects you though.
Because of my lupus, sustained lack of sleep will bring on lack of balance, coordination and a huge drop in cognitive ability. I wouldn't drive that's for sure.

I think that's probably relatively rare though, and I go to work when I'm 'normal tired' as most of us have to.

NoSquirrels · 11/04/2021 10:53

The thing is, OP, the employer has a duty of care to their employees, yes - allowing them time off sick and not discriminating. But they also have a duty to their other employees to operate a fair, equitable system - not putting others under pressure for a less than reliable colleague.

The odd day off to catch up on sleep because of a non-sleeping baby - fine.

But a pattern of this - not so good, because if the baby is as young as you say this could persist for years.

As an employer I’d also be concerned about attitude towards how they view their role at work as secondary to their personal life. It’s secondary for al of us - work to live is better than live to work! - but you can’t expect an employer to prioritise your ‘I don’t see my partner if we take shifts with the baby’ as anything other than an irrelevant reason to their business concerns.

In a situation like this, as others have said, there’s asking to flex hours, reduce hours temporarily, spell of parental leave etc that should be considered if the situation is so severe that both parents are taking time off work (‘a lot’, you said). Sick leave persistently in this situation isn’t appropriate.

Rachelinaa · 11/04/2021 10:51

I don't really have a problem with people assuming I'm the wife of the man in question since I'm clearly saying I believe it's fine and had zero shame doing it myself when my DS was small, but it seems most Mumsnet posts turn into this, where people want it to be more personal so their insults and attacks hopefully bruise more.
If it was about me, I'd have posted it was about me and my husband. But why would it make a difference eitherway? Why do people want it to be about me just so they think their opinion can sting more to say you think it's not a valid reason? Also don't you all talk to people you work with? We sit in an office for 8 hours a day doing admin, if we didn't talk we'd drive ourselves mad.

OP posts:
WeAllHaveWings · 11/04/2021 10:50

If I phoned in sick everytime I never got a lot of sleep I would have been off sick 50% of the time for the first couple of years after ds was born and 50% of the time now (menopause and insomnia).

The disruption of regular off sick due to lack of sleep won't be tolerated by most employers for long.

The couple have the option to need to sleep in shifts until they resolve the babys sleeping, even if it means one going to bed very very early. I often went to bed midweek before 8pm when ds was little to catch up on sleep.

SunbathingDragon · 11/04/2021 10:48

Having had a child who turned out to just not need much sleep and never slept longer than two hours in his first two years, I have a lot of sympathy. However, work still expected me to do 12+ hour shifts including driving at 90+mph to keep people alive so I’m also quite used to employers not having the same level of sympathy.

He’d probably do better to call in with how he actually feels eg lack of sleep can make you feel sick and exhausted, rather than saying his baby isn’t sleeping.

converseandjeans · 11/04/2021 10:47

I would have thought colic would be over by the time the mother went back to work.

This is why I did a routine with mine (back when DD was 5 months & DS 6 months) so I would be able to get enough sleep to function at work. It's always criticised on MN.

I don't think it's a valid reason - they need to sort out the baby's sleep. Hire a sleep consultant (who will probably charge a few hundred quid and tell them to try a routine 🤷🏻‍♀️)

yupyupyup · 11/04/2021 10:46

I think it's a little unfair on those without children. I wouldn't dream of calling in sick due to tiredness and I'd be on edge all day, worrying about having to go back to work and explain myself! So I probably wouldn't sleep anyway!

I remember a time I called in sick with a hangover. Obvs I didn't tell work the real reason... But I was right as rain by lunchtime and could easily have gone in and done my 8 hours, just later in the day. Similar with the OPs post... Get some kip and do your shift later on. I truly wish the workplace was more flexible like that.

Cannotgarden · 11/04/2021 10:45

Both my DC have woken every hour until 2 and then woken 3-4 times a night until 3. I had to get on with it. Sugar is your friend.

GeronimoHate · 11/04/2021 10:44

I don't understand why both parents are back at work when the baby is so young - colic lasts from 6-12 weeks old doesn't it? - The mother works for the NHS surely she should be entitled to full enhanced maternity pay - this all seems a bit odd.

Rachelinaa · 11/04/2021 10:44

@Hardbackwriter I've worked with him for several years. People talk at work and tell each other things.
And I know it's temporary but many couples struggle at the beginning with a baby, not spending time together isn't always a solution that fits everyone's relationship. My DH and I were fine nodding to one another on the way by as one got up and the other went to bed, but it's not for everyone and we shouldn't expect it to be.

OP posts:
8dpwoah · 11/04/2021 10:41

Isn't NHS maternity reasonably fair compared with SMP (assume she qualifies). If they've made a conscious choice to both be back at work when the child is younger than 'normal' then having sleep disturbances is part and parcel of that, surely? There's a reason SMP is paid til 9 months. Not that it guarantees baby is sleeping through (I went back at 9 months, she definitely wasn't!) But it gives you a fighting chance of having a few hours between wake-ups.
I've made some inferences there but what I'm saying is that whatever work/child decisions have been made they all have upsides and downsides and you can't expect other people to be impacted by the downsides you've selected to accept.

GeronimoHate · 11/04/2021 10:40

I think this is not a workmate - this is the OP's husband and you are both taking the piss.

sst1234 · 11/04/2021 10:40

It’s not the problem for your colleagues that you can’t sleep because of your baby. They woos almost always pick up the slack. Your choices, your responsibility.

Daleksatemyshed · 11/04/2021 10:39

@OverTheRubicon, it's my choice to take leave not my employers, I'm still entitled to sick leave. I only have a few more years to work and I'd find it hard to get another job so I'm willing to sacrifice leave to stay where I am. I'm afraid that with the impact of Covid and the poor economy people are going to have to face the fact that companies can pick and choose staff now.

NoSquirrels · 11/04/2021 10:39

I'm going to take a wild guess that the wife is you and the man is your DH?

My thoughts too, Hardback

It really is pretty unusual in the UK for both parents to be back at work with a baby young enough to be up all hours with ‘colic’ and not to have put into place a sleep system that enables them both to work.

It’s not that taking time off for lack of sleep is wrong; sleep is vital.

It’s whether steps are being taken to mitigate the effect on the employer and the employee for a predictable side effect of having a baby!

user7891011 · 11/04/2021 10:38

@SnowAllSpring

this guy obviously doesn't want to be there and has no obligation to do so either

He sort of does have an obligation to be there. That's what a job is.

Huh? To be at the point of a mental health breakdown like that poster? I'm not talking about his obligation to be at work
SnowAllSpring · 11/04/2021 10:36

this guy obviously doesn't want to be there and has no obligation to do so either

He sort of does have an obligation to be there. That's what a job is.

Me33 · 11/04/2021 10:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at OP's request.

SnowAllSpring · 11/04/2021 10:36

It's been obvious from your first post that you're the wife. Your last post confirms it. You and your husband need to get your act together.