Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I register baby with his last name?

165 replies

hgersta · 09/04/2021 21:51

I'm new here so I'm not sure where to put this.

I gave birth a week ago. When I was pregnant me and baby's dad argued a lot. When we found out I was pregnant he blamed me but then he apologised. We then split up in October because we constantly argued although we were still good friends. In January we decided to give it another go and since then we've argued a couple of times but not as much as last year. When I was pregnant I was told not to put his name on the birth certificate or give baby his last name by different family members.

I'm not sure now though as so far he's been a 'good' dad (although it's only been a week so it could change).

What would you do?

OP posts:
BusyLizzie61 · 10/04/2021 07:24

The best advice is your surname, and not on the bc. A week of father of the year is easy, though he hasn't managed any as partner of the year by the sounds of it...

However, if you want an amicable relationship, then likelihood is that this will hamper the relationship.

But in terms of protecting you and your lo, as lone parents, if you think this is inevitable, then I would keep that safeguarding. It doesn't mean that he couldn't still have contact etc if you split and would still be liable for paying child maintenance regardless of the bc.

MazekeenSmith · 10/04/2021 06:59

Why would any woman who has just given birth to a baby and split with the partner name the baby with the ex's last name??

KoalaOok · 10/04/2021 06:52

Register in your name. If he asks about it and shows an interest in registering the baby then I'd put him on the certificate. If he can't be bothered to look into registering the baby himself or show any interest then leave him off.

insancerre · 10/04/2021 06:49

The baby gets your name unless you both register the birth together and chose to put his
You can’t register in his name unless he is there if you are not married

DifficultBloodyWoman · 10/04/2021 06:43

This reply has been deleted

Post references deleted post Talk Guidelines.

Shoxfordian · 10/04/2021 06:07

Has he even proposed at any point? If he hasn’t offered you his name then you shouldn’t give it to the baby. Give the baby your name and think seriously about whether you want to stay with him

Rangoon · 10/04/2021 05:50

He hasn't married you. You've had the baby. Why should the baby have his surname? I would never put him on the birth certificate in these cirumstances as he'll end up with rights and you'll have all the responsibility. So far he's been supportive for a whole week. If he sticks around - which I very much doubt - it can be amended later. It doesnt mean he can't see the baby or spend time with her. He doesnt need to be on the birth certificate for you to claim child support either.

WisnaeMe · 10/04/2021 05:47

@ivfbeenbusy

He needs to go on the birth certificate - you were "adult" enough to make a baby with him and his contribution in that respect deserves recognition. You sound incredibly immature to leave him off because you had a few silly arguments and broke up for a while - whose to say the arguments weren't your fault - you don't get Carte Blanche because you're a woman and pregnant but MN does love to use the birth certificate to punish men. As for the name no you don't need to give the child his

I think OP's ex found the Thread

Rainbowqueeen · 10/04/2021 03:34

Your name. It will make life easier for you and is super easy to change to dads name later. Changing from dads name to mums name later is much more difficult and expensive

It’s really up to him if he is on the birth certificate as he has to go along. It’s a whole different set of issues as that gives him parental responsibility. Just remember even if he isn’t on there he will have to pay CMS. It sounds like you are not living together so please apply for that now. It may give you a sense of whether it would be a good idea to have him on the birth certificate. If he kicks off about paying the bare minimum to raise his child what does that say about him

And congrats on your baby

ivfbeenbusy · 10/04/2021 03:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 10/04/2021 02:28

No!

  1. You cannot put him on the birth certificate as you are not married. He has to put himself of the birth certificate. That is a separate issue to naming your baby.
  1. Do not give the baby his last name. There are lots of reasons for this (and some are better than others):
  • tradition - children traditionally have their mother’s surname which may or may not be the same as their father’s surname
  • spite - your on again/off again boyfriend hasn’t given you his name (via the security of marriage) so why would you give his name to your child?
  • practicality - you will be dealing with your child’s healthcare and education and travel to much greater degree than your on/off boyfriend so make sure those professionals easily link you and your baby
  • realistically, (I’m sorry) - you are unlikely to still be a couple in 10 years time. Do you really want the reminder of your exes name every day?
  • practicality (again) - if you marry him later it is very easy to change the child’s name. If you split up later, it is virtually impossible to change to your name.
WisnaeMe · 10/04/2021 02:14

Absolutely NOT.

Give baby YOUR surname OP Flowers

KarmaNoMore · 10/04/2021 01:12

In a nutshell: you just give your child a his name if he is likely to be present to raise child most of the time.

By the way, keeping him off the birth certificate is not a long term safety net, any man can get parental responsibility by simply requesting a DNA test in court.

Uniquerandomer · 10/04/2021 01:05

@girlofnow

If the OP is flagging this up, she must have doubts. I am just making her aware, incase there is any DV or issues going on, it could become a living nightmare for her if he is on the birth certificate.

Fuckitfuckit · 10/04/2021 01:01

Honestly, I'd say no.
DDs dad was useless, unbelievably so, I wanted her to have her fathers last name, I wanted him to have the same parental rights as me.

Even now I am paying for that woeful mistake.

He hasn't seen DD for 8 years. He hasn't sent a birthday or Christmas card, she has shoes that cost more than his input into her upbringing. He still has equal rights to her as I do.

All I can see, from my position is that you will be opening the door for him to cause trouble if he wishes to.

I'm sorry, I wish I could be more positive... its possible to give him parental rights when your child is a little older. I think its easier to give those rights than it is to take them away.

girlofnow · 10/04/2021 00:41

@YoniAndGuy

No no no no no!!

Your name.

He could be a distant memory in a year. And you’ll be left having a different family name to the child you’re raising.

Your surname. Every single time.

And being on the birth certificate is about a lot more than ‘recognition’. It gives him legal rights over your child. You never know how things are going to pan out, so no - don’t hand on a plate to this man the right to disagree that you should be able to move, to send your child to X school - everything.

Like others have said - if things work out - fine - you can add names, you can change surnames. But you can’t take him off the birth cert if he turns out to be a nightmare.

Well it gives him legal rights over his own child. This whole thread seems to be how to screw you child's father out of any relationship with them. And I've not seen why.
girlofnow · 10/04/2021 00:34

@Uniquerandomer

Give the baby your surname. Just so you know if you put his name on the birth certificate he will automatically have parental responsibility and rights.
But he's the father of the baby, whether he's with the OP or not is sort of irrelevant. Sounds like a volatile relationship. But maybe he wants to parent his baby?
girlofnow · 10/04/2021 00:30

In your situation I wouldn't. But it's just a name. My kids have their father's name but it doesn't make any difference to how I parent them. I keep reading horror stories about going on holiday with passports in different names but it's never been an issue. And that's the only complication I can think of.

Uniquerandomer · 10/04/2021 00:22

Give the baby your surname. Just so you know if you put his name on the birth certificate he will automatically have parental responsibility and rights.

Putthebiglighton · 10/04/2021 00:19

@StrawBeretMoose I’ve put mine first at least..but felt weird about that too. I guess with both our names it’s completely 50/50, not sure how these things work

Putthebiglighton · 10/04/2021 00:18

@StrawBeretMoose I honestly never knew that most babies take their mother’s surname. I think he would’ve wondered why it has to be my name and not his 🤷🏻‍♀️We’re together and we’re signing it together etc

JackieTheFart · 10/04/2021 00:15

I wouldn’t. He has proven himself an unreliable boyfriend, and I suspect he’d be an even more unreliable father.

SarahAndQuack · 10/04/2021 00:13

[quote MNWorldisCrazy]**@SarahAndQuack* That is not how birth certificates are set up to work.*

Erm. Yes that's exactly how they're set up to work!! To CERTIFY who the child''s biological parents are Hmm[/quote]
No, they don't.

This is a common misconception.

In fact, birth certificates by default assume that a married woman's husband is her child's father. Often, women who are acting as surrogates have to navigate this issue.

It is also perfectly legitimate to register two parents who cannot possibly, biologically, both be parents to a child. For example, if a lesbian couple decide to have a baby, the birth certificate will state that the mother is the woman who gave birth, and her female partner will be registered as the other parent.

No one imagines that all children born to married women are the biological offspring of those women's husbands (especially in the case where a married woman is a surrogate for another family!), and no one thinks that two women can be biological parents to the same baby. But birth certificates are designed to record both of those situations.

There is really no reason they can't cope with a much simpler situation where the OP just leaves a section blank!

StrawBeretMoose · 10/04/2021 00:10

@OddshoesOddsocks

Definitely your name and I’d think VERY carefully about putting him on the BC at all.

When dd1 was born my mum came at me with the ‘dd needs him to be on it’ argument so I went with it and I’ve regretted it ever since. This man has been absent for the last 6 years of her life, no contact, no money, no nothing and could snap his fingers at any second and demand to see her and I’d have to agree. He stops me having the freedom to live my life completely independently of him whilst he is able to live completely independently of me with no repercussions.

I know his name, I’m in contact with some of his family, we could find each other if needs be and, more importantly, dd could find him if she wanted. Being on the BC has no baring on whether the child knows their dad or not, the parents do and if he wants to be involved then he should prove it rather than be given the power to stop you raising your child as you see fit at the drop of a hat!

Sorry you received bad advice @OddshoesOddsocks. We were really shocked when my parents advised my sister not to put the father's name on my niece's birth certificate but it has worked out for the best.

The father's name doesn't need to be on a birth certificate to know it's their father, you can just tell them. Confused

How many kids have even seen their birth certificate by the time they leave primary school? Doesn't mean they don't know who their father is.
My niece knows who her father is, he plays a part in her upbringing but doesn't have a casting vote or a way to make my sister's life difficult.

Strokethefurrywall · 10/04/2021 00:02

Why the hell would you give your child this fools name? What exactly has he contributed aside from his spunk! Fuck. All.

Women too easily believe that if they give the baby the dads name then it will somehow mean he will morph into some dad/partner of the year and be with you through thick and thin. I'm going to take a wild stab in the dark that this happens in fewer than 25% of the cases (figures based on nothing at all but casual observation).

Why give him any credit when you're the one who has grown, birthed and cared for this human?