Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I register baby with his last name?

165 replies

hgersta · 09/04/2021 21:51

I'm new here so I'm not sure where to put this.

I gave birth a week ago. When I was pregnant me and baby's dad argued a lot. When we found out I was pregnant he blamed me but then he apologised. We then split up in October because we constantly argued although we were still good friends. In January we decided to give it another go and since then we've argued a couple of times but not as much as last year. When I was pregnant I was told not to put his name on the birth certificate or give baby his last name by different family members.

I'm not sure now though as so far he's been a 'good' dad (although it's only been a week so it could change).

What would you do?

OP posts:
Fuckitsstillraining · 02/05/2021 16:34

I'm astounded by suggestions that you don't put the fathers name on the birth certificate. I gave my son my surname but absolutely put his fathers name on the birth cert. Its a legal document and I think should be filled in honestly and completely. I'd hate any child to see a birth certificate with a blank place instead if a parents name.

Pinkpaisley · 02/05/2021 16:18

I’m happily married to my child’s father, she still has my surname.

cptartapp · 02/05/2021 16:16

Men want the status of the surname but most don't even bother with 50/50 in a split. All talk, no action.
Your relationship doesn't sound promising.
Your name.

Boo2997 · 02/05/2021 16:06

Personally I would give your baby your surname. I say this from experience. I had an on/off relationship with DS’s dad throughout pregnancy and he was in and out. Sometimes full on and sometimes non existent same after DS was born. It was a novelty when DS was born, things seemed great but he has been really inconsistent.

I am glad that DS took my name. His dad was still on birth certificate but there’s nothing wrong with a baby taking the mothers surname at all.

TurquoiseDragon · 02/05/2021 16:01

I think it should be law if unmarried the baby gets mother’s surname and I don’t know why there isn’t a law brought out for it to save so many arguments. I hate the thought of not having same surname as the baby but would also like to know if baby has his surname does he have more rights? He’s so bloody controlling!

Why are you with him @Dannibear7 ?

You don't need a law about surnames. Only you can register the birth of the baby, he can't. You should secretly go and register the baby with your surname and his name not on the birth certificate and then dump his controlling arse.

If you put him on the birth certificate (regardless of the surname) he could take your baby away and the police wouldn't be able to do anything because he is an equal parent to you in the eyes of the law. You'd have to go to court to get your baby back which could take a long time. Protect yourself and your baby.

It's already the legal default that the mother's name is used, it just so happens that if the parents are married it's also the father's name.

But yes, a father''s name (if the parents are not married) can only be added if they attend the appointment with the mother.

And fathers can't take a baby away if they aren't on the BC, the police can definitely get involved if the father doesn't have PR.

TurquoiseDragon · 02/05/2021 15:54

@DifficultBloodyWoman

No!
  1. You cannot put him on the birth certificate as you are not married. He has to put himself of the birth certificate. That is a separate issue to naming your baby.
  1. Do not give the baby his last name. There are lots of reasons for this (and some are better than others):
  • tradition - children traditionally have their mother’s surname which may or may not be the same as their father’s surname
  • spite - your on again/off again boyfriend hasn’t given you his name (via the security of marriage) so why would you give his name to your child?
  • practicality - you will be dealing with your child’s healthcare and education and travel to much greater degree than your on/off boyfriend so make sure those professionals easily link you and your baby
  • realistically, (I’m sorry) - you are unlikely to still be a couple in 10 years time. Do you really want the reminder of your exes name every day?
  • practicality (again) - if you marry him later it is very easy to change the child’s name. If you split up later, it is virtually impossible to change to your name.
In addition, if he's on the BC, he has equal rights regarding the baby and any decisions.

Means that it's never straight forward parenting by the mother.

I've seen more than one thread on MN where the father has taken the baby and refused to hand it back, leaving the mother having to go to court to try and get her baby back. If a father has PR, the police will not get involved.

As for this particular situation, I also do not think this relationship will last. I feel OP should give baby her surname, and also leave him off the BC for now.

SelkieFly · 02/05/2021 15:43

Give the baby your name.
You won't be preventing him from being a good man or a good father. He will have the freedom to be a good father, so, stand back and seee what he's got.

HerRoyalRisesAgain · 02/05/2021 15:40

Dannibear7 that's only tradition if you're married. Traditionally and historically a child took the mithers name if born out of wedlock.

Dannibear7 · 02/05/2021 15:33

Hi everyone thanks for reply's. Well I feel I am with him because of the baby now because he's already threatened to take her 50% she's a newborn and I'd be devastated if he did that but he would try to so I stay with him for my baby even though he's so controlling. All he says it's tradition to have his name and not mine but honestly if I didn't sign with his name as surname he would make my life awful for me so don't think it's worth it

AnotherEmma · 02/05/2021 14:50

@Dannibear7
The name is the least of your worries. LTB.

2bazookas · 02/05/2021 14:31

If you are not married, then if you go alone to register the birth you will not be allowed to register BF as the father. He has to be there himself, with proof of ID , to confirm he accepts the child is his.

CoffeeBeansGalore · 02/05/2021 14:21

@Dannibear7 Stop asking him, just go and register your child's birth with your name. If you feel like being kind then add his surname as a second middle name. He has not married you, why would baby only have his name? As others have stated he can hold control over you and your baby if you name him on the certificate. Don't give him that power.

Make your life hell? Quite honestly if he is that nasty why do you want him around?

yikesanotherbooboo · 02/05/2021 14:13

There is no reason for unmarried couples to even consider father's name. Even if you are married it is a moot point unless you share a surname. Add a complicated relationship into the mix and the risk that you might not be together for the rest of your baby's childhood and it really could be a big mistake and very unfair on your child.

LittlestBoho · 02/05/2021 14:11

@Dannibear7

Yeah I feel exactly the same but honestly he would make my life hell if I didn’t let him, I’ve asked for double barrel and he has said no to that aswell. We do all the hard work I think it should be law if unmarried the baby gets mother’s surname and I don’t know why there isn’t a law brought out for it to save so many arguments. I hate the thought of not having same surname as the baby but would also like to know if baby has his surname does he have more rights? He’s so bloody controlling!
Why are you with him @Dannibear7 ?

You don't need a law about surnames. Only you can register the birth of the baby, he can't. You should secretly go and register the baby with your surname and his name not on the birth certificate and then dump his controlling arse.

If you put him on the birth certificate (regardless of the surname) he could take your baby away and the police wouldn't be able to do anything because he is an equal parent to you in the eyes of the law. You'd have to go to court to get your baby back which could take a long time. Protect yourself and your baby.

My friend gave her kids her ex DPs name. He was a waste of space, left her when the youngest was a tiny baby, hasn't paid any maintenance or seen the kids in the years since, but he won't allow her to change their surname and she can't do it without his permission. She looks after them 24/7, 365 days a year, yet they all have their dad's name and there's nothing she can do about it.

georgarina · 02/05/2021 13:56

I had a similar situation with DS's dad. DS has my last time. Dad is not around now, DS and I are a family and we share the same name. I remember members of ex's family trying to guilt me and saying it was so generous of him to "allow" me to make that choice - which I just laughed at.

If they're not acting as the parent, why should the child have their name? Respect yourself as the parent, and give your child a last name that reflects the person who loves and cares about them.

Dannibear7 · 02/05/2021 13:50

Yeah I feel exactly the same but honestly he would make my life hell if I didn’t let him, I’ve asked for double barrel and he has said no to that aswell.
We do all the hard work I think it should be law if unmarried the baby gets mother’s surname and I don’t know why there isn’t a law brought out for it to save so many arguments. I hate the thought of not having same surname as the baby but would also like to know if baby has his surname does he have more rights? He’s so bloody controlling!

maddening · 02/05/2021 13:09

Put your name there, you are the one that has fought for your baby, it should be your name there.

Wonderingwhatwhere · 02/05/2021 12:47

Your name.
We registered our baby with both names, and we’d agreed to marry. We did marry, and doubled our names .
It was still odd having a baby with a double barrelled surname for a year, before it was my name too, and his.
It would drive me insane if my child didn’t have my surname at all.

Lorw · 02/05/2021 12:42

DONT DO IT OP. Give baby your name. ♥️

DinosaurDiana · 02/05/2021 12:35

No, don’t do it.
You could give baby dad’s surname as an extra middle name if you want to include him.
If you give baby dad’s surname you will not be able to change that.
If you give baby your surname you are able to change that in the future.
Keep the power in your hands.

nzborn · 02/05/2021 12:31

No

HerRoyalRisesAgain · 02/05/2021 11:59

My kids have my surname. And I'm so glad that they do.
My theory was, I gave birth they get my name.
Plus their dad is rubbish.he spent years abusing me emotionally and mentally, and even physically a couple of times. Now he's out of my life and me and the kids are much better off.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 02/05/2021 11:55

@Dannibear7

About to register baby and really want my surname in as not married but my partner has said more or less he will make my life hell if I don’t sign her birth certificate with his name as a surname 🤬🤬 he is the type that would aswell.
With that attitude, he is going to make your life hell anyway.

So why add to your troubles by giving the child his surname now? At the very least, go double barreled.

Aprilshowersandhail · 02/05/2021 11:39

My ds has just my name on his bc... It isn't shameful. It doesn't say Bastard Child in the space.
He has never met him as he wasn't interested.. Imagine if I had to try and find him whenever I needed a decision OK-ed because he had PR..
I can't imagine all the stress some women have dealing with a bastard ex who has power over them and a baby they don't really care about...
Most don't grasp what parental responsibility actually entails....

windisblowing · 02/05/2021 11:33

Definitely not