Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If each country had a two child policy

528 replies

Blackcat21 · 07/04/2021 16:38

Just an idea and my opinion, and fully aware I will probably get flamed for this.

The population is rising, not shrinking, and with that is coming ridiculous house prices, global warming, running low on natural resources and foods.

Health services are stretched and school classes are increasingly full.

Wouldn’t an solution to this be only letting per couple or mother/father have two biological children each.

I must admit, it does annoy me when some women go on to have 3rd, 4th child etc just because “they want to” or want a large family, love being with children or love being a mother.

Motherhood is a beautiful thing but it could be restricted to two biological children only.

Overpopulation is impacting the earth too much.

If this couple wanted more children they can adopt.
There are thousands of children in the U.K. and other countries each year wanting to be adopted.

Doing this could possibly tackle overpopulation but increase the adoption of children.

Obviously I’m aware there is problems of how to monitor this, what if a woman gets pregnant against her will, accidental pregnancies etc but not that is the not the point or idea I’m trying to get across right now.

AIBU to think this could be a good approach?

OP posts:
RincewindsHat · 07/04/2021 17:33

Overpopulation of the planet is in no way a myth, and I am with you OP, but people cannot see past the ends of their own noses on this issue.

Of course population control needs to be a thing (I'm talking about the global population, because it's a global issue. Is it fair? No. But do we want a planet fit for habitation and supporting life?). It's insanity to think otherwise. But when you get people who think the planet can support an infinite increase in people and animals because they think having as many kids as they want is their right that trumps EVERYTHING else, what can you do? When you have people crying 'BUT WHAT ABOUT MULTIPLES?' and thinking that's the end of the debate, where can the conversation go?

The planet has finite resources. Fresh water is a finite resource, believe it or not. Agricultural land is a finite resource. The planet can support a finite population and we're approaching the upper limit. It's a known issue, it's why some of the world's wealthiest people are buying farmland and land with its own fresh water source. They know what's coming, and they know it's not going to be pretty.

Before anyone has a hissy fit about China, wombs being regulated, second pregnancies being twins etc etc, why not read Ten Billion (it's short and very readable) and come back and tell me you think overpopulation of the planet is a myth rather than a very real impending problem that humanity could choose to solve.

ParadiseIsland · 07/04/2021 17:32

@Blackcat21 you are a full decade late at least.
In most countries, women have below the 2.4 children. It will take another 10~15 years to see the impact as population in some countries are young so they have children!

But all that is already happening wo needing rules like this. Educating women seem to be more efficient too Wink

HTH1 · 07/04/2021 17:32

We’ve been in a strange situation for a long time whereby the only people who could afford large families were the rich or those on benefits. I agree with the two child cap on benefits as it made no sense that so many people who work have a reduction of income and/or massively increased costs each time they have a child (and plan their families accordingly) while people on benefits used to effectively be paid by the state to keep having more babies.

However, such a policy would be problematic as PPs say and I can’t see how it could be implemented without terrible human rights abuses. There’s also the (no doubt unpopular) point that the impact of people having more children wildly varies according to their circs e.g I bet few people really think that a family with three adult DC, all of whom are surgeons/teachers etc, really had too many children whereas some children in third world countries are from huge families and literally starving.

Hhusky · 07/04/2021 17:32

We have an aging population. We have more old people than we have ever had before because of improvements to medicine and relative peace so people are living longer. On one hand you can say that's what over stretching health services but the main reason is under funding for years.
I do get your point and I see what you're trying to say but I don't think your solution would work. I do think we need more personal responsibility taken in so far as don't have four or five kids if you cant afford them or manage them. But policing reproductive rights is no good. I think more and more of us are having less kids anyway because one or two kids allow you to have a certain lifestyle that you couldn't really have with more.

terribleg · 07/04/2021 17:31

We have too many old people in the UK

terribleg · 07/04/2021 17:31

Do you know what the birth rate is & the average age of the population? 🤦🏻‍♀️

poppycat10 · 07/04/2021 17:31

[quote terribleg]@poppycat10 the uk doesn't have too many children though...[/quote]
It totally does.

Magnificentmug12 · 07/04/2021 17:30

Didn’t work well in China.

We’re not overpopulated, we are crammed into small spaces and need to spread out more and make work and pay more even across those spaces.

But that means taking over more land, I do think we are an invasive species though.

poppycat10 · 07/04/2021 17:30

But the population isn't increasing, in the developed world. It's shrinking, and so much so that we are facing economic disaster

How? We've far too many people, we are concreting over our countryside, we don't have enough facilities, healthcare, education and you think we need more people?

terribleg · 07/04/2021 17:30

@poppycat10 the uk doesn't have too many children though...

poppycat10 · 07/04/2021 17:30

@VladmirsPoutine

Over population is a myth - a nefarious one at that. Unequal distribution of resources among a host of other factors should be redressed first before we start regulating wombs.
Overpopulation isn't remotely a myth - there are far too many humans for this planet to sustain unless we all go back to being hunters and gatherers and then the majority of us will die anyway.

I don't know why people get to het up about the idea that two children is enough. It is enough. We have contraception - lots of options in fact - it's not about regulating wombs and trying to stop the planet imploding.

I am a bit surprised anyone is still having children at the moment with climate change and covid going on (and yes I know people had kids in WW2 but they didn't have contraception).

Rukaya · 07/04/2021 17:29

But the population isn't increasing, in the developed world. It's shrinking, and so much so that we are facing economic disaster.
Why are you trying to destroy your own society? And how do you propose to control people's reproduction, would you have forcibly terminated my third child, for example? Do tell us all the details.

RandomLondoner · 07/04/2021 17:28

The population is rising

The population is not rising because of birth rate, which is falling and is only slightly above replacement rate now. It is rising because life expectancy is increasing. Once life expectancy in the poorest countries matches that in Europe and North America population will start declining.

I think population is expected to peak later this century at 11 billion (up from 7 today?) and then start falling.

MyDcAreMarvel · 07/04/2021 17:28

We need people to have more children in the U.K. not less. We have an ageing population. The planet is not overcrowded it’s very much area specific.

LookAtAllThoseSocksSaidTheSock · 07/04/2021 17:28

Why does it have to be a women's issue (alone)? Are people saying that in this utopian/dystopian (depending on which side you're on) world OP's talking about, men can't have the snip? That way, women don't have to do anything. I think they've done enough tbh, so men could bear that burden if this ever happened. Which it won't.

DarkMatterA2Z · 07/04/2021 17:28

The birth rate has fallen to below replacement rate in most countries with free access to birth control and an even tolerable record on women's rights.

Turns out that if you don't force women to have children, a large proportion will choose not to or will voluntarily limit their family size.

So I'm not sure your rule is needed.

cravingmilkshake · 07/04/2021 17:27

So I had my daughter 20 months ago, she is lovely and we thought we would try this year/fell pregnant in January and have recently found out it's twins.... so I now am having a 3 child family..... what would I do in your hypothetical situation?

Choose my two favourites?

Love51 · 07/04/2021 17:26

The only advantage I can see is that it would unite the pro-choice and pro-life lobbies.
You would find the execution tricky. There is a massive move currently towards equality for all people. This would be a retrograde step if you tried to enforce it.
I have 2 kids. If I get pregnant again, would your new world order pay for an abortion? I wouldn't take it. So, do I have to give birth privately? Presumably no child benefit. I'll have to either fund private school or not educate my child. But by law I have to. So, bodge job home ed it is then. I do a bad job, my child can't access hospital, youth clubs etc. She becomes a second class citizen, hates the system, becomes an extremist, and you have riots on your hands from her and the other outcasts from society.

DdraigGoch · 07/04/2021 17:25

The UK's fertility rate is only 1.74. This policy would be superfluous here (and in the rest of the developed world) as the number of larger families is heavily outnumbered by households with one or no children.

The solution is female emancipation in developing countries, particularly Equatorial Africa. Provide access to female education and contraception and the problem resolves itself. No need for coercion.

ourworldindata.org/grapher/children-per-woman-un?country=~OWID_WRL

terribleg · 07/04/2021 17:25

One reason covid hit us so bad is because we have an ageing population, average age of 40.

Who is going to fund the older populations?

coffeeandgin26 · 07/04/2021 17:24

No.

I have four kids because I wanted to.

I wouldn't have ever have adopted a child anyway; if I couldn't have children naturally I wouldn't have had them.

terribleg · 07/04/2021 17:23

The birth rate is about 1.6 so people are already having less dc.

LookAtAllThoseSocksSaidTheSock · 07/04/2021 17:23

@thebillyotea

A welfare system that punishes people for the crime of being poor

it's not punishing anyone not to give anyone a lifestyle they can't afford because they can't or can't be bothered to work to afford it by themselves!

Welfare system is a safety net. Not more.

It's baffling isn't it? How a system encouraging you to not have more kids so you can take better care of the ones you have is "punishing" you. Yet when you do what you want, you demand that system takes care of them. Baffling!
stayathomer · 07/04/2021 17:22

I must admit, it does annoy me when some women go on to have 3rd, 4th child etc just because “they want to” or want a large family, love being with children or love being a mother.
Bit of a strange thing to get annoyed by, isn't it?!

terribleg · 07/04/2021 17:21

The thing is if we have a conversation about overpopulation why is it just focused on children? Should we be keeping people alive & on medication in their 90s. It's nefarious to think like that but we need workers who can pay tax.

Swipe left for the next trending thread