Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If each country had a two child policy

528 replies

Blackcat21 · 07/04/2021 16:38

Just an idea and my opinion, and fully aware I will probably get flamed for this.

The population is rising, not shrinking, and with that is coming ridiculous house prices, global warming, running low on natural resources and foods.

Health services are stretched and school classes are increasingly full.

Wouldn’t an solution to this be only letting per couple or mother/father have two biological children each.

I must admit, it does annoy me when some women go on to have 3rd, 4th child etc just because “they want to” or want a large family, love being with children or love being a mother.

Motherhood is a beautiful thing but it could be restricted to two biological children only.

Overpopulation is impacting the earth too much.

If this couple wanted more children they can adopt.
There are thousands of children in the U.K. and other countries each year wanting to be adopted.

Doing this could possibly tackle overpopulation but increase the adoption of children.

Obviously I’m aware there is problems of how to monitor this, what if a woman gets pregnant against her will, accidental pregnancies etc but not that is the not the point or idea I’m trying to get across right now.

AIBU to think this could be a good approach?

OP posts:
Unsinkablemoll · 07/04/2021 19:54

Population of the UK is falling and across the world it looks like developed nations are heading for a Covid-related birth bust. Why would we need this policy exactly? Or would it only apply to developing nations and if so, isn't that a touch colonial?

oblada · 07/04/2021 19:54

"I must admit, it does annoy me when some women go on to have 3rd, 4th child etc just because “they want to” or want a large family, love being with children or love being a mother."

What other reason could there be to have a child? That would apply to the first and second to. We have kids because we want to. End of.

I have 4 kids so naturally I wouldn't be keen. Im not sure overpopulation is really such an issue everywhere. In France the government actually promotes bigger families. But here in the UK the message clearly is to stop at 2. Ultimately imposing a limit on people isn't really a sensible way forward.

LemonMeringueThreePointOneFour · 07/04/2021 19:53

I must admit, it does annoy me when some women go on to have 3rd, 4th child etc just because “they want to” or want a large family, love being with children or love being a mother.

I agree. If someone ate four slices of cake "just because they wanted to" they'd be considered greedy, but want to populate the earth with four more humans to the detriment of others? Knock yourself out!

I think the only way this would ever happen in a democracy would be if it became socially unacceptable to have more than two children. (Although I did read something recently about fertility rates falling precipitously, so that may end up being what causes the birth rate to be reduced.)

C8H10N4O2 · 07/04/2021 19:52

Well you could improve the rights and status of women, women's education and access to reproductive and general health care, improve general primary care in many countries. That leads to drops in birth rates like day follows night.

You could reduce consumption per head in the wealthy west where one individual "costs the earth" many times an individual in less developed countries.

Of course these ideas have the disadvantage of not being fundamentally misogynist or racist so may not hit the desired audiencet unless cheap DM style blaming all the world's problems on "them" is the your desired audience.

alliejay81 · 07/04/2021 19:51

It's factually incorrect to say the population is continuing to grow, it's levelling off. The book Factfulness is very good and I'd highly recommend.

Chunkymenrock · 07/04/2021 19:50

Over population in not a myth, its extremely serious. I think 2 children each is too many, now we know how serious environmental problems are.

vomcomvomcom · 07/04/2021 19:50

I think it’s a great idea. I also think people should be sterilised after their two kids so they can’t break the rules.

Dddccc · 07/04/2021 19:48

Hmm kind of agree but its how it would be unforced is the issues in theory you could say unless you pay for birth or more children and can prove you can fully support them to adult hood pay for education ect however it would be then rich people could have more kids and normal people couldn't, but I also believe if you can't afford more kids don't have them, we have 1 could at a push afford a second but then if anything happened money wise we would be screwed

Abfabfanjo · 07/04/2021 19:48

I have 4 children, we wanted 4 children, we were able to provide for 4 children and our children are now intelligent, articulate and compassionate adults.

monkehsee · 07/04/2021 19:45

@GnomeDePlume

'right kids, time to chose your favourite grandparents'
Best comment of the thread!!
GrinGrin

rainbowfairydust · 07/04/2021 19:44

Maybe the Government should tell us all to eat Vegan then, and get rid of holidaying abroad too? What about only being allowed 2 changes of clothes and a certain amount of electricity and water to use?

terribleg · 07/04/2021 19:44

🤣

GnomeDePlume · 07/04/2021 19:43

[quote terribleg]@Blackcat21 how should we tackle the UKs ageing population? [/quote]
That's easy. Make the rule 'no more than 2 GPs beyond the age of 60'

right kids, time to chose your favourite grandparents

ChangedName4TheSakeOfIt · 07/04/2021 19:43

So what happens if a woman falls in love with a man who has already gathered his government allowed quota of children. She must live her life child free?

As the first poster who replied says, the world does not have a lack of resources, just an unequal distribution of them.
The UK wastes massive amounts of perfectly edible groceries that don't pass the appearance test to be sold to the public while people are starving in third world countries.

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 07/04/2021 19:42

@Kendodd

In the UK, if we don't start having more babies, there won't be enough lovely tax payers of working age to provide the funds to pay pensions or run anything much.

What a rubbish argument. If we are short of labour we could easily import it from high unemployment countries. We get tax payers, they get a job.

I see. And what happens to those countries, where you’ve imported your, young and probably educated, workforce from? Or doesn’t that matter? Ffs.
lioncitygirl · 07/04/2021 19:41

Twins, triplets etc? What a stupid comment to make op. Maybe you should look at China where people are aborting their second kids or putting them up for adoption.

terribleg · 07/04/2021 19:41

What a rubbish argument. If we are short of labour we could easily import it from high unemployment countries.

Do we just go over & grab them?

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 07/04/2021 19:40

Have you ever visited overpopulated countries like most of Asia? Overpopulation is not a myth but dark reality and it hits you hard when you ever live in such places. Forget about resources you get suffocated and wish you had a bit of more O2 first. Count me in for 2 child policy

I think Vladimirspoutine meant the globe as a whole, not individual countries or continents. And that’s the problem. In the ‘developed’ world, where women have contraception and education (and access to manifold resources for all), there isn’t an over abundance of populace, but in some areas, and some of those are developing countries, there is. Who exactly is going to even to attempt to impose this kind of restriction on those areas? And how is that even ‘fair’? Redistribution, or proper distribution, of education, wealth and resources would naturally sort out this issue without resorting to medieval imposition of ‘breeding’ quotas. And that, I’m afraid, will never happen.

LittleGreenGoblin · 07/04/2021 19:38

From a scientific and purely logical standpoint, I agree with you. In the real world, it is of course abominable to restrict people's reproductive rights.

FlashesOfRage · 07/04/2021 19:37

@Blackcat21

You could have done even the most basic research into population and development to know this is dumb as hell 👍
I teach yr10 geographers more than you know about this 🤷‍♀️

TutiFrutti · 07/04/2021 19:36

Does this mean I can sell one of my twins? Grin

BrumBoo · 07/04/2021 19:35

PP have made a very good point about our aging population. People have always had many children, usually due to high death rates in babies and toddlers' in the past and parents and grandparents dying earlier. We now can keep the elderly and very ill artificially going long after they should have passed away. I think your looking at the wrong issue, @Blackcat21.....

CaveMum · 07/04/2021 19:34

@DamsonTrousers

My Great Great Grandmother had 17 children, 7 of whom died before the age of 10. An extreme example but huge families weren’t that unusual in the not too distant past.
DH’s great-grandmother had 16 children, 15 of which made it to adulthood, in the space of 22 years. She was married at 19, first child the same year, she died aged 41 three months after giving birth to her youngest child. The eldest daughter, who was not long married herself, had to take the four youngest children in as her father could not cope as at that point there were 8 children under the age of 10 in the house.

God knows how people coped!

VladmirsPoutine · 07/04/2021 19:33

If we are short of labour we could easily import it from high unemployment countries.

Don't think this will be a vote winning idea.

Starlightstarbright1 · 07/04/2021 19:33

I know hundreds of parents, a handful have 3 , 2 i can think of have more than 3.most i know havebone or two and few i know have none.

Many issues- talking about adoptions isn't as easy as percieved. So many adoped children have additional issues to manage- it is not for many.

Secondly man has 2 children, leaves his wife , meets someone else. Can she have children?

The desire to reproduce is a biological urge , that is wht people spend thousands on fertility treatments.