Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother in law is a copycat.

143 replies

Loliie · 05/04/2021 09:50

Me and my partner moved into our first house over a year ago and we chose a lovely grey checked wallpaper for our feature wall in our livingroom. Everyone loved it except my MIL she hated it. But yesterday she sent us photos of her kitchen that has been freshly decorated with our exact wallpaper that she hated so much. Last year I bought myself new glasses and she said “they aren’t nice at all” and then she bought the same ones a few months later in a different colour. I’m unsure if she’s jealous or just a bitch

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
possumgoddess · 06/08/2021 16:00

My mum did some things in her house in a very similar way to us - I really don't think she realised where she got the ideas from! I took it as a compliment.

2bazookas · 05/08/2021 21:00

She's both; jealous and a bitch.

Also pathetic.

MauveMagnolia · 05/08/2021 20:39

@Stags401

I get your frustration I am a newly bride and my mil getting married the SAME YEAR as us as well as picked a dress that was one of my options and not to mention stole every last inch of my wedding colors I don’t know how to take this matter either
How dare she get married in the same year? (you of course have the entire year reserved just for you- indeed why not block out the next year as well)
Stags401 · 05/08/2021 20:23

I get your frustration I am a newly bride and my mil getting married the SAME YEAR as us as well as picked a dress that was one of my options and not to mention stole every last inch of my wedding colors I don’t know how to take this matter either

ViciousJackdaw · 06/04/2021 15:18

@Trumplosttheelection

It's no surprise she doesn't like you when you clearly loathe her
Yawn. Look dearie, you're going to have to up your 'I am so much better than you' game - your current lines are as old as the hills. Maybe try some new material?
SouthernBounce · 06/04/2021 14:58

Just imagine how insecure MIL must feel to do this. Some may pity her. Certainly she is no threat, be the better person and pretend you haven’t noticed.

PhilCornwall1 · 06/04/2021 05:31

When she shows you what she's done or what's she's got, tell her it looks shit and see what she comes back with.

If she says "well you've got that", tell her that's why you did it, because you knew she'd would copy. Very petty I know, but you could really have some fun messing with her here.

Wavey123 · 06/04/2021 04:32

@Loliie

I’ve mentioned to my partner that she previously didn’t like it and he says just to take it as a compliment but it’s very annoying. She’s the type of women who can’t compliment other women it’s always back handed or straight up rude.
Please ignore me if this is a typo/autocorrect but it’s “She’s the type of womAn”. You would never say “He’s the type of men”. See this a lot on here where people don’t know the difference between a woman and women and just had to say, sorry. Blush
GreyhoundG1rl · 06/04/2021 04:08

She does sound quite odd, op

Clarissa111 · 06/04/2021 03:52

Seems like mumsnet attracts bitches! Sorry if that's sexist. But come on. I only read a few answers. Your MIL is a bitch because she likes your taste? No the OP clearly stated that she she put down her taste, then bought the exact same thing!
You all pick on the slightest thing to have a go.
It's ridiculous.
OP. I had a mother in law like this. I started telling her I was going to buy the most ridiculous things. And sat back while she rushed to buy it first.

CommanderBurnham · 05/04/2021 17:53

You've described my mother in law exactly, right down to the miscarriage. Ignore her and call out her hypocrisy. She needs standing up to -a few well placed sharp comments should help.

Loliie · 05/04/2021 14:15

@ShipshapeShore

At least yours didn't decide that your honeymoon destinations sounded nice and then book up to go first! It was my first ever abroad holiday and I was so excited, I must admit it took the shine off a bit having to be all excited for them and then look at all their pictures before we went. These type of things wouldn't usually bother me but that did.
That would really piss me off
OP posts:
Oneearringlost · 05/04/2021 14:12

OP, the best outcome to all of these scenarios is to adopt the moral higher ground. She may not be able to concede that what you like, she likes.
But to stop feeling churned up about it means taking it as a tacit compliment, and not addressing it and moving on. So, not to engage when she says less than complimentary things, just to keep quiet and know that you are doing what you want, if she copies you, fine.
It takes away the churning resentment and keeps you feeling good and peaceful.
Inward resentment does not lead to inward happiness, I have discovered this for myself. You'll never change her, but you can change how you feel about these scenarios, so you don't find yourself ruminating. It worked for me.

GizmoBasil · 05/04/2021 14:11

@ShipshapeShore sorry but the OPs situation is much worse Hmm

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 05/04/2021 14:00

@Loliie

I’ll have a look into that. I’ve tried for years to just put my head down and deal with everything. She’s never been nice. We struggle with fertility issues and had a miscarriage last year and she basically said she believes it’s my fault. Yes the wallpaper thing is petty but it really is just the straw that broke the camels back
I understand. My in-laws did a similar thing to me and I did what you're doing for nigh-on 20 years; i.e. tried to pretend it wasn't happening.

Their behaviour when my DM died and when I too suffered a succession of miscarriages is something I can't look past. Of course with people like this it ends where it was always going to end: VLC.

Some people, you can simply do nothing with. And there's a peace that can come from an acceptance of that fact. I dropped the rope and now allow DH to manage that relationship for him and the DC, without my input.

It's sad and not what I wanted for any of us. But what is, is. Flowers

Loliie · 05/04/2021 13:56

I’ll have a look into that. I’ve tried for years to just put my head down and deal with everything. She’s never been nice. We struggle with fertility issues and had a miscarriage last year and she basically said she believes it’s my fault. Yes the wallpaper thing is petty but it really is just the straw that broke the camels back

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 05/04/2021 13:54

PS. have you read Susan Forward's book Toxic In-Laws? Despite its emotive title it's a useful tool for shutting down this kind of behaviour without resorting to WW3. I'd thoroughly recommend it.

Loliie · 05/04/2021 13:52

Some people on here really must have questionable personalities because they are just ignoring that she’s been horrible to me and focusing on the fact I’m offended she copied my wallpaper

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 05/04/2021 13:51

I know one thing. If I wanted advice from Mumsnet about my MiL I'd substitute her identify for that of another family member. The responses you'd get would doubtless be a lot more measured and less prickly.

The MiL/DiL relationship seems very incendiary. As far as I can see this tends to boil down to competition (she sees her daughter's children more often than her son's, or DiL wants her children to spend more time with her family than her DH.

Unfairly, MiL is sometimes seen to be transgressing boundaries when they are set at Fort Knox height for her whilst remaining at box-hedge level for everyone else. By the same token, if issues arise with the relationship MiLs will usually see DiL as the sources of problem, rather than examining their own relationship with their sons.

On Mumsnet the stock response is that MiLs are hated, and DiLs should just put up with whatever behaviour their MiLs care to dish out.

As far as this thread's concerned, yes, the copycat stuff is childish. But when someone keeps up this low-level antagonism for years on end I can see how it would become very wearing. The trouble with this brand of passive aggression is that if you challenge it, she'll deploy plausible deniability and you'll look unhinged (this is the PA's get-out clause, frustrating though that is). The only thing you can really do is protect your own wellbeing by deciding where your level of contact should lie (because she won't stop). Then stick with that.

Loliie · 05/04/2021 13:51

I never said that’s the main thing I was taking offence to I only brought up my sons name because everyone was attacking me for my original post.

OP posts:
PferdeMerde · 05/04/2021 13:45

You should have titled thread “mil was nasty about my sons name” or something like that. How bizarre the main thing you take offence to is her buying the same bloody wallpaper as you. Hmm

Catsaremybesties · 05/04/2021 13:27

Well when someone tells you they hate something yours - the truth is the opposite.
I had this many times. For example..
My so called best ex friend who hated my new coat so much that she made me to get rid of it as apparently too ugly- only to buy the same coat a weeks later and proudly wearing it!

AngeliaFields01 · 05/04/2021 13:24

I used to have a friend like this, if I wore anything new she would state that she didnt like it, but then 1 week later would appear wearing the same item. I think its annoying because she was adamant it was horrible, if she said she liked it and was going to buy it , I would absolutely have no problem.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 05/04/2021 13:23

I also don't get most of the first poster on this- it's a) rude to tell someone you hate their new wallpaper anyway b) very odd to copy the very distinct style of another family member without asking.

She's a weirdo for sure, but the best thing to do is just change your wallpaper if you aren't that fussed about it in a year or two and say nothing to her about anything.

VenusTiger · 05/04/2021 13:21

"Love your spruced-up kitchen, not sure I'd have that wallpaper in a kitchen though, it belongs in a bedroom or a lounge"