Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really hate it when friends and family ask me for legal advice?

156 replies

FixxerUpper · 04/04/2021 10:48

I’m a solicitor. This is something that has always bugged me but it seems to be happening a lot right now.

I feel like every time I speak to friends and family someone asks me for legal advice. Usually on the area of law in which I practice, but not always (I know as much about family law as the next person...).

I hate it. I mean I have nothing against helping people out if I can but I find it stressful and to be honest cheeky as fuck.

What if my advice is incorrect? I rarely know the full background to the issue at hand. I haven’t read the documents you’re referring to. I had a rare day off the other day and my mum phoned me to ask for advice ffs. It sounds stupid but it’s really getting to me!

I have a doctor friend who unsurprisingly has the same issue.

Please. Stop doing it.

OP posts:
Cactus1982 · 04/04/2021 13:41

My DF is a tradesman and the amount of random people who knock on his front door to ask for help or advice is unbelievable. We’re not talking about friends or close neighbours, these are people who’ve we’ve never seen before and who live round the corner or have just moved in up the road. It happens at all hours of the day, and they really do look at him as if he’s got three heads when it’s something he can’t help with. It’s very common for it to happen to plumbers, electrician, mechanics etc and one of the lads who works for him no longer answers his front door unless it’s someone he knows because he’s so sick of it.

One time I was dog sitting for them when they were on holiday and someone knocked asking a ‘bit of advice’, I told him my DF was away and wouldn’t be back until such and such and he actually said ‘well can’t you ring one of the lads for me’ sic. As in the lads who work for him. I told he could find their number in the yellow pages, he wasn’t happy..

It’s breathtakingly rude and entitled and I wouldn’t dream of doing it. It’s because they don’t want to have look up a phone number ring up and potentially pay a call out fee in my experience. The people who are telling you that your YABU are probably these sorts, wanting something for nothing types.

Horizons83 · 04/04/2021 13:34

I just say ‘Sorry, Law Society rules prevent me from providing advice unless I have a formal engagement in place.’

wishywashywoowoo70 · 04/04/2021 13:34

I get this too. Work as defendant insurer for injury claims. People ask me about their car damage claim 🤷🏼‍♀️

OldScrappyAndHungry · 04/04/2021 13:33

Yep another teacher who gets this all the time! At a party once, total stranger got chatting with me. “Oh you’re a teacher! My 6 year old is on Lime in the ORT, do you think she she should be higher?”

WTAF???? HmmShockGrin

PumpkinPie2016 · 04/04/2021 13:31

YANBU.

I am a teacher and my family are constantly asking me about xyz educational issue to do with their children. I do not teach in the schools their kids attend so don't know the policies etc. When my sister moved house and wanted her son to move school, she kept asking me 'oh, can you contact x school about ds going there' erm, no, it doesn't work like that.

When my Dad was a police officer, we lived in a fairly small village so lots of people knew his job. I kid you not, we used to get randomers knocking at the door with lost dogs/asking for him to sign their passport photos/trying to give information about things they'd seen or heard. He didn't even police the bloody village and my mum pointed out to several people that this was our home, not the local police station. It was very irritating!

It's common though - people across lots of professions get it.

DdraigGoch · 04/04/2021 13:29

@Macncheeseballs

Isn't being part of a community helping each other with bits and pieces according to our skill sets? Am I allowed to ask a gardener for gardening advice?
"Could you just cut my grass?" "That'll be £x" "But you should be helping me out with bits and pieces" "I do work, you pay me."
PerspicaciousGreen · 04/04/2021 13:11

Oh gosh, I'd think nothing of asking one of my lawyer friends for free advice if I was confused about something. I hope they'd ask me for free advice in my area of expertise too.

But I'd also think nothing of saying or hearing, "You know, it can actually get quite complicated, so it would take longer than you'd think to get that kind of thing right and I don't have the spare time for that, I'm afraid. But if you want to make a proper appointment, XYZ at our firm is very good at this sort of thing." (I don't work with friends or do mates rates - too many pitfalls!)

Trying looking up "ask vs guess culture".

Wotsnewpussycat · 04/04/2021 13:07

@Imnotbent

I wish I had thought of the insurance one, although I do say this is advisory only. It’s also often a drip feed of can you advise on this, which then turns into can you help on this? Or it turns out to be a lot more complicated. I have started to say no when it turns to help but really only since I felt totally taken advantage of.

I wouldn’t ask a friend or relative for a free haircut, a massage, to hang doors in my house or service my car. Although @Wotsnewpussycat my mother was a nurse and I can recall many a child lying on her kitchen table having butterfly stitches or wounds tended to etc.

Absolutely and I can't switch off Nursing whether on duty or not. It's nice to help people 😊 xx
Itsalwayssunnyin · 04/04/2021 13:05

Wow. This must be so annoying, especially on your day off.
I don’t blame you for feeling the way you do.

ImAlrightThanx · 04/04/2021 12:45

I think it depends.
General legal advice about your area of work (eg if you are an employment law specialist, and they ask 'are they allowed to do this' or whatever) is different to "I am in x situation and need specific, specialist legal advice about y topic".
Can you tell them you are not allowed to advise family?

onemouseplace · 04/04/2021 12:45

I've not practised for over 10 years, and I still get this. I don't mind very close friends asking a quick question or a bit of advice, but a couple of years ago I was on holiday and had a friend email me for urgent advice about a lease she was taking on. She expected an immediate answer, and the real cheek of it was that she openly said she was asking me because she thought the (perfectly reasonable) fee her solicitor was charging was more than she wanted to pay.

Marmaladesandwiches27 · 04/04/2021 12:40

I work in a role associated with infectious diseases-no one asked me anything until the last year or so Grin

ceilingsand · 04/04/2021 12:38

I was persuaded by my sister to help her latest partner with a pretty big issue in my line of work. It eventually involved me in three long distance meetings. He too won a large payout and didn't actually let me know-another relative told me quite some time later. I had no interest in his money but a thank you and some flowers would have been nice.

LowlandLucky · 04/04/2021 12:34

How dare they ! Bet you would never ask for medical advice if your cousin was a Doctor, ask the best flea treatment if your Auntie was a vet or ask your Niece the best way to cook Duck if she was a Chef. Your time must be so bloody precious, hope you never any kind of help form a family member.

Sansaplans · 04/04/2021 12:27

Just say no, although I would help my immediate family with the caveat they also need to pay for advice if neccessary from someone else, but would chat through something with them. Extended family and friends though, no. DH is in a similar position where people crawl out of the woodwork when they want his help and advice on something to do with his job, he just says he's not at work.

thatsforsure · 04/04/2021 12:27

I am a solicitor and get this all the time. The worst was when i went for a massage - a treat from my mum as she thought I looked stressed and tired and the woman doing the massage kept asking me about her legal problem. In the end I had to say that I had come due to stress from work and if she expected free legal advice I expected a free massage - to be fair she apologised and shut up

Jaxhog · 04/04/2021 12:25

But don't you always give half an hour free?

Yeah, right. I used to do that as a Business Adviser until I realized I was giving out free advice to all and sundry and not getting paid work. There has to be a limit.

OysterMonkey · 04/04/2021 12:22

@trinibrit

I tell people my insurance will not cover any legal advice I give ad hoc but if they would like to make an appointment during office hours I will bill them at a “friends and family rate” which is a bit cheaper for them but means everything is above board. It separates out the chancers from those who really need advice.
This is a perfect response.
Steptoeshorse1965 · 04/04/2021 12:22

Ask for an invoice address and charge accordingly, say it's not informal. Should see a change in matters for you.

1FootInTheRave · 04/04/2021 12:20

I'm a midwife and get this regularly.

I don't mind if it's a good mate or family.

It's usually distant acquaintances that take the piss though.

Oblomov21 · 04/04/2021 12:17

Isn't this the norm? I'm get asked about tax returns etc all the time, no problem.
Every lawyer, dentist, nurse will get the same surely?

CounsellorTroi · 04/04/2021 12:14

My SIL is a doctor but I’ve never asked her for medical advice. I wouldn’t feel comfortable.

CrazyCatLazy · 04/04/2021 12:14

YANBU. At all.

Ex vet nurse here and I used to have to turn my phone off some days as the CONSTANT messages for advice were draining. I worked 70+ hr weeks and then was expected to give advise in all of my down time too. Baring in mind it a physically, mentally and emotionally draining job.
I didn’t mind helping with the odd bit of course, I bandage my friends animals up a couple of times as a put me on through the middle of the night, but when it’s from people who otherwise would never contact me, no!
The worst thing was in addition to this, I would routinely tell people “unfortunately you need to see/speak to a vet for this” which was always met with sustain as they didn’t want to pay for veterinary advice/treatment, but yanno - I’m not a vet.

Imnotbent · 04/04/2021 12:13

Reading these I think it’s fine to give advice in an ad hoc way when it’s your area of expertise, however, and totally my own fault, mine has snowballed into actual work. Sometimes I’ve been happy to help but listening to other posters has made me realise I need to draw the line early on.

MargaretThursday · 04/04/2021 12:13

But don't you always give half an hour free? Grin

It depends on how well you know the person as to whether it's cheeky. I wouldn't think your mum was at all cheeky to run it past you, but the friend who hasn't spoke to you for ages messaging out of the blue and then asking is definitely.