Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School calling children piglets?

370 replies

GoToSleepBabyPlease · 03/04/2021 18:37

Came across this on another thread but felt discussing it there would constitute a derail, so bringing it up here.

On a school website (link below):

'To make table manners fun at Hanford we have devised the ‘Manners Table’, a ranking system of eleven different levels with ‘Piglet’ at the bottom and ‘Royal Guest’ at the top. Each level has a different name to describe the behaviour, for example, a messy eater will be a ‘Panda’ or even ‘Cave Lady’ whereas those girls who have mastered dining rather than merely eating will be a ‘Favourite Auntie’ or ‘Best Granny’. When new girls join they start somewhere in the middle with the aim of working their way up as quickly as possible. If they should become a ‘Royal Guest’ they are allowed to bring their own jam to breakfast. Every Friday after lunch, Miss Morrey reads out the week’s manners rankings. If a girl is moved up then they are given a sweet while others may be warned or some even moved down.

  1. Royal Guest (allowed to bring their own jam or other spread and can also move people up and down)
  2. Best Granny (allowed to move people up and down in manners)
  3. Favourite Aunty
  4. Primrose
  5. Panda
  6. Cat (can go to Tuck Shop on Sunday)
  7. Squirrel
  8. Hyena
  9. Boa Constrictor
  10. Cave Lady
10. Piglet'

AIBU to think that referring to children as piglets doesn't exactly model good manners?

hanfordschool.co.uk/wellbeing/manners/

OP posts:
BackIn · 05/04/2021 15:31

Oh goodness me! They’re wearing Boden! How dreadful!

NotDonna · 05/04/2021 15:30

[quote Puffykins]@Pics 👋🏽 fellow Ex-Hanfordian. Weren't we lucky..... [/quote]
I’m very envious. My DDs would have absolutely loved it too.
Love the idea of no uniform & that they’re all dressed in snuggly fleeces, leggings & wellies. Not sure what the problem is with what they’re wearing @Bishbashbosh101

Rukaya · 05/04/2021 15:24

So they should adapt them - thats what every other school does

You can't just adapt a listed Tudor building!!

Bishbashbosh101 · 05/04/2021 14:29

These girls make their own school skirts in needlework lessons

Well, they're all wearing Boden in the pictures, which you can stick a bit of embroidery on and it will look hotch potchy.

I've never seen so much Boden.

Ivy455 · 05/04/2021 14:19

That is weird as shit.

Puffykins · 05/04/2021 14:17

@Pics 👋🏽 fellow Ex-Hanfordian. Weren't we lucky.....

LuellaPilkington · 05/04/2021 14:16

@Pics They do not understand because they compare it to a standard primary school and as we know it’s not really a straight comparison. Because of the fees it’s also more exciting to chat about it. In the last primary school I worked (rated outstanding btw), misbehaved children got to leave the classroom for a time out. Basically sitting in the coat room and face the wall until they had calmed down. If that was 30k/year it would probably be labelled as ghastly on mumsnet.

Pics · 05/04/2021 13:58

This is pearl clutching, it really is. Yes, I also went there and we were encouraged to sit together, have conversations and treat each other with respect at meal times. the bottom 3 levels were almost never used and you would have to have been pretty intentionally rude to get there.
Bullying? People dont say this about prefects in other school systems and in a small school like this it would be picked up on fast - and of course you would instantly lose your position higher up the manners scale.
The names have changed a little and it looks like they have naturally evolved, probably with the children s input. And really how anyone can be offended by the idea of someone who has been really rude and treated others poorly over the course if several weeks being labelled as a piglet - I do not understand.
Only on social media are people so outraged and offended by things that dont affect them.

Camdenish · 05/04/2021 13:58

Can I join the summer school. I started out on Malory Towers but moved onto Antonia Forest. I see the ponies as being almost as good as the Ark. If I can have sweets and a cat sleeping on my Welsh blanketed bed I’ll be in heaven.

angieloumc · 05/04/2021 13:27

Oh I want to go to the Summer School for ladies who loved Malory Towers and St Clare's (though not Whyteleafe, too harsh).
My DD 16 says she wishes she was back in year 3 so she could have gone there instead of her 'very boring' school.

Ineedaneasteregg · 05/04/2021 13:05

I'd take all the support I could get in terms of my dc's table manners.
At one point I came up with a song about how to use a knife and fork properly and when tween dc were eating badly would threaten to start singing it. ( I can't sing)
This was a particularly effective threat in public spaces.

LuellaPilkington · 05/04/2021 11:49

Oh yes. It’s super serious. I shout Cave Man, very derogatory and make sure they are properly shamed by this. Then stripped them down and hose them off with cold tap water in the garden to make sure they never use their salad fork for their main again.

Seriously. Do you never joke with your kids?!

HeronLanyon · 05/04/2021 09:08

Well quite a few parents are working abroad, armed forces, etc. Not everyone is home based whether permanently/temporary etc.
Agree vast majority of us are able to fit the more usual parenting/schooling scenario so that boarding school is not a necessity.

randomer · 05/04/2021 09:04

How much is it and why would anyone want to send their daughter there when they have a bedroom at home and a school round the corner?

CakesOfVersailles · 05/04/2021 06:52

I'm kind of surprised at the overall negativity. I'm not associated with this school, but when I think of particular traditions at schools I attended and worked at they would sound absolutely bonkers written down, especially with any of the ones names by pupils (as this appears to have been).

There are two kinds of school traditions really - all in good fun traditions and quite nasty, humiliating ones (mostly phased out by now but things like being expelled in front of the whole school).

I would definitely think this one would be implemented in the "all in good fun" category. I really don't think that if it was terribly nasty and causing massive unrest that it would be going on still.

GoToSleepBabyPlease · 05/04/2021 06:18

@LuellaPilkington

So I’ve been eyeing this gem of a school up for a while. Incidentally I frequently call the kids cave men if they slip up their manners around the table at home. Seems to be the place for us.
Quite possibly. I've never felt the need to use name-calling as a behaviour management strategy (and would find it particularly unsuitable as a method of teaching good manners!), but different strokes for different folks, as they say.
OP posts:
Circumlocutious · 05/04/2021 02:49

@mustlovegin

The school traditionally would've been preparing them to be the country lady hosting lunches so is teaching etiquette

Etiquette and (table) manners has nothing to do with being a 'Stepford Wife'

Women lawyers/bankers will need to follow etiquette while at a business lunch. Surgeons/researchers will be networking with colleagues during a lunch break at a conference . Same with many careers or jobs.

Being taught manners and etiquette (at home or reinforced at school) is a blessing and it's disingenuous to tell children that these are 'old fashioned' and should be shunned.

Learning to deliberately turn up dishevelled, stump your feet, display an antagonistic or disruptive stance is not going to do children any favours when they grow up TBH

Threads on table manners on MN routinely gather upwards of 500+ response. I simply cannot see the same level of interest in this topic on a male-dominated forum. There is definitely a gendered dimension to this subject and men - provided they’re of a certain background - will get away with murder.

The worst table manners I’ve witnessed were from male; privately educated, Oxford undergrads (the ‘rowing lot’).

LuellaPilkington · 05/04/2021 01:15

So I’ve been eyeing this gem of a school up for a while. Incidentally I frequently call the kids cave men if they slip up their manners around the table at home. Seems to be the place for us.

mustlovegin · 04/04/2021 23:22

The school traditionally would've been preparing them to be the country lady hosting lunches so is teaching etiquette

Etiquette and (table) manners has nothing to do with being a 'Stepford Wife'

Women lawyers/bankers will need to follow etiquette while at a business lunch. Surgeons/researchers will be networking with colleagues during a lunch break at a conference . Same with many careers or jobs.

Being taught manners and etiquette (at home or reinforced at school) is a blessing and it's disingenuous to tell children that these are 'old fashioned' and should be shunned.

Learning to deliberately turn up dishevelled, stump your feet, display an antagonistic or disruptive stance is not going to do children any favours when they grow up TBH

Closetbeanmuncher · 04/04/2021 23:17

Another bright idea from a clueless, misinformed "think-tank" 🙄

manicinsomniac · 04/04/2021 22:59

Oh wow - this is insane. Literally like Enid Blyton come to life. I kind of love it, while acknowledging how bonkers it sounds. These girls make their own school skirts in needlework lessons, write letters home on a Sunday after chapel and serve trays of food to visitors at a beagle hunt?!? Grin Grin Grin

I work in a relatively posh private prep school and I can just imagine our children's faces if we gave them rules like these. They'd never be able to take it seriously. Elements of Hanford sound similar to how the school I'm at was when I first started working there 14 years ago - no phones, dens, tree climbing, riding etc - but so much has changed and modernised over the last decade that it's hard to believe there are still schools like this. Our 7-9 year olds still build dens. Sadly the older children turn their noses up now. And tree climbing above 1.5m was banned in a health and safety drive years ago. Our boarders only get very limited time on their 'devices' but I can just imagine the outrage if we tried to take them away from them. Hanford sounds like a little time capsule of loveliness that I can't quite believe really works. And not quite sure how the girls would cope even at a public school such as Stowe, Rugby or St Edwards. Maybe they're more likely to go on to smaller, single sex senior schools too.

re learning support being a paid for extra, it can be a bit deceptive. Prep school learning support isn't always the same as it would be in a state primary. We have two different types. Learning Support and Teaching Assistants who work in the classroom with individuals and small groups of children and/or take them out for intervention work are not paid for by the parents. The paid Learning Support lessons are 1:1 weekly or twice weekly sessions in the Learning Support base and are open to any parent who wants them - usually children with significant learning needs of course but sometimes high achieving children with dyslexia or children who have had their early education in a different language will pay for lessons to plug some gaps. The paid lessons also include internal screening and testing, exam access arrangements etc. So it isn't that a child with learning difficulties will be left without support if parents don't pay. It's more that they can choose to pay for more support (as they are by choosing private school in the first place, I suppose - unfair and inequal but that applies to the whole system, not just to learning supprot).

SirSamuelVimes · 04/04/2021 22:35

Also, I know from which room you can get out onto the roof, and where the loose floorboards are under which we used to hide our sweets.....

Arghhh!! Stop it, you're making me so so jealous. I want to go!

NotDonna · 04/04/2021 22:09

If I eat nicely can I bring a duvet instead of jam/primula etc please? And can we make the apple juice with the press (on Instagram) and forage for wild garlic & chives and make flatbreads on the fire pit (also Instagram). I used to beg to go to boarding school - this one would have been top of my list!

Puffykins · 04/04/2021 21:54

@HeronLanyon @notdonna Welsh blankets are a bit scratchy, but also very thick so very good for reading under by torchlight without anybody else knowing.
Also @camdenish I got my Welsh blanket from Ebay and it genuinely was not expensive - certainly nowhere near as expensive as a new one would have been anyway!

Puffykins · 04/04/2021 21:44

@camdenish thank you for your very kind words.

Re the school, it is a bit bonkers I suppose, but that is what makes it so very wonderful. And certainly there were cats when I was there. One year, a cat called Calypso slept on my bed every night, which made me very happy. But to the poster who says she's allergic to cats - do not fear: they are not compulsory bed companions! Also, being a Jacobean Manor house, the rooms are very well ventilated (ie drafty) so fingers crossed your allergies wouldn't be too bad.

I'd totally come back for summer school with you all, incidentally. Also, I know from which room you can get out onto the roof, and where the loose floorboards are under which we used to hide our sweets.....

Swipe left for the next trending thread