Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband sent a little too much money to his parents

262 replies

faithfulbird20 · 03/04/2021 13:11

Okay so I gave birth almost 5 weeks ago.

I've kinda been using up the cupboards since haven't been able to go shopping. Husband took me shopping almost 2 weeks ago and was like will it be done in 10-12 pounds and I was like omg. This week everything ran out and we didn't have basic things like bread etc. He sent 150 pounds to his parents abroad and I got quite angry saying why did you send 150 when normally u send 110-120. Plus the exchange rate in currency was quite high so he didn't need to.

DH and I had a full blown argument and he said so what if I sent it. I earn 2 grand a month and I can send it, it's not your money blah blah blah. When we got pregnant he didn't want me to work and we agreed I'd be a Sahm. I feel quite tired from arguing but AIBU to be angry about it?

OP posts:
Pancaketopping · 04/04/2021 00:05

@GrumpyHoonMain

Let me put another spin on this.

I’m Indian and when DH and I were earning 2,000 - 3,000 / mth between us he was sending 500-1000 per month to his family. We managed by treating it as a bill and cutting our cloth accordingly. We still managed to save, pay a mortgage, and our food budget was approx 50/mth. There’s no way we could have afforded for one of us to stay at home though.

The two of you need an open and honest conversation about how you plan to live and try to create a budget if one is workable and that allows you both access to family money. If you returning to work isn’t possible then he’s the one who has to search for a job with a higher salary.

You've been had, well and truly. £1000 a month is a huge amount in India and what a fairly top of the range professional would earn there, whereas a two-income family earning £3000 in the UK is tiny. £50 on food is a laugh. Looks like you were existing rather than living, scraping together every penny while your DH's family was in the lap of luxury with your family money.
Runnerduck34 · 03/04/2021 23:55

as his wife and the mother of his child you should have equal access to money. joint account all income and outgoings paid in and out of it, both of you have access to it.
he was happy to spend your savings, and yet it sounds like what he earns is his. he shouldnt see it as his money, its family money to support his wife and child. anything he sends to his parents should be agreed by both of you and providing for you and his child should take priority, he may have to bite the bullet and explain to his parents that now he has a family he cannot send so much money. £15 a week is not enough for groceries, not even close, you need to work out a budget together. Without equal access to money I would really think hard about being a sahm I would go back to work and split childcare costs between you

GrumpyHoonMain · 03/04/2021 23:49

@thenightsky

We still managed to save, pay a mortgage, and our food budget was approx 50/mth

£50 a month? Seriously? Like £12 quid a week? When was this? 1970?

10 years ago. Did it by using Tins, cupboard food, buying things close to expiry date, ignoring useby dates for veg and dairy, not drinking tea or coffee, cooking everything from scratch using cheapest possible ingredients. For example I never bought self-raising or plain flour, I bought the cheapest chapatti flour (you can still get 5-10kg for a couple of quid in some shops) and sifting it or grinding it to make what I needed. I also measured everything, butter and oil intake was carefully monitored, i bought spices loose and made them go further by preserving them.
Captpike · 03/04/2021 23:47

[quote Lovecakesandbakes]@Captpike “This seems like more than a challenge. It's financial abuse”

I didn’t see it as financial abuse. I saw it as a misunderstanding of finances and how they are spent and allocated - In addition to misplaced priorities on the husband’s part.[/quote]
So he used up all her savings and told her she doesn't get a say in how 'his' money is spent and its just a misunderstanding?

memberofthewedding · 03/04/2021 23:43

My parents never got a penny out of me once I left home.

TheSilveryPussycat · 03/04/2021 23:41

This sprang out at me: he was happy to use up all my savings
Was it a lot and what did he use it for?

Pinkbrush · 03/04/2021 23:35

OP you need to elaborate. Is he sending money to support his parents who live in a less developed country? If so, I understand your POV, but I also very much understand his. When you have parents “back home”, they are your responsibility and things can get difficult. His responsibility is also with you and his now immediate family and he should definitely communicate better with you, but I do understand where he’s coming from.

occa · 03/04/2021 23:35

You can’t be a SAHP under these circumstances. You just can’t. Maternity leave is only a few weeks in lots of places (e.g. 12 weeks in my home country). You don’t have to be out of work for years because you’ve had a baby.

Start looking for something in the next few weeks if you can. This is not ok. You need your own money.

thenightsky · 03/04/2021 23:32

We still managed to save, pay a mortgage, and our food budget was approx 50/mth

£50 a month? Seriously? Like £12 quid a week? When was this? 1970?

3Britnee · 03/04/2021 23:29

[quote faithfulbird20]@pepsicolagirl they think it's their God given right to ask their sons for money every month. My MIL makes him feel inadequate if he doesn't. It's my husbands fault tbh. I don't think he cares or thinks 'we'll manage'.

@TheWernethWife I will do but that might be another few years since I literally just give birth. He was happy to use up all my savings.

@VerityWibbleWobble I don't have access to money. It's his bank account. I just can use it online. Not for going out etc unless I ask him for it. But if I use it he automatically thinks if she's using it on herself let me send my parents money. [/quote]
What's the culture? Bit of a drip feed if they are indian for example 🙄

But that doesn't negate the financial abuse here.

firedog · 03/04/2021 23:29

£10-12 is a couple of days food for a family max. Taken shopping? Why isn't he shopping for you all? Sounds awful

GrumpyHoonMain · 03/04/2021 23:27

Let me put another spin on this.

I’m Indian and when DH and I were earning 2,000 - 3,000 / mth between us he was sending 500-1000 per month to his family. We managed by treating it as a bill and cutting our cloth accordingly. We still managed to save, pay a mortgage, and our food budget was approx 50/mth. There’s no way we could have afforded for one of us to stay at home though.

The two of you need an open and honest conversation about how you plan to live and try to create a budget if one is workable and that allows you both access to family money. If you returning to work isn’t possible then he’s the one who has to search for a job with a higher salary.

Lovecakesandbakes · 03/04/2021 23:23

@SmellsLikeTeenBedroom

I will add, I don't agree with all the posters saying you need to leave. There is every chance that he hasn't thought the money through yet (as it seems you haven't either) rather than him making a conscious decision to be financially manipulative. Once he has calmed down from the parents thing, spell out to him that money needs to be joint now, and give him a few days to get his head around it before going into panic stations about being financially abused. My DH had similar parent issues (not with money, just generally expecting me to do what his bossy DM wanted all the time). It took him a while to learn the new married pecking order but he got there in the end
I completely agree. You explained this so well.
Lovecakesandbakes · 03/04/2021 23:22

@Captpike “This seems like more than a challenge. It's financial abuse”

I didn’t see it as financial abuse. I saw it as a misunderstanding of finances and how they are spent and allocated - In addition to misplaced priorities on the husband’s part.

Lovecakesandbakes · 03/04/2021 23:17

@LolaSmiles

Yes, I’m reading the same as everyone else! I just don’t believe in insulting OP’s husband nor do I believe in encouraging her to leave her marriage or encouraging her to get back into her career so she can make her own money. Marriage has its ups and downs and it’s worth having a conversation about. You don't believe in people identifying financial abuse? Or think it's wrong for people to suggest women take actions so they are free to leave an abusive situation? Or you consider financial abuse to be one of marriage's 'challenges'?
When I read OP’s post, financial abuse honestly didn’t come to mind. I saw it as a misunderstanding over finances and how it should be allocated and spent. Perhaps there is some financial manipulation there.

I just don’t see how you can conclude financial abuse from one incident. I still think this can be spoken about and they can work through it together.

I don’t think we know enough of the situation to give concluding statements.

Do you know if this was an isolated incident or has been a consistent pattern of behaviour?

You shouldn’t just up and leave your marriage because of one argument. No marriage is perfect and this can be worked through. If there are consecutive marital issues, It’s best they speak to people who know them and their situation well so they can be offered appropriate counsel.

YoniAndGuy · 03/04/2021 23:04

He earns money = it’s not your money

You raise kids = they’re not his kids

would he like it if you said that?

You’re either a team where one works to earn the joint cash and one works to care for the joint kids, and both cash and kids belong to both and both get equal say in what happens to both...

... or you are not.

Lemmeout · 03/04/2021 23:04

Send him shopping with 10-12 pounds.
My mother put up with this shit. Not healthy, loving or respectful at all,

Lovecakesandbakes · 03/04/2021 23:03

@VerityWibbleWobble I’m sorry but I can’t make the judgement that OP should leave her husband because of one incident. I don’t know enough of their situation. It may be wise for them to receive counsel from someone who knows them and their situation well so they can give counsel specific to them.

When I first read this financial abuse honestly didn’t come to mind. I saw it as a misunderstanding that can be spoken about and hashed out.

Obviously OP’s husband’s actions have not been loving based on what’s been shared. I don’t see one incident as enough to end a marriage though unless there’s more to the story.

I absolutely do not believe that abuse of any form is ok and if OP is in danger, her safety is utmost priority.

SmellsLikeTeenBedroom · 03/04/2021 22:58

I will add, I don't agree with all the posters saying you need to leave. There is every chance that he hasn't thought the money through yet (as it seems you haven't either) rather than him making a conscious decision to be financially manipulative. Once he has calmed down from the parents thing, spell out to him that money needs to be joint now, and give him a few days to get his head around it before going into panic stations about being financially abused. My DH had similar parent issues (not with money, just generally expecting me to do what his bossy DM wanted all the time). It took him a while to learn the new married pecking order but he got there in the end

VerityWibbleWobble · 03/04/2021 22:50

@Lovecakesandbakes

Yes, I’m reading the same as everyone else! I just don’t believe in insulting OP’s husband nor do I believe in encouraging her to leave her marriage or encouraging her to get back into her career so she can make her own money. Marriage has its ups and downs and it’s worth having a conversation about.

Obviously I don’t know the whole situation so can only advise on what’s been said. I’m all for working at your marriage despite the challenges and this is one of those things that can be spoken about. Sorry if you don’t agree.

I asked you whether you'd read the same Op as the rest of us and this is your answer? Then please give me your thoughts on,

It's his money
Op has no direct access to money without justifying it
He TAKES her shopping expecting to so end £10/12
Op spent weeks using stuff up from cupboards to eat
HE decided he didn't want her to work.

There's more red flags in her two posts than I usually see on MN in an entire thread.

His culture has bugger all to do with it, he is abusing his wife by not giving her access to money and saying he doesn't want her to work, that in itself is bad enough. Then she has to wait for him to take her shopping whilst she's been cobbling meals from what's in the cupboard whilst being a month post partum. You really can't see issues that may require he to leave before her life becomes unsafe?

SmellsLikeTeenBedroom · 03/04/2021 22:39

If yoyr husband has encouraged you to be a SAHP to care for his baby, there should be no "his" money anymore. It all needs to be joint. And if you've just had a baby, your finances will change massively and he won't be able to afford to send as much to his parents. It's annoying that some men seem to want it both ways: you give up your income completely but he still has complete autonomy over his income. Leaving the parent issue aside, you need to make it clear that either you have entirely joint ownership over any money that comes into the home or he pays you the £1000+ per month that full time childcare would cost

LolaSmiles · 03/04/2021 22:15

Yes, I’m reading the same as everyone else! I just don’t believe in insulting OP’s husband nor do I believe in encouraging her to leave her marriage or encouraging her to get back into her career so she can make her own money. Marriage has its ups and downs and it’s worth having a conversation about.
You don't believe in people identifying financial abuse? Or think it's wrong for people to suggest women take actions so they are free to leave an abusive situation?
Or you consider financial abuse to be one of marriage's 'challenges'?

Devlesko · 03/04/2021 22:02

It's a pity you didn't understand his customs and financial abuse before you married him. Thanks
He won't change.

Silverfly · 03/04/2021 21:57

Yes, when I was a SAHM our money was completely shared. I had equal access to it.

tricky29 · 03/04/2021 21:43

When I was a SAHM, my OH salary was paid to him and then half was sent to me by SO. He used his half to pay all household bills and my half went on food, clothing, extras and our mutual savings.

The savings were in my name only. My OH knew the sacrifice I was making in giving up financial independence for our mutual benefit so wanted me to feel secure.

Now we earn similar amounts and contribute jointly in terms of time and money. I can’t see how you can be financially dependent without having an explicit agreement that any money is joint money, with you being able to spend without permission.

I think you might want to think about working again, just to protect yourself financially. It sounds like a difficult situation to be in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread